← All votes

National Council · roll call no. 12232 · · ✓ Adopted

Frais de formation et de perfectionnement. Imposition des frais. Loi — Loi fédérale sur l’imposition des frais de formation et de perfectionnement à des fins professionnelles (Gesamtabstimmung)

On 5 March 2013, National Council: vote adopted, 131 for, 23 against, 33 abstentions.

Official record ↗ ≈ vote on the whole
Summarize with an AI

External tool, not official: nothing is sent until you click, and an AI can make mistakes. The prompt only contains public data from this page. For tools that cannot be pre-filled, the prompt is copied: paste it.

Type of vote
Gesamtabstimmung
Voters
187
1 non-voting
Votes cast
154
for + against (excluding abstentions)

131 for 23 against 33 abstentions

Colour by:
Verts — 15 PS — 44 PVL — 10 Centre — 28 PBD — 8 PLR — 29 UDC — 55 - — 1 VertsPSPVLCentrePBDPLRUDC Yvonne Gilli (Verts) — For Bastien Girod (Verts) — Abstention Balthasar Glättli (Verts) — Against Maya Graf (Verts) — Non-voting Antonio Hodgers (Verts) — Against Francine John-Calame (Verts) — Against Ueli Leuenberger (Verts) — Against Geri Müller (Verts) — Against Regula Rytz (Verts) — Abstention Louis Schelbert (Verts) — Against Adèle Thorens Goumaz (Verts) — Abstention Aline Trede (Verts) — Against Daniel Vischer (Verts) — Against Christian van Singer (Verts) — Against Alec von Graffenried (Verts) — For Matthias Aebischer (PS) — Abstention Evi Allemann (PS) — Abstention Cesla Amarelle (PS) — Abstention Josiane Aubert (PS) — Abstention Jacqueline Badran (PS) — Abstention Maria Bernasconi (PS) — Absent Prisca Birrer-Heimo (PS) — Against Marina Carobbio Guscetti (PS) — Abstention Max Chopard-Acklin (PS) — Abstention Hans-Jürg Fehr (PS) — Against Jacqueline Fehr (PS) — Abstention Yvonne Feri (PS) — For Pierre-Alain Fridez (PS) — Abstention Claudia Friedl (PS) — For Edith Graf-Litscher (PS) — For Andreas Gross (PS) — Abstention Barbara Gysi (PS) — Against Philipp Hadorn (PS) — Abstention Thomas Hardegger (PS) — Abstention Bea Heim (PS) — For Beat Jans (PS) — Abstention Daniel Jositsch (PS) — For Margret Kiener Nellen (PS) — Against Susanne Leutenegger Oberholzer (PS) — Abstention Jacques-André Maire (PS) — Abstention Ada Marra (PS) — Abstention Nadine Masshardt (PS) — Abstention Martin Naef (PS) — For Roger Nordmann (PS) — Abstention Eric Nussbaumer (PS) — Abstention Corrado Pardini (PS) — Against Valérie Piller Carrard (PS) — Abstention Mathias Reynard (PS) — Abstention Stéphane Rossini (PS) — Abstention Silvia Schenker (PS) — Abstention Ursula Schneider Schüttel (PS) — Abstention Jean Christophe Schwaab (PS) — Against Silva Semadeni (PS) — Abstention Carlo Sommaruga (PS) — Against Jean-François Steiert (PS) — Abstention Manuel Tornare (PS) — Abstention Alexander Tschäppät (PS) — Abstention Andy Tschümperlin (PS) — For Eric Voruz (PS) — Abstention Thomas Böhni (PVL) — Against Isabelle Chevalley (PVL) — For Roland Fischer (PVL) — Against Beat Flach (PVL) — Against Josias F. Gasser (PVL) — For Jürg Grossen (PVL) — Against Margrit Kessler (PVL) — Against Thomas Maier (PVL) — Against Tiana Angelina Moser (PVL) — Against Thomas Weibel (PVL) — Abstention Luc Barthassat (Centre) — For Christine Bulliard-Marbach (Centre) — For Yannick Buttet (Centre) — For Jakob Büchler (Centre) — For Martin Candinas (Centre) — For Christophe Darbellay (Centre) — For Ida Glanzmann-Hunkeler (Centre) — For Alois Gmür (Centre) — For Jean-Paul Gschwind (Centre) — For Ruth Humbel (Centre) — For Maja Ingold (Centre) — For Markus Lehmann (Centre) — For Christian Lohr (Centre) — For Ruedi Lustenberger (Centre) — For Lucrezia Meier-Schatz (Centre) — For Leo Müller (Centre) — For Stefan Müller-Altermatt (Centre) — For Jacques Neirynck (Centre) — For Gerhard Pfister (Centre) — For Fabio Regazzi (Centre) — For Kathy Riklin (Centre) — For Markus Ritter (Centre) — For Marco Romano (Centre) — For Urs Schläfli (Centre) — For Barbara Schmid-Federer (Centre) — For Marianne Streiff-Feller (Centre) — For Karl Vogler (Centre) — For Dominique de Buman (Centre) — For Urs Gasche (PBD) — For Bernhard Guhl (PBD) — For Ursula Haller Vannini (PBD) — For Hansjörg Hassler (PBD) — For Lorenz Hess (PBD) — For Martin Landolt (PBD) — For Rosmarie Quadranti (PBD) — For Lothar Ziörjen (PBD) — For Jacques Bourgeois (PLR) — For Andrea Caroni (PLR) — For Ignazio Cassis (PLR) — For Fathi Derder (PLR) — For Corina Eichenberger-Walther (PLR) — For Laurent Favre (PLR) — For Olivier Feller (PLR) — For Doris Fiala (PLR) — For Kurt Fluri (PLR) — For Olivier Français (PLR) — For Jean-René Germanier (PLR) — For Petra Gössi (PLR) — For Hugues Hiltpold (PLR) — For Gabi Huber (PLR) — For Markus Hutter (PLR) — For Filippo Leutenegger (PLR) — For Christian Lüscher (PLR) — For Christa Markwalder (PLR) — For Isabelle Moret (PLR) — For Philipp Müller (PLR) — For Walter Müller (PLR) — For Ruedi Noser (PLR) — For Fulvio Pelli (PLR) — For Alain Ribaux (PLR) — For Peter Schilliger (PLR) — For Daniela Schneeberger (PLR) — For Daniel Stolz (PLR) — For Albert Vitali (PLR) — For Christian Wasserfallen (PLR) — For Andreas Aebi (UDC) — For Thomas Aeschi (UDC) — For Céline Amaudruz (UDC) — For Adrian Amstutz (UDC) — For Caspar Baader (UDC) — For Max Binder (UDC) — For Christoph Blocher (UDC) — For Roland F. Borer (UDC) — For Toni Bortoluzzi (UDC) — For Heinz Brand (UDC) — For Toni Brunner (UDC) — For André Bugnon (UDC) — For Roland Rino Büchel (UDC) — For Hans Egloff (UDC) — For Yvette Estermann (UDC) — For Hans Fehr (UDC) — For Sylvia Flückiger-Bäni (UDC) — For Sebastian Frehner (UDC) — For Oskar Freysinger (UDC) — For Andrea Martina Geissbühler (UDC) — For Ulrich Giezendanner (UDC) — For Jean-Pierre Grin (UDC) — For Markus Hausammann (UDC) — For Alfred Heer (UDC) — For Thomas Hurter (UDC) — For Rudolf Joder (UDC) — For Hans Kaufmann (UDC) — For Peter Keller (UDC) — For Hans Killer (UDC) — For Hansjörg Knecht (UDC) — For Christoph Mörgeli (UDC) — For Thomas Müller (UDC) — For Felix Müri (UDC) — For Yves Nidegger (UDC) — For Roberta Pantani (UDC) — For Guy Parmelin (UDC) — For Yvan Perrin (UDC) — For Lorenzo Quadri (UDC) — For Lukas Reimann (UDC) — For Maximilian Reimann (UDC) — For Natalie Rickli (UDC) — For Jean-François Rime (UDC) — For Pierre Rusconi (UDC) — For Gregor Rutz (UDC) — For Albert Rösti (UDC) — For Pirmin Schwander (UDC) — For Jürg Stahl (UDC) — For Luzi Stamm (UDC) — For Nadja Umbricht Pieren (UDC) — For Pierre-François Veillon (UDC) — Absent Hansjörg Walter (UDC) — For Hansruedi Wandfluh (UDC) — For Walter Wobmann (UDC) — For Thomas de Courten (UDC) — For Erich von Siebenthal (UDC) — For Mauro Poggia (-) — For

Official note: Vote of 2013-03-05 11:26, Session de printemps 2025. The source gives no totals or result: they are calculated by this site from the individual ballots.

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
Verts 293 1015
PS 7729 0144
PVL 271 0010
Centre 2800 0028
PBD 800 008
PLR 2900 0029
UDC 5400 0155
- 100 001

All National Councillors

National CouncillorGroupVote
Andreas Aebi UDC For
Matthias Aebischer PS Abstention
Thomas Aeschi UDC For
Evi Allemann PS Abstention
Cesla Amarelle PS Abstention
Céline Amaudruz UDC For
Adrian Amstutz UDC For
Josiane Aubert PS Abstention
Caspar Baader UDC For
Jacqueline Badran PS Abstention
Luc Barthassat Centre For
Maria Bernasconi PS Absent
Max Binder UDC For
Prisca Birrer-Heimo PS Against
Christoph Blocher UDC For
Thomas Böhni PVL Against
Roland F. Borer UDC For
Toni Bortoluzzi UDC For
Jacques Bourgeois PLR For
Heinz Brand UDC For
Toni Brunner UDC For
Roland Rino Büchel UDC For
Jakob Büchler Centre For
André Bugnon UDC For
Christine Bulliard-Marbach Centre For
Yannick Buttet Centre For
Martin Candinas Centre For
Marina Carobbio Guscetti PS Abstention
Andrea Caroni PLR For
Ignazio Cassis PLR For
Isabelle Chevalley PVL For
Max Chopard-Acklin PS Abstention
Christophe Darbellay Centre For
Dominique de Buman Centre For
Thomas de Courten UDC For
Fathi Derder PLR For
Hans Egloff UDC For
Corina Eichenberger-Walther PLR For
Yvette Estermann UDC For
Laurent Favre PLR For
Hans Fehr UDC For
Hans-Jürg Fehr PS Against
Jacqueline Fehr PS Abstention
Olivier Feller PLR For
Yvonne Feri PS For
Doris Fiala PLR For
Roland Fischer PVL Against
Beat Flach PVL Against
Sylvia Flückiger-Bäni UDC For
Kurt Fluri PLR For
Olivier Français PLR For
Sebastian Frehner UDC For
Oskar Freysinger UDC For
Pierre-Alain Fridez PS Abstention
Claudia Friedl PS For
Urs Gasche PBD For
Josias F. Gasser PVL For
Andrea Martina Geissbühler UDC For
Jean-René Germanier PLR For
Ulrich Giezendanner UDC For
Yvonne Gilli Verts For
Bastien Girod Verts Abstention
Ida Glanzmann-Hunkeler Centre For
Balthasar Glättli Verts Against
Alois Gmür Centre For
Petra Gössi PLR For
Maya Graf Verts Non-voting
Edith Graf-Litscher PS For
Jean-Pierre Grin UDC For
Andreas Gross PS Abstention
Jürg Grossen PVL Against
Jean-Paul Gschwind Centre For
Bernhard Guhl PBD For
Barbara Gysi PS Against
Philipp Hadorn PS Abstention
Ursula Haller Vannini PBD For
Thomas Hardegger PS Abstention
Hansjörg Hassler PBD For
Markus Hausammann UDC For
Alfred Heer UDC For
Bea Heim PS For
Lorenz Hess PBD For
Hugues Hiltpold PLR For
Antonio Hodgers Verts Against
Gabi Huber PLR For
Ruth Humbel Centre For
Thomas Hurter UDC For
Markus Hutter PLR For
Maja Ingold Centre For
Beat Jans PS Abstention
Rudolf Joder UDC For
Francine John-Calame Verts Against
Daniel Jositsch PS For
Hans Kaufmann UDC For
Peter Keller UDC For
Margrit Kessler PVL Against
Margret Kiener Nellen PS Against
Hans Killer UDC For
Hansjörg Knecht UDC For
Martin Landolt PBD For
Markus Lehmann Centre For
Ueli Leuenberger Verts Against
Filippo Leutenegger PLR For
Susanne Leutenegger Oberholzer PS Abstention
Christian Lohr Centre For
Christian Lüscher PLR For
Ruedi Lustenberger Centre For
Thomas Maier PVL Against
Jacques-André Maire PS Abstention
Christa Markwalder PLR For
Ada Marra PS Abstention
Nadine Masshardt PS Abstention
Lucrezia Meier-Schatz Centre For
Isabelle Moret PLR For
Christoph Mörgeli UDC For
Tiana Angelina Moser PVL Against
Geri Müller Verts Against
Leo Müller Centre For
Philipp Müller PLR For
Thomas Müller UDC For
Walter Müller PLR For
Stefan Müller-Altermatt Centre For
Felix Müri UDC For
Martin Naef PS For
Jacques Neirynck Centre For
Yves Nidegger UDC For
Roger Nordmann PS Abstention
Ruedi Noser PLR For
Eric Nussbaumer PS Abstention
Roberta Pantani UDC For
Corrado Pardini PS Against
Guy Parmelin UDC For
Fulvio Pelli PLR For
Yvan Perrin UDC For
Gerhard Pfister Centre For
Valérie Piller Carrard PS Abstention
Mauro Poggia - For
Rosmarie Quadranti PBD For
Lorenzo Quadri UDC For
Fabio Regazzi Centre For
Lukas Reimann UDC For
Maximilian Reimann UDC For
Mathias Reynard PS Abstention
Alain Ribaux PLR For
Natalie Rickli UDC For
Kathy Riklin Centre For
Jean-François Rime UDC For
Markus Ritter Centre For
Marco Romano Centre For
Stéphane Rossini PS Abstention
Albert Rösti UDC For
Pierre Rusconi UDC For
Gregor Rutz UDC For
Regula Rytz Verts Abstention
Louis Schelbert Verts Against
Silvia Schenker PS Abstention
Peter Schilliger PLR For
Urs Schläfli Centre For
Barbara Schmid-Federer Centre For
Daniela Schneeberger PLR For
Ursula Schneider Schüttel PS Abstention
Jean Christophe Schwaab PS Against
Pirmin Schwander UDC For
Silva Semadeni PS Abstention
Carlo Sommaruga PS Against
Jürg Stahl UDC For
Luzi Stamm UDC For
Jean-François Steiert PS Abstention
Daniel Stolz PLR For
Marianne Streiff-Feller Centre For
Adèle Thorens Goumaz Verts Abstention
Manuel Tornare PS Abstention
Aline Trede Verts Against
Alexander Tschäppät PS Abstention
Andy Tschümperlin PS For
Nadja Umbricht Pieren UDC For
Christian van Singer Verts Against
Pierre-François Veillon UDC Absent
Daniel Vischer Verts Against
Albert Vitali PLR For
Karl Vogler Centre For
Alec von Graffenried Verts For
Erich von Siebenthal UDC For
Eric Voruz PS Abstention
Hansjörg Walter UDC For
Hansruedi Wandfluh UDC For
Christian Wasserfallen PLR For
Thomas Weibel PVL Abstention
Walter Wobmann UDC For
Lothar Ziörjen PBD For