← All votes

National Council · roll call no. 32080 · · ✗ Rejected

Obligation pour les héritiers de restituer des prestations conformément à l'article 16a LPC

On 7 March 2024, National Council: vote rejected, 57 for, 117 against, 13 abstentions.

Official record ↗
Summarize with an AI

External tool, not official: nothing is sent until you click, and an AI can make mistakes. The prompt only contains public data from this page. For tools that cannot be pre-filled, the prompt is copied: paste it.

Type of vote
Roll-call vote
Voters
187
1 non-voting
Votes cast
174
for + against (excluding abstentions)

57 for 117 against 13 abstentions

Colour by:
Verts — 23 PS — 41 PVL — 10 Centre — 31 PLR — 28 UDC — 67 VertsPSPVLCentrePLRUDC Gerhard Andrey (Verts) — For Sibel Arslan (Verts) — For Christine Badertscher (Verts) — Abstention Kilian Baumann (Verts) — For Florence Brenzikofer (Verts) — Abstention Christophe Clivaz (Verts) — Abstention Fabien Fivaz (Verts) — For Bastien Girod (Verts) — For Balthasar Glättli (Verts) — Absent Greta Gysin (Verts) — Abstention Delphine Klopfenstein Broggini (Verts) — For Irène Kälin (Verts) — For Raphaël Mahaim (Verts) — For Sophie Michaud Gigon (Verts) — Abstention Léonore Porchet (Verts) — For Katharina Prelicz-Huber (Verts) — Absent Franziska Ryser (Verts) — Absent Marionna Schlatter (Verts) — For Aline Trede (Verts) — Abstention Michael Töngi (Verts) — Abstention Nicolas Walder (Verts) — For Manuela Weichelt (Verts) — For Felix Wettstein (Verts) — For Matthias Aebischer (PS) — Absent Islam Alijaj (PS) — For Emmanuel Amoos (PS) — For Jacqueline Badran (PS) — Absent Samuel Bendahan (PS) — For Simona Brizzi (PS) — For Hasan Candan (PS) — For Brigitte Crottaz (PS) — For Christian Dandrès (PS) — For Martine Docourt (PS) — For Laurence Fehlmann Rielle (PS) — For Pierre-Alain Fridez (PS) — Absent Claudia Friedl (PS) — For Tamara Funiciello (PS) — For Barbara Gysi (PS) — For Jessica Jaccoud (PS) — For Min Li Marti (PS) — For Samira Marti (PS) — For Nadine Masshardt (PS) — For Mattea Meyer (PS) — For Fabian Molina (PS) — For Martina Munz (PS) — For Roger Nordmann (PS) — For Eric Nussbaumer (PS) — Non-voting Valérie Piller Carrard (PS) — For Jon Pult (PS) — For Estelle Revaz (PS) — For Anna Rosenwasser (PS) — For David Roth (PS) — For Farah Rumy (PS) — For Nina Schläfli (PS) — For Priska Seiler Graf (PS) — For Bruno Storni (PS) — For Gabriela Suter (PS) — For Jean Tschopp (PS) — For Brenda Tuosto (PS) — For Cédric Wermuth (PS) — For Céline Widmer (PS) — For Sarah Wyss (PS) — For Andrea Zryd (PS) — For Ursula Zybach (PS) — For Kathrin Bertschy (PVL) — Against Martin Bäumle (PVL) — Absent Katja Christ (PVL) — Against Beat Flach (PVL) — Against Corina Gredig (PVL) — Against Jürg Grossen (PVL) — Against Patrick Hässig (PVL) — Against Melanie Mettler (PVL) — Against Barbara Schaffner (PVL) — Against Céline Weber (PVL) — Against Maya Bally (Centre) — Against Nicole Barandun (Centre) — Against Dominik Blunschy (Centre) — Against Philipp Matthias Bregy (Centre) — Against Christine Bulliard-Marbach (Centre) — Against Yvonne Bürgin (Centre) — Against Martin Candinas (Centre) — Against Isabelle Chappuis (Centre) — Abstention Regina Durrer-Knobel (Centre) — Against Giorgio Fonio (Centre) — Abstention Niklaus-Samuel Gugger (Centre) — Abstention Lorenz Hess (Centre) — Against Marc Jost (Centre) — For Sidney Kamerzin (Centre) — For Pius Kaufmann (Centre) — Against Philipp Kutter (Centre) — Absent Christian Lohr (Centre) — Against Vincent Maitre (Centre) — Against Andreas Meier (Centre) — Against Leo Müller (Centre) — Against Stefan Müller-Altermatt (Centre) — Against Reto Nause (Centre) — Against Nicolò Paganini (Centre) — Against Gerhard Pfister (Centre) — Against Thomas Rechsteiner (Centre) — Against Markus Ritter (Centre) — Against Benjamin Roduit (Centre) — For Marie-France Roth Pasquier (Centre) — Against Elisabeth Schneider-Schneiter (Centre) — Against Simon Stadler (Centre) — Against Priska Wismer-Felder (Centre) — Against Cyril Aellen (PLR) — Against Bettina Balmer (PLR) — Against Damien Cottier (PLR) — Against Marcel Dobler (PLR) — Against Alex Farinelli (PLR) — Against Olivier Feller (PLR) — Against Anna Giacometti (PLR) — Against Simone Gianini (PLR) — Against Nadine Gobet (PLR) — Against Matthias Samuel Jauslin (PLR) — Against Simon Michel (PLR) — Against Philippe Nantermod (PLR) — Against Hans-Peter Portmann (PLR) — Against Maja Riniker (PLR) — Against Daniel Ruch (PLR) — Against Regine Sauter (PLR) — Against Peter Schilliger (PLR) — Against Daniela Schneeberger (PLR) — Abstention Andri Silberschmidt (PLR) — Against Heinz Theiler (PLR) — Against Kris Vietze (PLR) — Against Susanne Vincenz-Stauffacher (PLR) — Against Beat Walti (PLR) — Against Christian Wasserfallen (PLR) — Against Laurent Wehrli (PLR) — Abstention Simone de Montmollin (PLR) — Against Jacqueline de Quattro (PLR) — Absent Patricia von Falkenstein (PLR) — Against Jean-Luc Addor (UDC) — Against Thomas Aeschi (UDC) — Against Céline Amaudruz (UDC) — Against Martina Bircher (UDC) — Against Thomas Bläsi (UDC) — Against Michaël Buffat (UDC) — Against Thomas Burgherr (UDC) — Absent Roland Rino Büchel (UDC) — Against Manfred Bühler (UDC) — For Roman Bürgi (UDC) — Against Didier Calame (UDC) — Against Marcel Dettling (UDC) — Against Mike Egger (UDC) — Against Nina Fehr Düsel (UDC) — Against Benjamin Fischer (UDC) — Against Sylvain Freymond (UDC) — Against Andreas Gafner (UDC) — Against Walter Gartmann (UDC) — Against Benjamin Giezendanner (UDC) — Against Andreas Glarner (UDC) — Against Roger Golay (UDC) — Against Michael Graber (UDC) — Against Franz Grüter (UDC) — Against Lars Guggisberg (UDC) — Against Diana Gutjahr (UDC) — Against Michael Götte (UDC) — Against Martin Haab (UDC) — Against Alfred Heer (UDC) — Against Stefanie Heimgartner (UDC) — Against Erich Hess (UDC) — Against Alois Huber (UDC) — Against Roman Hug (UDC) — Against Thomas Hurter (UDC) — Against Martin Hübscher (UDC) — Against Christian Imark (UDC) — Against Thomas Knutti (UDC) — Against Nicolas Kolly (UDC) — Against Piero Marchesi (UDC) — Against Magdalena Martullo-Blocher (UDC) — Against Thomas Matter (UDC) — Against Jacques Nicolet (UDC) — Against Pierre-André Page (UDC) — Against Yvan Pahud (UDC) — Against Paolo Pamini (UDC) — Against Lorenzo Quadri (UDC) — For Lukas Reimann (UDC) — Against Christoph Riner (UDC) — Against Gregor Rutz (UDC) — Against Monika Rüegger (UDC) — Against Hans Jörg Rüegsegger (UDC) — Against Pascal Schmid (UDC) — Against Markus Schnyder (UDC) — Against Sandra Sollberger (UDC) — Against Daniel Sormanni (UDC) — Abstention Barbara Steinemann (UDC) — Against Thomas Stettler (UDC) — Against Katja Stettler-Riem (UDC) — Against Manuel Strupler (UDC) — Absent Vroni Thalmann-Bieri (UDC) — For Mauro Tuena (UDC) — Against Nadja Umbricht Pieren (UDC) — Against Erich Vontobel (UDC) — Against Bruno Walliser (UDC) — Against Ernst Wandfluh (UDC) — Absent Rémy Wyssmann (UDC) — Against David Zuberbühler (UDC) — Against Thomas de Courten (UDC) — For

Official note: Vote of 2024-03-07 12:40, Session de printemps 2024. The source gives no totals or result: they are calculated by this site from the individual ballots.

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
Verts 1307 0323
PS 3700 1341
PVL 090 0110
Centre 3243 0131
PLR 0252 0128
UDC 4591 0367

All National Councillors

National CouncillorGroupVote
Jean-Luc Addor UDC Against
Matthias Aebischer PS Absent
Cyril Aellen PLR Against
Thomas Aeschi UDC Against
Islam Alijaj PS For
Céline Amaudruz UDC Against
Emmanuel Amoos PS For
Gerhard Andrey Verts For
Sibel Arslan Verts For
Christine Badertscher Verts Abstention
Jacqueline Badran PS Absent
Maya Bally Centre Against
Bettina Balmer PLR Against
Nicole Barandun Centre Against
Kilian Baumann Verts For
Martin Bäumle PVL Absent
Samuel Bendahan PS For
Kathrin Bertschy PVL Against
Martina Bircher UDC Against
Thomas Bläsi UDC Against
Dominik Blunschy Centre Against
Philipp Matthias Bregy Centre Against
Florence Brenzikofer Verts Abstention
Simona Brizzi PS For
Roland Rino Büchel UDC Against
Michaël Buffat UDC Against
Manfred Bühler UDC For
Christine Bulliard-Marbach Centre Against
Thomas Burgherr UDC Absent
Roman Bürgi UDC Against
Yvonne Bürgin Centre Against
Didier Calame UDC Against
Hasan Candan PS For
Martin Candinas Centre Against
Isabelle Chappuis Centre Abstention
Katja Christ PVL Against
Christophe Clivaz Verts Abstention
Damien Cottier PLR Against
Brigitte Crottaz PS For
Christian Dandrès PS For
Thomas de Courten UDC For
Simone de Montmollin PLR Against
Jacqueline de Quattro PLR Absent
Marcel Dettling UDC Against
Marcel Dobler PLR Against
Martine Docourt PS For
Regina Durrer-Knobel Centre Against
Mike Egger UDC Against
Alex Farinelli PLR Against
Laurence Fehlmann Rielle PS For
Nina Fehr Düsel UDC Against
Olivier Feller PLR Against
Benjamin Fischer UDC Against
Fabien Fivaz Verts For
Beat Flach PVL Against
Giorgio Fonio Centre Abstention
Sylvain Freymond UDC Against
Pierre-Alain Fridez PS Absent
Claudia Friedl PS For
Tamara Funiciello PS For
Andreas Gafner UDC Against
Walter Gartmann UDC Against
Anna Giacometti PLR Against
Simone Gianini PLR Against
Benjamin Giezendanner UDC Against
Bastien Girod Verts For
Andreas Glarner UDC Against
Balthasar Glättli Verts Absent
Nadine Gobet PLR Against
Roger Golay UDC Against
Michael Götte UDC Against
Michael Graber UDC Against
Corina Gredig PVL Against
Jürg Grossen PVL Against
Franz Grüter UDC Against
Niklaus-Samuel Gugger Centre Abstention
Lars Guggisberg UDC Against
Diana Gutjahr UDC Against
Barbara Gysi PS For
Greta Gysin Verts Abstention
Martin Haab UDC Against
Patrick Hässig PVL Against
Alfred Heer UDC Against
Stefanie Heimgartner UDC Against
Erich Hess UDC Against
Lorenz Hess Centre Against
Alois Huber UDC Against
Martin Hübscher UDC Against
Roman Hug UDC Against
Thomas Hurter UDC Against
Christian Imark UDC Against
Jessica Jaccoud PS For
Matthias Samuel Jauslin PLR Against
Marc Jost Centre For
Irène Kälin Verts For
Sidney Kamerzin Centre For
Pius Kaufmann Centre Against
Delphine Klopfenstein Broggini Verts For
Thomas Knutti UDC Against
Nicolas Kolly UDC Against
Philipp Kutter Centre Absent
Christian Lohr Centre Against
Raphaël Mahaim Verts For
Vincent Maitre Centre Against
Piero Marchesi UDC Against
Min Li Marti PS For
Samira Marti PS For
Magdalena Martullo-Blocher UDC Against
Nadine Masshardt PS For
Thomas Matter UDC Against
Andreas Meier Centre Against
Melanie Mettler PVL Against
Mattea Meyer PS For
Sophie Michaud Gigon Verts Abstention
Simon Michel PLR Against
Fabian Molina PS For
Leo Müller Centre Against
Stefan Müller-Altermatt Centre Against
Martina Munz PS For
Philippe Nantermod PLR Against
Reto Nause Centre Against
Jacques Nicolet UDC Against
Roger Nordmann PS For
Eric Nussbaumer PS Non-voting
Nicolò Paganini Centre Against
Pierre-André Page UDC Against
Yvan Pahud UDC Against
Paolo Pamini UDC Against
Gerhard Pfister Centre Against
Valérie Piller Carrard PS For
Léonore Porchet Verts For
Hans-Peter Portmann PLR Against
Katharina Prelicz-Huber Verts Absent
Jon Pult PS For
Lorenzo Quadri UDC For
Thomas Rechsteiner Centre Against
Lukas Reimann UDC Against
Estelle Revaz PS For
Christoph Riner UDC Against
Maja Riniker PLR Against
Markus Ritter Centre Against
Benjamin Roduit Centre For
Anna Rosenwasser PS For
David Roth PS For
Marie-France Roth Pasquier Centre Against
Daniel Ruch PLR Against
Monika Rüegger UDC Against
Hans Jörg Rüegsegger UDC Against
Farah Rumy PS For
Gregor Rutz UDC Against
Franziska Ryser Verts Absent
Regine Sauter PLR Against
Barbara Schaffner PVL Against
Peter Schilliger PLR Against
Nina Schläfli PS For
Marionna Schlatter Verts For
Pascal Schmid UDC Against
Daniela Schneeberger PLR Abstention
Elisabeth Schneider-Schneiter Centre Against
Markus Schnyder UDC Against
Priska Seiler Graf PS For
Andri Silberschmidt PLR Against
Sandra Sollberger UDC Against
Daniel Sormanni UDC Abstention
Simon Stadler Centre Against
Barbara Steinemann UDC Against
Thomas Stettler UDC Against
Katja Stettler-Riem UDC Against
Bruno Storni PS For
Manuel Strupler UDC Absent
Gabriela Suter PS For
Vroni Thalmann-Bieri UDC For
Heinz Theiler PLR Against
Michael Töngi Verts Abstention
Aline Trede Verts Abstention
Jean Tschopp PS For
Mauro Tuena UDC Against
Brenda Tuosto PS For
Nadja Umbricht Pieren UDC Against
Kris Vietze PLR Against
Susanne Vincenz-Stauffacher PLR Against
Patricia von Falkenstein PLR Against
Erich Vontobel UDC Against
Nicolas Walder Verts For
Bruno Walliser UDC Against
Beat Walti PLR Against
Ernst Wandfluh UDC Absent
Christian Wasserfallen PLR Against
Céline Weber PVL Against
Laurent Wehrli PLR Abstention
Manuela Weichelt Verts For
Cédric Wermuth PS For
Felix Wettstein Verts For
Céline Widmer PS For
Priska Wismer-Felder Centre Against
Sarah Wyss PS For
Rémy Wyssmann UDC Against
Andrea Zryd PS For
David Zuberbühler UDC Against
Ursula Zybach PS For