← All votes

National Assembly · vote no. 1533 · · ✓ Adopted

The entire draft law on speeding up procedures for the construction of new nuclear facilities in the vicinity of existing nuclear sites and the operation of existing facilities (text of the Joint Joint Committee).

≈ automatic translation Official title: Projet de loi relatif à l'accélération des procédures liées à la construction de nouvelles installations nucléaires à proximité de sites nucléaires existants et au fonctionnement des installations existantes (texte de la commission mixte paritaire)

Promulgated after partial censure by the Constitutional Council See this text's full journey →

Promulgated on 22 June 2023 Published in the Official Journal on 23 June 2023 Law no. 2023-491 Constitutional Council: partiellement conforme Text on Légifrance ↗ Legislative file ↗

Type of vote
Solemn roll-call vote
Voters
538
1 non-voting
Votes cast
499
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
250 votes
Majorité absolue des suffrages exprimés

399 for 100 against 39 abstentions ▏threshold : 250 votes

Colour by:
LFI-NUPES — 75 GDR-NUPES — 22 ECOLO — 23 SOC — 31 LIOT — 21 DEM — 51 RE — 171 HOR — 29 LR — 62 RN — 88 NI — 4 LFI-NUPESGDR-NUPESECOLOSOCDEMREHORLRRN Nadège Abomangoli (LFI-NUPES) — Against Laurent Alexandre (LFI-NUPES) — Against Gabriel Amard (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Ségolène Amiot (LFI-NUPES) — Against Farida Amrani (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Rodrigo Arenas (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Clémentine Autain (LFI-NUPES) — Against Ugo Bernalicis (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Christophe Bex (LFI-NUPES) — Against Carlos Martens Bilongo (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Manuel Bompard (LFI-NUPES) — Against Idir Boumertit (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Louis Boyard (LFI-NUPES) — Against Aymeric Caron (LFI-NUPES) — Against Sylvain Carrière (LFI-NUPES) — Against Florian Chauche (LFI-NUPES) — Against Sophia Chikirou (LFI-NUPES) — Against Hadrien Clouet (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Éric Coquerel (LFI-NUPES) — Against Alexis Corbière (LFI-NUPES) — Against Jean-François Coulomme (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Catherine Couturier (LFI-NUPES) — Against Hendrik Davi (LFI-NUPES) — Against Sébastien Delogu (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Alma Dufour (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Karen Erodi (LFI-NUPES) — Against Martine Etienne (LFI-NUPES) — Against Emmanuel Fernandes (LFI-NUPES) — Against Sylvie Ferrer (LFI-NUPES) — Against Caroline Fiat (LFI-NUPES) — Against Perceval Gaillard (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Raquel Garrido (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Clémence Guetté (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy David Guiraud (LFI-NUPES) — Against Mathilde Hignet (LFI-NUPES) — Against Rachel Keke (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Andy Kerbrat (LFI-NUPES) — Against Bastien Lachaud (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Maxime Laisney (LFI-NUPES) — Against Arnaud Le Gall (LFI-NUPES) — Against Élise Leboucher (LFI-NUPES) — Against Charlotte Leduc (LFI-NUPES) — Against Jérôme Legavre (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Sarah Legrain (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Murielle Lepvraud (LFI-NUPES) — Against Antoine Léaument (LFI-NUPES) — Against Pascale Martin (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Élisa Martin (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy William Martinet (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Frédéric Mathieu (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Damien Maudet (LFI-NUPES) — Against Marianne Maximi (LFI-NUPES) — Against Manon Meunier (LFI-NUPES) — Against Jean-Philippe Nilor (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Danièle Obono (LFI-NUPES) — Against Nathalie Oziol (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Mathilde Panot (LFI-NUPES) — Against René Pilato (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy François Piquemal (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Thomas Portes (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Loïc Prud'homme (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Adrien Quatennens (LFI-NUPES) — Against Jean-Hugues Ratenon (LFI-NUPES) — Against Sébastien Rome (LFI-NUPES) — Against François Ruffin (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Aurélien Saintoul (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Michel Sala (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Danielle Simonnet (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Ersilia Soudais (LFI-NUPES) — Against Anne Stambach-Terrenoir (LFI-NUPES) — Against Andrée Taurinya (LFI-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Matthias Tavel (LFI-NUPES) — Against Aurélie Trouvé (LFI-NUPES) — Against Paul Vannier (LFI-NUPES) — Against Léo Walter (LFI-NUPES) — Against Soumya Bourouaha (GDR-NUPES) — Abstention Moetai Brotherson (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Jean-Victor Castor (GDR-NUPES) — Abstention — by proxy Steve Chailloux (GDR-NUPES) — Absent André Chassaigne (GDR-NUPES) — For Pierre Dharréville (GDR-NUPES) — For Elsa Faucillon (GDR-NUPES) — Against Sébastien Jumel (GDR-NUPES) — For Émeline K/Bidi (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Tematai Le Gayic (GDR-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Karine Lebon (GDR-NUPES) — Against — by proxy Jean-Paul Lecoq (GDR-NUPES) — Against Frédéric Maillot (GDR-NUPES) — Abstention — by proxy Yannick Monnet (GDR-NUPES) — For Marcellin Nadeau (GDR-NUPES) — Abstention Stéphane Peu (GDR-NUPES) — For Davy Rimane (GDR-NUPES) — For — by proxy Fabien Roussel (GDR-NUPES) — For — by proxy Nicolas Sansu (GDR-NUPES) — For Jean-Marc Tellier (GDR-NUPES) — For — by proxy Jiovanny William (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Hubert Wulfranc (GDR-NUPES) — For Christine Arrighi (ECOLO) — Against — by proxy Delphine Batho (ECOLO) — Against — by proxy Julien Bayou (ECOLO) — Against Lisa Belluco (ECOLO) — Against Karim Ben Cheikh (ECOLO) — Against Cyrielle Chatelain (ECOLO) — Against Charles Fournier (ECOLO) — Against Marie-Charlotte Garin (ECOLO) — Against — by proxy Jérémie Iordanoff (ECOLO) — Against Hubert Julien-Laferrière (ECOLO) — Against — by proxy Julie Laernoes (ECOLO) — Against Benjamin Lucas-Lundy (ECOLO) — Against Francesca Pasquini (ECOLO) — Against Sébastien Peytavie (ECOLO) — Against Marie Pochon (ECOLO) — Against Jean-Claude Raux (ECOLO) — Against Sandra Regol (ECOLO) — Against Sandrine Rousseau (ECOLO) — Against Eva Sas (ECOLO) — Against Sabrina Sebaihi (ECOLO) — Against Aurélien Taché (ECOLO) — Against — by proxy Sophie Taillé-Polian (ECOLO) — Against Nicolas Thierry (ECOLO) — Against Joël Aviragnet (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Christian Baptiste (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Marie-Noëlle Battistel (SOC) — Abstention Mickaël Bouloux (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Philippe Brun (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Elie Califer (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Alain David (SOC) — Abstention Arthur Delaporte (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Stéphane Delautrette (SOC) — Abstention Iñaki Echaniz (SOC) — Abstention Olivier Faure (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Guillaume Garot (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Jérôme Guedj (SOC) — Abstention Johnny Hajjar (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Chantal Jourdan (SOC) — Absent Marietta Karamanli (SOC) — Abstention Fatiha Keloua Hachi (SOC) — Abstention Gérard Leseul (SOC) — Abstention Philippe Naillet (SOC) — Abstention Bertrand Petit (SOC) — Abstention Anna Pic (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Christine Pirès Beaune (SOC) — Abstention Dominique Potier (SOC) — Abstention Valérie Rabault (SOC) — Abstention Claudia Rouaux (SOC) — Abstention Isabelle Santiago (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Hervé Saulignac (SOC) — Abstention Mélanie Thomin (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Cécile Untermaier (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Boris Vallaud (SOC) — Abstention Roger Vicot (SOC) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-Félix Acquaviva (LIOT) — Abstention Nathalie Bassire (LIOT) — For — by proxy Guy Bricout (LIOT) — For Jean-Louis Bricout (LIOT) — For Michel Castellani (LIOT) — Abstention Paul-André Colombani (LIOT) — Abstention Béatrice Descamps (LIOT) — For Martine Froger (LIOT) — For — by proxy Stéphane Lenormand (LIOT) — For — by proxy Max Mathiasin (LIOT) — Abstention — by proxy Paul Molac (LIOT) — Abstention Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier (LIOT) — For — by proxy Christophe Naegelen (LIOT) — For — by proxy Bertrand Pancher (LIOT) — For Laurent Panifous (LIOT) — For Benjamin Saint-Huile (LIOT) — For Olivier Serva (LIOT) — Absent David Taupiac (LIOT) — For Jean-Luc Warsmann (LIOT) — For — by proxy Estelle Youssouffa (LIOT) — For — by proxy Charles de Courson (LIOT) — For Anne-Laure Babault (DEM) — For — by proxy Erwan Balanant (DEM) — For Géraldine Bannier (DEM) — For — by proxy Anne Bergantz (DEM) — For Philippe Berta (DEM) — For Christophe Blanchet (DEM) — For Philippe Bolo (DEM) — For — by proxy Jean-Louis Bourlanges (DEM) — Absent Blandine Brocard (DEM) — Absent Vincent Bru (DEM) — For — by proxy Mickaël Cosson (DEM) — Absent Laurent Croizier (DEM) — For Jean-Pierre Cubertafon (DEM) — For — by proxy Romain Daubié (DEM) — For Mathilde Desjonquères (DEM) — For Laurent Esquenet-Goxes (DEM) — Absent Olivier Falorni (DEM) — For Marina Ferrari (DEM) — For Estelle Folest (DEM) — For Bruno Fuchs (DEM) — For — by proxy Maud Gatel (DEM) — For — by proxy Luc Geismar (DEM) — For Perrine Goulet (DEM) — Absent Frantz Gumbs (DEM) — For Cyrille Isaac-Sibille (DEM) — For Élodie Jacquier-Laforge (DEM) — Non-voting Sandrine Josso (DEM) — Absent Fabien Lainé (DEM) — For — by proxy Mohamed Laqhila (DEM) — For Florence Lasserre (DEM) — For Philippe Latombe (DEM) — Absent Pascal Lecamp (DEM) — For Delphine Lingemann (DEM) — For Aude Luquet (DEM) — For Emmanuel Mandon (DEM) — Absent Éric Martineau (DEM) — For Jean-Paul Mattei (DEM) — For Sophie Mette (DEM) — For Bruno Millienne (DEM) — For Louise Morel (DEM) — For Hubert Ott (DEM) — Against Jimmy Pahun (DEM) — Absent Frédéric Petit (DEM) — For Maud Petit (DEM) — For Josy Poueyto (DEM) — For — by proxy Richard Ramos (DEM) — For — by proxy Sabine Thillaye (DEM) — For Nicolas Turquois (DEM) — For Laurence Vichnievsky (DEM) — For — by proxy Philippe Vigier (DEM) — For Frédéric Zgainski (DEM) — For Damien Abad (RE) — For Caroline Abadie (RE) — Absent Damien Adam (RE) — For Sabrina Agresti-Roubache (RE) — For Éric Alauzet (RE) — For — by proxy David Amiel (RE) — For Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade (RE) — Absent Jean-Philippe Ardouin (RE) — For Antoine Armand (RE) — For — by proxy Quentin Bataillon (RE) — For Xavier Batut (RE) — For Belkhir Belhaddad (RE) — For Mounir Belhamiti (RE) — For Fanta Berete (RE) — For Aurore Bergé (RE) — For Benoît Bordat (RE) — For Éric Bothorel (RE) — For — by proxy Florent Boudié (RE) — Absent Chantal Bouloux (RE) — For Bertrand Bouyx (RE) — For — by proxy Pascale Boyer (RE) — For — by proxy Yaël Braun-Pivet (RE) — Absent Maud Bregeon (RE) — For Anthony Brosse (RE) — For Anne Brugnera (RE) — For — by proxy Danielle Brulebois (RE) — For Stéphane Buchou (RE) — For Françoise Buffet (RE) — For Céline Calvez (RE) — For — by proxy Eléonore Caroit (RE) — For Lionel Causse (RE) — For Thomas Cazenave (RE) — For Jean-René Cazeneuve (RE) — For Pierre Cazeneuve (RE) — For Émilie Chandler (RE) — For Clara Chassaniol (RE) — For Yannick Chenevard (RE) — For — by proxy Mireille Clapot (RE) — For Fabienne Colboc (RE) — For Claire Colomb-Pitollat (RE) — Absent François Cormier-Bouligeon (RE) — For — by proxy Laurence Cristol (RE) — For — by proxy Dominique Da Silva (RE) — For Christine Decodts (RE) — For Julie Delpech (RE) — For Frédéric Descrozaille (RE) — For — by proxy Benjamin Dirx (RE) — For Nicole Dubré-Chirat (RE) — For Philippe Dunoyer (RE) — For — by proxy Stella Dupont (RE) — For Sophie Errante (RE) — For — by proxy Philippe Fait (RE) — For Marc Ferracci (RE) — For — by proxy Jean-Marie Fiévet (RE) — For Jean-Luc Fugit (RE) — For Thomas Gassilloud (RE) — For Anne Genetet (RE) — For — by proxy Hadrien Ghomi (RE) — For — by proxy Éric Girardin (RE) — For Joël Giraud (RE) — For — by proxy Olga Givernet (RE) — For Charlotte Goetschy-Bolognese (RE) — For Guillaume Gouffier Valente (RE) — For Jean-Carles Grelier (RE) — For Claire Guichard (RE) — For Philippe Guillemard (RE) — For Marie Guévenoux (RE) — For Raphaël Gérard (RE) — For — by proxy Benjamin Haddad (RE) — For — by proxy Nadia Hai (RE) — For Yannick Haury (RE) — For Pierre Henriet (RE) — For — by proxy Laurence Heydel Grillere (RE) — For Alexandre Holroyd (RE) — For Sacha Houlié (RE) — For — by proxy Servane Hugues (RE) — For Monique Iborra (RE) — For Alexis Izard (RE) — For Jean-Michel Jacques (RE) — For — by proxy Caroline Janvier (RE) — For — by proxy Guillaume Kasbarian (RE) — For Fadila Khattabi (RE) — For Brigitte Klinkert (RE) — For Daniel Labaronne (RE) — For Emmanuel Lacresse (RE) — For Amélia Lakrafi (RE) — For — by proxy Michel Lauzzana (RE) — For Pascal Lavergne (RE) — For Sandrine Le Feur (RE) — For Didier Le Gac (RE) — For — by proxy Gilles Le Gendre (RE) — For Constance Le Grip (RE) — For Annaïg Le Meur (RE) — For Christine Le Nabour (RE) — For Nicole Le Peih (RE) — For — by proxy Fabrice Le Vigoureux (RE) — For Marie Lebec (RE) — For Vincent Ledoux (RE) — For — by proxy Mathieu Lefèvre (RE) — For Patricia Lemoine (RE) — Absent Brigitte Liso (RE) — For Jean-François Lovisolo (RE) — For Sylvain Maillard (RE) — For Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie (RE) — For Jacqueline Maquet (RE) — For Bastien Marchive (RE) — For Louis Margueritte (RE) — For Christophe Marion (RE) — For Sandra Marsaud (RE) — For — by proxy Didier Martin (RE) — For Denis Masséglia (RE) — For Stéphane Mazars (RE) — For Graziella Melchior (RE) — For Ludovic Mendes (RE) — For — by proxy Nicolas Metzdorf (RE) — For Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert (RE) — For Paul Midy (RE) — For — by proxy Laure Miller (RE) — For Benoit Mournet (RE) — For Lysiane Métayer (RE) — For Karl Olive (RE) — For Nicolas Pacquot (RE) — For Sophie Panonacle (RE) — For Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet (RE) — For Didier Paris (RE) — For — by proxy Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq (RE) — For Emmanuel Pellerin (RE) — For Patrice Perrot (RE) — For — by proxy Anne-Laurence Petel (RE) — For Michèle Peyron (RE) — Absent Béatrice Piron (RE) — Absent Barbara Pompili (RE) — For — by proxy Jean-Pierre Pont (RE) — For Éric Poulliat (RE) — For — by proxy Natalia Pouzyreff (RE) — For — by proxy Rémy Rebeyrotte (RE) — For Robin Reda (RE) — For Cécile Rilhac (RE) — For Véronique Riotton (RE) — For — by proxy Stéphanie Rist (RE) — For Marie-Pierre Rixain (RE) — For — by proxy Charles Rodwell (RE) — For Xavier Roseren (RE) — For Jean-François Rousset (RE) — For Lionel Royer-Perreaut (RE) — For — by proxy Thomas Rudigoz (RE) — For Laetitia Saint-Paul (RE) — For Mikaele Seo (RE) — For — by proxy Freddy Sertin (RE) — For Charles Sitzenstuhl (RE) — Absent Philippe Sorez (RE) — For — by proxy Bertrand Sorre (RE) — For Violette Spillebout (RE) — Absent Bruno Studer (RE) — For — by proxy Liliana Tanguy (RE) — For — by proxy Sarah Tanzilli (RE) — For Jean Terlier (RE) — For Prisca Thevenot (RE) — For — by proxy Huguette Tiegna (RE) — For — by proxy Stéphane Travert (RE) — For David Valence (RE) — For Annie Vidal (RE) — For — by proxy Patrick Vignal (RE) — For — by proxy Corinne Vignon (RE) — For Stéphane Vojetta (RE) — For Lionel Vuibert (RE) — For Guillaume Vuilletet (RE) — Absent Christopher Weissberg (RE) — For — by proxy Éric Woerth (RE) — For — by proxy Caroline Yadan (RE) — For — by proxy Jean-Marc Zulesi (RE) — Absent Xavier Albertini (HOR) — For Henri Alfandari (HOR) — For — by proxy Béatrice Bellamy (HOR) — For Thierry Benoit (HOR) — For Agnès Carel (HOR) — For Paul Christophe (HOR) — For Yannick Favennec-Bécot (HOR) — For — by proxy François Gernigon (HOR) — For Félicie Gérard (HOR) — For François Jolivet (HOR) — For Loïc Kervran (HOR) — For Stéphanie Kochert (HOR) — For Luc Lamirault (HOR) — For Jean-Charles Larsonneur (HOR) — For Anne Le Hénanff (HOR) — For — by proxy Didier Lemaire (HOR) — For — by proxy Lise Magnier (HOR) — For Laurent Marcangeli (HOR) — For — by proxy Naïma Moutchou (HOR) — For Jérémie Patrier-Leitus (HOR) — For — by proxy Christophe Plassard (HOR) — For Jean-François Portarrieu (HOR) — For Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback (HOR) — For Philippe Pradal (HOR) — For Isabelle Rauch (HOR) — For — by proxy Vincent Thiébaut (HOR) — For Frédéric Valletoux (HOR) — For — by proxy André Villiers (HOR) — For Anne-Cécile Violland (HOR) — For — by proxy Emmanuelle Anthoine (LR) — For Thibault Bazin (LR) — For (vote correction) Valérie Bazin-Malgras (LR) — For Anne-Laure Blin (LR) — For Émilie Bonnivard (LR) — For Jean-Yves Bony (LR) — For Ian Boucard (LR) — For — by proxy Jean-Luc Bourgeaux (LR) — For Xavier Breton (LR) — For — by proxy Hubert Brigand (LR) — For Fabrice Brun (LR) — For Dino Cinieri (LR) — For Éric Ciotti (LR) — For — by proxy Pierre Cordier (LR) — For Josiane Corneloup (LR) — For Christelle D'Intorni (LR) — For — by proxy Marie-Christine Dalloz (LR) — For Vincent Descoeur (LR) — For Fabien Di Filippo (LR) — For Julien Dive (LR) — For Francis Dubois (LR) — For Virginie Duby-Muller (LR) — For Pierre-Henri Dumont (LR) — For — by proxy Nicolas Forissier (LR) — For Jean-Jacques Gaultier (LR) — For Annie Genevard (LR) — For — by proxy Philippe Gosselin (LR) — For Justine Gruet (LR) — For Victor Habert-Dassault (LR) — For Meyer Habib (LR) — For — by proxy Michel Herbillon (LR) — For — by proxy Patrick Hetzel (LR) — For — by proxy Philippe Juvin (LR) — For Mansour Kamardine (LR) — For — by proxy Marc Le Fur (LR) — For — by proxy Véronique Louwagie (LR) — For Emmanuel Maquet (LR) — For Olivier Marleix (LR) — For Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) (LR) — For Frédérique Meunier (LR) — For Maxime Minot (LR) — For Yannick Neuder (LR) — Absent Jérôme Nury (LR) — For Éric Pauget (LR) — For Christelle Petex (LR) — For — by proxy Alexandre Portier (LR) — Absent Aurélien Pradié (LR) — For — by proxy Isabelle Périgault (LR) — For Nicolas Ray (LR) — For Vincent Rolland (LR) — For Raphaël Schellenberger (LR) — For Vincent Seitlinger (LR) — For Nathalie Serre (LR) — For Michèle Tabarot (LR) — For Jean-Pierre Taite (LR) — For Jean-Louis Thiériot (LR) — For Isabelle Valentin (LR) — For Pierre Vatin (LR) — For Antoine Vermorel (LR) — For — by proxy Jean-Pierre Vigier (LR) — For Alexandre Vincendet (LR) — For Stéphane Viry (LR) — For — by proxy Franck Allisio (RN) — For Bénédicte Auzanot (RN) — For — by proxy Philippe Ballard (RN) — For Christophe Barthès (RN) — For Romain Baubry (RN) — For José Beaurain (RN) — Absent Christophe Bentz (RN) — For Pierrick Berteloot (RN) — Absent Bruno Bilde (RN) — For — by proxy Emmanuel Blairy (RN) — For Sophie Blanc (RN) — For — by proxy Frédéric Boccaletti (RN) — For — by proxy Pascale Bordes (RN) — For Jorys Bovet (RN) — For — by proxy Jérôme Buisson (RN) — For Frédéric Cabrolier (RN) — For Victor Catteau (RN) — For Sébastien Chenu (RN) — For — by proxy Roger Chudeau (RN) — For Caroline Colombier (RN) — For — by proxy Annick Cousin (RN) — For Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho (RN) — For — by proxy Jocelyn Dessigny (RN) — For Edwige Diaz (RN) — For Sandrine Dogor-Such (RN) — For Nicolas Dragon (RN) — For Christine Engrand (RN) — For Frédéric Falcon (RN) — For Thibaut François (RN) — For Thierry Frappé (RN) — For Stéphanie Galzy (RN) — For Frank Giletti (RN) — For Yoann Gillet (RN) — For Christian Girard (RN) — For — by proxy José Gonzalez (RN) — For Florence Goulet (RN) — For Géraldine Grangier (RN) — For Daniel Grenon (RN) — For Michel Guiniot (RN) — For Jordan Guitton (RN) — For — by proxy Marine Hamelet (RN) — For Timothée Houssin (RN) — For Joris Hébrard (RN) — For Laurent Jacobelli (RN) — For Alexis Jolly (RN) — For — by proxy Hélène Laporte (RN) — For — by proxy Laure Lavalette (RN) — For — by proxy Marine Le Pen (RN) — For Julie Lechanteux (RN) — For Gisèle Lelouis (RN) — For Katiana Levavasseur (RN) — For — by proxy Christine Loir (RN) — For Aurélien Lopez-Liguori (RN) — For Marie-France Lorho (RN) — For Philippe Lottiaux (RN) — For — by proxy Alexandre Loubet (RN) — For — by proxy Matthieu Marchio (RN) — For Michèle Martinez (RN) — For Alexandra Masson (RN) — For — by proxy Bryan Masson (RN) — For — by proxy Kévin Mauvieux (RN) — For Nicolas Meizonnet (RN) — For Pierre Meurin (RN) — For Serge Muller (RN) — For Joëlle Mélin (RN) — For Yaël Ménaché (RN) — For Thomas Ménagé (RN) — For Julien Odoul (RN) — Absent Mathilde Paris (RN) — For Caroline Parmentier (RN) — For Kévin Pfeffer (RN) — For — by proxy Lisette Pollet (RN) — For Stéphane Rambaud (RN) — For Angélique Ranc (RN) — For Julien Rancoule (RN) — For Laurence Robert-Dehault (RN) — For Béatrice Roullaud (RN) — Absent Anaïs Sabatini (RN) — For Alexandre Sabatou (RN) — For Emeric Salmon (RN) — For Philippe Schreck (RN) — For — by proxy Emmanuel Taché (RN) — For Jean-Philippe Tanguy (RN) — For Michaël Taverne (RN) — For Lionel Tivoli (RN) — For Antoine Villedieu (RN) — For Grégoire de Fournas (RN) — For Hervé de Lépinau (RN) — For Véronique Besse (NI) — For Nicolas Dupont-Aignan (NI) — For David Habib (NI) — Absent Emmanuelle Ménard (NI) — For

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
LFI-NUPES 0720 0375
GDR-NUPES 1044 0422
ECOLO 0230 0023
SOC 0030 0131
LIOT 1505 0121
DEM 4010 1951
RE 15900 012171
HOR 2900 0029
LR 6000 0262
RN 8400 0488
NI 300 014

All deputies

DeputyGroupVote
Damien Abad RE For
Caroline Abadie RE Absent
Nadège Abomangoli LFI-NUPES Against
Jean-Félix Acquaviva LIOT Abstention
Damien Adam RE For
Sabrina Agresti-Roubache RE For
Éric Alauzet RE For by proxy
Xavier Albertini HOR For
Laurent Alexandre LFI-NUPES Against
Henri Alfandari HOR For by proxy
Franck Allisio RN For
Gabriel Amard LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
David Amiel RE For
Ségolène Amiot LFI-NUPES Against
Farida Amrani LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade RE Absent
Emmanuelle Anthoine LR For
Jean-Philippe Ardouin RE For
Rodrigo Arenas LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Antoine Armand RE For by proxy
Christine Arrighi ECOLO Against by proxy
Clémentine Autain LFI-NUPES Against
Bénédicte Auzanot RN For by proxy
Joël Aviragnet SOC Abstention by proxy
Anne-Laure Babault DEM For by proxy
Erwan Balanant DEM For
Philippe Ballard RN For
Géraldine Bannier DEM For by proxy
Christian Baptiste SOC Abstention by proxy
Christophe Barthès RN For
Nathalie Bassire LIOT For by proxy
Quentin Bataillon RE For
Delphine Batho ECOLO Against by proxy
Marie-Noëlle Battistel SOC Abstention
Xavier Batut RE For
Romain Baubry RN For
Julien Bayou ECOLO Against
Thibault Bazin LR For corrected (originally: absent)
Valérie Bazin-Malgras LR For
José Beaurain RN Absent
Belkhir Belhaddad RE For
Mounir Belhamiti RE For
Béatrice Bellamy HOR For
Lisa Belluco ECOLO Against
Karim Ben Cheikh ECOLO Against
Thierry Benoit HOR For
Christophe Bentz RN For
Fanta Berete RE For
Anne Bergantz DEM For
Aurore Bergé RE For
Ugo Bernalicis LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Philippe Berta DEM For
Pierrick Berteloot RN Absent
Véronique Besse NI For
Christophe Bex LFI-NUPES Against
Bruno Bilde RN For by proxy
Carlos Martens Bilongo LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Emmanuel Blairy RN For
Sophie Blanc RN For by proxy
Christophe Blanchet DEM For
Anne-Laure Blin LR For
Frédéric Boccaletti RN For by proxy
Philippe Bolo DEM For by proxy
Manuel Bompard LFI-NUPES Against
Émilie Bonnivard LR For
Jean-Yves Bony LR For
Benoît Bordat RE For
Pascale Bordes RN For
Éric Bothorel RE For by proxy
Ian Boucard LR For by proxy
Florent Boudié RE Absent
Chantal Bouloux RE For
Mickaël Bouloux SOC Abstention by proxy
Idir Boumertit LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Jean-Luc Bourgeaux LR For
Jean-Louis Bourlanges DEM Absent
Soumya Bourouaha GDR-NUPES Abstention
Bertrand Bouyx RE For by proxy
Jorys Bovet RN For by proxy
Louis Boyard LFI-NUPES Against
Pascale Boyer RE For by proxy
Yaël Braun-Pivet RE Absent
Maud Bregeon RE For
Xavier Breton LR For by proxy
Guy Bricout LIOT For
Jean-Louis Bricout LIOT For
Hubert Brigand LR For
Blandine Brocard DEM Absent
Anthony Brosse RE For
Moetai Brotherson GDR-NUPES Absent
Vincent Bru DEM For by proxy
Anne Brugnera RE For by proxy
Danielle Brulebois RE For
Fabrice Brun LR For
Philippe Brun SOC Abstention by proxy
Stéphane Buchou RE For
Françoise Buffet RE For
Jérôme Buisson RN For
Frédéric Cabrolier RN For
Elie Califer SOC Abstention by proxy
Céline Calvez RE For by proxy
Agnès Carel HOR For
Eléonore Caroit RE For
Aymeric Caron LFI-NUPES Against
Sylvain Carrière LFI-NUPES Against
Michel Castellani LIOT Abstention
Jean-Victor Castor GDR-NUPES Abstention by proxy
Victor Catteau RN For
Lionel Causse RE For
Thomas Cazenave RE For
Jean-René Cazeneuve RE For
Pierre Cazeneuve RE For
Steve Chailloux GDR-NUPES Absent
Émilie Chandler RE For
André Chassaigne GDR-NUPES For
Clara Chassaniol RE For
Cyrielle Chatelain ECOLO Against
Florian Chauche LFI-NUPES Against
Yannick Chenevard RE For by proxy
Sébastien Chenu RN For by proxy
Sophia Chikirou LFI-NUPES Against
Paul Christophe HOR For
Roger Chudeau RN For
Dino Cinieri LR For
Éric Ciotti LR For by proxy
Mireille Clapot RE For
Hadrien Clouet LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Fabienne Colboc RE For
Claire Colomb-Pitollat RE Absent
Paul-André Colombani LIOT Abstention
Caroline Colombier RN For by proxy
Éric Coquerel LFI-NUPES Against
Alexis Corbière LFI-NUPES Against
Pierre Cordier LR For
François Cormier-Bouligeon RE For by proxy
Josiane Corneloup LR For
Mickaël Cosson DEM Absent
Jean-François Coulomme LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Annick Cousin RN For
Catherine Couturier LFI-NUPES Against
Laurence Cristol RE For by proxy
Laurent Croizier DEM For
Jean-Pierre Cubertafon DEM For by proxy
Christelle D'Intorni LR For by proxy
Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho RN For by proxy
Dominique Da Silva RE For
Marie-Christine Dalloz LR For
Romain Daubié DEM For
Hendrik Davi LFI-NUPES Against
Alain David SOC Abstention
Charles de Courson LIOT For
Grégoire de Fournas RN For
Hervé de Lépinau RN For
Christine Decodts RE For
Arthur Delaporte SOC Abstention by proxy
Stéphane Delautrette SOC Abstention
Sébastien Delogu LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Julie Delpech RE For
Béatrice Descamps LIOT For
Vincent Descoeur LR For
Frédéric Descrozaille RE For by proxy
Mathilde Desjonquères DEM For
Jocelyn Dessigny RN For
Pierre Dharréville GDR-NUPES For
Fabien Di Filippo LR For
Edwige Diaz RN For
Benjamin Dirx RE For
Julien Dive LR For
Sandrine Dogor-Such RN For
Nicolas Dragon RN For
Francis Dubois LR For
Nicole Dubré-Chirat RE For
Virginie Duby-Muller LR For
Alma Dufour LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Pierre-Henri Dumont LR For by proxy
Philippe Dunoyer RE For by proxy
Stella Dupont RE For
Nicolas Dupont-Aignan NI For
Iñaki Echaniz SOC Abstention
Christine Engrand RN For
Karen Erodi LFI-NUPES Against
Sophie Errante RE For by proxy
Laurent Esquenet-Goxes DEM Absent
Martine Etienne LFI-NUPES Against
Philippe Fait RE For
Frédéric Falcon RN For
Olivier Falorni DEM For
Elsa Faucillon GDR-NUPES Against
Olivier Faure SOC Abstention by proxy
Yannick Favennec-Bécot HOR For by proxy
Emmanuel Fernandes LFI-NUPES Against
Marc Ferracci RE For by proxy
Marina Ferrari DEM For
Sylvie Ferrer LFI-NUPES Against
Caroline Fiat LFI-NUPES Against
Jean-Marie Fiévet RE For
Estelle Folest DEM For
Nicolas Forissier LR For
Charles Fournier ECOLO Against
Thibaut François RN For
Thierry Frappé RN For
Martine Froger LIOT For by proxy
Bruno Fuchs DEM For by proxy
Jean-Luc Fugit RE For
Perceval Gaillard LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Stéphanie Galzy RN For
Marie-Charlotte Garin ECOLO Against by proxy
Guillaume Garot SOC Abstention by proxy
Raquel Garrido LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Thomas Gassilloud RE For
Maud Gatel DEM For by proxy
Jean-Jacques Gaultier LR For
Luc Geismar DEM For
Anne Genetet RE For by proxy
Annie Genevard LR For by proxy
Félicie Gérard HOR For
Raphaël Gérard RE For by proxy
François Gernigon HOR For
Hadrien Ghomi RE For by proxy
Frank Giletti RN For
Yoann Gillet RN For
Christian Girard RN For by proxy
Éric Girardin RE For
Joël Giraud RE For by proxy
Olga Givernet RE For
Charlotte Goetschy-Bolognese RE For
José Gonzalez RN For
Philippe Gosselin LR For
Guillaume Gouffier Valente RE For
Florence Goulet RN For
Perrine Goulet DEM Absent
Géraldine Grangier RN For
Jean-Carles Grelier RE For
Daniel Grenon RN For
Justine Gruet LR For
Jérôme Guedj SOC Abstention
Clémence Guetté LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Marie Guévenoux RE For
Claire Guichard RE For
Philippe Guillemard RE For
Michel Guiniot RN For
David Guiraud LFI-NUPES Against
Jordan Guitton RN For by proxy
Frantz Gumbs DEM For
Victor Habert-Dassault LR For
David Habib NI Absent
Meyer Habib LR For by proxy
Benjamin Haddad RE For by proxy
Nadia Hai RE For
Johnny Hajjar SOC Abstention by proxy
Marine Hamelet RN For
Yannick Haury RE For
Joris Hébrard RN For
Pierre Henriet RE For by proxy
Michel Herbillon LR For by proxy
Patrick Hetzel LR For by proxy
Laurence Heydel Grillere RE For
Mathilde Hignet LFI-NUPES Against
Alexandre Holroyd RE For
Sacha Houlié RE For by proxy
Timothée Houssin RN For
Servane Hugues RE For
Monique Iborra RE For
Jérémie Iordanoff ECOLO Against
Cyrille Isaac-Sibille DEM For
Alexis Izard RE For
Laurent Jacobelli RN For
Jean-Michel Jacques RE For by proxy
Élodie Jacquier-Laforge DEM Non-voting
Caroline Janvier RE For by proxy
François Jolivet HOR For
Alexis Jolly RN For by proxy
Sandrine Josso DEM Absent
Chantal Jourdan SOC Absent
Hubert Julien-Laferrière ECOLO Against by proxy
Sébastien Jumel GDR-NUPES For
Philippe Juvin LR For
Émeline K/Bidi GDR-NUPES Absent
Mansour Kamardine LR For by proxy
Marietta Karamanli SOC Abstention
Guillaume Kasbarian RE For
Rachel Keke LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Fatiha Keloua Hachi SOC Abstention
Andy Kerbrat LFI-NUPES Against
Loïc Kervran HOR For
Fadila Khattabi RE For
Brigitte Klinkert RE For
Stéphanie Kochert HOR For
Daniel Labaronne RE For
Bastien Lachaud LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Emmanuel Lacresse RE For
Julie Laernoes ECOLO Against
Fabien Lainé DEM For by proxy
Maxime Laisney LFI-NUPES Against
Amélia Lakrafi RE For by proxy
Luc Lamirault HOR For
Hélène Laporte RN For by proxy
Mohamed Laqhila DEM For
Jean-Charles Larsonneur HOR For
Florence Lasserre DEM For
Philippe Latombe DEM Absent
Michel Lauzzana RE For
Laure Lavalette RN For by proxy
Pascal Lavergne RE For
Sandrine Le Feur RE For
Marc Le Fur LR For by proxy
Didier Le Gac RE For by proxy
Arnaud Le Gall LFI-NUPES Against
Tematai Le Gayic GDR-NUPES Against by proxy
Gilles Le Gendre RE For
Constance Le Grip RE For
Anne Le Hénanff HOR For by proxy
Annaïg Le Meur RE For
Christine Le Nabour RE For
Nicole Le Peih RE For by proxy
Marine Le Pen RN For
Fabrice Le Vigoureux RE For
Antoine Léaument LFI-NUPES Against
Marie Lebec RE For
Karine Lebon GDR-NUPES Against by proxy
Élise Leboucher LFI-NUPES Against
Pascal Lecamp DEM For
Julie Lechanteux RN For
Jean-Paul Lecoq GDR-NUPES Against
Vincent Ledoux RE For by proxy
Charlotte Leduc LFI-NUPES Against
Mathieu Lefèvre RE For
Jérôme Legavre LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Sarah Legrain LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Gisèle Lelouis RN For
Didier Lemaire HOR For by proxy
Patricia Lemoine RE Absent
Stéphane Lenormand LIOT For by proxy
Murielle Lepvraud LFI-NUPES Against
Gérard Leseul SOC Abstention
Katiana Levavasseur RN For by proxy
Delphine Lingemann DEM For
Brigitte Liso RE For
Christine Loir RN For
Aurélien Lopez-Liguori RN For
Marie-France Lorho RN For
Philippe Lottiaux RN For by proxy
Alexandre Loubet RN For by proxy
Véronique Louwagie LR For
Jean-François Lovisolo RE For
Benjamin Lucas-Lundy ECOLO Against
Aude Luquet DEM For
Lise Magnier HOR For
Sylvain Maillard RE For
Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie RE For
Frédéric Maillot GDR-NUPES Abstention by proxy
Emmanuel Mandon DEM Absent
Emmanuel Maquet LR For
Jacqueline Maquet RE For
Laurent Marcangeli HOR For by proxy
Matthieu Marchio RN For
Bastien Marchive RE For
Louis Margueritte RE For
Christophe Marion RE For
Olivier Marleix LR For
Sandra Marsaud RE For by proxy
Didier Martin RE For
Élisa Martin LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Pascale Martin LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) LR For
Éric Martineau DEM For
William Martinet LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Michèle Martinez RN For
Denis Masséglia RE For
Alexandra Masson RN For by proxy
Bryan Masson RN For by proxy
Max Mathiasin LIOT Abstention by proxy
Frédéric Mathieu LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Jean-Paul Mattei DEM For
Damien Maudet LFI-NUPES Against
Kévin Mauvieux RN For
Marianne Maximi LFI-NUPES Against
Stéphane Mazars RE For
Nicolas Meizonnet RN For
Graziella Melchior RE For
Joëlle Mélin RN For
Yaël Ménaché RN For
Thomas Ménagé RN For
Emmanuelle Ménard NI For
Ludovic Mendes RE For by proxy
Lysiane Métayer RE For
Sophie Mette DEM For
Nicolas Metzdorf RE For
Frédérique Meunier LR For
Manon Meunier LFI-NUPES Against
Pierre Meurin RN For
Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert RE For
Paul Midy RE For by proxy
Laure Miller RE For
Bruno Millienne DEM For
Maxime Minot LR For
Paul Molac LIOT Abstention
Yannick Monnet GDR-NUPES For
Louise Morel DEM For
Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier LIOT For by proxy
Benoit Mournet RE For
Naïma Moutchou HOR For
Serge Muller RN For
Marcellin Nadeau GDR-NUPES Abstention
Christophe Naegelen LIOT For by proxy
Philippe Naillet SOC Abstention
Yannick Neuder LR Absent
Jean-Philippe Nilor LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Jérôme Nury LR For
Danièle Obono LFI-NUPES Against
Julien Odoul RN Absent
Karl Olive RE For
Hubert Ott DEM Against
Nathalie Oziol LFI-NUPES Absent
Nicolas Pacquot RE For
Jimmy Pahun DEM Absent
Bertrand Pancher LIOT For
Laurent Panifous LIOT For
Sophie Panonacle RE For
Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet RE For
Mathilde Panot LFI-NUPES Against
Didier Paris RE For by proxy
Mathilde Paris RN For
Caroline Parmentier RN For
Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq RE For
Francesca Pasquini ECOLO Against
Jérémie Patrier-Leitus HOR For by proxy
Éric Pauget LR For
Emmanuel Pellerin RE For
Isabelle Périgault LR For
Patrice Perrot RE For by proxy
Anne-Laurence Petel RE For
Christelle Petex LR For by proxy
Bertrand Petit SOC Abstention
Frédéric Petit DEM For
Maud Petit DEM For
Stéphane Peu GDR-NUPES For
Michèle Peyron RE Absent
Sébastien Peytavie ECOLO Against
Kévin Pfeffer RN For by proxy
Anna Pic SOC Abstention by proxy
René Pilato LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
François Piquemal LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Christine Pirès Beaune SOC Abstention
Béatrice Piron RE Absent
Christophe Plassard HOR For
Marie Pochon ECOLO Against
Lisette Pollet RN For
Barbara Pompili RE For by proxy
Jean-Pierre Pont RE For
Jean-François Portarrieu HOR For
Thomas Portes LFI-NUPES Absent
Alexandre Portier LR Absent
Dominique Potier SOC Abstention
Josy Poueyto DEM For by proxy
Éric Poulliat RE For by proxy
Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback HOR For
Natalia Pouzyreff RE For by proxy
Philippe Pradal HOR For
Aurélien Pradié LR For by proxy
Loïc Prud'homme LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Adrien Quatennens LFI-NUPES Against
Valérie Rabault SOC Abstention
Stéphane Rambaud RN For
Richard Ramos DEM For by proxy
Angélique Ranc RN For
Julien Rancoule RN For
Jean-Hugues Ratenon LFI-NUPES Against
Isabelle Rauch HOR For by proxy
Jean-Claude Raux ECOLO Against
Nicolas Ray LR For
Rémy Rebeyrotte RE For
Robin Reda RE For
Sandra Regol ECOLO Against
Cécile Rilhac RE For
Davy Rimane GDR-NUPES For by proxy
Véronique Riotton RE For by proxy
Stéphanie Rist RE For
Marie-Pierre Rixain RE For by proxy
Laurence Robert-Dehault RN For
Charles Rodwell RE For
Vincent Rolland LR For
Sébastien Rome LFI-NUPES Against
Xavier Roseren RE For
Claudia Rouaux SOC Abstention
Béatrice Roullaud RN Absent
Sandrine Rousseau ECOLO Against
Fabien Roussel GDR-NUPES For by proxy
Jean-François Rousset RE For
Lionel Royer-Perreaut RE For by proxy
Thomas Rudigoz RE For
François Ruffin LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Anaïs Sabatini RN For
Alexandre Sabatou RN For
Benjamin Saint-Huile LIOT For
Laetitia Saint-Paul RE For
Aurélien Saintoul LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Michel Sala LFI-NUPES Absent
Emeric Salmon RN For
Nicolas Sansu GDR-NUPES For
Isabelle Santiago SOC Abstention by proxy
Eva Sas ECOLO Against
Hervé Saulignac SOC Abstention
Raphaël Schellenberger LR For
Philippe Schreck RN For by proxy
Sabrina Sebaihi ECOLO Against
Vincent Seitlinger LR For
Mikaele Seo RE For by proxy
Nathalie Serre LR For
Freddy Sertin RE For
Olivier Serva LIOT Absent
Danielle Simonnet LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Charles Sitzenstuhl RE Absent
Philippe Sorez RE For by proxy
Bertrand Sorre RE For
Ersilia Soudais LFI-NUPES Against
Violette Spillebout RE Absent
Anne Stambach-Terrenoir LFI-NUPES Against
Bruno Studer RE For by proxy
Michèle Tabarot LR For
Aurélien Taché ECOLO Against by proxy
Emmanuel Taché RN For
Sophie Taillé-Polian ECOLO Against
Jean-Pierre Taite LR For
Jean-Philippe Tanguy RN For
Liliana Tanguy RE For by proxy
Sarah Tanzilli RE For
David Taupiac LIOT For
Andrée Taurinya LFI-NUPES Against by proxy
Matthias Tavel LFI-NUPES Against
Michaël Taverne RN For
Jean-Marc Tellier GDR-NUPES For by proxy
Jean Terlier RE For
Prisca Thevenot RE For by proxy
Vincent Thiébaut HOR For
Jean-Louis Thiériot LR For
Nicolas Thierry ECOLO Against
Sabine Thillaye DEM For
Mélanie Thomin SOC Abstention by proxy
Huguette Tiegna RE For by proxy
Lionel Tivoli RN For
Stéphane Travert RE For
Aurélie Trouvé LFI-NUPES Against
Nicolas Turquois DEM For
Cécile Untermaier SOC Abstention by proxy
David Valence RE For
Isabelle Valentin LR For
Boris Vallaud SOC Abstention
Frédéric Valletoux HOR For by proxy
Paul Vannier LFI-NUPES Against
Pierre Vatin LR For
Antoine Vermorel LR For by proxy
Laurence Vichnievsky DEM For by proxy
Roger Vicot SOC Abstention by proxy
Annie Vidal RE For by proxy
Jean-Pierre Vigier LR For
Philippe Vigier DEM For
Patrick Vignal RE For by proxy
Corinne Vignon RE For
Antoine Villedieu RN For
André Villiers HOR For
Alexandre Vincendet LR For
Anne-Cécile Violland HOR For by proxy
Stéphane Viry LR For by proxy
Stéphane Vojetta RE For
Lionel Vuibert RE For
Guillaume Vuilletet RE Absent
Léo Walter LFI-NUPES Against
Jean-Luc Warsmann LIOT For by proxy
Christopher Weissberg RE For by proxy
Jiovanny William GDR-NUPES Absent
Éric Woerth RE For by proxy
Hubert Wulfranc GDR-NUPES For
Caroline Yadan RE For by proxy
Estelle Youssouffa LIOT For by proxy
Frédéric Zgainski DEM For
Jean-Marc Zulesi RE Absent