← All votes

National Assembly · vote no. 5728 · · ✓ Adopted

The whole bill to ensure equal access for all to accompaniment and palliative care (second reading).

≈ automatic translation Official title: Proposition de loi visant à garantir l'égal accès de tous à l'accompagnement et aux soins palliatifs (deuxième lecture)

Promulgated See this text's full journey →

Promulgated on 26 May 2026 Published in the Official Journal on 27 May 2026 Law no. 2026-404 Text on Légifrance ↗ Legislative file ↗

Type of vote
Solemn roll-call vote
Voters
560
1 non-voting
Votes cast
491
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
246 votes
Majorité absolue des suffrages exprimés

491 for 0 against 69 abstentions ▏threshold : 246 votes

Colour by:
LFI-NFP — 71 GDR — 17 ECOS — 38 SOC — 69 LIOT — 22 DEM — 36 EPR — 92 HOR — 34 DR — 49 UDR — 17 RN — 122 NI — 10 LFI-NFPECOSSOCLIOTDEMEPRHORDRRN Nadège Abomangoli (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Laurent Alexandre (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Gabriel Amard (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Ségolène Amiot (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Farida Amrani (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Rodrigo Arenas (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Raphaël Arnault (LFI-NFP) — Absent Anaïs Belouassa-Cherifi (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Ugo Bernalicis (LFI-NFP) — Absent Christophe Bex (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Carlos Martens Bilongo (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Manuel Bompard (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Idir Boumertit (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Louis Boyard (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Pierre-Yves Cadalen (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Aymeric Caron (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Sylvain Carrière (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Gabrielle Cathala (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Bérenger Cernon (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Sophia Chikirou (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Hadrien Clouet (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Éric Coquerel (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-François Coulomme (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Sébastien Delogu (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Aly Diouara (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Alma Dufour (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Karen Erodi (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Mathilde Feld (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Emmanuel Fernandes (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Sylvie Ferrer (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Perceval Gaillard (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Clémence Guetté (LFI-NFP) — Abstention David Guiraud (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Zahia Hamdane (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Mathilde Hignet (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Andy Kerbrat (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Bastien Lachaud (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Abdelkader Lahmar (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Maxime Laisney (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Aurélien Le Coq (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Arnaud Le Gall (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Élise Leboucher (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Jérôme Legavre (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Sarah Legrain (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Claire Lejeune (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Murielle Lepvraud (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Antoine Léaument (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Élisa Martin (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Damien Maudet (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Marianne Maximi (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Marie Mesmeur (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Manon Meunier (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-Philippe Nilor (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Sandrine Nosbé (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Danièle Obono (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Nathalie Oziol (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Mathilde Panot (LFI-NFP) — Abstention René Pilato (LFI-NFP) — Abstention François Piquemal (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Thomas Portes (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Loïc Prud'homme (LFI-NFP) — For Jean-Hugues Ratenon (LFI-NFP) — For — by proxy Arnaud Saint-Martin (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Aurélien Saintoul (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Ersilia Soudais (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Anne Stambach-Terrenoir (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Aurélien Taché (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Andrée Taurinya (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Matthias Tavel (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Aurélie Trouvé (LFI-NFP) — Abstention Paul Vannier (LFI-NFP) — Abstention — by proxy Soumya Bourouaha (GDR) — For Julien Brugerolles (GDR) — For Édouard Bénard (GDR) — For Jean-Victor Castor (GDR) — Absent Elsa Faucillon (GDR) — For Émeline K/Bidi (GDR) — Absent Karine Lebon (GDR) — Absent Jean-Paul Lecoq (GDR) — For Frédéric Maillot (GDR) — Absent Emmanuel Maurel (GDR) — For Yannick Monnet (GDR) — For Marcellin Nadeau (GDR) — Absent Stéphane Peu (GDR) — For Mereana Reid Arbelot (GDR) — For Davy Rimane (GDR) — For Nicolas Sansu (GDR) — Absent Emmanuel Tjibaou (GDR) — For Pouria Amirshahi (ECOS) — For — by proxy Christine Arrighi (ECOS) — For Clémentine Autain (ECOS) — For — by proxy Léa Balage El Mariky (ECOS) — Absent Delphine Batho (ECOS) — For Lisa Belluco (ECOS) — Absent Karim Ben Cheikh (ECOS) — For — by proxy Benoît Biteau (ECOS) — For Arnaud Bonnet (ECOS) — For Nicolas Bonnet (ECOS) — For — by proxy Cyrielle Chatelain (ECOS) — For Alexis Corbière (ECOS) — For Hendrik Davi (ECOS) — For — by proxy Emmanuel Duplessy (ECOS) — For — by proxy Charles Fournier (ECOS) — For — by proxy Marie-Charlotte Garin (ECOS) — For — by proxy Damien Girard (ECOS) — For Steevy Gustave (ECOS) — For — by proxy Catherine Hervieu (ECOS) — For — by proxy Jérémie Iordanoff (ECOS) — For Julie Laernoes (ECOS) — For Tristan Lahais (ECOS) — For Benjamin Lucas-Lundy (ECOS) — For — by proxy Julie Ozenne (ECOS) — For Sébastien Peytavie (ECOS) — For Marie Pochon (ECOS) — For (vote correction) Jean-Claude Raux (ECOS) — For Sandra Regol (ECOS) — For Jean-Louis Roumégas (ECOS) — For — by proxy Sandrine Rousseau (ECOS) — For François Ruffin (ECOS) — For — by proxy Eva Sas (ECOS) — For — by proxy Sabrina Sebaihi (ECOS) — For (vote correction) — by proxy Danielle Simonnet (ECOS) — For Sophie Taillé-Polian (ECOS) — For Boris Tavernier (ECOS) — For — by proxy Nicolas Thierry (ECOS) — For Dominique Voynet (ECOS) — For Marie-José Allemand (SOC) — For Joël Aviragnet (SOC) — For Christian Baptiste (SOC) — For Fabrice Barusseau (SOC) — For — by proxy Marie-Noëlle Battistel (SOC) — For — by proxy Laurent Baumel (SOC) — For Belkhir Belhaddad (SOC) — For Béatrice Bellay (SOC) — For — by proxy Karim Benbrahim (SOC) — For Mickaël Bouloux (SOC) — For Philippe Brun (SOC) — For Elie Califer (SOC) — For Colette Capdevielle (SOC) — For Paul Christophle (SOC) — For — by proxy Pierrick Courbon (SOC) — For Alain David (SOC) — For — by proxy Arthur Delaporte (SOC) — For Stéphane Delautrette (SOC) — For Dieynaba Diop (SOC) — For Fanny Dombre Coste (SOC) — For — by proxy Peio Dufau (SOC) — For Iñaki Echaniz (SOC) — For Romain Eskenazi (SOC) — For Olivier Faure (SOC) — For — by proxy Martine Froger (SOC) — For Denis Fégné (SOC) — For — by proxy Guillaume Garot (SOC) — For Océane Godard (SOC) — For Julien Gokel (SOC) — For — by proxy Pascale Got (SOC) — For Emmanuel Grégoire (SOC) — For — by proxy Jérôme Guedj (SOC) — For Stéphane Hablot (SOC) — For — by proxy Ayda Hadizadeh (SOC) — For Florence Herouin-Léautey (SOC) — For Céline Hervieu (SOC) — For François Hollande (SOC) — For Sacha Houlié (SOC) — For Chantal Jourdan (SOC) — For Marietta Karamanli (SOC) — For — by proxy Fatiha Keloua Hachi (SOC) — For Gérard Leseul (SOC) — For — by proxy Laurent Lhardit (SOC) — For — by proxy Estelle Mercier (SOC) — For Philippe Naillet (SOC) — For — by proxy Jacques Oberti (SOC) — For Sophie Pantel (SOC) — For Marc Pena (SOC) — For — by proxy Anna Pic (SOC) — For Christine Pirès Beaune (SOC) — For — by proxy Dominique Potier (SOC) — For Pierre Pribetich (SOC) — For Christophe Proença (SOC) — For — by proxy Valérie Rossi (SOC) — For Claudia Rouaux (SOC) — For — by proxy Aurélien Rousseau (SOC) — For Fabrice Roussel (SOC) — For — by proxy Sandrine Runel (SOC) — For Marie Récalde (SOC) — For Sébastien Saint-Pasteur (SOC) — For — by proxy Isabelle Santiago (SOC) — For Hervé Saulignac (SOC) — For Arnaud Simion (SOC) — For Thierry Sother (SOC) — For Céline Thiébault-Martinez (SOC) — For Mélanie Thomin (SOC) — For — by proxy Boris Vallaud (SOC) — For Roger Vicot (SOC) — For Jiovanny William (SOC) — For — by proxy Audrey Abadie-Amiel (LIOT) — For Jean-Pierre Bataille (LIOT) — For Joël Bruneau (LIOT) — For Michel Castellani (LIOT) — For Paul-André Colombani (LIOT) — For Yannick Favennec-Bécot (LIOT) — For — by proxy David Habib (LIOT) — For — by proxy Harold Huwart (LIOT) — For Stéphane Lenormand (LIOT) — For Valérie Létard (LIOT) — For Max Mathiasin (LIOT) — For — by proxy Laurent Mazaury (LIOT) — For Paul Molac (LIOT) — For — by proxy Christophe Naegelen (LIOT) — For — by proxy Nicole Sanquer (LIOT) — For — by proxy Olivier Serva (LIOT) — For — by proxy David Taupiac (LIOT) — For — by proxy Stéphane Viry (LIOT) — For Jean-Luc Warsmann (LIOT) — For — by proxy Estelle Youssouffa (LIOT) — For Charles de Courson (LIOT) — For Constance de Pélichy (LIOT) — For — by proxy Erwan Balanant (DEM) — For Géraldine Bannier (DEM) — For Anne Bergantz (DEM) — For Christophe Blanchet (DEM) — For Philippe Bolo (DEM) — For Blandine Brocard (DEM) — For Mickaël Cosson (DEM) — For Laurent Croizier (DEM) — For — by proxy Geneviève Darrieussecq (DEM) — For — by proxy Romain Daubié (DEM) — For — by proxy Olivier Falorni (DEM) — For Marc Fesneau (DEM) — For Bruno Fuchs (DEM) — For — by proxy Perrine Goulet (DEM) — For Jean-Carles Grelier (DEM) — For Frantz Gumbs (DEM) — For Cyrille Isaac-Sibille (DEM) — For Sandrine Josso (DEM) — For Philippe Latombe (DEM) — For Pascal Lecamp (DEM) — For — by proxy Delphine Lingemann (DEM) — For Emmanuel Mandon (DEM) — For Éric Martineau (DEM) — For Jean-Paul Mattei (DEM) — For Sophie Mette (DEM) — For Louise Morel (DEM) — For Hubert Ott (DEM) — For — by proxy Didier Padey (DEM) — For Jimmy Pahun (DEM) — For Frédéric Petit (DEM) — For — by proxy Maud Petit (DEM) — For Josy Poueyto (DEM) — For — by proxy Richard Ramos (DEM) — For Sabine Thillaye (DEM) — For Nicolas Turquois (DEM) — For — by proxy Philippe Vigier (DEM) — For — by proxy Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade (EPR) — For — by proxy Antoine Armand (EPR) — For — by proxy Gabriel Attal (EPR) — For — by proxy Olivier Becht (EPR) — For — by proxy Hervé Berville (EPR) — Absent Élisabeth Borne (EPR) — For Éric Bothorel (EPR) — For Florent Boudié (EPR) — For Yaël Braun-Pivet (EPR) — For Anthony Brosse (EPR) — For Danielle Brulebois (EPR) — For Stéphane Buchou (EPR) — For Françoise Buffet (EPR) — For — by proxy Céline Calvez (EPR) — For Vincent Caure (EPR) — For — by proxy Lionel Causse (EPR) — For Thomas Cazenave (EPR) — For — by proxy Jean-René Cazeneuve (EPR) — For Pierre Cazeneuve (EPR) — Absent Yannick Chenevard (EPR) — For Nathalie Coggia (EPR) — For François Cormier-Bouligeon (EPR) — For — by proxy Julie Delpech (EPR) — For — by proxy Benjamin Dirx (EPR) — For Nicole Dubré-Chirat (EPR) — For Marc Ferracci (EPR) — For — by proxy Jean-Marie Fiévet (EPR) — For Moerani Frébault (EPR) — For — by proxy Jean-Luc Fugit (EPR) — For Camille Galliard-Minier (EPR) — For Thomas Gassilloud (EPR) — For Anne Genetet (EPR) — For — by proxy Olga Givernet (EPR) — For Guillaume Gouffier Valente (EPR) — For Olivia Grégoire (EPR) — For Sébastien Huyghe (EPR) — For Catherine Ibled (EPR) — For Jean-Michel Jacques (EPR) — For — by proxy Guillaume Kasbarian (EPR) — For Brigitte Klinkert (EPR) — For Daniel Labaronne (EPR) — For Amélia Lakrafi (EPR) — For — by proxy Sandrine Lalanne (EPR) — For Benoît Larrouquis (EPR) — For Michel Lauzzana (EPR) — For Sandrine Le Feur (EPR) — For — by proxy Didier Le Gac (EPR) — For Constance Le Grip (EPR) — For — by proxy Annaïg Le Meur (EPR) — For Christine Le Nabour (EPR) — For Nicole Le Peih (EPR) — For Marie Lebec (EPR) — For — by proxy Vincent Ledoux (EPR) — For — by proxy Brigitte Liso (EPR) — For Sylvain Maillard (EPR) — For — by proxy Bastien Marchive (EPR) — For Christophe Marion (EPR) — For — by proxy Sandra Marsaud (EPR) — For — by proxy Denis Masséglia (EPR) — For Stéphane Mazars (EPR) — For — by proxy Graziella Melchior (EPR) — For Ludovic Mendes (EPR) — For — by proxy Nicolas Metzdorf (EPR) — For — by proxy Paul Midy (EPR) — For Laure Miller (EPR) — For Joséphine Missoffe (EPR) — For Christophe Mongardien (EPR) — For Karl Olive (EPR) — For — by proxy Agnès Pannier-Runacher (EPR) — For — by proxy Sophie Panonacle (EPR) — For Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet (EPR) — For Natalia Pouzyreff (EPR) — For — by proxy Franck Riester (EPR) — For — by proxy Véronique Riotton (EPR) — For — by proxy Stéphanie Rist (EPR) — Non-voting Marie-Pierre Rixain (EPR) — For Charles Rodwell (EPR) — For Anne-Sophie Ronceret (EPR) — For — by proxy Jean-François Rousset (EPR) — For Mikaele Seo (EPR) — Absent Charles Sitzenstuhl (EPR) — For Bertrand Sorre (EPR) — For Violette Spillebout (EPR) — For — by proxy Liliana Tanguy (EPR) — For Jean Terlier (EPR) — For — by proxy Prisca Thevenot (EPR) — For Stéphane Travert (EPR) — For — by proxy Annie Vidal (EPR) — For Corinne Vignon (EPR) — For Christopher Weissberg (EPR) — For — by proxy Éric Woerth (EPR) — For Caroline Yadan (EPR) — For — by proxy Xavier Albertini (HOR) — For — by proxy Henri Alfandari (HOR) — For — by proxy Béatrice Bellamy (HOR) — For — by proxy Thierry Benoit (HOR) — For Sylvain Berrios (HOR) — For Benoît Blanchard (HOR) — For Bertrand Bouyx (HOR) — For Jean-Michel Brard (HOR) — For Paul Christophe (HOR) — For Nathalie Colin-Oesterlé (HOR) — For Michel Criaud (HOR) — For Philippe Fait (HOR) — For Agnès Firmin Le Bodo (HOR) — For François Gernigon (HOR) — For Félicie Gérard (HOR) — For Pierre Henriet (HOR) — For François Jolivet (HOR) — For Loïc Kervran (HOR) — For Thomas Lam (HOR) — For — by proxy Didier Lemaire (HOR) — For — by proxy Lise Magnier (HOR) — For Laurent Marcangeli (HOR) — For — by proxy Jean Moulliere (HOR) — For Jérémie Patrier-Leitus (HOR) — For — by proxy Béatrice Piron (HOR) — For Christophe Plassard (HOR) — For — by proxy Jean-François Portarrieu (HOR) — For Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback (HOR) — For Isabelle Rauch (HOR) — For Xavier Roseren (HOR) — For Laetitia Saint-Paul (HOR) — For — by proxy Vincent Thiébaut (HOR) — For Frédéric Valletoux (HOR) — For Anne-Cécile Violland (HOR) — For Michel Barnier (DR) — For — by proxy Thibault Bazin (DR) — For — by proxy Valérie Bazin-Malgras (DR) — For — by proxy Jean-Didier Berger (DR) — For Anne-Laure Blin (DR) — For — by proxy Sylvie Bonnet (DR) — For Émilie Bonnivard (DR) — For Jean-Yves Bony (DR) — For Ian Boucard (DR) — For Jean-Luc Bourgeaux (DR) — For Xavier Breton (DR) — For — by proxy Hubert Brigand (DR) — For — by proxy Fabrice Brun (DR) — For François-Xavier Ceccoli (DR) — For Pierre Cordier (DR) — For — by proxy Josiane Corneloup (DR) — For (vote correction) Marie-Christine Dalloz (DR) — For — by proxy Vincent Descoeur (DR) — For Fabien Di Filippo (DR) — For — by proxy Julien Dive (DR) — For — by proxy Virginie Duby-Muller (DR) — For Lionel Duparay (DR) — For Alix Fruchon (DR) — For Philippe Gosselin (DR) — For (vote correction) Justine Gruet (DR) — For Michel Herbillon (DR) — For Patrick Hetzel (DR) — For Philippe Juvin (DR) — For Corentin Le Fur (DR) — For Guillaume Lepers (DR) — For — by proxy Eric Liégeon (DR) — For Véronique Louwagie (DR) — For — by proxy Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) (DR) — For Frédérique Meunier (DR) — For Christelle Minard (DR) — For — by proxy Yannick Neuder (DR) — For Jérôme Nury (DR) — For Éric Pauget (DR) — For — by proxy Alexandre Portier (DR) — For Nicolas Ray (DR) — For Vincent Rolland (DR) — For Michèle Tabarot (DR) — For — by proxy Jean-Pierre Taite (DR) — For — by proxy Jean-Louis Thiériot (DR) — For Nicolas Tryzna (DR) — For Antoine Vermorel (DR) — For — by proxy Jean-Pierre Vigier (DR) — For — by proxy Laurent Wauquiez (DR) — For — by proxy Élisabeth de Maistre (DR) — For Alexandre Allegret-Pilot (UDR) — For Charles Alloncle (UDR) — For — by proxy Matthieu Bloch (UDR) — For Pierre-Henri Carbonnel (UDR) — For Bernard Chaix (UDR) — For — by proxy Marc Chavent (UDR) — For Éric Ciotti (UDR) — For — by proxy Christelle D'Intorni (UDR) — For — by proxy Olivier Fayssat (UDR) — For Bartolomé Lenoir (UDR) — For Hanane Mansouri (UDR) — For Maxime Michelet (UDR) — For Éric Michoux (UDR) — For — by proxy Sophie Ricourt Vaginay (UDR) — For Vincent Trébuchet (UDR) — For Antoine Valentin (UDR) — For Gérault Verny (UDR) — For — by proxy Franck Allisio (RN) — For — by proxy Maxime Amblard (RN) — For Bénédicte Auzanot (RN) — For — by proxy Philippe Ballard (RN) — For Anchya Bamana (RN) — For Christophe Barthès (RN) — For Romain Baubry (RN) — For — by proxy José Beaurain (RN) — For Christophe Bentz (RN) — For Théo Bernhardt (RN) — For Guillaume Bigot (RN) — For — by proxy Bruno Bilde (RN) — For — by proxy Emmanuel Blairy (RN) — For Sophie Blanc (RN) — For Frédéric Boccaletti (RN) — For — by proxy Pascale Bordes (RN) — For — by proxy Anthony Boulogne (RN) — For Manon Bouquin (RN) — For Jorys Bovet (RN) — For Jérôme Buisson (RN) — For Eddy Casterman (RN) — For — by proxy Sébastien Chenu (RN) — For Roger Chudeau (RN) — For — by proxy Bruno Clavet (RN) — For — by proxy Caroline Colombier (RN) — For Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho (RN) — For Jocelyn Dessigny (RN) — For Edwige Diaz (RN) — For — by proxy Sandrine Dogor-Such (RN) — For Nicolas Dragon (RN) — For Alexandre Dufosset (RN) — For Gaëtan Dussausaye (RN) — For Aurélien Dutremble (RN) — For — by proxy Auguste Evrard (RN) — For Frédéric Falcon (RN) — For Guillaume Florquin (RN) — For Emmanuel Fouquart (RN) — For — by proxy Thierry Frappé (RN) — For Julien Gabarron (RN) — For — by proxy Stéphanie Galzy (RN) — For Jonathan Gery (RN) — For Frank Giletti (RN) — For Yoann Gillet (RN) — For — by proxy Christian Girard (RN) — For Antoine Golliot (RN) — For — by proxy José Gonzalez (RN) — For Florence Goulet (RN) — For Géraldine Grangier (RN) — For Monique Griseti (RN) — For Julien Guibert (RN) — For — by proxy Michel Guiniot (RN) — For Jordan Guitton (RN) — For Marine Hamelet (RN) — For — by proxy Timothée Houssin (RN) — For Sébastien Humbert (RN) — For Laurent Jacobelli (RN) — For Pascal Jenft (RN) — For Alexis Jolly (RN) — For Tiffany Joncour (RN) — For — by proxy Sylvie Josserand (RN) — For Florence Joubert (RN) — For Hélène Laporte (RN) — For Laure Lavalette (RN) — For — by proxy Robert Le Bourgeois (RN) — For Marine Le Pen (RN) — For — by proxy Julie Lechanteux (RN) — For — by proxy Nadine Lechon (RN) — For Gisèle Lelouis (RN) — For Katiana Levavasseur (RN) — For Julien Limongi (RN) — For René Lioret (RN) — For — by proxy Christine Loir (RN) — For — by proxy Aurélien Lopez-Liguori (RN) — For Marie-France Lorho (RN) — For Philippe Lottiaux (RN) — For Alexandre Loubet (RN) — For David Magnier (RN) — For Claire Marais-Beuil (RN) — For Matthieu Marchio (RN) — For Pascal Markowsky (RN) — For Patrice Martin (RN) — For Michèle Martinez (RN) — For Alexandra Masson (RN) — For — by proxy Bryan Masson (RN) — For — by proxy Kévin Mauvieux (RN) — For — by proxy Nicolas Meizonnet (RN) — For — by proxy Pierre Meurin (RN) — For Thibaut Monnier (RN) — For Serge Muller (RN) — For Joëlle Mélin (RN) — For Yaël Ménaché (RN) — For Thomas Ménagé (RN) — For Julien Odoul (RN) — For — by proxy Caroline Parmentier (RN) — For — by proxy Thierry Perez (RN) — For Kévin Pfeffer (RN) — For — by proxy Lisette Pollet (RN) — For Stéphane Rambaud (RN) — For Angélique Ranc (RN) — For Julien Rancoule (RN) — For — by proxy Matthias Renault (RN) — For Catherine Rimbert (RN) — For — by proxy Joseph Rivière (RN) — For Laurence Robert-Dehault (RN) — For — by proxy Béatrice Roullaud (RN) — For — by proxy Sophie-Laurence Roy (RN) — For Anaïs Sabatini (RN) — For — by proxy Alexandre Sabatou (RN) — For — by proxy Emeric Salmon (RN) — For Philippe Schreck (RN) — For — by proxy Anne Sicard (RN) — For Emmanuel Taché (RN) — For — by proxy Jean-Philippe Tanguy (RN) — For Michaël Taverne (RN) — For Thierry Tesson (RN) — For — by proxy Lionel Tivoli (RN) — For Romain Tonussi (RN) — For Antoine Villedieu (RN) — For — by proxy Frédéric-Pierre Vos (RN) — For Frédéric Weber (RN) — For Marc de Fleurian (RN) — For Hervé de Lépinau (RN) — For Véronique Besse (NI) — For Philippe Bonnecarrère (NI) — For Sandra Delannoy (NI) — For Stella Dupont (NI) — For Christine Engrand (NI) — For — by proxy Sophie Errante (NI) — For Daniel Grenon (NI) — For Aurélien Pradié (NI) — Absent Raphaël Schellenberger (NI) — For — by proxy Lionel Vuibert (NI) — For

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
LFI-NFP 2067 0271
GDR 1100 0617
ECOS 3600 0238
SOC 6900 0069
LIOT 2200 0022
DEM 3600 0036
EPR 8800 1392
HOR 3400 0034
DR 4900 0049
UDR 1700 0017
RN 12200 00122
NI 900 0110

All deputies

DeputyGroupVote
Audrey Abadie-Amiel LIOT For
Nadège Abomangoli LFI-NFP Abstention
Xavier Albertini HOR For by proxy
Laurent Alexandre LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Henri Alfandari HOR For by proxy
Alexandre Allegret-Pilot UDR For
Marie-José Allemand SOC For
Franck Allisio RN For by proxy
Charles Alloncle UDR For by proxy
Gabriel Amard LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Maxime Amblard RN For
Ségolène Amiot LFI-NFP Abstention
Pouria Amirshahi ECOS For by proxy
Farida Amrani LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade EPR For by proxy
Rodrigo Arenas LFI-NFP Abstention
Antoine Armand EPR For by proxy
Raphaël Arnault LFI-NFP Absent
Christine Arrighi ECOS For
Gabriel Attal EPR For by proxy
Clémentine Autain ECOS For by proxy
Bénédicte Auzanot RN For by proxy
Joël Aviragnet SOC For
Léa Balage El Mariky ECOS Absent
Erwan Balanant DEM For
Philippe Ballard RN For
Anchya Bamana RN For
Géraldine Bannier DEM For
Christian Baptiste SOC For
Michel Barnier DR For by proxy
Christophe Barthès RN For
Fabrice Barusseau SOC For by proxy
Jean-Pierre Bataille LIOT For
Delphine Batho ECOS For
Marie-Noëlle Battistel SOC For by proxy
Romain Baubry RN For by proxy
Laurent Baumel SOC For
Thibault Bazin DR For by proxy
Valérie Bazin-Malgras DR For by proxy
José Beaurain RN For
Olivier Becht EPR For by proxy
Belkhir Belhaddad SOC For
Béatrice Bellamy HOR For by proxy
Béatrice Bellay SOC For by proxy
Lisa Belluco ECOS Absent
Anaïs Belouassa-Cherifi LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Karim Ben Cheikh ECOS For by proxy
Édouard Bénard GDR For
Karim Benbrahim SOC For
Thierry Benoit HOR For
Christophe Bentz RN For
Anne Bergantz DEM For
Jean-Didier Berger DR For
Ugo Bernalicis LFI-NFP Absent
Théo Bernhardt RN For
Sylvain Berrios HOR For
Hervé Berville EPR Absent
Véronique Besse NI For
Christophe Bex LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Guillaume Bigot RN For by proxy
Bruno Bilde RN For by proxy
Carlos Martens Bilongo LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Benoît Biteau ECOS For
Emmanuel Blairy RN For
Sophie Blanc RN For
Benoît Blanchard HOR For
Christophe Blanchet DEM For
Anne-Laure Blin DR For by proxy
Matthieu Bloch UDR For
Frédéric Boccaletti RN For by proxy
Philippe Bolo DEM For
Manuel Bompard LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Philippe Bonnecarrère NI For
Arnaud Bonnet ECOS For
Nicolas Bonnet ECOS For by proxy
Sylvie Bonnet DR For
Émilie Bonnivard DR For
Jean-Yves Bony DR For
Pascale Bordes RN For by proxy
Élisabeth Borne EPR For
Éric Bothorel EPR For
Ian Boucard DR For
Florent Boudié EPR For
Anthony Boulogne RN For
Mickaël Bouloux SOC For
Idir Boumertit LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Manon Bouquin RN For
Jean-Luc Bourgeaux DR For
Soumya Bourouaha GDR For
Bertrand Bouyx HOR For
Jorys Bovet RN For
Louis Boyard LFI-NFP Abstention
Jean-Michel Brard HOR For
Yaël Braun-Pivet EPR For
Xavier Breton DR For by proxy
Hubert Brigand DR For by proxy
Blandine Brocard DEM For
Anthony Brosse EPR For
Julien Brugerolles GDR For
Danielle Brulebois EPR For
Fabrice Brun DR For
Philippe Brun SOC For
Joël Bruneau LIOT For
Stéphane Buchou EPR For
Françoise Buffet EPR For by proxy
Jérôme Buisson RN For
Pierre-Yves Cadalen LFI-NFP Abstention
Elie Califer SOC For
Céline Calvez EPR For
Colette Capdevielle SOC For
Pierre-Henri Carbonnel UDR For
Aymeric Caron LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Sylvain Carrière LFI-NFP Abstention
Michel Castellani LIOT For
Eddy Casterman RN For by proxy
Jean-Victor Castor GDR Absent
Gabrielle Cathala LFI-NFP Abstention
Vincent Caure EPR For by proxy
Lionel Causse EPR For
Thomas Cazenave EPR For by proxy
Jean-René Cazeneuve EPR For
Pierre Cazeneuve EPR Absent
François-Xavier Ceccoli DR For
Bérenger Cernon LFI-NFP Abstention
Bernard Chaix UDR For by proxy
Cyrielle Chatelain ECOS For
Marc Chavent UDR For
Yannick Chenevard EPR For
Sébastien Chenu RN For
Sophia Chikirou LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Paul Christophe HOR For
Paul Christophle SOC For by proxy
Roger Chudeau RN For by proxy
Éric Ciotti UDR For by proxy
Bruno Clavet RN For by proxy
Hadrien Clouet LFI-NFP Abstention
Nathalie Coggia EPR For
Nathalie Colin-Oesterlé HOR For
Paul-André Colombani LIOT For
Caroline Colombier RN For
Éric Coquerel LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Alexis Corbière ECOS For
Pierre Cordier DR For by proxy
François Cormier-Bouligeon EPR For by proxy
Josiane Corneloup DR For corrected (originally: absent)
Mickaël Cosson DEM For
Jean-François Coulomme LFI-NFP Abstention
Pierrick Courbon SOC For
Michel Criaud HOR For
Laurent Croizier DEM For by proxy
Christelle D'Intorni UDR For by proxy
Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho RN For
Marie-Christine Dalloz DR For by proxy
Geneviève Darrieussecq DEM For by proxy
Romain Daubié DEM For by proxy
Hendrik Davi ECOS For by proxy
Alain David SOC For by proxy
Charles de Courson LIOT For
Marc de Fleurian RN For
Hervé de Lépinau RN For
Élisabeth de Maistre DR For
Constance de Pélichy LIOT For by proxy
Sandra Delannoy NI For
Arthur Delaporte SOC For
Stéphane Delautrette SOC For
Sébastien Delogu LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Julie Delpech EPR For by proxy
Vincent Descoeur DR For
Jocelyn Dessigny RN For
Fabien Di Filippo DR For by proxy
Edwige Diaz RN For by proxy
Dieynaba Diop SOC For
Aly Diouara LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Benjamin Dirx EPR For
Julien Dive DR For by proxy
Sandrine Dogor-Such RN For
Fanny Dombre Coste SOC For by proxy
Nicolas Dragon RN For
Nicole Dubré-Chirat EPR For
Virginie Duby-Muller DR For
Peio Dufau SOC For
Alexandre Dufosset RN For
Alma Dufour LFI-NFP Abstention
Lionel Duparay DR For
Emmanuel Duplessy ECOS For by proxy
Stella Dupont NI For
Gaëtan Dussausaye RN For
Aurélien Dutremble RN For by proxy
Iñaki Echaniz SOC For
Christine Engrand NI For by proxy
Karen Erodi LFI-NFP Abstention
Sophie Errante NI For
Romain Eskenazi SOC For
Auguste Evrard RN For
Philippe Fait HOR For
Frédéric Falcon RN For
Olivier Falorni DEM For
Elsa Faucillon GDR For
Olivier Faure SOC For by proxy
Yannick Favennec-Bécot LIOT For by proxy
Olivier Fayssat UDR For
Denis Fégné SOC For by proxy
Mathilde Feld LFI-NFP Abstention
Emmanuel Fernandes LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Marc Ferracci EPR For by proxy
Sylvie Ferrer LFI-NFP Abstention
Marc Fesneau DEM For
Jean-Marie Fiévet EPR For
Agnès Firmin Le Bodo HOR For
Guillaume Florquin RN For
Emmanuel Fouquart RN For by proxy
Charles Fournier ECOS For by proxy
Thierry Frappé RN For
Moerani Frébault EPR For by proxy
Martine Froger SOC For
Alix Fruchon DR For
Bruno Fuchs DEM For by proxy
Jean-Luc Fugit EPR For
Julien Gabarron RN For by proxy
Perceval Gaillard LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Camille Galliard-Minier EPR For
Stéphanie Galzy RN For
Marie-Charlotte Garin ECOS For by proxy
Guillaume Garot SOC For
Thomas Gassilloud EPR For
Anne Genetet EPR For by proxy
Félicie Gérard HOR For
François Gernigon HOR For
Jonathan Gery RN For
Frank Giletti RN For
Yoann Gillet RN For by proxy
Christian Girard RN For
Damien Girard ECOS For
Olga Givernet EPR For
Océane Godard SOC For
Julien Gokel SOC For by proxy
Antoine Golliot RN For by proxy
José Gonzalez RN For
Philippe Gosselin DR For corrected (originally: absent)
Pascale Got SOC For
Guillaume Gouffier Valente EPR For
Florence Goulet RN For
Perrine Goulet DEM For
Géraldine Grangier RN For
Emmanuel Grégoire SOC For by proxy
Olivia Grégoire EPR For
Jean-Carles Grelier DEM For
Daniel Grenon NI For
Monique Griseti RN For
Justine Gruet DR For
Jérôme Guedj SOC For
Clémence Guetté LFI-NFP Abstention
Julien Guibert RN For by proxy
Michel Guiniot RN For
David Guiraud LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Jordan Guitton RN For
Frantz Gumbs DEM For
Steevy Gustave ECOS For by proxy
David Habib LIOT For by proxy
Stéphane Hablot SOC For by proxy
Ayda Hadizadeh SOC For
Zahia Hamdane LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Marine Hamelet RN For by proxy
Pierre Henriet HOR For
Michel Herbillon DR For
Florence Herouin-Léautey SOC For
Catherine Hervieu ECOS For by proxy
Céline Hervieu SOC For
Patrick Hetzel DR For
Mathilde Hignet LFI-NFP Abstention
François Hollande SOC For
Sacha Houlié SOC For
Timothée Houssin RN For
Sébastien Humbert RN For
Harold Huwart LIOT For
Sébastien Huyghe EPR For
Catherine Ibled EPR For
Jérémie Iordanoff ECOS For
Cyrille Isaac-Sibille DEM For
Laurent Jacobelli RN For
Jean-Michel Jacques EPR For by proxy
Pascal Jenft RN For
François Jolivet HOR For
Alexis Jolly RN For
Tiffany Joncour RN For by proxy
Sylvie Josserand RN For
Sandrine Josso DEM For
Florence Joubert RN For
Chantal Jourdan SOC For
Philippe Juvin DR For
Émeline K/Bidi GDR Absent
Marietta Karamanli SOC For by proxy
Guillaume Kasbarian EPR For
Fatiha Keloua Hachi SOC For
Andy Kerbrat LFI-NFP Abstention
Loïc Kervran HOR For
Brigitte Klinkert EPR For
Daniel Labaronne EPR For
Bastien Lachaud LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Julie Laernoes ECOS For
Tristan Lahais ECOS For
Abdelkader Lahmar LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Maxime Laisney LFI-NFP Abstention
Amélia Lakrafi EPR For by proxy
Sandrine Lalanne EPR For
Thomas Lam HOR For by proxy
Hélène Laporte RN For
Benoît Larrouquis EPR For
Philippe Latombe DEM For
Michel Lauzzana EPR For
Laure Lavalette RN For by proxy
Robert Le Bourgeois RN For
Aurélien Le Coq LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Sandrine Le Feur EPR For by proxy
Corentin Le Fur DR For
Didier Le Gac EPR For
Arnaud Le Gall LFI-NFP Abstention
Constance Le Grip EPR For by proxy
Annaïg Le Meur EPR For
Christine Le Nabour EPR For
Nicole Le Peih EPR For
Marine Le Pen RN For by proxy
Antoine Léaument LFI-NFP Abstention
Marie Lebec EPR For by proxy
Karine Lebon GDR Absent
Élise Leboucher LFI-NFP Abstention
Pascal Lecamp DEM For by proxy
Julie Lechanteux RN For by proxy
Nadine Lechon RN For
Jean-Paul Lecoq GDR For
Vincent Ledoux EPR For by proxy
Jérôme Legavre LFI-NFP Abstention
Sarah Legrain LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Claire Lejeune LFI-NFP Abstention
Gisèle Lelouis RN For
Didier Lemaire HOR For by proxy
Bartolomé Lenoir UDR For
Stéphane Lenormand LIOT For
Guillaume Lepers DR For by proxy
Murielle Lepvraud LFI-NFP Abstention
Gérard Leseul SOC For by proxy
Valérie Létard LIOT For
Katiana Levavasseur RN For
Laurent Lhardit SOC For by proxy
Eric Liégeon DR For
Julien Limongi RN For
Delphine Lingemann DEM For
René Lioret RN For by proxy
Brigitte Liso EPR For
Christine Loir RN For by proxy
Aurélien Lopez-Liguori RN For
Marie-France Lorho RN For
Philippe Lottiaux RN For
Alexandre Loubet RN For
Véronique Louwagie DR For by proxy
Benjamin Lucas-Lundy ECOS For by proxy
David Magnier RN For
Lise Magnier HOR For
Sylvain Maillard EPR For by proxy
Frédéric Maillot GDR Absent
Emmanuel Mandon DEM For
Hanane Mansouri UDR For
Claire Marais-Beuil RN For
Laurent Marcangeli HOR For by proxy
Matthieu Marchio RN For
Bastien Marchive EPR For
Christophe Marion EPR For by proxy
Pascal Markowsky RN For
Sandra Marsaud EPR For by proxy
Élisa Martin LFI-NFP Abstention
Patrice Martin RN For
Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) DR For
Éric Martineau DEM For
Michèle Martinez RN For
Denis Masséglia EPR For
Alexandra Masson RN For by proxy
Bryan Masson RN For by proxy
Max Mathiasin LIOT For by proxy
Jean-Paul Mattei DEM For
Damien Maudet LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Emmanuel Maurel GDR For
Kévin Mauvieux RN For by proxy
Marianne Maximi LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Stéphane Mazars EPR For by proxy
Laurent Mazaury LIOT For
Nicolas Meizonnet RN For by proxy
Graziella Melchior EPR For
Joëlle Mélin RN For
Yaël Ménaché RN For
Thomas Ménagé RN For
Ludovic Mendes EPR For by proxy
Estelle Mercier SOC For
Marie Mesmeur LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Sophie Mette DEM For
Nicolas Metzdorf EPR For by proxy
Frédérique Meunier DR For
Manon Meunier LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Pierre Meurin RN For
Maxime Michelet UDR For
Éric Michoux UDR For by proxy
Paul Midy EPR For
Laure Miller EPR For
Christelle Minard DR For by proxy
Joséphine Missoffe EPR For
Paul Molac LIOT For by proxy
Christophe Mongardien EPR For
Yannick Monnet GDR For
Thibaut Monnier RN For
Louise Morel DEM For
Jean Moulliere HOR For
Serge Muller RN For
Marcellin Nadeau GDR Absent
Christophe Naegelen LIOT For by proxy
Philippe Naillet SOC For by proxy
Yannick Neuder DR For
Jean-Philippe Nilor LFI-NFP Abstention
Sandrine Nosbé LFI-NFP Abstention
Jérôme Nury DR For
Jacques Oberti SOC For
Danièle Obono LFI-NFP Abstention
Julien Odoul RN For by proxy
Karl Olive EPR For by proxy
Hubert Ott DEM For by proxy
Julie Ozenne ECOS For
Nathalie Oziol LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Didier Padey DEM For
Jimmy Pahun DEM For
Agnès Pannier-Runacher EPR For by proxy
Sophie Panonacle EPR For
Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet EPR For
Mathilde Panot LFI-NFP Abstention
Sophie Pantel SOC For
Caroline Parmentier RN For by proxy
Jérémie Patrier-Leitus HOR For by proxy
Éric Pauget DR For by proxy
Marc Pena SOC For by proxy
Thierry Perez RN For
Frédéric Petit DEM For by proxy
Maud Petit DEM For
Stéphane Peu GDR For
Sébastien Peytavie ECOS For
Kévin Pfeffer RN For by proxy
Anna Pic SOC For
René Pilato LFI-NFP Abstention
François Piquemal LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Christine Pirès Beaune SOC For by proxy
Béatrice Piron HOR For
Christophe Plassard HOR For by proxy
Marie Pochon ECOS For corrected (originally: abstention)
Lisette Pollet RN For
Jean-François Portarrieu HOR For
Thomas Portes LFI-NFP Abstention
Alexandre Portier DR For
Dominique Potier SOC For
Josy Poueyto DEM For by proxy
Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback HOR For
Natalia Pouzyreff EPR For by proxy
Aurélien Pradié NI Absent
Pierre Pribetich SOC For
Christophe Proença SOC For by proxy
Loïc Prud'homme LFI-NFP For
Stéphane Rambaud RN For
Richard Ramos DEM For
Angélique Ranc RN For
Julien Rancoule RN For by proxy
Jean-Hugues Ratenon LFI-NFP For by proxy
Isabelle Rauch HOR For
Jean-Claude Raux ECOS For
Nicolas Ray DR For
Marie Récalde SOC For
Sandra Regol ECOS For
Mereana Reid Arbelot GDR For
Matthias Renault RN For
Sophie Ricourt Vaginay UDR For
Franck Riester EPR For by proxy
Davy Rimane GDR For
Catherine Rimbert RN For by proxy
Véronique Riotton EPR For by proxy
Stéphanie Rist EPR Non-voting
Joseph Rivière RN For
Marie-Pierre Rixain EPR For
Laurence Robert-Dehault RN For by proxy
Charles Rodwell EPR For
Vincent Rolland DR For
Anne-Sophie Ronceret EPR For by proxy
Xavier Roseren HOR For
Valérie Rossi SOC For
Claudia Rouaux SOC For by proxy
Béatrice Roullaud RN For by proxy
Jean-Louis Roumégas ECOS For by proxy
Aurélien Rousseau SOC For
Sandrine Rousseau ECOS For
Fabrice Roussel SOC For by proxy
Jean-François Rousset EPR For
Sophie-Laurence Roy RN For
François Ruffin ECOS For by proxy
Sandrine Runel SOC For
Anaïs Sabatini RN For by proxy
Alexandre Sabatou RN For by proxy
Arnaud Saint-Martin LFI-NFP Abstention
Sébastien Saint-Pasteur SOC For by proxy
Laetitia Saint-Paul HOR For by proxy
Aurélien Saintoul LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Emeric Salmon RN For
Nicole Sanquer LIOT For by proxy
Nicolas Sansu GDR Absent
Isabelle Santiago SOC For
Eva Sas ECOS For by proxy
Hervé Saulignac SOC For
Raphaël Schellenberger NI For by proxy
Philippe Schreck RN For by proxy
Sabrina Sebaihi ECOS For corrected (originally: abstention) by proxy
Mikaele Seo EPR Absent
Olivier Serva LIOT For by proxy
Anne Sicard RN For
Arnaud Simion SOC For
Danielle Simonnet ECOS For
Charles Sitzenstuhl EPR For
Bertrand Sorre EPR For
Thierry Sother SOC For
Ersilia Soudais LFI-NFP Abstention
Violette Spillebout EPR For by proxy
Anne Stambach-Terrenoir LFI-NFP Abstention
Michèle Tabarot DR For by proxy
Aurélien Taché LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Emmanuel Taché RN For by proxy
Sophie Taillé-Polian ECOS For
Jean-Pierre Taite DR For by proxy
Jean-Philippe Tanguy RN For
Liliana Tanguy EPR For
David Taupiac LIOT For by proxy
Andrée Taurinya LFI-NFP Abstention
Matthias Tavel LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Michaël Taverne RN For
Boris Tavernier ECOS For by proxy
Jean Terlier EPR For by proxy
Thierry Tesson RN For by proxy
Prisca Thevenot EPR For
Céline Thiébault-Martinez SOC For
Vincent Thiébaut HOR For
Jean-Louis Thiériot DR For
Nicolas Thierry ECOS For
Sabine Thillaye DEM For
Mélanie Thomin SOC For by proxy
Lionel Tivoli RN For
Emmanuel Tjibaou GDR For
Romain Tonussi RN For
Stéphane Travert EPR For by proxy
Vincent Trébuchet UDR For
Aurélie Trouvé LFI-NFP Abstention
Nicolas Tryzna DR For
Nicolas Turquois DEM For by proxy
Antoine Valentin UDR For
Boris Vallaud SOC For
Frédéric Valletoux HOR For
Paul Vannier LFI-NFP Abstention by proxy
Antoine Vermorel DR For by proxy
Gérault Verny UDR For by proxy
Roger Vicot SOC For
Annie Vidal EPR For
Jean-Pierre Vigier DR For by proxy
Philippe Vigier DEM For by proxy
Corinne Vignon EPR For
Antoine Villedieu RN For by proxy
Anne-Cécile Violland HOR For
Stéphane Viry LIOT For
Frédéric-Pierre Vos RN For
Dominique Voynet ECOS For
Lionel Vuibert NI For
Jean-Luc Warsmann LIOT For by proxy
Laurent Wauquiez DR For by proxy
Frédéric Weber RN For
Christopher Weissberg EPR For by proxy
Jiovanny William SOC For by proxy
Éric Woerth EPR For
Caroline Yadan EPR For by proxy
Estelle Youssouffa LIOT For