← All votes

National Assembly · vote no. 3463 · · ✗ Rejected

L'amendement n° 1232 de Mme Colin-Oesterlé après l'article 8 du projet de loi de financement de la sécurité sociale pour 2026 (première lecture)

Type of vote
Ordinary roll-call vote
Voters
237
14 non-voting
Votes cast
150
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
76 votes
Majorité absolue des suffrages exprimés

20 for 130 against 87 abstentions ▏threshold : 76 votes

Colour by:
LFI-NFP — 71 GDR — 17 ECOS — 38 SOC — 69 LIOT — 21 DEM — 36 EPR — 92 HOR — 34 DR — 50 UDR — 16 RN — 123 NI — 10 LFI-NFPECOSSOCDEMEPRHORDRRN Nadège Abomangoli (LFI-NFP) — Against Laurent Alexandre (LFI-NFP) — Against Gabriel Amard (LFI-NFP) — Absent Ségolène Amiot (LFI-NFP) — Against Farida Amrani (LFI-NFP) — Against — by proxy Rodrigo Arenas (LFI-NFP) — Absent Raphaël Arnault (LFI-NFP) — Against Anaïs Belouassa-Cherifi (LFI-NFP) — Absent Ugo Bernalicis (LFI-NFP) — Absent Christophe Bex (LFI-NFP) — Absent Carlos Martens Bilongo (LFI-NFP) — Absent Manuel Bompard (LFI-NFP) — Against Idir Boumertit (LFI-NFP) — Absent Louis Boyard (LFI-NFP) — Absent Pierre-Yves Cadalen (LFI-NFP) — Against Aymeric Caron (LFI-NFP) — Absent Sylvain Carrière (LFI-NFP) — Against Gabrielle Cathala (LFI-NFP) — Against Bérenger Cernon (LFI-NFP) — Against Sophia Chikirou (LFI-NFP) — Absent Hadrien Clouet (LFI-NFP) — Against Éric Coquerel (LFI-NFP) — Absent Jean-François Coulomme (LFI-NFP) — Absent Sébastien Delogu (LFI-NFP) — Against Aly Diouara (LFI-NFP) — Absent Alma Dufour (LFI-NFP) — Absent Karen Erodi (LFI-NFP) — Against Mathilde Feld (LFI-NFP) — Absent Emmanuel Fernandes (LFI-NFP) — Against Sylvie Ferrer (LFI-NFP) — Absent Perceval Gaillard (LFI-NFP) — Against — by proxy Clémence Guetté (LFI-NFP) — Absent David Guiraud (LFI-NFP) — Absent Zahia Hamdane (LFI-NFP) — Against Mathilde Hignet (LFI-NFP) — Against — by proxy Andy Kerbrat (LFI-NFP) — Absent Bastien Lachaud (LFI-NFP) — Against Abdelkader Lahmar (LFI-NFP) — Absent Maxime Laisney (LFI-NFP) — Absent Aurélien Le Coq (LFI-NFP) — Absent Arnaud Le Gall (LFI-NFP) — Against — by proxy Élise Leboucher (LFI-NFP) — Against Jérôme Legavre (LFI-NFP) — Absent Sarah Legrain (LFI-NFP) — Against — by proxy Claire Lejeune (LFI-NFP) — Absent Murielle Lepvraud (LFI-NFP) — Absent Antoine Léaument (LFI-NFP) — Absent Élisa Martin (LFI-NFP) — Against Damien Maudet (LFI-NFP) — Against Marianne Maximi (LFI-NFP) — Absent Marie Mesmeur (LFI-NFP) — Absent Manon Meunier (LFI-NFP) — Absent Jean-Philippe Nilor (LFI-NFP) — Absent Sandrine Nosbé (LFI-NFP) — Absent Danièle Obono (LFI-NFP) — Absent Nathalie Oziol (LFI-NFP) — Absent Mathilde Panot (LFI-NFP) — Absent René Pilato (LFI-NFP) — Absent François Piquemal (LFI-NFP) — Absent Thomas Portes (LFI-NFP) — Absent Loïc Prud'homme (LFI-NFP) — Against Jean-Hugues Ratenon (LFI-NFP) — Against — by proxy Arnaud Saint-Martin (LFI-NFP) — Absent Aurélien Saintoul (LFI-NFP) — Absent Ersilia Soudais (LFI-NFP) — Absent Anne Stambach-Terrenoir (LFI-NFP) — Absent Aurélien Taché (LFI-NFP) — Absent Andrée Taurinya (LFI-NFP) — Against — by proxy Matthias Tavel (LFI-NFP) — Absent Aurélie Trouvé (LFI-NFP) — Against Paul Vannier (LFI-NFP) — Absent Soumya Bourouaha (GDR) — Absent Julien Brugerolles (GDR) — Absent Édouard Bénard (GDR) — Against Jean-Victor Castor (GDR) — Absent Elsa Faucillon (GDR) — Against Émeline K/Bidi (GDR) — Absent Karine Lebon (GDR) — Against Jean-Paul Lecoq (GDR) — Absent Frédéric Maillot (GDR) — Absent Emmanuel Maurel (GDR) — Absent Yannick Monnet (GDR) — Against Marcellin Nadeau (GDR) — Absent Stéphane Peu (GDR) — Against Mereana Reid Arbelot (GDR) — Absent Davy Rimane (GDR) — Absent Nicolas Sansu (GDR) — Absent Emmanuel Tjibaou (GDR) — Absent Pouria Amirshahi (ECOS) — Absent Christine Arrighi (ECOS) — Absent Clémentine Autain (ECOS) — Absent Léa Balage El Mariky (ECOS) — Absent Delphine Batho (ECOS) — Absent Lisa Belluco (ECOS) — Absent Karim Ben Cheikh (ECOS) — Absent Benoît Biteau (ECOS) — Absent Arnaud Bonnet (ECOS) — Against Nicolas Bonnet (ECOS) — Against Cyrielle Chatelain (ECOS) — Absent Alexis Corbière (ECOS) — Against — by proxy Hendrik Davi (ECOS) — Against Emmanuel Duplessy (ECOS) — Absent Charles Fournier (ECOS) — Absent Marie-Charlotte Garin (ECOS) — Against Damien Girard (ECOS) — Absent Steevy Gustave (ECOS) — Against Catherine Hervieu (ECOS) — Against Jérémie Iordanoff (ECOS) — Absent Julie Laernoes (ECOS) — Absent Tristan Lahais (ECOS) — Absent Benjamin Lucas-Lundy (ECOS) — Against Julie Ozenne (ECOS) — Against Sébastien Peytavie (ECOS) — Against — by proxy Marie Pochon (ECOS) — Against Jean-Claude Raux (ECOS) — Absent Sandra Regol (ECOS) — Against Jean-Louis Roumégas (ECOS) — Absent Sandrine Rousseau (ECOS) — Against François Ruffin (ECOS) — Absent Eva Sas (ECOS) — Absent Sabrina Sebaihi (ECOS) — Absent Danielle Simonnet (ECOS) — Absent Sophie Taillé-Polian (ECOS) — Absent Boris Tavernier (ECOS) — Absent Nicolas Thierry (ECOS) — Absent Dominique Voynet (ECOS) — Against Marie-José Allemand (SOC) — Against Joël Aviragnet (SOC) — Absent Christian Baptiste (SOC) — Absent Fabrice Barusseau (SOC) — Absent Marie-Noëlle Battistel (SOC) — Against Laurent Baumel (SOC) — Absent Belkhir Belhaddad (SOC) — Absent Béatrice Bellay (SOC) — Absent Karim Benbrahim (SOC) — Against Mickaël Bouloux (SOC) — Against Philippe Brun (SOC) — Against Elie Califer (SOC) — Against Colette Capdevielle (SOC) — Against Paul Christophle (SOC) — Against Pierrick Courbon (SOC) — Against Alain David (SOC) — Absent Arthur Delaporte (SOC) — Against — by proxy Stéphane Delautrette (SOC) — Against Dieynaba Diop (SOC) — Against Fanny Dombre Coste (SOC) — Against — by proxy Peio Dufau (SOC) — Against Iñaki Echaniz (SOC) — Against Romain Eskenazi (SOC) — Against Olivier Faure (SOC) — Absent Martine Froger (SOC) — Absent Denis Fégné (SOC) — Absent Guillaume Garot (SOC) — Against Océane Godard (SOC) — Against Julien Gokel (SOC) — Absent Pascale Got (SOC) — Against Emmanuel Grégoire (SOC) — Absent Jérôme Guedj (SOC) — Against Stéphane Hablot (SOC) — Absent Ayda Hadizadeh (SOC) — Absent Florence Herouin-Léautey (SOC) — Absent Céline Hervieu (SOC) — Absent François Hollande (SOC) — Absent Sacha Houlié (SOC) — Against Chantal Jourdan (SOC) — Absent Marietta Karamanli (SOC) — Absent Fatiha Keloua Hachi (SOC) — Against Gérard Leseul (SOC) — Absent Laurent Lhardit (SOC) — Absent Estelle Mercier (SOC) — Absent Philippe Naillet (SOC) — Absent Jacques Oberti (SOC) — Against Sophie Pantel (SOC) — Against Marc Pena (SOC) — Absent Anna Pic (SOC) — Absent Christine Pirès Beaune (SOC) — Absent Dominique Potier (SOC) — Absent Pierre Pribetich (SOC) — Against Christophe Proença (SOC) — Absent Valérie Rossi (SOC) — Against Claudia Rouaux (SOC) — Against Aurélien Rousseau (SOC) — Absent Fabrice Roussel (SOC) — Against Sandrine Runel (SOC) — Absent Marie Récalde (SOC) — Absent Sébastien Saint-Pasteur (SOC) — Against Isabelle Santiago (SOC) — Absent Hervé Saulignac (SOC) — Absent Arnaud Simion (SOC) — Against Thierry Sother (SOC) — Absent Céline Thiébault-Martinez (SOC) — Against Mélanie Thomin (SOC) — Absent Boris Vallaud (SOC) — Against Roger Vicot (SOC) — Absent Jiovanny William (SOC) — Absent Jean-Pierre Bataille (LIOT) — Absent Joël Bruneau (LIOT) — For Michel Castellani (LIOT) — Absent Paul-André Colombani (LIOT) — Against (vote correction) Yannick Favennec-Bécot (LIOT) — Against David Habib (LIOT) — Absent Harold Huwart (LIOT) — Absent Stéphane Lenormand (LIOT) — Absent Max Mathiasin (LIOT) — Absent Laurent Mazaury (LIOT) — Absent Paul Molac (LIOT) — Absent Christophe Naegelen (LIOT) — Absent Laurent Panifous (LIOT) — Non-voting Nicole Sanquer (LIOT) — Absent Olivier Serva (LIOT) — Absent David Taupiac (LIOT) — Against Stéphane Viry (LIOT) — Absent Jean-Luc Warsmann (LIOT) — Against Estelle Youssouffa (LIOT) — Absent Charles de Courson (LIOT) — Absent Constance de Pélichy (LIOT) — Absent Erwan Balanant (DEM) — Absent Géraldine Bannier (DEM) — Absent Anne Bergantz (DEM) — Against Christophe Blanchet (DEM) — Absent Philippe Bolo (DEM) — Absent Blandine Brocard (DEM) — Absent Mickaël Cosson (DEM) — Absent Laurent Croizier (DEM) — Absent Geneviève Darrieussecq (DEM) — Against Romain Daubié (DEM) — Absent Olivier Falorni (DEM) — Against Marina Ferrari (DEM) — Non-voting Marc Fesneau (DEM) — Absent Bruno Fuchs (DEM) — Absent Perrine Goulet (DEM) — Absent Jean-Carles Grelier (DEM) — Absent Frantz Gumbs (DEM) — Absent Cyrille Isaac-Sibille (DEM) — Against Sandrine Josso (DEM) — Against — by proxy Philippe Latombe (DEM) — Abstention Pascal Lecamp (DEM) — Absent Delphine Lingemann (DEM) — Absent Emmanuel Mandon (DEM) — Absent Éric Martineau (DEM) — Absent Jean-Paul Mattei (DEM) — Absent Sophie Mette (DEM) — Absent Louise Morel (DEM) — Absent Hubert Ott (DEM) — Absent Jimmy Pahun (DEM) — Absent Frédéric Petit (DEM) — Absent Maud Petit (DEM) — Absent Josy Poueyto (DEM) — Against — by proxy Richard Ramos (DEM) — Absent Sabine Thillaye (DEM) — Absent Nicolas Turquois (DEM) — Absent Philippe Vigier (DEM) — Against David Amiel (EPR) — Non-voting Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade (EPR) — Against Antoine Armand (EPR) — Absent Gabriel Attal (EPR) — Absent Olivier Becht (EPR) — Absent Hervé Berville (EPR) — Absent Éric Bothorel (EPR) — Against — by proxy Florent Boudié (EPR) — Absent Yaël Braun-Pivet (EPR) — Non-voting Maud Bregeon (EPR) — Non-voting Anthony Brosse (EPR) — Against — by proxy Danielle Brulebois (EPR) — Against Stéphane Buchou (EPR) — Against Françoise Buffet (EPR) — Against Céline Calvez (EPR) — Against Eléonore Caroit (EPR) — Non-voting Vincent Caure (EPR) — Absent Lionel Causse (EPR) — Against Thomas Cazenave (EPR) — Absent Jean-René Cazeneuve (EPR) — Against Pierre Cazeneuve (EPR) — For Yannick Chenevard (EPR) — Against Nathalie Coggia (EPR) — Against François Cormier-Bouligeon (EPR) — Against Julie Delpech (EPR) — Against Benjamin Dirx (EPR) — Absent Nicole Dubré-Chirat (EPR) — Absent Marc Ferracci (EPR) — Against Jean-Marie Fiévet (EPR) — Absent Moerani Frébault (EPR) — Absent Jean-Luc Fugit (EPR) — Against Camille Galliard-Minier (EPR) — Against Thomas Gassilloud (EPR) — Absent Anne Genetet (EPR) — Against Olga Givernet (EPR) — Absent Guillaume Gouffier Valente (EPR) — Against — by proxy Olivia Grégoire (EPR) — Absent Sébastien Huyghe (EPR) — Against Jean-Michel Jacques (EPR) — Against Guillaume Kasbarian (EPR) — Absent Brigitte Klinkert (EPR) — Absent Daniel Labaronne (EPR) — Absent Amélia Lakrafi (EPR) — Absent Michel Lauzzana (EPR) — Absent Sandrine Le Feur (EPR) — Against Didier Le Gac (EPR) — Against Constance Le Grip (EPR) — Absent Annaïg Le Meur (EPR) — Absent Christine Le Nabour (EPR) — Absent Nicole Le Peih (EPR) — Absent Marie Lebec (EPR) — Absent Vincent Ledoux (EPR) — Absent Mathieu Lefèvre (EPR) — Non-voting Roland Lescure (EPR) — Non-voting Pauline Levasseur (EPR) — Absent Brigitte Liso (EPR) — Absent Sylvain Maillard (EPR) — Against Bastien Marchive (EPR) — Against Christophe Marion (EPR) — Absent Sandra Marsaud (EPR) — Against Denis Masséglia (EPR) — Absent Stéphane Mazars (EPR) — Against Graziella Melchior (EPR) — Against Ludovic Mendes (EPR) — Against Nicolas Metzdorf (EPR) — Absent Paul Midy (EPR) — Absent Laure Miller (EPR) — Absent Joséphine Missoffe (EPR) — Absent Karl Olive (EPR) — Absent Sophie Panonacle (EPR) — Absent Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet (EPR) — Absent Natalia Pouzyreff (EPR) — Against Franck Riester (EPR) — Against Véronique Riotton (EPR) — Absent Stéphanie Rist (EPR) — Non-voting Marie-Pierre Rixain (EPR) — Absent Charles Rodwell (EPR) — Absent Anne-Sophie Ronceret (EPR) — Against Jean-François Rousset (EPR) — Against Mikaele Seo (EPR) — Absent Freddy Sertin (EPR) — Absent Charles Sitzenstuhl (EPR) — Absent Bertrand Sorre (EPR) — Absent Violette Spillebout (EPR) — Absent Liliana Tanguy (EPR) — Absent Jean Terlier (EPR) — Against Prisca Thevenot (EPR) — Against Stéphane Travert (EPR) — Absent Annie Vidal (EPR) — Against Corinne Vignon (EPR) — Absent Éric Woerth (EPR) — Against — by proxy Caroline Yadan (EPR) — Against Xavier Albertini (HOR) — Absent Henri Alfandari (HOR) — Absent Béatrice Bellamy (HOR) — For Thierry Benoit (HOR) — Absent Sylvain Berrios (HOR) — Absent Bertrand Bouyx (HOR) — For Jean-Michel Brard (HOR) — For Paul Christophe (HOR) — Absent Nathalie Colin-Oesterlé (HOR) — For Philippe Fait (HOR) — Absent Agnès Firmin Le Bodo (HOR) — Absent François Gernigon (HOR) — For Félicie Gérard (HOR) — Absent Pierre Henriet (HOR) — For François Jolivet (HOR) — Absent Loïc Kervran (HOR) — For Thomas Lam (HOR) — Absent Anne Le Hénanff (HOR) — Non-voting Didier Lemaire (HOR) — Absent Lise Magnier (HOR) — Absent Laurent Marcangeli (HOR) — For Jean Moulliere (HOR) — For Naïma Moutchou (HOR) — Non-voting Jérémie Patrier-Leitus (HOR) — For — by proxy Béatrice Piron (HOR) — Absent Christophe Plassard (HOR) — Absent Jean-François Portarrieu (HOR) — Absent Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback (HOR) — Absent Isabelle Rauch (HOR) — Absent Xavier Roseren (HOR) — Absent Laetitia Saint-Paul (HOR) — Absent Vincent Thiébaut (HOR) — Absent Frédéric Valletoux (HOR) — For Anne-Cécile Violland (HOR) — Absent Michel Barnier (DR) — Absent Thibault Bazin (DR) — Abstention Valérie Bazin-Malgras (DR) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-Didier Berger (DR) — Absent Anne-Laure Blin (DR) — Absent Sylvie Bonnet (DR) — For Émilie Bonnivard (DR) — Abstention Jean-Yves Bony (DR) — Against Ian Boucard (DR) — Abstention Jean-Luc Bourgeaux (DR) — Absent Xavier Breton (DR) — Absent Hubert Brigand (DR) — Absent Fabrice Brun (DR) — Absent François-Xavier Ceccoli (DR) — Abstention Pierre Cordier (DR) — Absent Josiane Corneloup (DR) — Abstention Marie-Christine Dalloz (DR) — Absent Vincent Descoeur (DR) — Abstention Fabien Di Filippo (DR) — Absent Julien Dive (DR) — Absent Virginie Duby-Muller (DR) — Absent Nicolas Forissier (DR) — Non-voting Philippe Gosselin (DR) — Absent Justine Gruet (DR) — Abstention Michel Herbillon (DR) — Absent Patrick Hetzel (DR) — For — by proxy Vincent Jeanbrun (DR) — Non-voting Philippe Juvin (DR) — Absent Corentin Le Fur (DR) — For Guillaume Lepers (DR) — Absent Eric Liégeon (DR) — Abstention Véronique Louwagie (DR) — Absent Sébastien Martin (DR) — Non-voting Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) (DR) — Abstention Frédérique Meunier (DR) — Absent Christelle Minard (DR) — Absent Yannick Neuder (DR) — Absent Jérôme Nury (DR) — Absent Éric Pauget (DR) — Absent Christelle Petex (DR) — Absent Alexandre Portier (DR) — Absent Nicolas Ray (DR) — Absent Vincent Rolland (DR) — Absent Michèle Tabarot (DR) — Absent Jean-Pierre Taite (DR) — Absent Jean-Louis Thiériot (DR) — Absent Antoine Vermorel (DR) — Absent Jean-Pierre Vigier (DR) — Absent Laurent Wauquiez (DR) — Absent Élisabeth de Maistre (DR) — For Alexandre Allegret-Pilot (UDR) — Abstention Charles Alloncle (UDR) — Abstention Matthieu Bloch (UDR) — Abstention Pierre-Henri Carbonnel (UDR) — Absent Bernard Chaix (UDR) — Absent Marc Chavent (UDR) — Abstention Éric Ciotti (UDR) — Absent Christelle D'Intorni (UDR) — Absent Olivier Fayssat (UDR) — Abstention Bartolomé Lenoir (UDR) — Abstention Hanane Mansouri (UDR) — Absent Maxime Michelet (UDR) — Abstention Éric Michoux (UDR) — Abstention Sophie Ricourt Vaginay (UDR) — Abstention Vincent Trébuchet (UDR) — Abstention — by proxy Gérault Verny (UDR) — Absent Franck Allisio (RN) — Absent Maxime Amblard (RN) — Abstention Bénédicte Auzanot (RN) — Absent Philippe Ballard (RN) — Absent Anchya Bamana (RN) — Against Christophe Barthès (RN) — Abstention Romain Baubry (RN) — Abstention José Beaurain (RN) — Abstention Christophe Bentz (RN) — Abstention Théo Bernhardt (RN) — Absent Guillaume Bigot (RN) — Absent Bruno Bilde (RN) — Abstention Emmanuel Blairy (RN) — Absent Sophie Blanc (RN) — Absent Frédéric Boccaletti (RN) — Absent Pascale Bordes (RN) — Abstention Anthony Boulogne (RN) — Absent Manon Bouquin (RN) — Abstention Jorys Bovet (RN) — Abstention Jérôme Buisson (RN) — Absent Eddy Casterman (RN) — Absent Sébastien Chenu (RN) — Absent Roger Chudeau (RN) — Abstention Bruno Clavet (RN) — Abstention Caroline Colombier (RN) — Absent Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Sandra Delannoy (RN) — Against Jocelyn Dessigny (RN) — Abstention Edwige Diaz (RN) — Abstention Sandrine Dogor-Such (RN) — Abstention Nicolas Dragon (RN) — Absent Alexandre Dufosset (RN) — Absent Gaëtan Dussausaye (RN) — Abstention Aurélien Dutremble (RN) — Abstention Auguste Evrard (RN) — Absent Frédéric Falcon (RN) — Absent Guillaume Florquin (RN) — Abstention Emmanuel Fouquart (RN) — Absent Thierry Frappé (RN) — Abstention Julien Gabarron (RN) — Abstention Stéphanie Galzy (RN) — Absent Jonathan Gery (RN) — Abstention Frank Giletti (RN) — Absent Yoann Gillet (RN) — Absent Christian Girard (RN) — Abstention Antoine Golliot (RN) — Abstention José Gonzalez (RN) — Abstention Florence Goulet (RN) — Abstention (vote correction) Géraldine Grangier (RN) — Abstention Monique Griseti (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Julien Guibert (RN) — Abstention Michel Guiniot (RN) — Absent Jordan Guitton (RN) — Absent Marine Hamelet (RN) — Abstention Timothée Houssin (RN) — Abstention Sébastien Humbert (RN) — Abstention Laurent Jacobelli (RN) — Abstention Pascal Jenft (RN) — Abstention Alexis Jolly (RN) — Absent Tiffany Joncour (RN) — Abstention Sylvie Josserand (RN) — Abstention Florence Joubert (RN) — Abstention Hélène Laporte (RN) — Absent Laure Lavalette (RN) — Absent Robert Le Bourgeois (RN) — Abstention Marine Le Pen (RN) — Absent Julie Lechanteux (RN) — Absent Nadine Lechon (RN) — Abstention Gisèle Lelouis (RN) — Abstention Katiana Levavasseur (RN) — Abstention Julien Limongi (RN) — Abstention René Lioret (RN) — Abstention Christine Loir (RN) — Absent Aurélien Lopez-Liguori (RN) — Absent Marie-France Lorho (RN) — Absent Philippe Lottiaux (RN) — Absent Alexandre Loubet (RN) — Abstention David Magnier (RN) — Absent Claire Marais-Beuil (RN) — Absent Matthieu Marchio (RN) — Abstention Pascal Markowsky (RN) — Absent Patrice Martin (RN) — Abstention Michèle Martinez (RN) — Absent Alexandra Masson (RN) — Absent Bryan Masson (RN) — Absent Kévin Mauvieux (RN) — Absent Nicolas Meizonnet (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Pierre Meurin (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Thibaut Monnier (RN) — Absent Serge Muller (RN) — Abstention Joëlle Mélin (RN) — Abstention Yaël Ménaché (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Thomas Ménagé (RN) — Abstention Julien Odoul (RN) — Abstention Caroline Parmentier (RN) — Absent Thierry Perez (RN) — Abstention Kévin Pfeffer (RN) — Abstention Lisette Pollet (RN) — Abstention Stéphane Rambaud (RN) — Abstention Angélique Ranc (RN) — Abstention Julien Rancoule (RN) — Absent Matthias Renault (RN) — Absent Catherine Rimbert (RN) — Absent Joseph Rivière (RN) — Abstention Laurence Robert-Dehault (RN) — Absent Béatrice Roullaud (RN) — Abstention Sophie-Laurence Roy (RN) — Absent Anaïs Sabatini (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Alexandre Sabatou (RN) — Absent Emeric Salmon (RN) — Absent Philippe Schreck (RN) — Abstention Anne Sicard (RN) — Abstention Emmanuel Taché (RN) — Absent Jean-Philippe Tanguy (RN) — Absent Michaël Taverne (RN) — Absent Thierry Tesson (RN) — Abstention Lionel Tivoli (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Romain Tonussi (RN) — Absent Antoine Villedieu (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Frédéric-Pierre Vos (RN) — Absent Frédéric Weber (RN) — Absent Marc de Fleurian (RN) — Abstention Hervé de Lépinau (RN) — Abstention Véronique Besse (NI) — Absent Philippe Bonnecarrère (NI) — For Stella Dupont (NI) — Against — by proxy Christine Engrand (NI) — Absent Sophie Errante (NI) — Absent Daniel Grenon (NI) — Absent Valérie Létard (NI) — Absent Aurélien Pradié (NI) — Absent Raphaël Schellenberger (NI) — Absent Lionel Vuibert (NI) — For

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
LFI-NFP 0270 04471
GDR 050 01217
ECOS 0140 02438
SOC 0320 03769
LIOT 140 11521
DEM 071 12736
EPR 1370 74792
HOR 1100 22134
DR 4110 33250
UDR 0010 0616
RN 0267 054123
NI 210 0710

All deputies

DeputyGroupVote
Nadège Abomangoli LFI-NFP Against
Xavier Albertini HOR Absent
Laurent Alexandre LFI-NFP Against
Henri Alfandari HOR Absent
Alexandre Allegret-Pilot UDR Abstention
Marie-José Allemand SOC Against
Franck Allisio RN Absent
Charles Alloncle UDR Abstention
Gabriel Amard LFI-NFP Absent
Maxime Amblard RN Abstention
David Amiel EPR Non-voting
Ségolène Amiot LFI-NFP Against
Pouria Amirshahi ECOS Absent
Farida Amrani LFI-NFP Against by proxy
Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade EPR Against
Rodrigo Arenas LFI-NFP Absent
Antoine Armand EPR Absent
Raphaël Arnault LFI-NFP Against
Christine Arrighi ECOS Absent
Gabriel Attal EPR Absent
Clémentine Autain ECOS Absent
Bénédicte Auzanot RN Absent
Joël Aviragnet SOC Absent
Léa Balage El Mariky ECOS Absent
Erwan Balanant DEM Absent
Philippe Ballard RN Absent
Anchya Bamana RN Against
Géraldine Bannier DEM Absent
Christian Baptiste SOC Absent
Michel Barnier DR Absent
Christophe Barthès RN Abstention
Fabrice Barusseau SOC Absent
Jean-Pierre Bataille LIOT Absent
Delphine Batho ECOS Absent
Marie-Noëlle Battistel SOC Against
Romain Baubry RN Abstention
Laurent Baumel SOC Absent
Thibault Bazin DR Abstention
Valérie Bazin-Malgras DR Abstention by proxy
José Beaurain RN Abstention
Olivier Becht EPR Absent
Belkhir Belhaddad SOC Absent
Béatrice Bellamy HOR For
Béatrice Bellay SOC Absent
Lisa Belluco ECOS Absent
Anaïs Belouassa-Cherifi LFI-NFP Absent
Karim Ben Cheikh ECOS Absent
Édouard Bénard GDR Against
Karim Benbrahim SOC Against
Thierry Benoit HOR Absent
Christophe Bentz RN Abstention
Anne Bergantz DEM Against
Jean-Didier Berger DR Absent
Ugo Bernalicis LFI-NFP Absent
Théo Bernhardt RN Absent
Sylvain Berrios HOR Absent
Hervé Berville EPR Absent
Véronique Besse NI Absent
Christophe Bex LFI-NFP Absent
Guillaume Bigot RN Absent
Bruno Bilde RN Abstention
Carlos Martens Bilongo LFI-NFP Absent
Benoît Biteau ECOS Absent
Emmanuel Blairy RN Absent
Sophie Blanc RN Absent
Christophe Blanchet DEM Absent
Anne-Laure Blin DR Absent
Matthieu Bloch UDR Abstention
Frédéric Boccaletti RN Absent
Philippe Bolo DEM Absent
Manuel Bompard LFI-NFP Against
Philippe Bonnecarrère NI For
Arnaud Bonnet ECOS Against
Nicolas Bonnet ECOS Against
Sylvie Bonnet DR For
Émilie Bonnivard DR Abstention
Jean-Yves Bony DR Against
Pascale Bordes RN Abstention
Éric Bothorel EPR Against by proxy
Ian Boucard DR Abstention
Florent Boudié EPR Absent
Anthony Boulogne RN Absent
Mickaël Bouloux SOC Against
Idir Boumertit LFI-NFP Absent
Manon Bouquin RN Abstention
Jean-Luc Bourgeaux DR Absent
Soumya Bourouaha GDR Absent
Bertrand Bouyx HOR For
Jorys Bovet RN Abstention
Louis Boyard LFI-NFP Absent
Jean-Michel Brard HOR For
Yaël Braun-Pivet EPR Non-voting
Maud Bregeon EPR Non-voting
Xavier Breton DR Absent
Hubert Brigand DR Absent
Blandine Brocard DEM Absent
Anthony Brosse EPR Against by proxy
Julien Brugerolles GDR Absent
Danielle Brulebois EPR Against
Fabrice Brun DR Absent
Philippe Brun SOC Against
Joël Bruneau LIOT For
Stéphane Buchou EPR Against
Françoise Buffet EPR Against
Jérôme Buisson RN Absent
Pierre-Yves Cadalen LFI-NFP Against
Elie Califer SOC Against
Céline Calvez EPR Against
Colette Capdevielle SOC Against
Pierre-Henri Carbonnel UDR Absent
Eléonore Caroit EPR Non-voting
Aymeric Caron LFI-NFP Absent
Sylvain Carrière LFI-NFP Against
Michel Castellani LIOT Absent
Eddy Casterman RN Absent
Jean-Victor Castor GDR Absent
Gabrielle Cathala LFI-NFP Against
Vincent Caure EPR Absent
Lionel Causse EPR Against
Thomas Cazenave EPR Absent
Jean-René Cazeneuve EPR Against
Pierre Cazeneuve EPR For
François-Xavier Ceccoli DR Abstention
Bérenger Cernon LFI-NFP Against
Bernard Chaix UDR Absent
Cyrielle Chatelain ECOS Absent
Marc Chavent UDR Abstention
Yannick Chenevard EPR Against
Sébastien Chenu RN Absent
Sophia Chikirou LFI-NFP Absent
Paul Christophe HOR Absent
Paul Christophle SOC Against
Roger Chudeau RN Abstention
Éric Ciotti UDR Absent
Bruno Clavet RN Abstention
Hadrien Clouet LFI-NFP Against
Nathalie Coggia EPR Against
Nathalie Colin-Oesterlé HOR For
Paul-André Colombani LIOT Against corrected (originally: for)
Caroline Colombier RN Absent
Éric Coquerel LFI-NFP Absent
Alexis Corbière ECOS Against by proxy
Pierre Cordier DR Absent
François Cormier-Bouligeon EPR Against
Josiane Corneloup DR Abstention
Mickaël Cosson DEM Absent
Jean-François Coulomme LFI-NFP Absent
Pierrick Courbon SOC Against
Laurent Croizier DEM Absent
Christelle D'Intorni UDR Absent
Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho RN Abstention by proxy
Marie-Christine Dalloz DR Absent
Geneviève Darrieussecq DEM Against
Romain Daubié DEM Absent
Hendrik Davi ECOS Against
Alain David SOC Absent
Charles de Courson LIOT Absent
Marc de Fleurian RN Abstention
Hervé de Lépinau RN Abstention
Élisabeth de Maistre DR For
Constance de Pélichy LIOT Absent
Sandra Delannoy RN Against
Arthur Delaporte SOC Against by proxy
Stéphane Delautrette SOC Against
Sébastien Delogu LFI-NFP Against
Julie Delpech EPR Against
Vincent Descoeur DR Abstention
Jocelyn Dessigny RN Abstention
Fabien Di Filippo DR Absent
Edwige Diaz RN Abstention
Dieynaba Diop SOC Against
Aly Diouara LFI-NFP Absent
Benjamin Dirx EPR Absent
Julien Dive DR Absent
Sandrine Dogor-Such RN Abstention
Fanny Dombre Coste SOC Against by proxy
Nicolas Dragon RN Absent
Nicole Dubré-Chirat EPR Absent
Virginie Duby-Muller DR Absent
Peio Dufau SOC Against
Alexandre Dufosset RN Absent
Alma Dufour LFI-NFP Absent
Emmanuel Duplessy ECOS Absent
Stella Dupont NI Against by proxy
Gaëtan Dussausaye RN Abstention
Aurélien Dutremble RN Abstention
Iñaki Echaniz SOC Against
Christine Engrand NI Absent
Karen Erodi LFI-NFP Against
Sophie Errante NI Absent
Romain Eskenazi SOC Against
Auguste Evrard RN Absent
Philippe Fait HOR Absent
Frédéric Falcon RN Absent
Olivier Falorni DEM Against
Elsa Faucillon GDR Against
Olivier Faure SOC Absent
Yannick Favennec-Bécot LIOT Against
Olivier Fayssat UDR Abstention
Denis Fégné SOC Absent
Mathilde Feld LFI-NFP Absent
Emmanuel Fernandes LFI-NFP Against
Marc Ferracci EPR Against
Marina Ferrari DEM Non-voting
Sylvie Ferrer LFI-NFP Absent
Marc Fesneau DEM Absent
Jean-Marie Fiévet EPR Absent
Agnès Firmin Le Bodo HOR Absent
Guillaume Florquin RN Abstention
Nicolas Forissier DR Non-voting
Emmanuel Fouquart RN Absent
Charles Fournier ECOS Absent
Thierry Frappé RN Abstention
Moerani Frébault EPR Absent
Martine Froger SOC Absent
Bruno Fuchs DEM Absent
Jean-Luc Fugit EPR Against
Julien Gabarron RN Abstention
Perceval Gaillard LFI-NFP Against by proxy
Camille Galliard-Minier EPR Against
Stéphanie Galzy RN Absent
Marie-Charlotte Garin ECOS Against
Guillaume Garot SOC Against
Thomas Gassilloud EPR Absent
Anne Genetet EPR Against
Félicie Gérard HOR Absent
François Gernigon HOR For
Jonathan Gery RN Abstention
Frank Giletti RN Absent
Yoann Gillet RN Absent
Christian Girard RN Abstention
Damien Girard ECOS Absent
Olga Givernet EPR Absent
Océane Godard SOC Against
Julien Gokel SOC Absent
Antoine Golliot RN Abstention
José Gonzalez RN Abstention
Philippe Gosselin DR Absent
Pascale Got SOC Against
Guillaume Gouffier Valente EPR Against by proxy
Florence Goulet RN Abstention corrected (originally: against)
Perrine Goulet DEM Absent
Géraldine Grangier RN Abstention
Emmanuel Grégoire SOC Absent
Olivia Grégoire EPR Absent
Jean-Carles Grelier DEM Absent
Daniel Grenon NI Absent
Monique Griseti RN Abstention by proxy
Justine Gruet DR Abstention
Jérôme Guedj SOC Against
Clémence Guetté LFI-NFP Absent
Julien Guibert RN Abstention
Michel Guiniot RN Absent
David Guiraud LFI-NFP Absent
Jordan Guitton RN Absent
Frantz Gumbs DEM Absent
Steevy Gustave ECOS Against
David Habib LIOT Absent
Stéphane Hablot SOC Absent
Ayda Hadizadeh SOC Absent
Zahia Hamdane LFI-NFP Against
Marine Hamelet RN Abstention
Pierre Henriet HOR For
Michel Herbillon DR Absent
Florence Herouin-Léautey SOC Absent
Catherine Hervieu ECOS Against
Céline Hervieu SOC Absent
Patrick Hetzel DR For by proxy
Mathilde Hignet LFI-NFP Against by proxy
François Hollande SOC Absent
Sacha Houlié SOC Against
Timothée Houssin RN Abstention
Sébastien Humbert RN Abstention
Harold Huwart LIOT Absent
Sébastien Huyghe EPR Against
Jérémie Iordanoff ECOS Absent
Cyrille Isaac-Sibille DEM Against
Laurent Jacobelli RN Abstention
Jean-Michel Jacques EPR Against
Vincent Jeanbrun DR Non-voting
Pascal Jenft RN Abstention
François Jolivet HOR Absent
Alexis Jolly RN Absent
Tiffany Joncour RN Abstention
Sylvie Josserand RN Abstention
Sandrine Josso DEM Against by proxy
Florence Joubert RN Abstention
Chantal Jourdan SOC Absent
Philippe Juvin DR Absent
Émeline K/Bidi GDR Absent
Marietta Karamanli SOC Absent
Guillaume Kasbarian EPR Absent
Fatiha Keloua Hachi SOC Against
Andy Kerbrat LFI-NFP Absent
Loïc Kervran HOR For
Brigitte Klinkert EPR Absent
Daniel Labaronne EPR Absent
Bastien Lachaud LFI-NFP Against
Julie Laernoes ECOS Absent
Tristan Lahais ECOS Absent
Abdelkader Lahmar LFI-NFP Absent
Maxime Laisney LFI-NFP Absent
Amélia Lakrafi EPR Absent
Thomas Lam HOR Absent
Hélène Laporte RN Absent
Philippe Latombe DEM Abstention
Michel Lauzzana EPR Absent
Laure Lavalette RN Absent
Robert Le Bourgeois RN Abstention
Aurélien Le Coq LFI-NFP Absent
Sandrine Le Feur EPR Against
Corentin Le Fur DR For
Didier Le Gac EPR Against
Arnaud Le Gall LFI-NFP Against by proxy
Constance Le Grip EPR Absent
Anne Le Hénanff HOR Non-voting
Annaïg Le Meur EPR Absent
Christine Le Nabour EPR Absent
Nicole Le Peih EPR Absent
Marine Le Pen RN Absent
Antoine Léaument LFI-NFP Absent
Marie Lebec EPR Absent
Karine Lebon GDR Against
Élise Leboucher LFI-NFP Against
Pascal Lecamp DEM Absent
Julie Lechanteux RN Absent
Nadine Lechon RN Abstention
Jean-Paul Lecoq GDR Absent
Vincent Ledoux EPR Absent
Mathieu Lefèvre EPR Non-voting
Jérôme Legavre LFI-NFP Absent
Sarah Legrain LFI-NFP Against by proxy
Claire Lejeune LFI-NFP Absent
Gisèle Lelouis RN Abstention
Didier Lemaire HOR Absent
Bartolomé Lenoir UDR Abstention
Stéphane Lenormand LIOT Absent
Guillaume Lepers DR Absent
Murielle Lepvraud LFI-NFP Absent
Roland Lescure EPR Non-voting
Gérard Leseul SOC Absent
Valérie Létard NI Absent
Pauline Levasseur EPR Absent
Katiana Levavasseur RN Abstention
Laurent Lhardit SOC Absent
Eric Liégeon DR Abstention
Julien Limongi RN Abstention
Delphine Lingemann DEM Absent
René Lioret RN Abstention
Brigitte Liso EPR Absent
Christine Loir RN Absent
Aurélien Lopez-Liguori RN Absent
Marie-France Lorho RN Absent
Philippe Lottiaux RN Absent
Alexandre Loubet RN Abstention
Véronique Louwagie DR Absent
Benjamin Lucas-Lundy ECOS Against
David Magnier RN Absent
Lise Magnier HOR Absent
Sylvain Maillard EPR Against
Frédéric Maillot GDR Absent
Emmanuel Mandon DEM Absent
Hanane Mansouri UDR Absent
Claire Marais-Beuil RN Absent
Laurent Marcangeli HOR For
Matthieu Marchio RN Abstention
Bastien Marchive EPR Against
Christophe Marion EPR Absent
Pascal Markowsky RN Absent
Sandra Marsaud EPR Against
Élisa Martin LFI-NFP Against
Patrice Martin RN Abstention
Sébastien Martin DR Non-voting
Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) DR Abstention
Éric Martineau DEM Absent
Michèle Martinez RN Absent
Denis Masséglia EPR Absent
Alexandra Masson RN Absent
Bryan Masson RN Absent
Max Mathiasin LIOT Absent
Jean-Paul Mattei DEM Absent
Damien Maudet LFI-NFP Against
Emmanuel Maurel GDR Absent
Kévin Mauvieux RN Absent
Marianne Maximi LFI-NFP Absent
Stéphane Mazars EPR Against
Laurent Mazaury LIOT Absent
Nicolas Meizonnet RN Abstention by proxy
Graziella Melchior EPR Against
Joëlle Mélin RN Abstention
Yaël Ménaché RN Abstention by proxy
Thomas Ménagé RN Abstention
Ludovic Mendes EPR Against
Estelle Mercier SOC Absent
Marie Mesmeur LFI-NFP Absent
Sophie Mette DEM Absent
Nicolas Metzdorf EPR Absent
Frédérique Meunier DR Absent
Manon Meunier LFI-NFP Absent
Pierre Meurin RN Abstention by proxy
Maxime Michelet UDR Abstention
Éric Michoux UDR Abstention
Paul Midy EPR Absent
Laure Miller EPR Absent
Christelle Minard DR Absent
Joséphine Missoffe EPR Absent
Paul Molac LIOT Absent
Yannick Monnet GDR Against
Thibaut Monnier RN Absent
Louise Morel DEM Absent
Jean Moulliere HOR For
Naïma Moutchou HOR Non-voting
Serge Muller RN Abstention
Marcellin Nadeau GDR Absent
Christophe Naegelen LIOT Absent
Philippe Naillet SOC Absent
Yannick Neuder DR Absent
Jean-Philippe Nilor LFI-NFP Absent
Sandrine Nosbé LFI-NFP Absent
Jérôme Nury DR Absent
Jacques Oberti SOC Against
Danièle Obono LFI-NFP Absent
Julien Odoul RN Abstention
Karl Olive EPR Absent
Hubert Ott DEM Absent
Julie Ozenne ECOS Against
Nathalie Oziol LFI-NFP Absent
Jimmy Pahun DEM Absent
Laurent Panifous LIOT Non-voting
Sophie Panonacle EPR Absent
Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet EPR Absent
Mathilde Panot LFI-NFP Absent
Sophie Pantel SOC Against
Caroline Parmentier RN Absent
Jérémie Patrier-Leitus HOR For by proxy
Éric Pauget DR Absent
Marc Pena SOC Absent
Thierry Perez RN Abstention
Christelle Petex DR Absent
Frédéric Petit DEM Absent
Maud Petit DEM Absent
Stéphane Peu GDR Against
Sébastien Peytavie ECOS Against by proxy
Kévin Pfeffer RN Abstention
Anna Pic SOC Absent
René Pilato LFI-NFP Absent
François Piquemal LFI-NFP Absent
Christine Pirès Beaune SOC Absent
Béatrice Piron HOR Absent
Christophe Plassard HOR Absent
Marie Pochon ECOS Against
Lisette Pollet RN Abstention
Jean-François Portarrieu HOR Absent
Thomas Portes LFI-NFP Absent
Alexandre Portier DR Absent
Dominique Potier SOC Absent
Josy Poueyto DEM Against by proxy
Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback HOR Absent
Natalia Pouzyreff EPR Against
Aurélien Pradié NI Absent
Pierre Pribetich SOC Against
Christophe Proença SOC Absent
Loïc Prud'homme LFI-NFP Against
Stéphane Rambaud RN Abstention
Richard Ramos DEM Absent
Angélique Ranc RN Abstention
Julien Rancoule RN Absent
Jean-Hugues Ratenon LFI-NFP Against by proxy
Isabelle Rauch HOR Absent
Jean-Claude Raux ECOS Absent
Nicolas Ray DR Absent
Marie Récalde SOC Absent
Sandra Regol ECOS Against
Mereana Reid Arbelot GDR Absent
Matthias Renault RN Absent
Sophie Ricourt Vaginay UDR Abstention
Franck Riester EPR Against
Davy Rimane GDR Absent
Catherine Rimbert RN Absent
Véronique Riotton EPR Absent
Stéphanie Rist EPR Non-voting
Joseph Rivière RN Abstention
Marie-Pierre Rixain EPR Absent
Laurence Robert-Dehault RN Absent
Charles Rodwell EPR Absent
Vincent Rolland DR Absent
Anne-Sophie Ronceret EPR Against
Xavier Roseren HOR Absent
Valérie Rossi SOC Against
Claudia Rouaux SOC Against
Béatrice Roullaud RN Abstention
Jean-Louis Roumégas ECOS Absent
Aurélien Rousseau SOC Absent
Sandrine Rousseau ECOS Against
Fabrice Roussel SOC Against
Jean-François Rousset EPR Against
Sophie-Laurence Roy RN Absent
François Ruffin ECOS Absent
Sandrine Runel SOC Absent
Anaïs Sabatini RN Abstention by proxy
Alexandre Sabatou RN Absent
Arnaud Saint-Martin LFI-NFP Absent
Sébastien Saint-Pasteur SOC Against
Laetitia Saint-Paul HOR Absent
Aurélien Saintoul LFI-NFP Absent
Emeric Salmon RN Absent
Nicole Sanquer LIOT Absent
Nicolas Sansu GDR Absent
Isabelle Santiago SOC Absent
Eva Sas ECOS Absent
Hervé Saulignac SOC Absent
Raphaël Schellenberger NI Absent
Philippe Schreck RN Abstention
Sabrina Sebaihi ECOS Absent
Mikaele Seo EPR Absent
Freddy Sertin EPR Absent
Olivier Serva LIOT Absent
Anne Sicard RN Abstention
Arnaud Simion SOC Against
Danielle Simonnet ECOS Absent
Charles Sitzenstuhl EPR Absent
Bertrand Sorre EPR Absent
Thierry Sother SOC Absent
Ersilia Soudais LFI-NFP Absent
Violette Spillebout EPR Absent
Anne Stambach-Terrenoir LFI-NFP Absent
Michèle Tabarot DR Absent
Aurélien Taché LFI-NFP Absent
Emmanuel Taché RN Absent
Sophie Taillé-Polian ECOS Absent
Jean-Pierre Taite DR Absent
Jean-Philippe Tanguy RN Absent
Liliana Tanguy EPR Absent
David Taupiac LIOT Against
Andrée Taurinya LFI-NFP Against by proxy
Matthias Tavel LFI-NFP Absent
Michaël Taverne RN Absent
Boris Tavernier ECOS Absent
Jean Terlier EPR Against
Thierry Tesson RN Abstention
Prisca Thevenot EPR Against
Céline Thiébault-Martinez SOC Against
Vincent Thiébaut HOR Absent
Jean-Louis Thiériot DR Absent
Nicolas Thierry ECOS Absent
Sabine Thillaye DEM Absent
Mélanie Thomin SOC Absent
Lionel Tivoli RN Abstention by proxy
Emmanuel Tjibaou GDR Absent
Romain Tonussi RN Absent
Stéphane Travert EPR Absent
Vincent Trébuchet UDR Abstention by proxy
Aurélie Trouvé LFI-NFP Against
Nicolas Turquois DEM Absent
Boris Vallaud SOC Against
Frédéric Valletoux HOR For
Paul Vannier LFI-NFP Absent
Antoine Vermorel DR Absent
Gérault Verny UDR Absent
Roger Vicot SOC Absent
Annie Vidal EPR Against
Jean-Pierre Vigier DR Absent
Philippe Vigier DEM Against
Corinne Vignon EPR Absent
Antoine Villedieu RN Abstention by proxy
Anne-Cécile Violland HOR Absent
Stéphane Viry LIOT Absent
Frédéric-Pierre Vos RN Absent
Dominique Voynet ECOS Against
Lionel Vuibert NI For
Jean-Luc Warsmann LIOT Against
Laurent Wauquiez DR Absent
Frédéric Weber RN Absent
Jiovanny William SOC Absent
Éric Woerth EPR Against by proxy
Caroline Yadan EPR Against
Estelle Youssouffa LIOT Absent