← All votes

National Assembly · vote no. 3010 · · ✓ Adopted

The entire draft finance law of end of management for 2023 (text of the Joint Committee).

≈ automatic translation Official title: Projet de loi de finances de fin de gestion pour 2023 (texte de la commission paritaire)

Promulgated See this text's full journey →

Promulgated on 30 November 2023 Published in the Official Journal on 1 December 2023 Law no. 2023-1114 Text on Légifrance ↗ Legislative file ↗

Type of vote
Ordinary roll-call vote
Voters
192
1 non-voting
Votes cast
123
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
62 votes
Majorité absolue des suffrages exprimés

99 for 24 against 69 abstentions ▏threshold : 62 votes

Colour by:
LFI-NUPES — 75 GDR-NUPES — 22 ECOLO — 23 SOC — 9 SOC-A — 22 LIOT — 21 DEM — 51 RE — 170 HOR — 30 LR — 62 RN — 88 NI — 4 LFI-NUPESGDR-NUPESECOLOSOC-ADEMREHORLRRN Nadège Abomangoli (LFI-NUPES) — Against Laurent Alexandre (LFI-NUPES) — Against Gabriel Amard (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Ségolène Amiot (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Farida Amrani (LFI-NUPES) — Against Rodrigo Arenas (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Clémentine Autain (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Ugo Bernalicis (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Christophe Bex (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Carlos Martens Bilongo (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Manuel Bompard (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Idir Boumertit (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Louis Boyard (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Aymeric Caron (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Sylvain Carrière (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Florian Chauche (LFI-NUPES) — Against Sophia Chikirou (LFI-NUPES) — Against Hadrien Clouet (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Éric Coquerel (LFI-NUPES) — Against Alexis Corbière (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Jean-François Coulomme (LFI-NUPES) — Against Catherine Couturier (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Hendrik Davi (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Sébastien Delogu (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Alma Dufour (LFI-NUPES) — Against Karen Erodi (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Martine Etienne (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Emmanuel Fernandes (LFI-NUPES) — Against Sylvie Ferrer (LFI-NUPES) — Against Caroline Fiat (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Perceval Gaillard (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Raquel Garrido (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Clémence Guetté (LFI-NUPES) — Absent David Guiraud (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Mathilde Hignet (LFI-NUPES) — Against Rachel Keke (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Andy Kerbrat (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Bastien Lachaud (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Maxime Laisney (LFI-NUPES) — Against Arnaud Le Gall (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Élise Leboucher (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Charlotte Leduc (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Jérôme Legavre (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Sarah Legrain (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Murielle Lepvraud (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Antoine Léaument (LFI-NUPES) — Against Pascale Martin (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Élisa Martin (LFI-NUPES) — Absent William Martinet (LFI-NUPES) — Against Frédéric Mathieu (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Damien Maudet (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Marianne Maximi (LFI-NUPES) — Against Manon Meunier (LFI-NUPES) — Against Jean-Philippe Nilor (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Danièle Obono (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Nathalie Oziol (LFI-NUPES) — Against Mathilde Panot (LFI-NUPES) — Absent René Pilato (LFI-NUPES) — Absent François Piquemal (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Thomas Portes (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Loïc Prud'homme (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Adrien Quatennens (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Jean-Hugues Ratenon (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Sébastien Rome (LFI-NUPES) — Absent François Ruffin (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Aurélien Saintoul (LFI-NUPES) — Against Michel Sala (LFI-NUPES) — Against Danielle Simonnet (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Ersilia Soudais (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Anne Stambach-Terrenoir (LFI-NUPES) — Against Andrée Taurinya (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Matthias Tavel (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Aurélie Trouvé (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Paul Vannier (LFI-NUPES) — Against Léo Walter (LFI-NUPES) — Absent Soumya Bourouaha (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Jean-Victor Castor (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Steve Chailloux (GDR-NUPES) — Absent André Chassaigne (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Pierre Dharréville (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Elsa Faucillon (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Sébastien Jumel (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Émeline K/Bidi (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Tematai Le Gayic (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Karine Lebon (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Jean-Paul Lecoq (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Frédéric Maillot (GDR-NUPES) — Against Yannick Monnet (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Marcellin Nadeau (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Stéphane Peu (GDR-NUPES) — Against Mereana Reid Arbelot (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Davy Rimane (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Fabien Roussel (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Nicolas Sansu (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Jean-Marc Tellier (GDR-NUPES) — Against Jiovanny William (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Hubert Wulfranc (GDR-NUPES) — Absent Christine Arrighi (ECOLO) — Abstention Delphine Batho (ECOLO) — Absent Julien Bayou (ECOLO) — Absent Lisa Belluco (ECOLO) — Absent Karim Ben Cheikh (ECOLO) — Abstention Cyrielle Chatelain (ECOLO) — Absent Charles Fournier (ECOLO) — Absent Marie-Charlotte Garin (ECOLO) — Absent Jérémie Iordanoff (ECOLO) — Abstention Hubert Julien-Laferrière (ECOLO) — Absent Julie Laernoes (ECOLO) — Absent Benjamin Lucas-Lundy (ECOLO) — Abstention Francesca Pasquini (ECOLO) — Absent Sébastien Peytavie (ECOLO) — Absent Marie Pochon (ECOLO) — Abstention Jean-Claude Raux (ECOLO) — Abstention Sandra Regol (ECOLO) — Abstention Sandrine Rousseau (ECOLO) — Absent Eva Sas (ECOLO) — Abstention Sabrina Sebaihi (ECOLO) — Absent Aurélien Taché (ECOLO) — Absent Sophie Taillé-Polian (ECOLO) — Absent Nicolas Thierry (ECOLO) — Absent Marie-Noëlle Battistel (SOC) — Abstention Mickaël Bouloux (SOC) — Abstention Guillaume Garot (SOC) — Abstention Marietta Karamanli (SOC) — Abstention Fatiha Keloua Hachi (SOC) — Abstention Philippe Naillet (SOC) — Abstention Christine Pirès Beaune (SOC) — Abstention Hervé Saulignac (SOC) — Abstention Mélanie Thomin (SOC) — Abstention Joël Aviragnet (SOC-A) — Absent Christian Baptiste (SOC-A) — Absent Philippe Brun (SOC-A) — Absent Elie Califer (SOC-A) — Absent Alain David (SOC-A) — Absent Arthur Delaporte (SOC-A) — Absent Stéphane Delautrette (SOC-A) — Absent Iñaki Echaniz (SOC-A) — Absent Olivier Faure (SOC-A) — Absent Jérôme Guedj (SOC-A) — Absent Johnny Hajjar (SOC-A) — Absent Chantal Jourdan (SOC-A) — Absent Gérard Leseul (SOC-A) — Absent Bertrand Petit (SOC-A) — Absent Anna Pic (SOC-A) — Absent Dominique Potier (SOC-A) — Absent Valérie Rabault (SOC-A) — Absent Claudia Rouaux (SOC-A) — Absent Isabelle Santiago (SOC-A) — Absent Cécile Untermaier (SOC-A) — Absent Boris Vallaud (SOC-A) — Absent Roger Vicot (SOC-A) — Absent Jean-Félix Acquaviva (LIOT) — Absent Nathalie Bassire (LIOT) — Absent Guy Bricout (LIOT) — Abstention Jean-Louis Bricout (LIOT) — Abstention Michel Castellani (LIOT) — Absent Paul-André Colombani (LIOT) — Absent Béatrice Descamps (LIOT) — Absent Martine Froger (LIOT) — Abstention Stéphane Lenormand (LIOT) — Abstention Max Mathiasin (LIOT) — Absent Paul Molac (LIOT) — Absent Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier (LIOT) — Abstention Christophe Naegelen (LIOT) — Absent Bertrand Pancher (LIOT) — Abstention Laurent Panifous (LIOT) — Abstention Benjamin Saint-Huile (LIOT) — Abstention Olivier Serva (LIOT) — Absent David Taupiac (LIOT) — Abstention Jean-Luc Warsmann (LIOT) — Absent Estelle Youssouffa (LIOT) — Absent Charles de Courson (LIOT) — Abstention Anne-Laure Babault (DEM) — Absent Erwan Balanant (DEM) — Absent Géraldine Bannier (DEM) — Absent Anne Bergantz (DEM) — Absent Philippe Berta (DEM) — For Christophe Blanchet (DEM) — For Philippe Bolo (DEM) — Absent Jean-Louis Bourlanges (DEM) — Absent Blandine Brocard (DEM) — Absent Vincent Bru (DEM) — Absent Mickaël Cosson (DEM) — Absent Laurent Croizier (DEM) — For Jean-Pierre Cubertafon (DEM) — Absent Geneviève Darrieussecq (DEM) — Absent Romain Daubié (DEM) — Absent Mathilde Desjonquères (DEM) — Absent Laurent Esquenet-Goxes (DEM) — Absent Olivier Falorni (DEM) — Absent Marina Ferrari (DEM) — For — by proxy Estelle Folest (DEM) — Absent Bruno Fuchs (DEM) — Absent Maud Gatel (DEM) — For Luc Geismar (DEM) — Absent Perrine Goulet (DEM) — Absent Frantz Gumbs (DEM) — Absent Cyrille Isaac-Sibille (DEM) — Absent Élodie Jacquier-Laforge (DEM) — Non-voting Sandrine Josso (DEM) — Absent Mohamed Laqhila (DEM) — For Florence Lasserre (DEM) — For Philippe Latombe (DEM) — Absent Pascal Lecamp (DEM) — For Laurent Leclercq (DEM) — For Delphine Lingemann (DEM) — For Aude Luquet (DEM) — For Emmanuel Mandon (DEM) — For Éric Martineau (DEM) — For Jean-Paul Mattei (DEM) — For Sophie Mette (DEM) — Absent Bruno Millienne (DEM) — For Louise Morel (DEM) — For Hubert Ott (DEM) — Absent Jimmy Pahun (DEM) — For Frédéric Petit (DEM) — Absent Maud Petit (DEM) — Absent Josy Poueyto (DEM) — For Richard Ramos (DEM) — Absent Sabine Thillaye (DEM) — Absent Nicolas Turquois (DEM) — Absent Laurence Vichnievsky (DEM) — Absent Frédéric Zgainski (DEM) — Absent Damien Abad (RE) — Absent Caroline Abadie (RE) — Absent Damien Adam (RE) — Absent Éric Alauzet (RE) — Absent David Amiel (RE) — For — by proxy Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade (RE) — Absent Jean-Philippe Ardouin (RE) — For Antoine Armand (RE) — For Quentin Bataillon (RE) — For Belkhir Belhaddad (RE) — For Mounir Belhamiti (RE) — Absent Fanta Berete (RE) — Absent Benoît Bordat (RE) — Absent Éric Bothorel (RE) — Absent Florent Boudié (RE) — Absent Chantal Bouloux (RE) — Absent Bertrand Bouyx (RE) — For Pascale Boyer (RE) — Absent Yaël Braun-Pivet (RE) — Absent Maud Bregeon (RE) — For Anthony Brosse (RE) — For Anne Brugnera (RE) — For Danielle Brulebois (RE) — For Stéphane Buchou (RE) — For Françoise Buffet (RE) — For Céline Calvez (RE) — Absent Eléonore Caroit (RE) — For Lionel Causse (RE) — Absent Jean-René Cazeneuve (RE) — For Pierre Cazeneuve (RE) — For Émilie Chandler (RE) — For Clara Chassaniol (RE) — For Yannick Chenevard (RE) — Absent Mireille Clapot (RE) — For Fabienne Colboc (RE) — Absent Claire Colomb-Pitollat (RE) — Absent François Cormier-Bouligeon (RE) — For Laurence Cristol (RE) — Absent Dominique Da Silva (RE) — For Christine Decodts (RE) — For Julie Delpech (RE) — Absent Frédéric Descrozaille (RE) — Absent Benjamin Dirx (RE) — Absent Ingrid Dordain (RE) — Absent Nicole Dubré-Chirat (RE) — Absent Philippe Dunoyer (RE) — Absent Stella Dupont (RE) — For Philippe Emmanuel (RE) — For Sophie Errante (RE) — Absent Philippe Fait (RE) — Absent Marc Ferracci (RE) — Absent Jean-Marie Fiévet (RE) — Absent Philippe Frei (RE) — Absent Jean-Luc Fugit (RE) — Absent Thomas Gassilloud (RE) — Absent Anne Genetet (RE) — Absent Hadrien Ghomi (RE) — Absent Éric Girardin (RE) — Absent Joël Giraud (RE) — For Olga Givernet (RE) — Absent Charlotte Goetschy-Bolognese (RE) — For Guillaume Gouffier Valente (RE) — Absent Jean-Carles Grelier (RE) — Absent Claire Guichard (RE) — Absent Philippe Guillemard (RE) — For Marie Guévenoux (RE) — Absent Raphaël Gérard (RE) — For — by proxy Benjamin Haddad (RE) — Absent Nadia Hai (RE) — Absent Yannick Haury (RE) — For Pierre Henriet (RE) — Absent Laurence Heydel Grillere (RE) — Absent Alexandre Holroyd (RE) — Absent Sacha Houlié (RE) — Absent Servane Hugues (RE) — Absent Monique Iborra (RE) — Absent Alexis Izard (RE) — For Jean-Michel Jacques (RE) — Absent Caroline Janvier (RE) — Absent Guillaume Kasbarian (RE) — Absent Brigitte Klinkert (RE) — For Daniel Labaronne (RE) — For Emmanuel Lacresse (RE) — Absent Amélia Lakrafi (RE) — Absent Virginie Lanlo (RE) — For Michel Lauzzana (RE) — For Pascal Lavergne (RE) — For Sandrine Le Feur (RE) — For Didier Le Gac (RE) — Absent Gilles Le Gendre (RE) — Absent Constance Le Grip (RE) — For Annaïg Le Meur (RE) — For — by proxy Christine Le Nabour (RE) — Absent Nicole Le Peih (RE) — Absent Fabrice Le Vigoureux (RE) — Absent Marie Lebec (RE) — For Vincent Ledoux (RE) — Absent Mathieu Lefèvre (RE) — For Patricia Lemoine (RE) — Absent Brigitte Liso (RE) — Absent Jean-François Lovisolo (RE) — Absent Sylvain Maillard (RE) — Absent Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie (RE) — Absent Jacqueline Maquet (RE) — For Bastien Marchive (RE) — For Louis Margueritte (RE) — For Christophe Marion (RE) — For Sandra Marsaud (RE) — For Didier Martin (RE) — Absent Alexandra Martin (Gironde) (RE) — For Denis Masséglia (RE) — For Stéphane Mazars (RE) — For Graziella Melchior (RE) — Absent Ludovic Mendes (RE) — Absent Nicolas Metzdorf (RE) — Absent Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert (RE) — For Paul Midy (RE) — Absent Laure Miller (RE) — Absent Benoit Mournet (RE) — For Lysiane Métayer (RE) — For Karl Olive (RE) — For Nicolas Pacquot (RE) — For Sophie Panonacle (RE) — Absent Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet (RE) — Absent Didier Parakian (RE) — For Didier Paris (RE) — Absent Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq (RE) — Absent Emmanuel Pellerin (RE) — For Patrice Perrot (RE) — For Anne-Laurence Petel (RE) — Absent Michèle Peyron (RE) — Absent Béatrice Piron (RE) — For Jean-Pierre Pont (RE) — Absent Éric Poulliat (RE) — For Natalia Pouzyreff (RE) — Absent Rémy Rebeyrotte (RE) — For Robin Reda (RE) — Absent Cécile Rilhac (RE) — Absent Véronique Riotton (RE) — Absent Stéphanie Rist (RE) — Absent Marie-Pierre Rixain (RE) — Absent Charles Rodwell (RE) — For — by proxy Xavier Roseren (RE) — Absent Jean-François Rousset (RE) — Absent Lionel Royer-Perreaut (RE) — For Thomas Rudigoz (RE) — For Laetitia Saint-Paul (RE) — For Mikaele Seo (RE) — Absent Freddy Sertin (RE) — For Charles Sitzenstuhl (RE) — For — by proxy Philippe Sorez (RE) — For Bertrand Sorre (RE) — Absent Violette Spillebout (RE) — Absent Bruno Studer (RE) — Absent Liliana Tanguy (RE) — For — by proxy Sarah Tanzilli (RE) — Absent Jean Terlier (RE) — For Huguette Tiegna (RE) — Absent Stéphane Travert (RE) — Absent David Valence (RE) — Absent Annie Vidal (RE) — Absent Patrick Vignal (RE) — Absent Corinne Vignon (RE) — Absent Stéphane Vojetta (RE) — Absent Lionel Vuibert (RE) — For Guillaume Vuilletet (RE) — Absent Christopher Weissberg (RE) — For Éric Woerth (RE) — For — by proxy Caroline Yadan (RE) — Absent Jean-Marc Zulesi (RE) — Absent Xavier Albertini (HOR) — For Henri Alfandari (HOR) — For Xavier Batut (HOR) — Absent Béatrice Bellamy (HOR) — Absent Thierry Benoit (HOR) — For Agnès Carel (HOR) — Absent Paul Christophe (HOR) — Absent Yannick Favennec-Bécot (HOR) — Absent François Gernigon (HOR) — Absent Félicie Gérard (HOR) — For François Jolivet (HOR) — For Loïc Kervran (HOR) — For Stéphanie Kochert (HOR) — Absent Luc Lamirault (HOR) — For Jean-Charles Larsonneur (HOR) — Absent Anne Le Hénanff (HOR) — Absent Didier Lemaire (HOR) — Absent Lise Magnier (HOR) — For Laurent Marcangeli (HOR) — For Naïma Moutchou (HOR) — Absent Jérémie Patrier-Leitus (HOR) — Absent Christophe Plassard (HOR) — Absent Jean-François Portarrieu (HOR) — For Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback (HOR) — Absent Philippe Pradal (HOR) — Absent Isabelle Rauch (HOR) — Absent Vincent Thiébaut (HOR) — For Frédéric Valletoux (HOR) — Absent André Villiers (HOR) — Absent Anne-Cécile Violland (HOR) — Absent Emmanuelle Anthoine (LR) — Absent Thibault Bazin (LR) — Abstention Valérie Bazin-Malgras (LR) — Absent Anne-Laure Blin (LR) — Absent Émilie Bonnivard (LR) — Absent Jean-Yves Bony (LR) — Absent Ian Boucard (LR) — Abstention Jean-Luc Bourgeaux (LR) — Abstention Xavier Breton (LR) — Absent Hubert Brigand (LR) — Abstention Fabrice Brun (LR) — Absent Dino Cinieri (LR) — Absent Éric Ciotti (LR) — Absent Pierre Cordier (LR) — Absent Josiane Corneloup (LR) — Absent Christelle D'Intorni (LR) — Absent Marie-Christine Dalloz (LR) — Absent Vincent Descoeur (LR) — Abstention Fabien Di Filippo (LR) — Absent Julien Dive (LR) — Absent Francis Dubois (LR) — Absent Virginie Duby-Muller (LR) — Absent Pierre-Henri Dumont (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Nicolas Forissier (LR) — Absent Jean-Jacques Gaultier (LR) — Abstention Annie Genevard (LR) — Absent Philippe Gosselin (LR) — Abstention Justine Gruet (LR) — Abstention Victor Habert-Dassault (LR) — Absent Meyer Habib (LR) — Absent Michel Herbillon (LR) — Absent Patrick Hetzel (LR) — Absent Philippe Juvin (LR) — Absent Mansour Kamardine (LR) — Absent Marc Le Fur (LR) — Absent Véronique Louwagie (LR) — Abstention Emmanuel Maquet (LR) — Absent Olivier Marleix (LR) — Absent Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) (LR) — Absent Frédérique Meunier (LR) — Absent Maxime Minot (LR) — Absent Yannick Neuder (LR) — Absent Jérôme Nury (LR) — Absent Éric Pauget (LR) — Absent Christelle Petex (LR) — Absent Alexandre Portier (LR) — Abstention Aurélien Pradié (LR) — Abstention Isabelle Périgault (LR) — Absent Nicolas Ray (LR) — Absent Vincent Rolland (LR) — Absent Raphaël Schellenberger (LR) — Absent Vincent Seitlinger (LR) — Absent Nathalie Serre (LR) — Absent Michèle Tabarot (LR) — Absent Jean-Pierre Taite (LR) — Absent Jean-Louis Thiériot (LR) — Absent Isabelle Valentin (LR) — Absent Pierre Vatin (LR) — Abstention Antoine Vermorel (LR) — Absent Jean-Pierre Vigier (LR) — Abstention Alexandre Vincendet (LR) — Abstention Stéphane Viry (LR) — Absent Franck Allisio (RN) — Absent Bénédicte Auzanot (RN) — Absent Philippe Ballard (RN) — Abstention Christophe Barthès (RN) — Absent Romain Baubry (RN) — Absent José Beaurain (RN) — Absent Christophe Bentz (RN) — Abstention Pierrick Berteloot (RN) — Abstention Bruno Bilde (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Emmanuel Blairy (RN) — Absent Sophie Blanc (RN) — Absent Frédéric Boccaletti (RN) — Abstention Pascale Bordes (RN) — Absent Jorys Bovet (RN) — Absent Jérôme Buisson (RN) — Absent Frédéric Cabrolier (RN) — Abstention Victor Catteau (RN) — Abstention Sébastien Chenu (RN) — Absent Roger Chudeau (RN) — Absent Caroline Colombier (RN) — Absent Annick Cousin (RN) — Abstention Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho (RN) — Absent Jocelyn Dessigny (RN) — Abstention Edwige Diaz (RN) — Abstention Sandrine Dogor-Such (RN) — Abstention Nicolas Dragon (RN) — Abstention Christine Engrand (RN) — Absent Frédéric Falcon (RN) — Abstention Thibaut François (RN) — Absent Thierry Frappé (RN) — Absent Stéphanie Galzy (RN) — Absent Frank Giletti (RN) — Abstention Yoann Gillet (RN) — Absent Christian Girard (RN) — Abstention José Gonzalez (RN) — Abstention Florence Goulet (RN) — Absent Géraldine Grangier (RN) — Absent Daniel Grenon (RN) — Absent Michel Guiniot (RN) — Absent Jordan Guitton (RN) — Absent Marine Hamelet (RN) — Absent Timothée Houssin (RN) — Absent Laurent Jacobelli (RN) — Absent Catherine Jaouen (RN) — Absent Alexis Jolly (RN) — Absent Hélène Laporte (RN) — Absent Laure Lavalette (RN) — Absent Marine Le Pen (RN) — Absent Julie Lechanteux (RN) — Absent Gisèle Lelouis (RN) — Absent Katiana Levavasseur (RN) — Absent Christine Loir (RN) — Absent Aurélien Lopez-Liguori (RN) — Absent Marie-France Lorho (RN) — Absent Philippe Lottiaux (RN) — Abstention Alexandre Loubet (RN) — Abstention Matthieu Marchio (RN) — Absent Michèle Martinez (RN) — Absent Alexandra Masson (RN) — Absent Bryan Masson (RN) — Absent Kévin Mauvieux (RN) — Abstention Nicolas Meizonnet (RN) — Abstention Pierre Meurin (RN) — Absent Serge Muller (RN) — Absent Joëlle Mélin (RN) — Absent Yaël Ménaché (RN) — Absent Thomas Ménagé (RN) — Abstention Julien Odoul (RN) — Absent Mathilde Paris (RN) — Abstention — by proxy Caroline Parmentier (RN) — Absent Kévin Pfeffer (RN) — Abstention Lisette Pollet (RN) — Absent Stéphane Rambaud (RN) — Absent Angélique Ranc (RN) — Absent Julien Rancoule (RN) — Absent Laurence Robert-Dehault (RN) — Abstention Béatrice Roullaud (RN) — Abstention Anaïs Sabatini (RN) — Absent Alexandre Sabatou (RN) — Abstention Emeric Salmon (RN) — Absent Philippe Schreck (RN) — Abstention Emmanuel Taché (RN) — Absent Jean-Philippe Tanguy (RN) — Absent Michaël Taverne (RN) — Absent Lionel Tivoli (RN) — Absent Antoine Villedieu (RN) — Absent Grégoire de Fournas (RN) — Absent Hervé de Lépinau (RN) — Absent Véronique Besse (NI) — Absent Nicolas Dupont-Aignan (NI) — Absent David Habib (NI) — Absent Emmanuelle Ménard (NI) — Absent

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
LFI-NUPES 0210 05475
GDR-NUPES 030 01922
ECOLO 008 01523
SOC 009 009
SOC-A 000 02222
LIOT 0010 01121
DEM 1800 13251
RE 7000 0100170
HOR 1100 01930
LR 0015 04762
RN 0027 06188
NI 000 044

All deputies

DeputyGroupVote
Damien Abad RE Absent
Caroline Abadie RE Absent
Nadège Abomangoli LFI-NUPES Against
Jean-Félix Acquaviva LIOT Absent
Damien Adam RE Absent
Éric Alauzet RE Absent
Xavier Albertini HOR For
Laurent Alexandre LFI-NUPES Against
Henri Alfandari HOR For
Franck Allisio RN Absent
Gabriel Amard LFI-NUPES Absent
David Amiel RE For by proxy
Ségolène Amiot LFI-NUPES Absent
Farida Amrani LFI-NUPES Against
Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade RE Absent
Emmanuelle Anthoine LR Absent
Jean-Philippe Ardouin RE For
Rodrigo Arenas LFI-NUPES Absent
Antoine Armand RE For
Christine Arrighi ECOLO Abstention
Clémentine Autain LFI-NUPES Absent
Bénédicte Auzanot RN Absent
Joël Aviragnet SOC-A Absent
Anne-Laure Babault DEM Absent
Erwan Balanant DEM Absent
Philippe Ballard RN Abstention
Géraldine Bannier DEM Absent
Christian Baptiste SOC-A Absent
Christophe Barthès RN Absent
Nathalie Bassire LIOT Absent
Quentin Bataillon RE For
Delphine Batho ECOLO Absent
Marie-Noëlle Battistel SOC Abstention
Xavier Batut HOR Absent
Romain Baubry RN Absent
Julien Bayou ECOLO Absent
Thibault Bazin LR Abstention
Valérie Bazin-Malgras LR Absent
José Beaurain RN Absent
Belkhir Belhaddad RE For
Mounir Belhamiti RE Absent
Béatrice Bellamy HOR Absent
Lisa Belluco ECOLO Absent
Karim Ben Cheikh ECOLO Abstention
Thierry Benoit HOR For
Christophe Bentz RN Abstention
Fanta Berete RE Absent
Anne Bergantz DEM Absent
Ugo Bernalicis LFI-NUPES Absent
Philippe Berta DEM For
Pierrick Berteloot RN Abstention
Véronique Besse NI Absent
Christophe Bex LFI-NUPES Absent
Bruno Bilde RN Abstention by proxy
Carlos Martens Bilongo LFI-NUPES Absent
Emmanuel Blairy RN Absent
Sophie Blanc RN Absent
Christophe Blanchet DEM For
Anne-Laure Blin LR Absent
Frédéric Boccaletti RN Abstention
Philippe Bolo DEM Absent
Manuel Bompard LFI-NUPES Absent
Émilie Bonnivard LR Absent
Jean-Yves Bony LR Absent
Benoît Bordat RE Absent
Pascale Bordes RN Absent
Éric Bothorel RE Absent
Ian Boucard LR Abstention
Florent Boudié RE Absent
Chantal Bouloux RE Absent
Mickaël Bouloux SOC Abstention
Idir Boumertit LFI-NUPES Absent
Jean-Luc Bourgeaux LR Abstention
Jean-Louis Bourlanges DEM Absent
Soumya Bourouaha GDR-NUPES Absent
Bertrand Bouyx RE For
Jorys Bovet RN Absent
Louis Boyard LFI-NUPES Absent
Pascale Boyer RE Absent
Yaël Braun-Pivet RE Absent
Maud Bregeon RE For
Xavier Breton LR Absent
Guy Bricout LIOT Abstention
Jean-Louis Bricout LIOT Abstention
Hubert Brigand LR Abstention
Blandine Brocard DEM Absent
Anthony Brosse RE For
Vincent Bru DEM Absent
Anne Brugnera RE For
Danielle Brulebois RE For
Fabrice Brun LR Absent
Philippe Brun SOC-A Absent
Stéphane Buchou RE For
Françoise Buffet RE For
Jérôme Buisson RN Absent
Frédéric Cabrolier RN Abstention
Elie Califer SOC-A Absent
Céline Calvez RE Absent
Agnès Carel HOR Absent
Eléonore Caroit RE For
Aymeric Caron LFI-NUPES Absent
Sylvain Carrière LFI-NUPES Absent
Michel Castellani LIOT Absent
Jean-Victor Castor GDR-NUPES Absent
Victor Catteau RN Abstention
Lionel Causse RE Absent
Jean-René Cazeneuve RE For
Pierre Cazeneuve RE For
Steve Chailloux GDR-NUPES Absent
Émilie Chandler RE For
André Chassaigne GDR-NUPES Absent
Clara Chassaniol RE For
Cyrielle Chatelain ECOLO Absent
Florian Chauche LFI-NUPES Against
Yannick Chenevard RE Absent
Sébastien Chenu RN Absent
Sophia Chikirou LFI-NUPES Against
Paul Christophe HOR Absent
Roger Chudeau RN Absent
Dino Cinieri LR Absent
Éric Ciotti LR Absent
Mireille Clapot RE For
Hadrien Clouet LFI-NUPES Absent
Fabienne Colboc RE Absent
Claire Colomb-Pitollat RE Absent
Paul-André Colombani LIOT Absent
Caroline Colombier RN Absent
Éric Coquerel LFI-NUPES Against
Alexis Corbière LFI-NUPES Absent
Pierre Cordier LR Absent
François Cormier-Bouligeon RE For
Josiane Corneloup LR Absent
Mickaël Cosson DEM Absent
Jean-François Coulomme LFI-NUPES Against
Annick Cousin RN Abstention
Catherine Couturier LFI-NUPES Absent
Laurence Cristol RE Absent
Laurent Croizier DEM For
Jean-Pierre Cubertafon DEM Absent
Christelle D'Intorni LR Absent
Nathalie Da Conceicao Carvalho RN Absent
Dominique Da Silva RE For
Marie-Christine Dalloz LR Absent
Geneviève Darrieussecq DEM Absent
Romain Daubié DEM Absent
Hendrik Davi LFI-NUPES Absent
Alain David SOC-A Absent
Charles de Courson LIOT Abstention
Grégoire de Fournas RN Absent
Hervé de Lépinau RN Absent
Christine Decodts RE For
Arthur Delaporte SOC-A Absent
Stéphane Delautrette SOC-A Absent
Sébastien Delogu LFI-NUPES Absent
Julie Delpech RE Absent
Béatrice Descamps LIOT Absent
Vincent Descoeur LR Abstention
Frédéric Descrozaille RE Absent
Mathilde Desjonquères DEM Absent
Jocelyn Dessigny RN Abstention
Pierre Dharréville GDR-NUPES Absent
Fabien Di Filippo LR Absent
Edwige Diaz RN Abstention
Benjamin Dirx RE Absent
Julien Dive LR Absent
Sandrine Dogor-Such RN Abstention
Ingrid Dordain RE Absent
Nicolas Dragon RN Abstention
Francis Dubois LR Absent
Nicole Dubré-Chirat RE Absent
Virginie Duby-Muller LR Absent
Alma Dufour LFI-NUPES Against
Pierre-Henri Dumont LR Abstention by proxy
Philippe Dunoyer RE Absent
Stella Dupont RE For
Nicolas Dupont-Aignan NI Absent
Iñaki Echaniz SOC-A Absent
Philippe Emmanuel RE For
Christine Engrand RN Absent
Karen Erodi LFI-NUPES Absent
Sophie Errante RE Absent
Laurent Esquenet-Goxes DEM Absent
Martine Etienne LFI-NUPES Absent
Philippe Fait RE Absent
Frédéric Falcon RN Abstention
Olivier Falorni DEM Absent
Elsa Faucillon GDR-NUPES Absent
Olivier Faure SOC-A Absent
Yannick Favennec-Bécot HOR Absent
Emmanuel Fernandes LFI-NUPES Against
Marc Ferracci RE Absent
Marina Ferrari DEM For by proxy
Sylvie Ferrer LFI-NUPES Against
Caroline Fiat LFI-NUPES Absent
Jean-Marie Fiévet RE Absent
Estelle Folest DEM Absent
Nicolas Forissier LR Absent
Charles Fournier ECOLO Absent
Thibaut François RN Absent
Thierry Frappé RN Absent
Philippe Frei RE Absent
Martine Froger LIOT Abstention
Bruno Fuchs DEM Absent
Jean-Luc Fugit RE Absent
Perceval Gaillard LFI-NUPES Absent
Stéphanie Galzy RN Absent
Marie-Charlotte Garin ECOLO Absent
Guillaume Garot SOC Abstention
Raquel Garrido LFI-NUPES Absent
Thomas Gassilloud RE Absent
Maud Gatel DEM For
Jean-Jacques Gaultier LR Abstention
Luc Geismar DEM Absent
Anne Genetet RE Absent
Annie Genevard LR Absent
Félicie Gérard HOR For
Raphaël Gérard RE For by proxy
François Gernigon HOR Absent
Hadrien Ghomi RE Absent
Frank Giletti RN Abstention
Yoann Gillet RN Absent
Christian Girard RN Abstention
Éric Girardin RE Absent
Joël Giraud RE For
Olga Givernet RE Absent
Charlotte Goetschy-Bolognese RE For
José Gonzalez RN Abstention
Philippe Gosselin LR Abstention
Guillaume Gouffier Valente RE Absent
Florence Goulet RN Absent
Perrine Goulet DEM Absent
Géraldine Grangier RN Absent
Jean-Carles Grelier RE Absent
Daniel Grenon RN Absent
Justine Gruet LR Abstention
Jérôme Guedj SOC-A Absent
Clémence Guetté LFI-NUPES Absent
Marie Guévenoux RE Absent
Claire Guichard RE Absent
Philippe Guillemard RE For
Michel Guiniot RN Absent
David Guiraud LFI-NUPES Absent
Jordan Guitton RN Absent
Frantz Gumbs DEM Absent
Victor Habert-Dassault LR Absent
David Habib NI Absent
Meyer Habib LR Absent
Benjamin Haddad RE Absent
Nadia Hai RE Absent
Johnny Hajjar SOC-A Absent
Marine Hamelet RN Absent
Yannick Haury RE For
Pierre Henriet RE Absent
Michel Herbillon LR Absent
Patrick Hetzel LR Absent
Laurence Heydel Grillere RE Absent
Mathilde Hignet LFI-NUPES Against
Alexandre Holroyd RE Absent
Sacha Houlié RE Absent
Timothée Houssin RN Absent
Servane Hugues RE Absent
Monique Iborra RE Absent
Jérémie Iordanoff ECOLO Abstention
Cyrille Isaac-Sibille DEM Absent
Alexis Izard RE For
Laurent Jacobelli RN Absent
Jean-Michel Jacques RE Absent
Élodie Jacquier-Laforge DEM Non-voting
Caroline Janvier RE Absent
Catherine Jaouen RN Absent
François Jolivet HOR For
Alexis Jolly RN Absent
Sandrine Josso DEM Absent
Chantal Jourdan SOC-A Absent
Hubert Julien-Laferrière ECOLO Absent
Sébastien Jumel GDR-NUPES Absent
Philippe Juvin LR Absent
Émeline K/Bidi GDR-NUPES Absent
Mansour Kamardine LR Absent
Marietta Karamanli SOC Abstention
Guillaume Kasbarian RE Absent
Rachel Keke LFI-NUPES Absent
Fatiha Keloua Hachi SOC Abstention
Andy Kerbrat LFI-NUPES Absent
Loïc Kervran HOR For
Brigitte Klinkert RE For
Stéphanie Kochert HOR Absent
Daniel Labaronne RE For
Bastien Lachaud LFI-NUPES Absent
Emmanuel Lacresse RE Absent
Julie Laernoes ECOLO Absent
Maxime Laisney LFI-NUPES Against
Amélia Lakrafi RE Absent
Luc Lamirault HOR For
Virginie Lanlo RE For
Hélène Laporte RN Absent
Mohamed Laqhila DEM For
Jean-Charles Larsonneur HOR Absent
Florence Lasserre DEM For
Philippe Latombe DEM Absent
Michel Lauzzana RE For
Laure Lavalette RN Absent
Pascal Lavergne RE For
Sandrine Le Feur RE For
Marc Le Fur LR Absent
Didier Le Gac RE Absent
Arnaud Le Gall LFI-NUPES Absent
Tematai Le Gayic GDR-NUPES Absent
Gilles Le Gendre RE Absent
Constance Le Grip RE For
Anne Le Hénanff HOR Absent
Annaïg Le Meur RE For by proxy
Christine Le Nabour RE Absent
Nicole Le Peih RE Absent
Marine Le Pen RN Absent
Fabrice Le Vigoureux RE Absent
Antoine Léaument LFI-NUPES Against
Marie Lebec RE For
Karine Lebon GDR-NUPES Absent
Élise Leboucher LFI-NUPES Absent
Pascal Lecamp DEM For
Julie Lechanteux RN Absent
Laurent Leclercq DEM For
Jean-Paul Lecoq GDR-NUPES Absent
Vincent Ledoux RE Absent
Charlotte Leduc LFI-NUPES Absent
Mathieu Lefèvre RE For
Jérôme Legavre LFI-NUPES Absent
Sarah Legrain LFI-NUPES Absent
Gisèle Lelouis RN Absent
Didier Lemaire HOR Absent
Patricia Lemoine RE Absent
Stéphane Lenormand LIOT Abstention
Murielle Lepvraud LFI-NUPES Absent
Gérard Leseul SOC-A Absent
Katiana Levavasseur RN Absent
Delphine Lingemann DEM For
Brigitte Liso RE Absent
Christine Loir RN Absent
Aurélien Lopez-Liguori RN Absent
Marie-France Lorho RN Absent
Philippe Lottiaux RN Abstention
Alexandre Loubet RN Abstention
Véronique Louwagie LR Abstention
Jean-François Lovisolo RE Absent
Benjamin Lucas-Lundy ECOLO Abstention
Aude Luquet DEM For
Lise Magnier HOR For
Sylvain Maillard RE Absent
Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie RE Absent
Frédéric Maillot GDR-NUPES Against
Emmanuel Mandon DEM For
Emmanuel Maquet LR Absent
Jacqueline Maquet RE For
Laurent Marcangeli HOR For
Matthieu Marchio RN Absent
Bastien Marchive RE For
Louis Margueritte RE For
Christophe Marion RE For
Olivier Marleix LR Absent
Sandra Marsaud RE For
Didier Martin RE Absent
Élisa Martin LFI-NUPES Absent
Pascale Martin LFI-NUPES Absent
Alexandra Martin (Alpes-Maritimes) LR Absent
Alexandra Martin (Gironde) RE For
Éric Martineau DEM For
William Martinet LFI-NUPES Against
Michèle Martinez RN Absent
Denis Masséglia RE For
Alexandra Masson RN Absent
Bryan Masson RN Absent
Max Mathiasin LIOT Absent
Frédéric Mathieu LFI-NUPES Absent
Jean-Paul Mattei DEM For
Damien Maudet LFI-NUPES Absent
Kévin Mauvieux RN Abstention
Marianne Maximi LFI-NUPES Against
Stéphane Mazars RE For
Nicolas Meizonnet RN Abstention
Graziella Melchior RE Absent
Joëlle Mélin RN Absent
Yaël Ménaché RN Absent
Thomas Ménagé RN Abstention
Emmanuelle Ménard NI Absent
Ludovic Mendes RE Absent
Lysiane Métayer RE For
Sophie Mette DEM Absent
Nicolas Metzdorf RE Absent
Frédérique Meunier LR Absent
Manon Meunier LFI-NUPES Against
Pierre Meurin RN Absent
Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert RE For
Paul Midy RE Absent
Laure Miller RE Absent
Bruno Millienne DEM For
Maxime Minot LR Absent
Paul Molac LIOT Absent
Yannick Monnet GDR-NUPES Absent
Louise Morel DEM For
Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier LIOT Abstention
Benoit Mournet RE For
Naïma Moutchou HOR Absent
Serge Muller RN Absent
Marcellin Nadeau GDR-NUPES Absent
Christophe Naegelen LIOT Absent
Philippe Naillet SOC Abstention
Yannick Neuder LR Absent
Jean-Philippe Nilor LFI-NUPES Absent
Jérôme Nury LR Absent
Danièle Obono LFI-NUPES Absent
Julien Odoul RN Absent
Karl Olive RE For
Hubert Ott DEM Absent
Nathalie Oziol LFI-NUPES Against
Nicolas Pacquot RE For
Jimmy Pahun DEM For
Bertrand Pancher LIOT Abstention
Laurent Panifous LIOT Abstention
Sophie Panonacle RE Absent
Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet RE Absent
Mathilde Panot LFI-NUPES Absent
Didier Parakian RE For
Didier Paris RE Absent
Mathilde Paris RN Abstention by proxy
Caroline Parmentier RN Absent
Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq RE Absent
Francesca Pasquini ECOLO Absent
Jérémie Patrier-Leitus HOR Absent
Éric Pauget LR Absent
Emmanuel Pellerin RE For
Isabelle Périgault LR Absent
Patrice Perrot RE For
Anne-Laurence Petel RE Absent
Christelle Petex LR Absent
Bertrand Petit SOC-A Absent
Frédéric Petit DEM Absent
Maud Petit DEM Absent
Stéphane Peu GDR-NUPES Against
Michèle Peyron RE Absent
Sébastien Peytavie ECOLO Absent
Kévin Pfeffer RN Abstention
Anna Pic SOC-A Absent
René Pilato LFI-NUPES Absent
François Piquemal LFI-NUPES Absent
Christine Pirès Beaune SOC Abstention
Béatrice Piron RE For
Christophe Plassard HOR Absent
Marie Pochon ECOLO Abstention
Lisette Pollet RN Absent
Jean-Pierre Pont RE Absent
Jean-François Portarrieu HOR For
Thomas Portes LFI-NUPES Absent
Alexandre Portier LR Abstention
Dominique Potier SOC-A Absent
Josy Poueyto DEM For
Éric Poulliat RE For
Marie-Agnès Poussier-Winsback HOR Absent
Natalia Pouzyreff RE Absent
Philippe Pradal HOR Absent
Aurélien Pradié LR Abstention
Loïc Prud'homme LFI-NUPES Absent
Adrien Quatennens LFI-NUPES Absent
Valérie Rabault SOC-A Absent
Stéphane Rambaud RN Absent
Richard Ramos DEM Absent
Angélique Ranc RN Absent
Julien Rancoule RN Absent
Jean-Hugues Ratenon LFI-NUPES Absent
Isabelle Rauch HOR Absent
Jean-Claude Raux ECOLO Abstention
Nicolas Ray LR Absent
Rémy Rebeyrotte RE For
Robin Reda RE Absent
Sandra Regol ECOLO Abstention
Mereana Reid Arbelot GDR-NUPES Absent
Cécile Rilhac RE Absent
Davy Rimane GDR-NUPES Absent
Véronique Riotton RE Absent
Stéphanie Rist RE Absent
Marie-Pierre Rixain RE Absent
Laurence Robert-Dehault RN Abstention
Charles Rodwell RE For by proxy
Vincent Rolland LR Absent
Sébastien Rome LFI-NUPES Absent
Xavier Roseren RE Absent
Claudia Rouaux SOC-A Absent
Béatrice Roullaud RN Abstention
Sandrine Rousseau ECOLO Absent
Fabien Roussel GDR-NUPES Absent
Jean-François Rousset RE Absent
Lionel Royer-Perreaut RE For
Thomas Rudigoz RE For
François Ruffin LFI-NUPES Absent
Anaïs Sabatini RN Absent
Alexandre Sabatou RN Abstention
Benjamin Saint-Huile LIOT Abstention
Laetitia Saint-Paul RE For
Aurélien Saintoul LFI-NUPES Against
Michel Sala LFI-NUPES Against
Emeric Salmon RN Absent
Nicolas Sansu GDR-NUPES Absent
Isabelle Santiago SOC-A Absent
Eva Sas ECOLO Abstention
Hervé Saulignac SOC Abstention
Raphaël Schellenberger LR Absent
Philippe Schreck RN Abstention
Sabrina Sebaihi ECOLO Absent
Vincent Seitlinger LR Absent
Mikaele Seo RE Absent
Nathalie Serre LR Absent
Freddy Sertin RE For
Olivier Serva LIOT Absent
Danielle Simonnet LFI-NUPES Absent
Charles Sitzenstuhl RE For by proxy
Philippe Sorez RE For
Bertrand Sorre RE Absent
Ersilia Soudais LFI-NUPES Absent
Violette Spillebout RE Absent
Anne Stambach-Terrenoir LFI-NUPES Against
Bruno Studer RE Absent
Michèle Tabarot LR Absent
Aurélien Taché ECOLO Absent
Emmanuel Taché RN Absent
Sophie Taillé-Polian ECOLO Absent
Jean-Pierre Taite LR Absent
Jean-Philippe Tanguy RN Absent
Liliana Tanguy RE For by proxy
Sarah Tanzilli RE Absent
David Taupiac LIOT Abstention
Andrée Taurinya LFI-NUPES Absent
Matthias Tavel LFI-NUPES Absent
Michaël Taverne RN Absent
Jean-Marc Tellier GDR-NUPES Against
Jean Terlier RE For
Vincent Thiébaut HOR For
Jean-Louis Thiériot LR Absent
Nicolas Thierry ECOLO Absent
Sabine Thillaye DEM Absent
Mélanie Thomin SOC Abstention
Huguette Tiegna RE Absent
Lionel Tivoli RN Absent
Stéphane Travert RE Absent
Aurélie Trouvé LFI-NUPES Absent
Nicolas Turquois DEM Absent
Cécile Untermaier SOC-A Absent
David Valence RE Absent
Isabelle Valentin LR Absent
Boris Vallaud SOC-A Absent
Frédéric Valletoux HOR Absent
Paul Vannier LFI-NUPES Against
Pierre Vatin LR Abstention
Antoine Vermorel LR Absent
Laurence Vichnievsky DEM Absent
Roger Vicot SOC-A Absent
Annie Vidal RE Absent
Jean-Pierre Vigier LR Abstention
Patrick Vignal RE Absent
Corinne Vignon RE Absent
Antoine Villedieu RN Absent
André Villiers HOR Absent
Alexandre Vincendet LR Abstention
Anne-Cécile Violland HOR Absent
Stéphane Viry LR Absent
Stéphane Vojetta RE Absent
Lionel Vuibert RE For
Guillaume Vuilletet RE Absent
Léo Walter LFI-NUPES Absent
Jean-Luc Warsmann LIOT Absent
Christopher Weissberg RE For
Jiovanny William GDR-NUPES Absent
Éric Woerth RE For by proxy
Hubert Wulfranc GDR-NUPES Absent
Caroline Yadan RE Absent
Estelle Youssouffa LIOT Absent
Frédéric Zgainski DEM Absent
Jean-Marc Zulesi RE Absent