← All votes

National Assembly · vote no. 472 · · ✗ Rejected

L'amendement n° 23 de M. Jacob et les amendements identiques suivants à l'article 3 du projet de loi pour un nouveau pacte ferroviaire (première lecture)

Type of vote
Ordinary roll-call vote
Voters
90
2 non-voting
Votes cast
84
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
43 votes
Majorité absolue des suffrages exprimés

25 for 59 against 6 abstentions ▏threshold : 43 votes

Colour by:
FI — 17 GDR — 16 NG — 31 MODEM — 47 LAREM — 312 UDI-AGIR — 32 LR — 102 NI — 18 NGMODEMLAREMUDI-AGIRLR Clémentine Autain (FI) — Absent Ugo Bernalicis (FI) — Abstention Éric Coquerel (FI) — Absent Alexis Corbière (FI) — Absent Caroline Fiat (FI) — Abstention Bastien Lachaud (FI) — Absent Michel Larive (FI) — Absent Jean-Luc Mélenchon (FI) — Absent Danièle Obono (FI) — Absent Mathilde Panot (FI) — Absent Loïc Prud'homme (FI) — Absent Adrien Quatennens (FI) — Absent Jean-Hugues Ratenon (FI) — Abstention Muriel Ressiguier (FI) — Absent Sabine Rubin (FI) — Absent François Ruffin (FI) — Absent Bénédicte Taurine (FI) — Absent Bruno Nestor Azerot (GDR) — Absent Huguette Bello (GDR) — Absent Moetai Brotherson (GDR) — Absent Alain Bruneel (GDR) — Absent Marie-George Buffet (GDR) — Absent André Chassaigne (GDR) — Absent Pierre Dharréville (GDR) — Absent Jean-Paul Dufrègne (GDR) — Absent Elsa Faucillon (GDR) — Absent Sébastien Jumel (GDR) — Absent Jean-Paul Lecoq (GDR) — Abstention Jean-Philippe Nilor (GDR) — Absent Stéphane Peu (GDR) — Absent Fabien Roussel (GDR) — Absent Gabriel Serville (GDR) — Absent Hubert Wulfranc (GDR) — Absent Joël Aviragnet (NG) — Absent Ericka Bareigts (NG) — Absent Delphine Batho (NG) — Absent Marie-Noëlle Battistel (NG) — For Gisèle Biémouret (NG) — Absent Christophe Bouillon (NG) — For Jean-Louis Bricout (NG) — For Luc Carvounas (NG) — Absent Alain David (NG) — Absent Laurence Dumont (NG) — Absent Olivier Faure (NG) — Absent Guillaume Garot (NG) — For David Habib (NG) — Absent Christian Hutin (NG) — Absent Régis Juanico (NG) — Absent Marietta Karamanli (NG) — Absent Jérôme Lambert (NG) — Absent Stéphane Le Foll (NG) — Absent Serge Letchimy (NG) — Absent Josette Manin (NG) — Absent George Pau-Langevin (NG) — Absent Christine Pirès Beaune (NG) — For Dominique Potier (NG) — Absent Joaquim Pueyo (NG) — Absent François Pupponi (NG) — Absent Valérie Rabault (NG) — Absent Hervé Saulignac (NG) — Absent Cécile Untermaier (NG) — Absent Hélène Vainqueur-Christophe (NG) — Absent Boris Vallaud (NG) — Absent Michèle Victory (NG) — For Erwan Balanant (MODEM) — Absent Géraldine Bannier (MODEM) — Absent Jean-Noël Barrot (MODEM) — Absent Justine Benin (MODEM) — Absent Philippe Berta (MODEM) — Against Philippe Bolo (MODEM) — Absent Jean-Louis Bourlanges (MODEM) — Absent Vincent Bru (MODEM) — Absent Jean-Pierre Cubertafon (MODEM) — Absent Marguerite Deprez-Audebert (MODEM) — Absent Bruno Duvergé (MODEM) — Absent Sarah El Haïry (MODEM) — Absent Nathalie Elimas (MODEM) — Absent Nadia Essayan (MODEM) — Against Michel Fanget (MODEM) — Absent Marc Fesneau (MODEM) — Absent Isabelle Florennes (MODEM) — Absent Bruno Fuchs (MODEM) — Absent Patricia Gallerneau (MODEM) — For (vote correction) Laurent Garcia (MODEM) — Absent Brahim Hammouche (MODEM) — Absent Cyrille Isaac-Sibille (MODEM) — Absent Élodie Jacquier-Laforge (MODEM) — Absent Bruno Joncour (MODEM) — Absent Jean-Luc Lagleize (MODEM) — For Fabien Lainé (MODEM) — Absent Mohamed Laqhila (MODEM) — For Florence Lasserre (MODEM) — For Philippe Latombe (MODEM) — Absent Aude Luquet (MODEM) — Absent Max Mathiasin (MODEM) — Absent Jean-Paul Mattei (MODEM) — Absent Sophie Mette (MODEM) — For Philippe Michel-Kleisbauer (MODEM) — Absent Patrick Mignola (MODEM) — Absent Bruno Millienne (MODEM) — Absent Jimmy Pahun (MODEM) — Absent Frédéric Petit (MODEM) — Absent Maud Petit (MODEM) — Absent Josy Poueyto (MODEM) — For Richard Ramos (MODEM) — Absent Thierry Robert (MODEM) — Absent Nicolas Turquois (MODEM) — Absent Laurence Vichnievsky (MODEM) — Absent Sylvain Waserman (MODEM) — Non-voting Marielle de Sarnez (MODEM) — Absent Michèle de Vaucouleurs (MODEM) — For Caroline Abadie (LAREM) — Absent Bérangère Abba (LAREM) — Against Damien Adam (LAREM) — Against Lénaïck Adam (LAREM) — Absent Saïd Ahamada (LAREM) — Absent Éric Alauzet (LAREM) — Absent Ramlati Ali (LAREM) — Absent Aude Amadou (LAREM) — Absent Patrice Anato (LAREM) — Absent François André (LAREM) — Absent Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Philippe Ardouin (LAREM) — Absent Christophe Arend (LAREM) — Against Gabriel Attal (LAREM) — Absent Laetitia Avia (LAREM) — Absent Florian Bachelier (LAREM) — Absent Delphine Bagarry (LAREM) — Against Didier Baichère (LAREM) — Absent Frédéric Barbier (LAREM) — Absent Xavier Batut (LAREM) — Absent Sophie Beaudouin-Hubiere (LAREM) — Absent Belkhir Belhaddad (LAREM) — Absent Aurore Bergé (LAREM) — Absent Hervé Berville (LAREM) — Absent Grégory Besson-Moreau (LAREM) — Absent Barbara Bessot Ballot (LAREM) — Absent Anne Blanc (LAREM) — Absent Christophe Blanchet (LAREM) — Absent Yves Blein (LAREM) — Absent Pascal Bois (LAREM) — Absent Bruno Bonnell (LAREM) — For Aude Bono-Vandorme (LAREM) — Absent Julien Borowczyk (LAREM) — Absent Éric Bothorel (LAREM) — Absent Florent Boudié (LAREM) — Absent Brigitte Bourguignon (LAREM) — Absent Bertrand Bouyx (LAREM) — Absent Pascale Boyer (LAREM) — Against Yaël Braun-Pivet (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Jacques Bridey (LAREM) — Absent Blandine Brocard (LAREM) — Absent Anne Brugnera (LAREM) — Absent Danielle Brulebois (LAREM) — Against Anne-France Brunet (LAREM) — Absent Stéphane Buchou (LAREM) — Absent Carole Bureau-Bonnard (LAREM) — Absent Pierre Cabaré (LAREM) — Absent Céline Calvez (LAREM) — Absent Émilie Cariou (LAREM) — Absent Anne-Laure Cattelot (LAREM) — Against Lionel Causse (LAREM) — Absent Danièle Cazarian (LAREM) — Absent Jean-René Cazeneuve (LAREM) — Absent Sébastien Cazenove (LAREM) — Absent Anthony Cellier (LAREM) — Absent Jean-François Cesarini (LAREM) — Absent Émilie Chalas (LAREM) — Absent Philippe Chalumeau (LAREM) — Absent Annie Chapelier (LAREM) — Absent Sylvie Charrière (LAREM) — Against Fannette Charvier (LAREM) — Absent Philippe Chassaing (LAREM) — Absent Guillaume Chiche (LAREM) — Absent Stéphane Claireaux (LAREM) — Absent Mireille Clapot (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Michel Clément (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Charles Colas-Roy (LAREM) — Absent Fabienne Colboc (LAREM) — Absent Claire Colomb-Pitollat (LAREM) — Absent François Cormier-Bouligeon (LAREM) — Absent Bérangère Couillard (LAREM) — Absent Michèle Crouzet (LAREM) — Absent Dominique Da Silva (LAREM) — Absent Olivier Damaisin (LAREM) — Absent Yves Daniel (LAREM) — Absent Dominique David (LAREM) — Absent Jennifer De Temmerman (LAREM) — Against Typhanie Degois (LAREM) — Absent Marc Delatte (LAREM) — Absent Michel Delpon (LAREM) — Absent Frédéric Descrozaille (LAREM) — Absent Christophe Di Pompeo (LAREM) — Absent Benjamin Dirx (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Baptiste Djebbari (LAREM) — Against Stéphanie Do (LAREM) — Absent Loïc Dombreval (LAREM) — Absent Jacqueline Dubois (LAREM) — Absent Christelle Dubos (LAREM) — Absent Coralie Dubost (LAREM) — Absent Nicole Dubré-Chirat (LAREM) — Against Audrey Dufeu (LAREM) — Absent Françoise Dumas (LAREM) — Absent Frédérique Dumas (LAREM) — Absent Stella Dupont (LAREM) — For (vote correction) Nicolas Démoulin (LAREM) — Absent Jean-François Eliaou (LAREM) — Absent Sophie Errante (LAREM) — Absent Christophe Euzet (LAREM) — Absent Catherine Fabre (LAREM) — Absent Élise Fajgeles (LAREM) — Absent Valéria Faure-Muntian (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Michel Fauvergue (LAREM) — Absent Richard Ferrand (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Marie Fiévet (LAREM) — Absent Philippe Folliot (LAREM) — Absent Emmanuelle Fontaine-Domeizel (LAREM) — Absent Pascale Fontenel-Personne (LAREM) — Absent Paula Forteza (LAREM) — Absent Alexandre Freschi (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Luc Fugit (LAREM) — Against Olivier Gaillard (LAREM) — Absent Albane Gaillot (LAREM) — Absent Grégory Galbadon (LAREM) — Absent Thomas Gassilloud (LAREM) — Absent Raphaël Gauvain (LAREM) — Absent Laurence Gayte (LAREM) — Against Anne Genetet (LAREM) — Absent Séverine Gipson (LAREM) — Absent Éric Girardin (LAREM) — Absent Joël Giraud (LAREM) — Absent Olga Givernet (LAREM) — Absent Valérie Gomez-Bassac (LAREM) — Absent Guillaume Gouffier Valente (LAREM) — Absent Perrine Goulet (LAREM) — Absent Fabien Gouttefarde (LAREM) — Absent Carole Grandjean (LAREM) — Against Florence Granjus (LAREM) — Absent Romain Grau (LAREM) — Absent Olivia Grégoire (LAREM) — Absent Émilie Guerel (LAREM) — Absent Stanislas Guerini (LAREM) — Absent Marie Guévenoux (LAREM) — Absent Raphaël Gérard (LAREM) — Absent Nadia Hai (LAREM) — Absent Véronique Hammerer (LAREM) — Absent Yannick Haury (LAREM) — Absent Christine Hennion (LAREM) — Absent Pierre Henriet (LAREM) — Absent Alexandre Holroyd (LAREM) — Absent Dimitri Houbron (LAREM) — Absent Sacha Houlié (LAREM) — Absent Philippe Huppé (LAREM) — Absent Danièle Hérin (LAREM) — Absent Monique Iborra (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Michel Jacques (LAREM) — Absent Caroline Janvier (LAREM) — For Christophe Jerretie (LAREM) — Absent François Jolivet (LAREM) — Absent Sandrine Josso (LAREM) — Absent Hubert Julien-Laferrière (LAREM) — Absent Catherine Kamowski (LAREM) — Against Guillaume Kasbarian (LAREM) — Absent Stéphanie Kerbarh (LAREM) — Against Yannick Kerlogot (LAREM) — Against Loïc Kervran (LAREM) — Absent Fadila Khattabi (LAREM) — Absent Anissa Khedher (LAREM) — Absent Rodrigue Kokouendo (LAREM) — Absent Jacques Krabal (LAREM) — Absent Sonia Krimi (LAREM) — Absent Aina Kuric (LAREM) — Absent Mustapha Laabid (LAREM) — Absent Daniel Labaronne (LAREM) — Absent Amélia Lakrafi (LAREM) — Absent François-Michel Lambert (LAREM) — Absent Anne-Christine Lang (LAREM) — Absent Frédérique Lardet (LAREM) — Against Jean-Charles Larsonneur (LAREM) — Absent Michel Lauzzana (LAREM) — Absent Fiona Lazaar (LAREM) — Absent Gaël Le Bohec (LAREM) — Absent Sandrine Le Feur (LAREM) — Absent Didier Le Gac (LAREM) — Absent Gilles Le Gendre (LAREM) — Absent Annaïg Le Meur (LAREM) — Absent Christine Le Nabour (LAREM) — Absent Nicole Le Peih (LAREM) — Absent Fabrice Le Vigoureux (LAREM) — Absent Marie Lebec (LAREM) — Against Jean-Claude Leclabart (LAREM) — Absent Martine Leguille-Balloy (LAREM) — Absent Christophe Lejeune (LAREM) — Absent Marion Lenne (LAREM) — Absent Roland Lescure (LAREM) — Absent Monique Limon (LAREM) — Absent Richard Lioger (LAREM) — Absent Brigitte Liso (LAREM) — Absent Alexandra Louis (LAREM) — Absent Marie-Ange Magne (LAREM) — Absent Sylvain Maillard (LAREM) — Absent Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie (LAREM) — Against Jacques Maire (LAREM) — Absent Jacqueline Maquet (LAREM) — Absent Jacques Marilossian (LAREM) — Against Sandra Marsaud (LAREM) — Against Didier Martin (LAREM) — Absent Denis Masséglia (LAREM) — Absent Fabien Matras (LAREM) — Absent Sereine Mauborgne (LAREM) — Absent Stéphane Mazars (LAREM) — Absent Jean François Mbaye (LAREM) — Absent Graziella Melchior (LAREM) — Absent Ludovic Mendes (LAREM) — Absent Thomas Mesnier (LAREM) — Absent Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert (LAREM) — Absent Monica Michel-Brassart (LAREM) — Absent Thierry Michels (LAREM) — Absent Patricia Mirallès (LAREM) — Against Jean-Michel Mis (LAREM) — Absent Paul Molac (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Baptiste Moreau (LAREM) — Absent Adrien Morenas (LAREM) — Against Cendra Motin (LAREM) — Absent Naïma Moutchou (LAREM) — Absent Cécile Muschotti (LAREM) — Absent Sandrine Mörch (LAREM) — Absent Sébastien Nadot (LAREM) — Absent Mickaël Nogal (LAREM) — Absent Delphine O (LAREM) — Absent Claire O'Petit (LAREM) — Absent Valérie Oppelt (LAREM) — Against Matthieu Orphelin (LAREM) — Absent Catherine Osson (LAREM) — Absent Xavier Paluszkiewicz (LAREM) — Absent Sophie Panonacle (LAREM) — Absent Didier Paris (LAREM) — Absent Zivka Park (LAREM) — Against Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq (LAREM) — Against Hervé Pellois (LAREM) — Against Alain Perea (LAREM) — Against Patrice Perrot (LAREM) — Absent Pierre Person (LAREM) — Absent Anne-Laurence Petel (LAREM) — Absent Valérie Petit (LAREM) — Against Bénédicte Peyrol (LAREM) — Absent Michèle Peyron (LAREM) — Against Damien Pichereau (LAREM) — Against Laurent Pietraszewski (LAREM) — Absent Béatrice Piron (LAREM) — Absent Barbara Pompili (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Pierre Pont (LAREM) — Against Jean-François Portarrieu (LAREM) — Absent Benoit Potterie (LAREM) — Absent Éric Poulliat (LAREM) — Absent Natalia Pouzyreff (LAREM) — Against Bruno Questel (LAREM) — Against Cathy Racon-Bouzon (LAREM) — Absent Pierre-Alain Raphan (LAREM) — Absent Isabelle Rauch (LAREM) — Absent Rémy Rebeyrotte (LAREM) — Against Hugues Renson (LAREM) — Absent Cécile Rilhac (LAREM) — Absent Véronique Riotton (LAREM) — Against Stéphanie Rist (LAREM) — Against Marie-Pierre Rixain (LAREM) — Absent Mireille Robert (LAREM) — Absent Laëtitia Romeiro Dias (LAREM) — Absent Xavier Roseren (LAREM) — Absent Laurianne Rossi (LAREM) — Absent Gwendal Rouillard (LAREM) — Absent Cédric Roussel (LAREM) — Against Thomas Rudigoz (LAREM) — Absent Pacôme Rupin (LAREM) — Absent Laurent Saint-Martin (LAREM) — Against Laetitia Saint-Paul (LAREM) — Absent Nathalie Sarles (LAREM) — Against Jacques Savatier (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Bernard Sempastous (LAREM) — Absent Olivier Serva (LAREM) — Absent Benoit Simian (LAREM) — For Thierry Solère (LAREM) — Absent Denis Sommer (LAREM) — Absent Joachim Son-Forget (LAREM) — Absent Bertrand Sorre (LAREM) — Absent Bruno Studer (LAREM) — Absent Sira Sylla (LAREM) — Absent Aurélien Taché (LAREM) — Absent Marie Tamarelle-Verhaeghe (LAREM) — Absent Buon Tan (LAREM) — Absent Liliana Tanguy (LAREM) — Absent Adrien Taquet (LAREM) — Absent Jean Terlier (LAREM) — Absent Stéphane Testé (LAREM) — Against Agnès Thill (LAREM) — Against Sabine Thillaye (LAREM) — Absent Vincent Thiébaut (LAREM) — Against Valérie Thomas (LAREM) — Absent Alice Thourot (LAREM) — Absent Huguette Tiegna (LAREM) — Absent Jean-Louis Touraine (LAREM) — For Alain Tourret (LAREM) — Absent Élisabeth Toutut-Picard (LAREM) — Absent Nicole Trisse (LAREM) — Against Stéphane Trompille (LAREM) — Absent Frédérique Tuffnell (LAREM) — Against Alexandra Valetta Ardisson (LAREM) — Absent Manuel Valls (LAREM) — Absent Laurence Vanceunebrock (LAREM) — Against Marie-Christine Verdier-Jouclas (LAREM) — Against Annie Vidal (LAREM) — Against Patrick Vignal (LAREM) — Absent Corinne Vignon (LAREM) — Absent Cédric Villani (LAREM) — Absent Guillaume Vuilletet (LAREM) — Absent Olivier Véran (LAREM) — Absent Martine Wonner (LAREM) — Absent Hélène Zannier (LAREM) — Against Jean-Marc Zulesi (LAREM) — Against Yolaine de Courson (LAREM) — Against Célia de Lavergne (LAREM) — Absent Amélie de Montchalin (LAREM) — Absent François de Rugy (LAREM) — Non-voting Sophie Auconie (UDI-AGIR) — Against Olivier Becht (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Thierry Benoit (UDI-AGIR) — Against Pierre-Yves Bournazel (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Guy Bricout (UDI-AGIR) — Abstention Paul Christophe (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Stéphane Demilly (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Béatrice Descamps (UDI-AGIR) — Against Philippe Dunoyer (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Yannick Favennec-Bécot (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Agnès Firmin Le Bodo (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Philippe Gomès (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Meyer Habib (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Antoine Herth (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Yves Jégo (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Jean-Christophe Lagarde (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Vincent Ledoux (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Maurice Leroy (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Lise Magnier (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Christophe Naegelen (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Bertrand Pancher (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Franck Riester (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Maina Sage (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Nicole Sanquer (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Francis Vercamer (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Philippe Vigier (UDI-AGIR) — Absent André Villiers (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Jean-Luc Warsmann (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Michel Zumkeller (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Charles de Courson (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Laure de La Raudière (UDI-AGIR) — Absent Damien Abad (LR) — Absent Emmanuelle Anthoine (LR) — Absent Julien Aubert (LR) — Absent Nathalie Bassire (LR) — Absent Thibault Bazin (LR) — Absent Valérie Bazin-Malgras (LR) — Absent Valérie Beauvais (LR) — Absent Émilie Bonnivard (LR) — For Jean-Yves Bony (LR) — Absent Ian Boucard (LR) — Absent Jean-Claude Bouchet (LR) — Absent Valérie Boyer (LR) — Absent Marine Brenier (LR) — Absent Xavier Breton (LR) — Absent Bernard Brochand (LR) — Absent Fabrice Brun (LR) — Absent Gilles Carrez (LR) — Absent Jacques Cattin (LR) — Absent Gérard Cherpion (LR) — Absent Dino Cinieri (LR) — Absent Éric Ciotti (LR) — For Pierre Cordier (LR) — Absent Josiane Corneloup (LR) — Absent François Cornut-Gentille (LR) — Absent Marie-Christine Dalloz (LR) — Absent Olivier Dassault (LR) — Absent Bernard Deflesselles (LR) — Absent Rémi Delatte (LR) — Absent Vincent Descoeur (LR) — Absent Fabien Di Filippo (LR) — Absent Éric Diard (LR) — Absent Julien Dive (LR) — Absent Jean-Pierre Door (LR) — Absent Marianne Dubois (LR) — Absent Virginie Duby-Muller (LR) — Absent Pierre-Henri Dumont (LR) — Absent Daniel Fasquelle (LR) — Absent Jean-Jacques Ferrara (LR) — Absent Nicolas Forissier (LR) — Absent Laurent Furst (LR) — Absent Jean-Jacques Gaultier (LR) — Absent Annie Genevard (LR) — For Claude Goasguen (LR) — Absent Philippe Gosselin (LR) — Absent Jean-Carles Grelier (LR) — Absent Claire Guion-Firmin (LR) — Absent Michel Herbillon (LR) — Absent Patrick Hetzel (LR) — Absent Sébastien Huyghe (LR) — Absent Christian Jacob (LR) — For Mansour Kamardine (LR) — Absent Brigitte Kuster (LR) — Absent Valérie Lacroute (LR) — Absent Guillaume Larrivé (LR) — Absent Marc Le Fur (LR) — Absent Constance Le Grip (LR) — Absent Sébastien Leclerc (LR) — Absent Geneviève Levy (LR) — Absent David Lorion (LR) — Absent Véronique Louwagie (LR) — Absent Gilles Lurton (LR) — For Emmanuel Maquet (LR) — Absent Olivier Marleix (LR) — Absent Franck Marlin (LR) — Absent Jean-Louis Masson (LR) — Absent Gérard Menuel (LR) — Absent Frédérique Meunier (LR) — Absent Maxime Minot (LR) — Absent Jérôme Nury (LR) — Absent Jean-François Parigi (LR) — Absent Éric Pauget (LR) — For Guillaume Peltier (LR) — Absent Bernard Perrut (LR) — Absent Bérengère Poletti (LR) — Absent Aurélien Pradié (LR) — Absent Didier Quentin (LR) — Absent Alain Ramadier (LR) — Absent Nadia Ramassamy (LR) — Absent Robin Reda (LR) — Absent Frédéric Reiss (LR) — For Jean-Luc Reitzer (LR) — Absent Bernard Reynès (LR) — Absent Vincent Rolland (LR) — Absent Martial Saddier (LR) — Absent Antoine Savignat (LR) — Absent Raphaël Schellenberger (LR) — Absent Jean-Marie Sermier (LR) — For Éric Straumann (LR) — For Michèle Tabarot (LR) — Absent Jean-Charles Taugourdeau (LR) — Absent Guy Teissier (LR) — Absent Laurence Trastour-Isnart (LR) — Absent Isabelle Valentin (LR) — Absent Pierre Vatin (LR) — Absent Patrice Verchère (LR) — Absent Arnaud Viala (LR) — Absent Michel Vialay (LR) — Absent Jean-Pierre Vigier (LR) — Absent Stéphane Viry (LR) — Absent Éric Woerth (LR) — Absent Claude de Ganay (LR) — Absent Charles de la Verpillière (LR) — Absent Jean-Félix Acquaviva (NI) — Absent Louis Aliot (NI) — Absent Bruno Bilde (NI) — Absent Michel Castellani (NI) — Absent Sébastien Chenu (NI) — Absent Gilbert Collard (NI) — Absent Paul-André Colombani (NI) — Absent Jeanine Dubié (NI) — Absent Nicolas Dupont-Aignan (NI) — Absent M'jid El Guerrab (NI) — Absent José Evrard (NI) — Abstention Olivier Falorni (NI) — Absent Jean Lassalle (NI) — Absent Marine Le Pen (NI) — Absent Marie-France Lorho (NI) — Absent Emmanuelle Ménard (NI) — Absent Ludovic Pajot (NI) — Absent Sylvia Pinel (NI) — Absent

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
FI 003 01417
GDR 001 01516
NG 600 02531
MODEM 720 13747
LAREM 5520 1254312
UDI-AGIR 031 02832
LR 900 093102
NI 001 01718

All deputies

DeputyGroupVote
Damien Abad LR Absent
Caroline Abadie LAREM Absent
Bérangère Abba LAREM Against
Jean-Félix Acquaviva NI Absent
Damien Adam LAREM Against
Lénaïck Adam LAREM Absent
Saïd Ahamada LAREM Absent
Éric Alauzet LAREM Absent
Ramlati Ali LAREM Absent
Louis Aliot NI Absent
Aude Amadou LAREM Absent
Patrice Anato LAREM Absent
François André LAREM Absent
Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade LAREM Absent
Emmanuelle Anthoine LR Absent
Jean-Philippe Ardouin LAREM Absent
Christophe Arend LAREM Against
Gabriel Attal LAREM Absent
Julien Aubert LR Absent
Sophie Auconie UDI-AGIR Against
Clémentine Autain FI Absent
Laetitia Avia LAREM Absent
Joël Aviragnet NG Absent
Bruno Nestor Azerot GDR Absent
Florian Bachelier LAREM Absent
Delphine Bagarry LAREM Against
Didier Baichère LAREM Absent
Erwan Balanant MODEM Absent
Géraldine Bannier MODEM Absent
Frédéric Barbier LAREM Absent
Ericka Bareigts NG Absent
Jean-Noël Barrot MODEM Absent
Nathalie Bassire LR Absent
Delphine Batho NG Absent
Marie-Noëlle Battistel NG For
Xavier Batut LAREM Absent
Thibault Bazin LR Absent
Valérie Bazin-Malgras LR Absent
Sophie Beaudouin-Hubiere LAREM Absent
Valérie Beauvais LR Absent
Olivier Becht UDI-AGIR Absent
Belkhir Belhaddad LAREM Absent
Huguette Bello GDR Absent
Justine Benin MODEM Absent
Thierry Benoit UDI-AGIR Against
Aurore Bergé LAREM Absent
Ugo Bernalicis FI Abstention
Philippe Berta MODEM Against
Hervé Berville LAREM Absent
Grégory Besson-Moreau LAREM Absent
Barbara Bessot Ballot LAREM Absent
Gisèle Biémouret NG Absent
Bruno Bilde NI Absent
Anne Blanc LAREM Absent
Christophe Blanchet LAREM Absent
Yves Blein LAREM Absent
Pascal Bois LAREM Absent
Philippe Bolo MODEM Absent
Bruno Bonnell LAREM For
Émilie Bonnivard LR For
Aude Bono-Vandorme LAREM Absent
Jean-Yves Bony LR Absent
Julien Borowczyk LAREM Absent
Éric Bothorel LAREM Absent
Ian Boucard LR Absent
Jean-Claude Bouchet LR Absent
Florent Boudié LAREM Absent
Christophe Bouillon NG For
Brigitte Bourguignon LAREM Absent
Jean-Louis Bourlanges MODEM Absent
Pierre-Yves Bournazel UDI-AGIR Absent
Bertrand Bouyx LAREM Absent
Pascale Boyer LAREM Against
Valérie Boyer LR Absent
Yaël Braun-Pivet LAREM Absent
Marine Brenier LR Absent
Xavier Breton LR Absent
Guy Bricout UDI-AGIR Abstention
Jean-Louis Bricout NG For
Jean-Jacques Bridey LAREM Absent
Blandine Brocard LAREM Absent
Bernard Brochand LR Absent
Moetai Brotherson GDR Absent
Vincent Bru MODEM Absent
Anne Brugnera LAREM Absent
Danielle Brulebois LAREM Against
Fabrice Brun LR Absent
Alain Bruneel GDR Absent
Anne-France Brunet LAREM Absent
Stéphane Buchou LAREM Absent
Marie-George Buffet GDR Absent
Carole Bureau-Bonnard LAREM Absent
Pierre Cabaré LAREM Absent
Céline Calvez LAREM Absent
Émilie Cariou LAREM Absent
Gilles Carrez LR Absent
Luc Carvounas NG Absent
Michel Castellani NI Absent
Anne-Laure Cattelot LAREM Against
Jacques Cattin LR Absent
Lionel Causse LAREM Absent
Danièle Cazarian LAREM Absent
Jean-René Cazeneuve LAREM Absent
Sébastien Cazenove LAREM Absent
Anthony Cellier LAREM Absent
Jean-François Cesarini LAREM Absent
Émilie Chalas LAREM Absent
Philippe Chalumeau LAREM Absent
Annie Chapelier LAREM Absent
Sylvie Charrière LAREM Against
Fannette Charvier LAREM Absent
André Chassaigne GDR Absent
Philippe Chassaing LAREM Absent
Sébastien Chenu NI Absent
Gérard Cherpion LR Absent
Guillaume Chiche LAREM Absent
Paul Christophe UDI-AGIR Absent
Dino Cinieri LR Absent
Éric Ciotti LR For
Stéphane Claireaux LAREM Absent
Mireille Clapot LAREM Absent
Jean-Michel Clément LAREM Absent
Jean-Charles Colas-Roy LAREM Absent
Fabienne Colboc LAREM Absent
Gilbert Collard NI Absent
Claire Colomb-Pitollat LAREM Absent
Paul-André Colombani NI Absent
Éric Coquerel FI Absent
Alexis Corbière FI Absent
Pierre Cordier LR Absent
François Cormier-Bouligeon LAREM Absent
Josiane Corneloup LR Absent
François Cornut-Gentille LR Absent
Bérangère Couillard LAREM Absent
Michèle Crouzet LAREM Absent
Jean-Pierre Cubertafon MODEM Absent
Dominique Da Silva LAREM Absent
Marie-Christine Dalloz LR Absent
Olivier Damaisin LAREM Absent
Yves Daniel LAREM Absent
Olivier Dassault LR Absent
Alain David NG Absent
Dominique David LAREM Absent
Charles de Courson UDI-AGIR Absent
Yolaine de Courson LAREM Against
Claude de Ganay LR Absent
Laure de La Raudière UDI-AGIR Absent
Charles de la Verpillière LR Absent
Célia de Lavergne LAREM Absent
Amélie de Montchalin LAREM Absent
François de Rugy LAREM Non-voting
Marielle de Sarnez MODEM Absent
Jennifer De Temmerman LAREM Against
Michèle de Vaucouleurs MODEM For
Bernard Deflesselles LR Absent
Typhanie Degois LAREM Absent
Marc Delatte LAREM Absent
Rémi Delatte LR Absent
Michel Delpon LAREM Absent
Stéphane Demilly UDI-AGIR Absent
Nicolas Démoulin LAREM Absent
Marguerite Deprez-Audebert MODEM Absent
Béatrice Descamps UDI-AGIR Against
Vincent Descoeur LR Absent
Frédéric Descrozaille LAREM Absent
Pierre Dharréville GDR Absent
Fabien Di Filippo LR Absent
Christophe Di Pompeo LAREM Absent
Éric Diard LR Absent
Benjamin Dirx LAREM Absent
Julien Dive LR Absent
Jean-Baptiste Djebbari LAREM Against
Stéphanie Do LAREM Absent
Loïc Dombreval LAREM Absent
Jean-Pierre Door LR Absent
Jeanine Dubié NI Absent
Jacqueline Dubois LAREM Absent
Marianne Dubois LR Absent
Christelle Dubos LAREM Absent
Coralie Dubost LAREM Absent
Nicole Dubré-Chirat LAREM Against
Virginie Duby-Muller LR Absent
Audrey Dufeu LAREM Absent
Jean-Paul Dufrègne GDR Absent
Françoise Dumas LAREM Absent
Frédérique Dumas LAREM Absent
Laurence Dumont NG Absent
Pierre-Henri Dumont LR Absent
Philippe Dunoyer UDI-AGIR Absent
Stella Dupont LAREM For corrected (originally: against)
Nicolas Dupont-Aignan NI Absent
Bruno Duvergé MODEM Absent
M'jid El Guerrab NI Absent
Sarah El Haïry MODEM Absent
Jean-François Eliaou LAREM Absent
Nathalie Elimas MODEM Absent
Sophie Errante LAREM Absent
Nadia Essayan MODEM Against
Christophe Euzet LAREM Absent
José Evrard NI Abstention
Catherine Fabre LAREM Absent
Élise Fajgeles LAREM Absent
Olivier Falorni NI Absent
Michel Fanget MODEM Absent
Daniel Fasquelle LR Absent
Elsa Faucillon GDR Absent
Olivier Faure NG Absent
Valéria Faure-Muntian LAREM Absent
Jean-Michel Fauvergue LAREM Absent
Yannick Favennec-Bécot UDI-AGIR Absent
Richard Ferrand LAREM Absent
Jean-Jacques Ferrara LR Absent
Marc Fesneau MODEM Absent
Caroline Fiat FI Abstention
Jean-Marie Fiévet LAREM Absent
Agnès Firmin Le Bodo UDI-AGIR Absent
Isabelle Florennes MODEM Absent
Philippe Folliot LAREM Absent
Emmanuelle Fontaine-Domeizel LAREM Absent
Pascale Fontenel-Personne LAREM Absent
Nicolas Forissier LR Absent
Paula Forteza LAREM Absent
Alexandre Freschi LAREM Absent
Bruno Fuchs MODEM Absent
Jean-Luc Fugit LAREM Against
Laurent Furst LR Absent
Olivier Gaillard LAREM Absent
Albane Gaillot LAREM Absent
Grégory Galbadon LAREM Absent
Patricia Gallerneau MODEM For corrected (originally: against)
Laurent Garcia MODEM Absent
Guillaume Garot NG For
Thomas Gassilloud LAREM Absent
Jean-Jacques Gaultier LR Absent
Raphaël Gauvain LAREM Absent
Laurence Gayte LAREM Against
Anne Genetet LAREM Absent
Annie Genevard LR For
Raphaël Gérard LAREM Absent
Séverine Gipson LAREM Absent
Éric Girardin LAREM Absent
Joël Giraud LAREM Absent
Olga Givernet LAREM Absent
Claude Goasguen LR Absent
Philippe Gomès UDI-AGIR Absent
Valérie Gomez-Bassac LAREM Absent
Philippe Gosselin LR Absent
Guillaume Gouffier Valente LAREM Absent
Perrine Goulet LAREM Absent
Fabien Gouttefarde LAREM Absent
Carole Grandjean LAREM Against
Florence Granjus LAREM Absent
Romain Grau LAREM Absent
Olivia Grégoire LAREM Absent
Jean-Carles Grelier LR Absent
Émilie Guerel LAREM Absent
Stanislas Guerini LAREM Absent
Marie Guévenoux LAREM Absent
Claire Guion-Firmin LR Absent
David Habib NG Absent
Meyer Habib UDI-AGIR Absent
Nadia Hai LAREM Absent
Véronique Hammerer LAREM Absent
Brahim Hammouche MODEM Absent
Yannick Haury LAREM Absent
Christine Hennion LAREM Absent
Pierre Henriet LAREM Absent
Michel Herbillon LR Absent
Danièle Hérin LAREM Absent
Antoine Herth UDI-AGIR Absent
Patrick Hetzel LR Absent
Alexandre Holroyd LAREM Absent
Dimitri Houbron LAREM Absent
Sacha Houlié LAREM Absent
Philippe Huppé LAREM Absent
Christian Hutin NG Absent
Sébastien Huyghe LR Absent
Monique Iborra LAREM Absent
Cyrille Isaac-Sibille MODEM Absent
Christian Jacob LR For
Jean-Michel Jacques LAREM Absent
Élodie Jacquier-Laforge MODEM Absent
Caroline Janvier LAREM For
Yves Jégo UDI-AGIR Absent
Christophe Jerretie LAREM Absent
François Jolivet LAREM Absent
Bruno Joncour MODEM Absent
Sandrine Josso LAREM Absent
Régis Juanico NG Absent
Hubert Julien-Laferrière LAREM Absent
Sébastien Jumel GDR Absent
Mansour Kamardine LR Absent
Catherine Kamowski LAREM Against
Marietta Karamanli NG Absent
Guillaume Kasbarian LAREM Absent
Stéphanie Kerbarh LAREM Against
Yannick Kerlogot LAREM Against
Loïc Kervran LAREM Absent
Fadila Khattabi LAREM Absent
Anissa Khedher LAREM Absent
Rodrigue Kokouendo LAREM Absent
Jacques Krabal LAREM Absent
Sonia Krimi LAREM Absent
Aina Kuric LAREM Absent
Brigitte Kuster LR Absent
Mustapha Laabid LAREM Absent
Daniel Labaronne LAREM Absent
Bastien Lachaud FI Absent
Valérie Lacroute LR Absent
Jean-Christophe Lagarde UDI-AGIR Absent
Jean-Luc Lagleize MODEM For
Fabien Lainé MODEM Absent
Amélia Lakrafi LAREM Absent
François-Michel Lambert LAREM Absent
Jérôme Lambert NG Absent
Anne-Christine Lang LAREM Absent
Mohamed Laqhila MODEM For
Frédérique Lardet LAREM Against
Michel Larive FI Absent
Guillaume Larrivé LR Absent
Jean-Charles Larsonneur LAREM Absent
Jean Lassalle NI Absent
Florence Lasserre MODEM For
Philippe Latombe MODEM Absent
Michel Lauzzana LAREM Absent
Fiona Lazaar LAREM Absent
Gaël Le Bohec LAREM Absent
Sandrine Le Feur LAREM Absent
Stéphane Le Foll NG Absent
Marc Le Fur LR Absent
Didier Le Gac LAREM Absent
Gilles Le Gendre LAREM Absent
Constance Le Grip LR Absent
Annaïg Le Meur LAREM Absent
Christine Le Nabour LAREM Absent
Nicole Le Peih LAREM Absent
Marine Le Pen NI Absent
Fabrice Le Vigoureux LAREM Absent
Marie Lebec LAREM Against
Jean-Claude Leclabart LAREM Absent
Sébastien Leclerc LR Absent
Jean-Paul Lecoq GDR Abstention
Vincent Ledoux UDI-AGIR Absent
Martine Leguille-Balloy LAREM Absent
Christophe Lejeune LAREM Absent
Marion Lenne LAREM Absent
Maurice Leroy UDI-AGIR Absent
Roland Lescure LAREM Absent
Serge Letchimy NG Absent
Geneviève Levy LR Absent
Monique Limon LAREM Absent
Richard Lioger LAREM Absent
Brigitte Liso LAREM Absent
Marie-France Lorho NI Absent
David Lorion LR Absent
Alexandra Louis LAREM Absent
Véronique Louwagie LR Absent
Aude Luquet MODEM Absent
Gilles Lurton LR For
Marie-Ange Magne LAREM Absent
Lise Magnier UDI-AGIR Absent
Sylvain Maillard LAREM Absent
Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie LAREM Against
Jacques Maire LAREM Absent
Josette Manin NG Absent
Emmanuel Maquet LR Absent
Jacqueline Maquet LAREM Absent
Jacques Marilossian LAREM Against
Olivier Marleix LR Absent
Franck Marlin LR Absent
Sandra Marsaud LAREM Against
Didier Martin LAREM Absent
Denis Masséglia LAREM Absent
Jean-Louis Masson LR Absent
Max Mathiasin MODEM Absent
Fabien Matras LAREM Absent
Jean-Paul Mattei MODEM Absent
Sereine Mauborgne LAREM Absent
Stéphane Mazars LAREM Absent
Jean François Mbaye LAREM Absent
Graziella Melchior LAREM Absent
Jean-Luc Mélenchon FI Absent
Emmanuelle Ménard NI Absent
Ludovic Mendes LAREM Absent
Gérard Menuel LR Absent
Thomas Mesnier LAREM Absent
Sophie Mette MODEM For
Frédérique Meunier LR Absent
Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert LAREM Absent
Monica Michel-Brassart LAREM Absent
Philippe Michel-Kleisbauer MODEM Absent
Thierry Michels LAREM Absent
Patrick Mignola MODEM Absent
Bruno Millienne MODEM Absent
Maxime Minot LR Absent
Patricia Mirallès LAREM Against
Jean-Michel Mis LAREM Absent
Paul Molac LAREM Absent
Sandrine Mörch LAREM Absent
Jean-Baptiste Moreau LAREM Absent
Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier UDI-AGIR Absent
Adrien Morenas LAREM Against
Cendra Motin LAREM Absent
Naïma Moutchou LAREM Absent
Cécile Muschotti LAREM Absent
Sébastien Nadot LAREM Absent
Christophe Naegelen UDI-AGIR Absent
Jean-Philippe Nilor GDR Absent
Mickaël Nogal LAREM Absent
Jérôme Nury LR Absent
Delphine O LAREM Absent
Claire O'Petit LAREM Absent
Danièle Obono FI Absent
Valérie Oppelt LAREM Against
Matthieu Orphelin LAREM Absent
Catherine Osson LAREM Absent
Jimmy Pahun MODEM Absent
Ludovic Pajot NI Absent
Xavier Paluszkiewicz LAREM Absent
Bertrand Pancher UDI-AGIR Absent
Sophie Panonacle LAREM Absent
Mathilde Panot FI Absent
Jean-François Parigi LR Absent
Didier Paris LAREM Absent
Zivka Park LAREM Against
Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq LAREM Against
George Pau-Langevin NG Absent
Éric Pauget LR For
Hervé Pellois LAREM Against
Guillaume Peltier LR Absent
Alain Perea LAREM Against
Patrice Perrot LAREM Absent
Bernard Perrut LR Absent
Pierre Person LAREM Absent
Anne-Laurence Petel LAREM Absent
Frédéric Petit MODEM Absent
Maud Petit MODEM Absent
Valérie Petit LAREM Against
Stéphane Peu GDR Absent
Bénédicte Peyrol LAREM Absent
Michèle Peyron LAREM Against
Damien Pichereau LAREM Against
Laurent Pietraszewski LAREM Absent
Sylvia Pinel NI Absent
Christine Pirès Beaune NG For
Béatrice Piron LAREM Absent
Bérengère Poletti LR Absent
Barbara Pompili LAREM Absent
Jean-Pierre Pont LAREM Against
Jean-François Portarrieu LAREM Absent
Dominique Potier NG Absent
Benoit Potterie LAREM Absent
Josy Poueyto MODEM For
Éric Poulliat LAREM Absent
Natalia Pouzyreff LAREM Against
Aurélien Pradié LR Absent
Loïc Prud'homme FI Absent
Joaquim Pueyo NG Absent
François Pupponi NG Absent
Adrien Quatennens FI Absent
Didier Quentin LR Absent
Bruno Questel LAREM Against
Valérie Rabault NG Absent
Cathy Racon-Bouzon LAREM Absent
Alain Ramadier LR Absent
Nadia Ramassamy LR Absent
Richard Ramos MODEM Absent
Pierre-Alain Raphan LAREM Absent
Jean-Hugues Ratenon FI Abstention
Isabelle Rauch LAREM Absent
Rémy Rebeyrotte LAREM Against
Robin Reda LR Absent
Frédéric Reiss LR For
Jean-Luc Reitzer LR Absent
Hugues Renson LAREM Absent
Muriel Ressiguier FI Absent
Bernard Reynès LR Absent
Franck Riester UDI-AGIR Absent
Cécile Rilhac LAREM Absent
Véronique Riotton LAREM Against
Stéphanie Rist LAREM Against
Marie-Pierre Rixain LAREM Absent
Mireille Robert LAREM Absent
Thierry Robert MODEM Absent
Vincent Rolland LR Absent
Laëtitia Romeiro Dias LAREM Absent
Xavier Roseren LAREM Absent
Laurianne Rossi LAREM Absent
Gwendal Rouillard LAREM Absent
Cédric Roussel LAREM Against
Fabien Roussel GDR Absent
Sabine Rubin FI Absent
Thomas Rudigoz LAREM Absent
François Ruffin FI Absent
Pacôme Rupin LAREM Absent
Martial Saddier LR Absent
Maina Sage UDI-AGIR Absent
Laurent Saint-Martin LAREM Against
Laetitia Saint-Paul LAREM Absent
Nicole Sanquer UDI-AGIR Absent
Nathalie Sarles LAREM Against
Hervé Saulignac NG Absent
Jacques Savatier LAREM Absent
Antoine Savignat LR Absent
Raphaël Schellenberger LR Absent
Jean-Bernard Sempastous LAREM Absent
Jean-Marie Sermier LR For
Olivier Serva LAREM Absent
Gabriel Serville GDR Absent
Benoit Simian LAREM For
Thierry Solère LAREM Absent
Denis Sommer LAREM Absent
Joachim Son-Forget LAREM Absent
Bertrand Sorre LAREM Absent
Éric Straumann LR For
Bruno Studer LAREM Absent
Sira Sylla LAREM Absent
Michèle Tabarot LR Absent
Aurélien Taché LAREM Absent
Marie Tamarelle-Verhaeghe LAREM Absent
Buon Tan LAREM Absent
Liliana Tanguy LAREM Absent
Adrien Taquet LAREM Absent
Jean-Charles Taugourdeau LR Absent
Bénédicte Taurine FI Absent
Guy Teissier LR Absent
Jean Terlier LAREM Absent
Stéphane Testé LAREM Against
Vincent Thiébaut LAREM Against
Agnès Thill LAREM Against
Sabine Thillaye LAREM Absent
Valérie Thomas LAREM Absent
Alice Thourot LAREM Absent
Huguette Tiegna LAREM Absent
Jean-Louis Touraine LAREM For
Alain Tourret LAREM Absent
Élisabeth Toutut-Picard LAREM Absent
Laurence Trastour-Isnart LR Absent
Nicole Trisse LAREM Against
Stéphane Trompille LAREM Absent
Frédérique Tuffnell LAREM Against
Nicolas Turquois MODEM Absent
Cécile Untermaier NG Absent
Hélène Vainqueur-Christophe NG Absent
Isabelle Valentin LR Absent
Alexandra Valetta Ardisson LAREM Absent
Boris Vallaud NG Absent
Manuel Valls LAREM Absent
Laurence Vanceunebrock LAREM Against
Pierre Vatin LR Absent
Olivier Véran LAREM Absent
Francis Vercamer UDI-AGIR Absent
Patrice Verchère LR Absent
Marie-Christine Verdier-Jouclas LAREM Against
Arnaud Viala LR Absent
Michel Vialay LR Absent
Laurence Vichnievsky MODEM Absent
Michèle Victory NG For
Annie Vidal LAREM Against
Jean-Pierre Vigier LR Absent
Philippe Vigier UDI-AGIR Absent
Patrick Vignal LAREM Absent
Corinne Vignon LAREM Absent
Cédric Villani LAREM Absent
André Villiers UDI-AGIR Absent
Stéphane Viry LR Absent
Guillaume Vuilletet LAREM Absent
Jean-Luc Warsmann UDI-AGIR Absent
Sylvain Waserman MODEM Non-voting
Éric Woerth LR Absent
Martine Wonner LAREM Absent
Hubert Wulfranc GDR Absent
Hélène Zannier LAREM Against
Jean-Marc Zulesi LAREM Against
Michel Zumkeller UDI-AGIR Absent