← All votes

National Assembly · vote no. 433 · · ✓ Adopted

The entire bill on military programming for the years 2019 to 2025 and containing various defence-related provisions (first reading).

≈ automatic translation Official title: Projet de loi relatif à la programmation militaire pour les années 2019 à 2025 et portant diverses dispositions intéressant la défense (première lecture)

Promulgated See this text's full journey →

Promulgated on 13 July 2018 Published in the Official Journal on 14 July 2018 Law no. 2018-607 Text on Légifrance ↗ Legislative file ↗

Type of vote
Solemn roll-call vote
Voters
563
1 non-voting
Votes cast
426
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
214 votes
Majorité absolue des suffrages exprimés

389 for 37 against 137 abstentions ▏threshold : 214 votes

Colour by:
FI — 17 GDR — 16 NG — 31 MODEM — 47 LAREM — 312 UDI-AGIR — 32 LR — 102 NI — 18 NGMODEMLAREMUDI-AGIRLR Clémentine Autain (FI) — Against Ugo Bernalicis (FI) — Against Éric Coquerel (FI) — Against Alexis Corbière (FI) — Against Caroline Fiat (FI) — Against Bastien Lachaud (FI) — Against Michel Larive (FI) — Against — by proxy Jean-Luc Mélenchon (FI) — Against Danièle Obono (FI) — Against — by proxy Mathilde Panot (FI) — Against Loïc Prud'homme (FI) — Against — by proxy Adrien Quatennens (FI) — Against Jean-Hugues Ratenon (FI) — Against — by proxy Muriel Ressiguier (FI) — Against Sabine Rubin (FI) — Against François Ruffin (FI) — Against Bénédicte Taurine (FI) — Against Bruno Nestor Azerot (GDR) — Against — by proxy Huguette Bello (GDR) — Against — by proxy Moetai Brotherson (GDR) — Against — by proxy Alain Bruneel (GDR) — Against — by proxy Marie-George Buffet (GDR) — Against — by proxy André Chassaigne (GDR) — Against Pierre Dharréville (GDR) — Against Jean-Paul Dufrègne (GDR) — Against Elsa Faucillon (GDR) — Against Sébastien Jumel (GDR) — Against Jean-Paul Lecoq (GDR) — Against — by proxy Jean-Philippe Nilor (GDR) — Against Stéphane Peu (GDR) — Against Fabien Roussel (GDR) — Against Gabriel Serville (GDR) — Against — by proxy Hubert Wulfranc (GDR) — Against Joël Aviragnet (NG) — Abstention Ericka Bareigts (NG) — Abstention Delphine Batho (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Marie-Noëlle Battistel (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Gisèle Biémouret (NG) — Abstention Christophe Bouillon (NG) — Abstention Jean-Louis Bricout (NG) — Abstention Luc Carvounas (NG) — Abstention Alain David (NG) — Abstention Laurence Dumont (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Olivier Faure (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Guillaume Garot (NG) — Abstention David Habib (NG) — Abstention Christian Hutin (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Régis Juanico (NG) — Abstention Marietta Karamanli (NG) — Abstention Jérôme Lambert (NG) — Abstention Stéphane Le Foll (NG) — Abstention Serge Letchimy (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Josette Manin (NG) — Abstention (vote correction) George Pau-Langevin (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Christine Pirès Beaune (NG) — Abstention Dominique Potier (NG) — Abstention Joaquim Pueyo (NG) — Abstention François Pupponi (NG) — Abstention Valérie Rabault (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Hervé Saulignac (NG) — Abstention Cécile Untermaier (NG) — Abstention Hélène Vainqueur-Christophe (NG) — Abstention — by proxy Boris Vallaud (NG) — Abstention Michèle Victory (NG) — Abstention Erwan Balanant (MODEM) — For Géraldine Bannier (MODEM) — For Jean-Noël Barrot (MODEM) — For — by proxy Justine Benin (MODEM) — For — by proxy Philippe Berta (MODEM) — For Philippe Bolo (MODEM) — For Jean-Louis Bourlanges (MODEM) — For Vincent Bru (MODEM) — For — by proxy Jean-Pierre Cubertafon (MODEM) — For Marguerite Deprez-Audebert (MODEM) — For — by proxy Bruno Duvergé (MODEM) — For Sarah El Haïry (MODEM) — For Nathalie Elimas (MODEM) — For Nadia Essayan (MODEM) — For — by proxy Michel Fanget (MODEM) — For — by proxy Marc Fesneau (MODEM) — For Isabelle Florennes (MODEM) — For Bruno Fuchs (MODEM) — For Patricia Gallerneau (MODEM) — For Laurent Garcia (MODEM) — For — by proxy Brahim Hammouche (MODEM) — For Cyrille Isaac-Sibille (MODEM) — For Élodie Jacquier-Laforge (MODEM) — For Bruno Joncour (MODEM) — For Jean-Luc Lagleize (MODEM) — For — by proxy Fabien Lainé (MODEM) — For Mohamed Laqhila (MODEM) — For Florence Lasserre (MODEM) — For Philippe Latombe (MODEM) — For Aude Luquet (MODEM) — For Max Mathiasin (MODEM) — For Jean-Paul Mattei (MODEM) — For — by proxy Sophie Mette (MODEM) — For Philippe Michel-Kleisbauer (MODEM) — For Patrick Mignola (MODEM) — For Bruno Millienne (MODEM) — For Jimmy Pahun (MODEM) — For Frédéric Petit (MODEM) — For Maud Petit (MODEM) — For Josy Poueyto (MODEM) — For Richard Ramos (MODEM) — For Thierry Robert (MODEM) — For Nicolas Turquois (MODEM) — Absent Laurence Vichnievsky (MODEM) — For — by proxy Sylvain Waserman (MODEM) — For Marielle de Sarnez (MODEM) — For Michèle de Vaucouleurs (MODEM) — For Caroline Abadie (LAREM) — For Bérangère Abba (LAREM) — For Damien Adam (LAREM) — For Lénaïck Adam (LAREM) — For — by proxy Saïd Ahamada (LAREM) — For Éric Alauzet (LAREM) — Absent Ramlati Ali (LAREM) — For — by proxy Aude Amadou (LAREM) — For — by proxy Patrice Anato (LAREM) — For François André (LAREM) — For Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade (LAREM) — For Jean-Philippe Ardouin (LAREM) — For Christophe Arend (LAREM) — For Gabriel Attal (LAREM) — For Laetitia Avia (LAREM) — For Florian Bachelier (LAREM) — For Delphine Bagarry (LAREM) — For Didier Baichère (LAREM) — For Frédéric Barbier (LAREM) — For Xavier Batut (LAREM) — For Sophie Beaudouin-Hubiere (LAREM) — For Belkhir Belhaddad (LAREM) — For Aurore Bergé (LAREM) — For Hervé Berville (LAREM) — For Grégory Besson-Moreau (LAREM) — For — by proxy Barbara Bessot Ballot (LAREM) — For Anne Blanc (LAREM) — For — by proxy Christophe Blanchet (LAREM) — For Yves Blein (LAREM) — For Pascal Bois (LAREM) — For Bruno Bonnell (LAREM) — For Aude Bono-Vandorme (LAREM) — For Julien Borowczyk (LAREM) — For Éric Bothorel (LAREM) — For Florent Boudié (LAREM) — For Brigitte Bourguignon (LAREM) — For Bertrand Bouyx (LAREM) — For Pascale Boyer (LAREM) — For Yaël Braun-Pivet (LAREM) — For Jean-Jacques Bridey (LAREM) — For Blandine Brocard (LAREM) — For Anne Brugnera (LAREM) — For Danielle Brulebois (LAREM) — For Anne-France Brunet (LAREM) — For Stéphane Buchou (LAREM) — For Carole Bureau-Bonnard (LAREM) — For Pierre Cabaré (LAREM) — For Céline Calvez (LAREM) — For Émilie Cariou (LAREM) — For Anne-Laure Cattelot (LAREM) — For Lionel Causse (LAREM) — For Danièle Cazarian (LAREM) — For Jean-René Cazeneuve (LAREM) — For Sébastien Cazenove (LAREM) — For Anthony Cellier (LAREM) — For Jean-François Cesarini (LAREM) — For — by proxy Émilie Chalas (LAREM) — For Philippe Chalumeau (LAREM) — For Annie Chapelier (LAREM) — For Sylvie Charrière (LAREM) — For Fannette Charvier (LAREM) — For Philippe Chassaing (LAREM) — For Guillaume Chiche (LAREM) — For Stéphane Claireaux (LAREM) — For — by proxy Mireille Clapot (LAREM) — For Jean-Michel Clément (LAREM) — For — by proxy Jean-Charles Colas-Roy (LAREM) — For Fabienne Colboc (LAREM) — For Claire Colomb-Pitollat (LAREM) — For François Cormier-Bouligeon (LAREM) — For Bérangère Couillard (LAREM) — For — by proxy Michèle Crouzet (LAREM) — For (vote correction) Dominique Da Silva (LAREM) — For Olivier Damaisin (LAREM) — For Yves Daniel (LAREM) — For Dominique David (LAREM) — For Jennifer De Temmerman (LAREM) — For — by proxy Typhanie Degois (LAREM) — For Marc Delatte (LAREM) — For Michel Delpon (LAREM) — For Frédéric Descrozaille (LAREM) — For — by proxy Christophe Di Pompeo (LAREM) — For Benjamin Dirx (LAREM) — For — by proxy Jean-Baptiste Djebbari (LAREM) — For Stéphanie Do (LAREM) — For Loïc Dombreval (LAREM) — For — by proxy Jacqueline Dubois (LAREM) — For — by proxy Christelle Dubos (LAREM) — For Coralie Dubost (LAREM) — For — by proxy Nicole Dubré-Chirat (LAREM) — For Audrey Dufeu (LAREM) — For Françoise Dumas (LAREM) — For Frédérique Dumas (LAREM) — For — by proxy Stella Dupont (LAREM) — For Nicolas Démoulin (LAREM) — For Jean-François Eliaou (LAREM) — For Sophie Errante (LAREM) — For — by proxy Christophe Euzet (LAREM) — For — by proxy Catherine Fabre (LAREM) — For Élise Fajgeles (LAREM) — For Valéria Faure-Muntian (LAREM) — For — by proxy Jean-Michel Fauvergue (LAREM) — For — by proxy Richard Ferrand (LAREM) — For Jean-Marie Fiévet (LAREM) — For Philippe Folliot (LAREM) — For Emmanuelle Fontaine-Domeizel (LAREM) — Absent Pascale Fontenel-Personne (LAREM) — For Paula Forteza (LAREM) — For — by proxy Alexandre Freschi (LAREM) — For Jean-Luc Fugit (LAREM) — For Olivier Gaillard (LAREM) — For Albane Gaillot (LAREM) — For Grégory Galbadon (LAREM) — For — by proxy Thomas Gassilloud (LAREM) — For Raphaël Gauvain (LAREM) — For — by proxy Laurence Gayte (LAREM) — For — by proxy Anne Genetet (LAREM) — For Séverine Gipson (LAREM) — For Éric Girardin (LAREM) — For Joël Giraud (LAREM) — For Olga Givernet (LAREM) — For Valérie Gomez-Bassac (LAREM) — For Guillaume Gouffier Valente (LAREM) — For Perrine Goulet (LAREM) — For Fabien Gouttefarde (LAREM) — For — by proxy Carole Grandjean (LAREM) — For Florence Granjus (LAREM) — For Romain Grau (LAREM) — For Olivia Grégoire (LAREM) — For Émilie Guerel (LAREM) — For Stanislas Guerini (LAREM) — For Marie Guévenoux (LAREM) — For Raphaël Gérard (LAREM) — For Nadia Hai (LAREM) — For — by proxy Véronique Hammerer (LAREM) — For Yannick Haury (LAREM) — For — by proxy Christine Hennion (LAREM) — For Pierre Henriet (LAREM) — For Alexandre Holroyd (LAREM) — For Dimitri Houbron (LAREM) — For Sacha Houlié (LAREM) — For Philippe Huppé (LAREM) — For Danièle Hérin (LAREM) — For Monique Iborra (LAREM) — For — by proxy Jean-Michel Jacques (LAREM) — For Caroline Janvier (LAREM) — For Christophe Jerretie (LAREM) — For — by proxy François Jolivet (LAREM) — For Sandrine Josso (LAREM) — For Hubert Julien-Laferrière (LAREM) — For Catherine Kamowski (LAREM) — For Guillaume Kasbarian (LAREM) — For Stéphanie Kerbarh (LAREM) — For — by proxy Yannick Kerlogot (LAREM) — For Loïc Kervran (LAREM) — For Fadila Khattabi (LAREM) — For Anissa Khedher (LAREM) — For Rodrigue Kokouendo (LAREM) — For Jacques Krabal (LAREM) — For Sonia Krimi (LAREM) — For Aina Kuric (LAREM) — For Mustapha Laabid (LAREM) — For Daniel Labaronne (LAREM) — For Amélia Lakrafi (LAREM) — For — by proxy François-Michel Lambert (LAREM) — For — by proxy Anne-Christine Lang (LAREM) — For Frédérique Lardet (LAREM) — For Jean-Charles Larsonneur (LAREM) — For — by proxy Michel Lauzzana (LAREM) — For Fiona Lazaar (LAREM) — For Gaël Le Bohec (LAREM) — For Sandrine Le Feur (LAREM) — For Didier Le Gac (LAREM) — For Gilles Le Gendre (LAREM) — For Annaïg Le Meur (LAREM) — For — by proxy Christine Le Nabour (LAREM) — For — by proxy Nicole Le Peih (LAREM) — For Fabrice Le Vigoureux (LAREM) — For Marie Lebec (LAREM) — For Jean-Claude Leclabart (LAREM) — For Martine Leguille-Balloy (LAREM) — For Christophe Lejeune (LAREM) — For Marion Lenne (LAREM) — For Roland Lescure (LAREM) — For Monique Limon (LAREM) — For Richard Lioger (LAREM) — For Brigitte Liso (LAREM) — For Alexandra Louis (LAREM) — For — by proxy Marie-Ange Magne (LAREM) — For Sylvain Maillard (LAREM) — For Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie (LAREM) — For — by proxy Jacques Maire (LAREM) — For Jacqueline Maquet (LAREM) — For Jacques Marilossian (LAREM) — For Sandra Marsaud (LAREM) — For Didier Martin (LAREM) — For Denis Masséglia (LAREM) — Abstention Fabien Matras (LAREM) — For Sereine Mauborgne (LAREM) — For Stéphane Mazars (LAREM) — For Jean François Mbaye (LAREM) — For Graziella Melchior (LAREM) — For — by proxy Ludovic Mendes (LAREM) — For — by proxy Thomas Mesnier (LAREM) — For Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert (LAREM) — For Monica Michel-Brassart (LAREM) — For — by proxy Thierry Michels (LAREM) — For Patricia Mirallès (LAREM) — For Jean-Michel Mis (LAREM) — For Paul Molac (LAREM) — For Jean-Baptiste Moreau (LAREM) — For Adrien Morenas (LAREM) — For Cendra Motin (LAREM) — For Naïma Moutchou (LAREM) — For Cécile Muschotti (LAREM) — For Sandrine Mörch (LAREM) — For Sébastien Nadot (LAREM) — For — by proxy Mickaël Nogal (LAREM) — For Delphine O (LAREM) — For — by proxy Claire O'Petit (LAREM) — For Valérie Oppelt (LAREM) — For Matthieu Orphelin (LAREM) — For Catherine Osson (LAREM) — For Xavier Paluszkiewicz (LAREM) — For Sophie Panonacle (LAREM) — For Didier Paris (LAREM) — For Zivka Park (LAREM) — For Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq (LAREM) — For Hervé Pellois (LAREM) — For Alain Perea (LAREM) — For — by proxy Patrice Perrot (LAREM) — For — by proxy Pierre Person (LAREM) — For Anne-Laurence Petel (LAREM) — For Valérie Petit (LAREM) — For Bénédicte Peyrol (LAREM) — For Michèle Peyron (LAREM) — For Damien Pichereau (LAREM) — For Laurent Pietraszewski (LAREM) — For Béatrice Piron (LAREM) — For Barbara Pompili (LAREM) — For Jean-Pierre Pont (LAREM) — For Jean-François Portarrieu (LAREM) — For Benoit Potterie (LAREM) — For Éric Poulliat (LAREM) — For — by proxy Natalia Pouzyreff (LAREM) — For Bruno Questel (LAREM) — For Cathy Racon-Bouzon (LAREM) — For Pierre-Alain Raphan (LAREM) — For — by proxy Isabelle Rauch (LAREM) — For — by proxy Rémy Rebeyrotte (LAREM) — For Hugues Renson (LAREM) — For Cécile Rilhac (LAREM) — For Véronique Riotton (LAREM) — For — by proxy Stéphanie Rist (LAREM) — For Marie-Pierre Rixain (LAREM) — For Mireille Robert (LAREM) — For — by proxy Laëtitia Romeiro Dias (LAREM) — For Xavier Roseren (LAREM) — For Laurianne Rossi (LAREM) — For Gwendal Rouillard (LAREM) — For Cédric Roussel (LAREM) — For — by proxy Thomas Rudigoz (LAREM) — For Pacôme Rupin (LAREM) — For Laurent Saint-Martin (LAREM) — For — by proxy Laetitia Saint-Paul (LAREM) — For Nathalie Sarles (LAREM) — For Jacques Savatier (LAREM) — For Jean-Bernard Sempastous (LAREM) — For Olivier Serva (LAREM) — For — by proxy Benoit Simian (LAREM) — For — by proxy Thierry Solère (LAREM) — For — by proxy Denis Sommer (LAREM) — For Joachim Son-Forget (LAREM) — For Bertrand Sorre (LAREM) — For Bruno Studer (LAREM) — For Sira Sylla (LAREM) — For Aurélien Taché (LAREM) — For — by proxy Marie Tamarelle-Verhaeghe (LAREM) — For Buon Tan (LAREM) — For Liliana Tanguy (LAREM) — For — by proxy Adrien Taquet (LAREM) — For Jean Terlier (LAREM) — For Stéphane Testé (LAREM) — For Agnès Thill (LAREM) — For Sabine Thillaye (LAREM) — For Vincent Thiébaut (LAREM) — For Valérie Thomas (LAREM) — For — by proxy Alice Thourot (LAREM) — For — by proxy Huguette Tiegna (LAREM) — For Jean-Louis Touraine (LAREM) — For Alain Tourret (LAREM) — For Élisabeth Toutut-Picard (LAREM) — For Nicole Trisse (LAREM) — For Stéphane Trompille (LAREM) — For Frédérique Tuffnell (LAREM) — For Alexandra Valetta Ardisson (LAREM) — Absent Manuel Valls (LAREM) — For — by proxy Laurence Vanceunebrock (LAREM) — For Marie-Christine Verdier-Jouclas (LAREM) — For Annie Vidal (LAREM) — For Patrick Vignal (LAREM) — For Corinne Vignon (LAREM) — For Cédric Villani (LAREM) — For Guillaume Vuilletet (LAREM) — For Olivier Véran (LAREM) — For Martine Wonner (LAREM) — For Hélène Zannier (LAREM) — For — by proxy Jean-Marc Zulesi (LAREM) — For Yolaine de Courson (LAREM) — For Célia de Lavergne (LAREM) — For Amélie de Montchalin (LAREM) — For François de Rugy (LAREM) — Non-voting Sophie Auconie (UDI-AGIR) — For Olivier Becht (UDI-AGIR) — For Thierry Benoit (UDI-AGIR) — For Pierre-Yves Bournazel (UDI-AGIR) — For Guy Bricout (UDI-AGIR) — For Paul Christophe (UDI-AGIR) — For Stéphane Demilly (UDI-AGIR) — For Béatrice Descamps (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Philippe Dunoyer (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Yannick Favennec-Bécot (UDI-AGIR) — For Agnès Firmin Le Bodo (UDI-AGIR) — For Philippe Gomès (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Meyer Habib (UDI-AGIR) — For Antoine Herth (UDI-AGIR) — For Yves Jégo (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Jean-Christophe Lagarde (UDI-AGIR) — For Vincent Ledoux (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Maurice Leroy (UDI-AGIR) — For Lise Magnier (UDI-AGIR) — For Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier (UDI-AGIR) — For Christophe Naegelen (UDI-AGIR) — For Bertrand Pancher (UDI-AGIR) — For Franck Riester (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Maina Sage (UDI-AGIR) — Abstention Nicole Sanquer (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Francis Vercamer (UDI-AGIR) — For Philippe Vigier (UDI-AGIR) — For André Villiers (UDI-AGIR) — For Jean-Luc Warsmann (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Michel Zumkeller (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Charles de Courson (UDI-AGIR) — For — by proxy Laure de La Raudière (UDI-AGIR) — For Damien Abad (LR) — Abstention Emmanuelle Anthoine (LR) — Abstention Julien Aubert (LR) — Abstention Nathalie Bassire (LR) — Abstention Thibault Bazin (LR) — Abstention Valérie Bazin-Malgras (LR) — Abstention Valérie Beauvais (LR) — Abstention Émilie Bonnivard (LR) — Abstention Jean-Yves Bony (LR) — Abstention Ian Boucard (LR) — Abstention Jean-Claude Bouchet (LR) — Abstention Valérie Boyer (LR) — Abstention Marine Brenier (LR) — Abstention (vote correction) Xavier Breton (LR) — Abstention Bernard Brochand (LR) — Abstention Fabrice Brun (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Gilles Carrez (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Jacques Cattin (LR) — Abstention Gérard Cherpion (LR) — Abstention Dino Cinieri (LR) — Abstention Éric Ciotti (LR) — Abstention Pierre Cordier (LR) — Abstention Josiane Corneloup (LR) — Abstention François Cornut-Gentille (LR) — Abstention Marie-Christine Dalloz (LR) — Abstention Olivier Dassault (LR) — Absent Bernard Deflesselles (LR) — Abstention Rémi Delatte (LR) — For Vincent Descoeur (LR) — Abstention Fabien Di Filippo (LR) — Abstention Éric Diard (LR) — Abstention Julien Dive (LR) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Door (LR) — Abstention Marianne Dubois (LR) — Abstention Virginie Duby-Muller (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Pierre-Henri Dumont (LR) — Abstention Daniel Fasquelle (LR) — Abstention Jean-Jacques Ferrara (LR) — Abstention Nicolas Forissier (LR) — Abstention Laurent Furst (LR) — Abstention Jean-Jacques Gaultier (LR) — Abstention Annie Genevard (LR) — Abstention Claude Goasguen (LR) — Abstention Philippe Gosselin (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-Carles Grelier (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Claire Guion-Firmin (LR) — Abstention Michel Herbillon (LR) — Abstention Patrick Hetzel (LR) — Abstention Sébastien Huyghe (LR) — Abstention Christian Jacob (LR) — Abstention Mansour Kamardine (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Brigitte Kuster (LR) — Abstention Valérie Lacroute (LR) — Abstention Guillaume Larrivé (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Marc Le Fur (LR) — Abstention Constance Le Grip (LR) — Abstention Sébastien Leclerc (LR) — Abstention Geneviève Levy (LR) — Abstention David Lorion (LR) — Abstention Véronique Louwagie (LR) — Abstention Gilles Lurton (LR) — Abstention Emmanuel Maquet (LR) — Abstention Olivier Marleix (LR) — Abstention Franck Marlin (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-Louis Masson (LR) — Abstention Gérard Menuel (LR) — Abstention Frédérique Meunier (LR) — Abstention Maxime Minot (LR) — Abstention Jérôme Nury (LR) — Abstention Jean-François Parigi (LR) — Abstention Éric Pauget (LR) — Abstention Guillaume Peltier (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Bernard Perrut (LR) — Abstention Bérengère Poletti (LR) — Abstention Aurélien Pradié (LR) — Absent Didier Quentin (LR) — Abstention Alain Ramadier (LR) — Abstention Nadia Ramassamy (LR) — Abstention Robin Reda (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Frédéric Reiss (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-Luc Reitzer (LR) — Abstention Bernard Reynès (LR) — Abstention Vincent Rolland (LR) — Abstention Martial Saddier (LR) — Abstention Antoine Savignat (LR) — Abstention Raphaël Schellenberger (LR) — Abstention Jean-Marie Sermier (LR) — Abstention Éric Straumann (LR) — Abstention Michèle Tabarot (LR) — Abstention Jean-Charles Taugourdeau (LR) — Abstention Guy Teissier (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Laurence Trastour-Isnart (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Isabelle Valentin (LR) — Abstention Pierre Vatin (LR) — Abstention Patrice Verchère (LR) — Abstention Arnaud Viala (LR) — For Michel Vialay (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Jean-Pierre Vigier (LR) — Abstention Stéphane Viry (LR) — Abstention — by proxy Éric Woerth (LR) — Abstention Claude de Ganay (LR) — Abstention Charles de la Verpillière (LR) — Abstention Jean-Félix Acquaviva (NI) — Abstention Louis Aliot (NI) — Abstention Bruno Bilde (NI) — Abstention Michel Castellani (NI) — Abstention — by proxy Sébastien Chenu (NI) — Abstention Gilbert Collard (NI) — Absent Paul-André Colombani (NI) — Abstention Jeanine Dubié (NI) — For Nicolas Dupont-Aignan (NI) — Against M'jid El Guerrab (NI) — For José Evrard (NI) — Against Olivier Falorni (NI) — For Jean Lassalle (NI) — Against Marine Le Pen (NI) — Abstention Marie-France Lorho (NI) — Absent Emmanuelle Ménard (NI) — Absent Ludovic Pajot (NI) — Abstention Sylvia Pinel (NI) — For

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
FI 0170 0017
GDR 0160 0016
NG 0031 0031
MODEM 4600 0147
LAREM 30701 13312
UDI-AGIR 3101 0032
LR 2098 02102
NI 438 0318

All deputies

DeputyGroupVote
Damien Abad LR Abstention
Caroline Abadie LAREM For
Bérangère Abba LAREM For
Jean-Félix Acquaviva NI Abstention
Damien Adam LAREM For
Lénaïck Adam LAREM For by proxy
Saïd Ahamada LAREM For
Éric Alauzet LAREM Absent
Ramlati Ali LAREM For by proxy
Louis Aliot NI Abstention
Aude Amadou LAREM For by proxy
Patrice Anato LAREM For
François André LAREM For
Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade LAREM For
Emmanuelle Anthoine LR Abstention
Jean-Philippe Ardouin LAREM For
Christophe Arend LAREM For
Gabriel Attal LAREM For
Julien Aubert LR Abstention
Sophie Auconie UDI-AGIR For
Clémentine Autain FI Against
Laetitia Avia LAREM For
Joël Aviragnet NG Abstention
Bruno Nestor Azerot GDR Against by proxy
Florian Bachelier LAREM For
Delphine Bagarry LAREM For
Didier Baichère LAREM For
Erwan Balanant MODEM For
Géraldine Bannier MODEM For
Frédéric Barbier LAREM For
Ericka Bareigts NG Abstention
Jean-Noël Barrot MODEM For by proxy
Nathalie Bassire LR Abstention
Delphine Batho NG Abstention by proxy
Marie-Noëlle Battistel NG Abstention by proxy
Xavier Batut LAREM For
Thibault Bazin LR Abstention
Valérie Bazin-Malgras LR Abstention
Sophie Beaudouin-Hubiere LAREM For
Valérie Beauvais LR Abstention
Olivier Becht UDI-AGIR For
Belkhir Belhaddad LAREM For
Huguette Bello GDR Against by proxy
Justine Benin MODEM For by proxy
Thierry Benoit UDI-AGIR For
Aurore Bergé LAREM For
Ugo Bernalicis FI Against
Philippe Berta MODEM For
Hervé Berville LAREM For
Grégory Besson-Moreau LAREM For by proxy
Barbara Bessot Ballot LAREM For
Gisèle Biémouret NG Abstention
Bruno Bilde NI Abstention
Anne Blanc LAREM For by proxy
Christophe Blanchet LAREM For
Yves Blein LAREM For
Pascal Bois LAREM For
Philippe Bolo MODEM For
Bruno Bonnell LAREM For
Émilie Bonnivard LR Abstention
Aude Bono-Vandorme LAREM For
Jean-Yves Bony LR Abstention
Julien Borowczyk LAREM For
Éric Bothorel LAREM For
Ian Boucard LR Abstention
Jean-Claude Bouchet LR Abstention
Florent Boudié LAREM For
Christophe Bouillon NG Abstention
Brigitte Bourguignon LAREM For
Jean-Louis Bourlanges MODEM For
Pierre-Yves Bournazel UDI-AGIR For
Bertrand Bouyx LAREM For
Pascale Boyer LAREM For
Valérie Boyer LR Abstention
Yaël Braun-Pivet LAREM For
Marine Brenier LR Abstention corrected (originally: against)
Xavier Breton LR Abstention
Guy Bricout UDI-AGIR For
Jean-Louis Bricout NG Abstention
Jean-Jacques Bridey LAREM For
Blandine Brocard LAREM For
Bernard Brochand LR Abstention
Moetai Brotherson GDR Against by proxy
Vincent Bru MODEM For by proxy
Anne Brugnera LAREM For
Danielle Brulebois LAREM For
Fabrice Brun LR Abstention by proxy
Alain Bruneel GDR Against by proxy
Anne-France Brunet LAREM For
Stéphane Buchou LAREM For
Marie-George Buffet GDR Against by proxy
Carole Bureau-Bonnard LAREM For
Pierre Cabaré LAREM For
Céline Calvez LAREM For
Émilie Cariou LAREM For
Gilles Carrez LR Abstention by proxy
Luc Carvounas NG Abstention
Michel Castellani NI Abstention by proxy
Anne-Laure Cattelot LAREM For
Jacques Cattin LR Abstention
Lionel Causse LAREM For
Danièle Cazarian LAREM For
Jean-René Cazeneuve LAREM For
Sébastien Cazenove LAREM For
Anthony Cellier LAREM For
Jean-François Cesarini LAREM For by proxy
Émilie Chalas LAREM For
Philippe Chalumeau LAREM For
Annie Chapelier LAREM For
Sylvie Charrière LAREM For
Fannette Charvier LAREM For
André Chassaigne GDR Against
Philippe Chassaing LAREM For
Sébastien Chenu NI Abstention
Gérard Cherpion LR Abstention
Guillaume Chiche LAREM For
Paul Christophe UDI-AGIR For
Dino Cinieri LR Abstention
Éric Ciotti LR Abstention
Stéphane Claireaux LAREM For by proxy
Mireille Clapot LAREM For
Jean-Michel Clément LAREM For by proxy
Jean-Charles Colas-Roy LAREM For
Fabienne Colboc LAREM For
Gilbert Collard NI Absent
Claire Colomb-Pitollat LAREM For
Paul-André Colombani NI Abstention
Éric Coquerel FI Against
Alexis Corbière FI Against
Pierre Cordier LR Abstention
François Cormier-Bouligeon LAREM For
Josiane Corneloup LR Abstention
François Cornut-Gentille LR Abstention
Bérangère Couillard LAREM For by proxy
Michèle Crouzet LAREM For corrected (originally: absent)
Jean-Pierre Cubertafon MODEM For
Dominique Da Silva LAREM For
Marie-Christine Dalloz LR Abstention
Olivier Damaisin LAREM For
Yves Daniel LAREM For
Olivier Dassault LR Absent
Alain David NG Abstention
Dominique David LAREM For
Charles de Courson UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Yolaine de Courson LAREM For
Claude de Ganay LR Abstention
Laure de La Raudière UDI-AGIR For
Charles de la Verpillière LR Abstention
Célia de Lavergne LAREM For
Amélie de Montchalin LAREM For
François de Rugy LAREM Non-voting
Marielle de Sarnez MODEM For
Jennifer De Temmerman LAREM For by proxy
Michèle de Vaucouleurs MODEM For
Bernard Deflesselles LR Abstention
Typhanie Degois LAREM For
Marc Delatte LAREM For
Rémi Delatte LR For
Michel Delpon LAREM For
Stéphane Demilly UDI-AGIR For
Nicolas Démoulin LAREM For
Marguerite Deprez-Audebert MODEM For by proxy
Béatrice Descamps UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Vincent Descoeur LR Abstention
Frédéric Descrozaille LAREM For by proxy
Pierre Dharréville GDR Against
Fabien Di Filippo LR Abstention
Christophe Di Pompeo LAREM For
Éric Diard LR Abstention
Benjamin Dirx LAREM For by proxy
Julien Dive LR Abstention
Jean-Baptiste Djebbari LAREM For
Stéphanie Do LAREM For
Loïc Dombreval LAREM For by proxy
Jean-Pierre Door LR Abstention
Jeanine Dubié NI For
Jacqueline Dubois LAREM For by proxy
Marianne Dubois LR Abstention
Christelle Dubos LAREM For
Coralie Dubost LAREM For by proxy
Nicole Dubré-Chirat LAREM For
Virginie Duby-Muller LR Abstention by proxy
Audrey Dufeu LAREM For
Jean-Paul Dufrègne GDR Against
Françoise Dumas LAREM For
Frédérique Dumas LAREM For by proxy
Laurence Dumont NG Abstention by proxy
Pierre-Henri Dumont LR Abstention
Philippe Dunoyer UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Stella Dupont LAREM For
Nicolas Dupont-Aignan NI Against
Bruno Duvergé MODEM For
M'jid El Guerrab NI For
Sarah El Haïry MODEM For
Jean-François Eliaou LAREM For
Nathalie Elimas MODEM For
Sophie Errante LAREM For by proxy
Nadia Essayan MODEM For by proxy
Christophe Euzet LAREM For by proxy
José Evrard NI Against
Catherine Fabre LAREM For
Élise Fajgeles LAREM For
Olivier Falorni NI For
Michel Fanget MODEM For by proxy
Daniel Fasquelle LR Abstention
Elsa Faucillon GDR Against
Olivier Faure NG Abstention by proxy
Valéria Faure-Muntian LAREM For by proxy
Jean-Michel Fauvergue LAREM For by proxy
Yannick Favennec-Bécot UDI-AGIR For
Richard Ferrand LAREM For
Jean-Jacques Ferrara LR Abstention
Marc Fesneau MODEM For
Caroline Fiat FI Against
Jean-Marie Fiévet LAREM For
Agnès Firmin Le Bodo UDI-AGIR For
Isabelle Florennes MODEM For
Philippe Folliot LAREM For
Emmanuelle Fontaine-Domeizel LAREM Absent
Pascale Fontenel-Personne LAREM For
Nicolas Forissier LR Abstention
Paula Forteza LAREM For by proxy
Alexandre Freschi LAREM For
Bruno Fuchs MODEM For
Jean-Luc Fugit LAREM For
Laurent Furst LR Abstention
Olivier Gaillard LAREM For
Albane Gaillot LAREM For
Grégory Galbadon LAREM For by proxy
Patricia Gallerneau MODEM For
Laurent Garcia MODEM For by proxy
Guillaume Garot NG Abstention
Thomas Gassilloud LAREM For
Jean-Jacques Gaultier LR Abstention
Raphaël Gauvain LAREM For by proxy
Laurence Gayte LAREM For by proxy
Anne Genetet LAREM For
Annie Genevard LR Abstention
Raphaël Gérard LAREM For
Séverine Gipson LAREM For
Éric Girardin LAREM For
Joël Giraud LAREM For
Olga Givernet LAREM For
Claude Goasguen LR Abstention
Philippe Gomès UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Valérie Gomez-Bassac LAREM For
Philippe Gosselin LR Abstention by proxy
Guillaume Gouffier Valente LAREM For
Perrine Goulet LAREM For
Fabien Gouttefarde LAREM For by proxy
Carole Grandjean LAREM For
Florence Granjus LAREM For
Romain Grau LAREM For
Olivia Grégoire LAREM For
Jean-Carles Grelier LR Abstention by proxy
Émilie Guerel LAREM For
Stanislas Guerini LAREM For
Marie Guévenoux LAREM For
Claire Guion-Firmin LR Abstention
David Habib NG Abstention
Meyer Habib UDI-AGIR For
Nadia Hai LAREM For by proxy
Véronique Hammerer LAREM For
Brahim Hammouche MODEM For
Yannick Haury LAREM For by proxy
Christine Hennion LAREM For
Pierre Henriet LAREM For
Michel Herbillon LR Abstention
Danièle Hérin LAREM For
Antoine Herth UDI-AGIR For
Patrick Hetzel LR Abstention
Alexandre Holroyd LAREM For
Dimitri Houbron LAREM For
Sacha Houlié LAREM For
Philippe Huppé LAREM For
Christian Hutin NG Abstention by proxy
Sébastien Huyghe LR Abstention
Monique Iborra LAREM For by proxy
Cyrille Isaac-Sibille MODEM For
Christian Jacob LR Abstention
Jean-Michel Jacques LAREM For
Élodie Jacquier-Laforge MODEM For
Caroline Janvier LAREM For
Yves Jégo UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Christophe Jerretie LAREM For by proxy
François Jolivet LAREM For
Bruno Joncour MODEM For
Sandrine Josso LAREM For
Régis Juanico NG Abstention
Hubert Julien-Laferrière LAREM For
Sébastien Jumel GDR Against
Mansour Kamardine LR Abstention by proxy
Catherine Kamowski LAREM For
Marietta Karamanli NG Abstention
Guillaume Kasbarian LAREM For
Stéphanie Kerbarh LAREM For by proxy
Yannick Kerlogot LAREM For
Loïc Kervran LAREM For
Fadila Khattabi LAREM For
Anissa Khedher LAREM For
Rodrigue Kokouendo LAREM For
Jacques Krabal LAREM For
Sonia Krimi LAREM For
Aina Kuric LAREM For
Brigitte Kuster LR Abstention
Mustapha Laabid LAREM For
Daniel Labaronne LAREM For
Bastien Lachaud FI Against
Valérie Lacroute LR Abstention
Jean-Christophe Lagarde UDI-AGIR For
Jean-Luc Lagleize MODEM For by proxy
Fabien Lainé MODEM For
Amélia Lakrafi LAREM For by proxy
François-Michel Lambert LAREM For by proxy
Jérôme Lambert NG Abstention
Anne-Christine Lang LAREM For
Mohamed Laqhila MODEM For
Frédérique Lardet LAREM For
Michel Larive FI Against by proxy
Guillaume Larrivé LR Abstention by proxy
Jean-Charles Larsonneur LAREM For by proxy
Jean Lassalle NI Against
Florence Lasserre MODEM For
Philippe Latombe MODEM For
Michel Lauzzana LAREM For
Fiona Lazaar LAREM For
Gaël Le Bohec LAREM For
Sandrine Le Feur LAREM For
Stéphane Le Foll NG Abstention
Marc Le Fur LR Abstention
Didier Le Gac LAREM For
Gilles Le Gendre LAREM For
Constance Le Grip LR Abstention
Annaïg Le Meur LAREM For by proxy
Christine Le Nabour LAREM For by proxy
Nicole Le Peih LAREM For
Marine Le Pen NI Abstention
Fabrice Le Vigoureux LAREM For
Marie Lebec LAREM For
Jean-Claude Leclabart LAREM For
Sébastien Leclerc LR Abstention
Jean-Paul Lecoq GDR Against by proxy
Vincent Ledoux UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Martine Leguille-Balloy LAREM For
Christophe Lejeune LAREM For
Marion Lenne LAREM For
Maurice Leroy UDI-AGIR For
Roland Lescure LAREM For
Serge Letchimy NG Abstention by proxy
Geneviève Levy LR Abstention
Monique Limon LAREM For
Richard Lioger LAREM For
Brigitte Liso LAREM For
Marie-France Lorho NI Absent
David Lorion LR Abstention
Alexandra Louis LAREM For by proxy
Véronique Louwagie LR Abstention
Aude Luquet MODEM For
Gilles Lurton LR Abstention
Marie-Ange Magne LAREM For
Lise Magnier UDI-AGIR For
Sylvain Maillard LAREM For
Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie LAREM For by proxy
Jacques Maire LAREM For
Josette Manin NG Abstention corrected (originally: absent)
Emmanuel Maquet LR Abstention
Jacqueline Maquet LAREM For
Jacques Marilossian LAREM For
Olivier Marleix LR Abstention
Franck Marlin LR Abstention by proxy
Sandra Marsaud LAREM For
Didier Martin LAREM For
Denis Masséglia LAREM Abstention
Jean-Louis Masson LR Abstention
Max Mathiasin MODEM For
Fabien Matras LAREM For
Jean-Paul Mattei MODEM For by proxy
Sereine Mauborgne LAREM For
Stéphane Mazars LAREM For
Jean François Mbaye LAREM For
Graziella Melchior LAREM For by proxy
Jean-Luc Mélenchon FI Against
Emmanuelle Ménard NI Absent
Ludovic Mendes LAREM For by proxy
Gérard Menuel LR Abstention
Thomas Mesnier LAREM For
Sophie Mette MODEM For
Frédérique Meunier LR Abstention
Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert LAREM For
Monica Michel-Brassart LAREM For by proxy
Philippe Michel-Kleisbauer MODEM For
Thierry Michels LAREM For
Patrick Mignola MODEM For
Bruno Millienne MODEM For
Maxime Minot LR Abstention
Patricia Mirallès LAREM For
Jean-Michel Mis LAREM For
Paul Molac LAREM For
Sandrine Mörch LAREM For
Jean-Baptiste Moreau LAREM For
Pierre Morel-À-L'Huissier UDI-AGIR For
Adrien Morenas LAREM For
Cendra Motin LAREM For
Naïma Moutchou LAREM For
Cécile Muschotti LAREM For
Sébastien Nadot LAREM For by proxy
Christophe Naegelen UDI-AGIR For
Jean-Philippe Nilor GDR Against
Mickaël Nogal LAREM For
Jérôme Nury LR Abstention
Delphine O LAREM For by proxy
Claire O'Petit LAREM For
Danièle Obono FI Against by proxy
Valérie Oppelt LAREM For
Matthieu Orphelin LAREM For
Catherine Osson LAREM For
Jimmy Pahun MODEM For
Ludovic Pajot NI Abstention
Xavier Paluszkiewicz LAREM For
Bertrand Pancher UDI-AGIR For
Sophie Panonacle LAREM For
Mathilde Panot FI Against
Jean-François Parigi LR Abstention
Didier Paris LAREM For
Zivka Park LAREM For
Charlotte Parmentier-Lecocq LAREM For
George Pau-Langevin NG Abstention by proxy
Éric Pauget LR Abstention
Hervé Pellois LAREM For
Guillaume Peltier LR Abstention by proxy
Alain Perea LAREM For by proxy
Patrice Perrot LAREM For by proxy
Bernard Perrut LR Abstention
Pierre Person LAREM For
Anne-Laurence Petel LAREM For
Frédéric Petit MODEM For
Maud Petit MODEM For
Valérie Petit LAREM For
Stéphane Peu GDR Against
Bénédicte Peyrol LAREM For
Michèle Peyron LAREM For
Damien Pichereau LAREM For
Laurent Pietraszewski LAREM For
Sylvia Pinel NI For
Christine Pirès Beaune NG Abstention
Béatrice Piron LAREM For
Bérengère Poletti LR Abstention
Barbara Pompili LAREM For
Jean-Pierre Pont LAREM For
Jean-François Portarrieu LAREM For
Dominique Potier NG Abstention
Benoit Potterie LAREM For
Josy Poueyto MODEM For
Éric Poulliat LAREM For by proxy
Natalia Pouzyreff LAREM For
Aurélien Pradié LR Absent
Loïc Prud'homme FI Against by proxy
Joaquim Pueyo NG Abstention
François Pupponi NG Abstention
Adrien Quatennens FI Against
Didier Quentin LR Abstention
Bruno Questel LAREM For
Valérie Rabault NG Abstention by proxy
Cathy Racon-Bouzon LAREM For
Alain Ramadier LR Abstention
Nadia Ramassamy LR Abstention
Richard Ramos MODEM For
Pierre-Alain Raphan LAREM For by proxy
Jean-Hugues Ratenon FI Against by proxy
Isabelle Rauch LAREM For by proxy
Rémy Rebeyrotte LAREM For
Robin Reda LR Abstention by proxy
Frédéric Reiss LR Abstention by proxy
Jean-Luc Reitzer LR Abstention
Hugues Renson LAREM For
Muriel Ressiguier FI Against
Bernard Reynès LR Abstention
Franck Riester UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Cécile Rilhac LAREM For
Véronique Riotton LAREM For by proxy
Stéphanie Rist LAREM For
Marie-Pierre Rixain LAREM For
Mireille Robert LAREM For by proxy
Thierry Robert MODEM For
Vincent Rolland LR Abstention
Laëtitia Romeiro Dias LAREM For
Xavier Roseren LAREM For
Laurianne Rossi LAREM For
Gwendal Rouillard LAREM For
Cédric Roussel LAREM For by proxy
Fabien Roussel GDR Against
Sabine Rubin FI Against
Thomas Rudigoz LAREM For
François Ruffin FI Against
Pacôme Rupin LAREM For
Martial Saddier LR Abstention
Maina Sage UDI-AGIR Abstention
Laurent Saint-Martin LAREM For by proxy
Laetitia Saint-Paul LAREM For
Nicole Sanquer UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Nathalie Sarles LAREM For
Hervé Saulignac NG Abstention
Jacques Savatier LAREM For
Antoine Savignat LR Abstention
Raphaël Schellenberger LR Abstention
Jean-Bernard Sempastous LAREM For
Jean-Marie Sermier LR Abstention
Olivier Serva LAREM For by proxy
Gabriel Serville GDR Against by proxy
Benoit Simian LAREM For by proxy
Thierry Solère LAREM For by proxy
Denis Sommer LAREM For
Joachim Son-Forget LAREM For
Bertrand Sorre LAREM For
Éric Straumann LR Abstention
Bruno Studer LAREM For
Sira Sylla LAREM For
Michèle Tabarot LR Abstention
Aurélien Taché LAREM For by proxy
Marie Tamarelle-Verhaeghe LAREM For
Buon Tan LAREM For
Liliana Tanguy LAREM For by proxy
Adrien Taquet LAREM For
Jean-Charles Taugourdeau LR Abstention
Bénédicte Taurine FI Against
Guy Teissier LR Abstention by proxy
Jean Terlier LAREM For
Stéphane Testé LAREM For
Vincent Thiébaut LAREM For
Agnès Thill LAREM For
Sabine Thillaye LAREM For
Valérie Thomas LAREM For by proxy
Alice Thourot LAREM For by proxy
Huguette Tiegna LAREM For
Jean-Louis Touraine LAREM For
Alain Tourret LAREM For
Élisabeth Toutut-Picard LAREM For
Laurence Trastour-Isnart LR Abstention by proxy
Nicole Trisse LAREM For
Stéphane Trompille LAREM For
Frédérique Tuffnell LAREM For
Nicolas Turquois MODEM Absent
Cécile Untermaier NG Abstention
Hélène Vainqueur-Christophe NG Abstention by proxy
Isabelle Valentin LR Abstention
Alexandra Valetta Ardisson LAREM Absent
Boris Vallaud NG Abstention
Manuel Valls LAREM For by proxy
Laurence Vanceunebrock LAREM For
Pierre Vatin LR Abstention
Olivier Véran LAREM For
Francis Vercamer UDI-AGIR For
Patrice Verchère LR Abstention
Marie-Christine Verdier-Jouclas LAREM For
Arnaud Viala LR For
Michel Vialay LR Abstention by proxy
Laurence Vichnievsky MODEM For by proxy
Michèle Victory NG Abstention
Annie Vidal LAREM For
Jean-Pierre Vigier LR Abstention
Philippe Vigier UDI-AGIR For
Patrick Vignal LAREM For
Corinne Vignon LAREM For
Cédric Villani LAREM For
André Villiers UDI-AGIR For
Stéphane Viry LR Abstention by proxy
Guillaume Vuilletet LAREM For
Jean-Luc Warsmann UDI-AGIR For by proxy
Sylvain Waserman MODEM For
Éric Woerth LR Abstention
Martine Wonner LAREM For
Hubert Wulfranc GDR Against
Hélène Zannier LAREM For by proxy
Jean-Marc Zulesi LAREM For
Michel Zumkeller UDI-AGIR For by proxy