Larticle 9 constituant lensemble du projet de loi relative aux résultats de la gestion et portant approbation des comptes de l'année 2023
- Type of vote
- Roll-call vote
- Voters
- 343
- 4 non-voting
- Votes cast
- 202
- for + against (excluding abstentions)
- Majority required
- 102 votes
- to be adopted
19 for 183 against 141 abstentions ▏threshold : 102 votes
In the Senate, “absent” means “did not take part in the vote”: a senator absent from the chamber may have had a colleague vote for them by proxy, which counts as a vote.
Colour by:
- For 19
- Against 183
- Abstention 141
- Non-voting 1
- Absent 3
- CRC 18
- GEST 16
- SOC 64
- RDSE 16
- RTLI 19
- LREM 20
- UC 60
- UMP 130
- NI 4
By group
| Group | For | Against | Abst. | Non-voting | Absent | Total | Breakdown |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CRC | 0 | 18 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 18 | |
| GEST | 0 | 16 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 16 | |
| SOC | 0 | 0 | 64 | 0 | 0 | 64 | |
| RDSE | 0 | 14 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 16 | |
| RTLI | 0 | 0 | 18 | 0 | 1 | 19 | |
| LREM | 19 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 20 | |
| UC | 0 | 2 | 58 | 0 | 0 | 60 | |
| UMP | 0 | 129 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 130 | |
| NI | 0 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 4 |
All senators
| Senator | Group | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Marie-Do Aeschlimann | UMP | Against |
| Pascal Allizard | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Claude Anglars | UMP | Against |
| Jocelyne Antoine | UC | Abstention |
| Cathy Apourceau-Poly | CRC | Against |
| Jean-Michel Arnaud | UC | Abstention |
| Viviane Artigalas | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Jérémy Bacchi | CRC | Against |
| Jean Bacci | UMP | Against |
| Pierre Barros | CRC | Against |
| Philippe Bas | UMP | Against |
| Arnaud Bazin | UMP | Against |
| Audrey Bélim | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Bruno Belin | UMP | Against |
| Marie-Jeanne Bellamy | UMP | Against |
| Nadine Bellurot | UMP | Against |
| Catherine Belrhiti | UMP | Against |
| Guy Benarroche | GEST | Against |
| Martine Berthet | UMP | Against |
| Christian Bilhac | RDSE | Against |
| Annick Billon | UC | Abstention |
| Olivier Bitz | UC | Abstention |
| Étienne Blanc | UMP | Against |
| Grégory Blanc | GEST | Against |
| Jean-Baptiste Blanc | UMP | Against |
| Florence Blatrix Contat | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Yves Bleunven | UC | Abstention |
| Éric Bocquet | CRC | Against |
| Christine Bonfanti-Dossat | UMP | Against |
| François Bonhomme | UMP | Against |
| François Bonneau | UC | Abstention |
| Nicole Bonnefoy | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Michel Bonnus | UMP | Against |
| Alexandra Borchio Fontimp | UMP | Against |
| Denis Bouad | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Gilbert Bouchet | UMP | Against |
| Corinne Bourcier | RTLI | Abstention |
| Hussein Bourgi | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Jean-Marc Boyer | UMP | Against |
| Valérie Boyer | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Luc Brault | RTLI | Abstention |
| Sophie Briante Guillemont | RDSE | Against |
| Isabelle Briquet | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Max Brisson | UMP | Against |
| Ian Brossat | CRC | Against |
| Colombe Brossel | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Céline Brulin | CRC | Against |
| Christian Bruyen | UMP | Against |
| Bernard Buis | LREM | For |
| Laurent Burgoa | UMP | Against |
| Frédéric Buval | LREM | For |
| Henri Cabanel | RDSE | Against |
| Alain Cadec | UMP | Against |
| Olivier Cadic | UC | Abstention |
| Guislain Cambier | UC | Abstention |
| Christian Cambon | UMP | Against |
| Marion Canalès | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Michel Canévet | UC | Abstention |
| Vincent Capo-Canellas | UC | Abstention |
| Emmanuel Capus | RTLI | Abstention |
| Rémi Cardon | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Marie-Arlette Carlotti | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Maryse Carrère | RDSE | Against |
| Alain Cazabonne | UC | Abstention |
| Samantha Cazebonne | LREM | For |
| Christophe Chaillou | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Anne Chain-Larché | UMP | Against |
| Patrick Chaize | UMP | Against |
| Yan Chantrel | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Daniel Chasseing | RTLI | Abstention |
| Alain Chatillon | UMP | Against |
| Patrick Chauvet | UC | Abstention |
| Cédric Chevalier | RTLI | Abstention |
| Guillaume Chevrollier | UMP | Against |
| Olivier Cigolotti | UC | Abstention |
| Marie-Carole Ciuntu | UMP | Against |
| Catherine Conconne | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Mireille Conte Jaubert | RDSE | Absent |
| Hélène Conway-Mouret | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Evelyne Corbière Naminzo | CRC | Against |
| Jean-Pierre Corbisez | CRC | Against |
| Édouard Courtial | UC | Abstention |
| Thierry Cozic | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Cécile Cukierman | CRC | Against |
| Pierre Cuypers | UMP | Against |
| Karine Daniel | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Ronan Dantec | GEST | Against |
| Laure Darcos | RTLI | Abstention |
| Mathieu Darnaud | UMP | Against |
| Jérôme Darras | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Raphaël Daubet | RDSE | Against |
| Marc-Philippe Daubresse | UMP | Against |
| Marta de Cidrac | UMP | Against |
| Marie-Pierre de La Gontrie | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Sonia de La Provôté | UC | Abstention |
| Dominique de Legge | UMP | Against |
| Monique de Marco | GEST | Against |
| Albéric de Montgolfier | UMP | Against |
| Louis-Jean de Nicolaÿ | UMP | Against |
| Vincent Delahaye | UC | Against |
| Bernard Delcros | UC | Abstention |
| Patricia Demas | UMP | Against |
| Stéphane Demilly | UC | Abstention |
| Chantal Deseyne | UMP | Against |
| Brigitte Devésa | UC | Against |
| Gilbert-Luc Devinaz | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Franck Dhersin | UC | Abstention |
| Catherine Di Folco | UMP | Against |
| Élisabeth Doineau | UC | Abstention |
| Thomas Dossus | GEST | Against |
| Sabine Drexler | UMP | Against |
| Alain Duffourg | UC | Abstention |
| Catherine Dumas | UMP | Against |
| Françoise Dumont | UMP | Against |
| Éric Dumoulin | UMP | Against |
| Laurent Duplomb | UMP | Against |
| Jérôme Durain | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Nicole Duranton | LREM | For |
| Aymeric Durox | NI | Against |
| Vincent Éblé | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Frédérique Espagnac | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Dominique Estrosi Sassone | UMP | Against |
| Jacqueline Eustache-Brinio | UMP | Against |
| Agnès Evren | UMP | Against |
| Sébastien Fagnen | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Daniel Fargeot | UC | Abstention |
| Gilbert Favreau | UMP | Against |
| Rémi Féraud | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Corinne Féret | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Jacques Fernique | GEST | Against |
| Bernard Fialaire | RDSE | Against |
| Jean-Luc Fichet | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Isabelle Florennes | UC | Abstention |
| Philippe Folliot | UC | Abstention |
| Stéphane Fouassin | LREM | For |
| Christophe-André Frassa | UMP | Against |
| Amel Gacquerre | UC | Abstention |
| Fabien Gay | CRC | Against |
| Fabien Genet | UMP | Against |
| Frédérique Gerbaud | UMP | Against |
| Hervé Gillé | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Éric Gold | RDSE | Against |
| Guillaume Gontard | GEST | Against |
| Béatrice Gosselin | UMP | Against |
| Nathalie Goulet | UC | Abstention |
| Sylvie Goy-Chavent | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Pierre Grand | RTLI | Abstention |
| Michelle Gréaume | CRC | Against |
| Daniel Gremillet | UMP | Against |
| Jacques Grosperrin | UMP | Against |
| Philippe Grosvalet | RDSE | Against |
| Pascale Gruny | UMP | Against |
| Daniel Gueret | UMP | Against |
| Joël Guerriau | RTLI | Absent |
| Antoinette Guhl | GEST | Against |
| Jocelyne Guidez | UC | Abstention |
| Véronique Guillotin | RDSE | Abstention |
| André Guiol | RDSE | Against |
| Laurence Harribey | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Nadège Havet | LREM | For |
| Ludovic Haye | UC | Abstention |
| Olivier Henno | UC | Abstention |
| Loïc Hervé | UC | Abstention |
| Christine Herzog | UC | Abstention |
| Jean Hingray | UC | Abstention |
| Joshua Hochart | NI | Against |
| Alain Houpert | UMP | Against |
| Marie-Lise Housseau | UC | Abstention |
| Jean-Raymond Hugonet | UMP | Against |
| Jean-François Husson | UMP | Against |
| Brigitte Hybert | UMP | Against |
| Xavier Iacovelli | LREM | For |
| Corinne Imbert | UMP | Against |
| Annick Jacquemet | UC | Abstention |
| Micheline Jacques | UMP | Against |
| Olivier Jacquin | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Yannick Jadot | GEST | Against |
| Éric Jeansannetas | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Patrice Joly | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Bernard Jomier | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Lauriane Josende | UMP | Against |
| Else Joseph | UMP | Against |
| Gisèle Jourda | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Muriel Jourda | UMP | Against |
| Mireille Jouve | RDSE | Against |
| Alain Joyandet | UMP | Against |
| Patrick Kanner | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Roger Karoutchi | UMP | Against |
| Claude Kern | UC | Abstention |
| Éric Kerrouche | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Khalifé Khalifé | UMP | Against |
| Christian Klinger | UMP | Against |
| Mikaele Kulimoetoke | LREM | For |
| Laurent Lafon | UC | Abstention |
| Gérard Lahellec | CRC | Against |
| Marc Laménie | RTLI | Abstention |
| Ahmed Laouedj | RDSE | Against |
| Gérard Larcher | UMP | Absent |
| Florence Lassarade | UMP | Against |
| Michel Laugier | UC | Abstention |
| Daniel Laurent | UMP | Against |
| Christine Lavarde | UMP | Against |
| Ronan Le Gleut | UMP | Against |
| Annie Le Houerou | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Stéphane Le Rudulier | UMP | Against |
| Antoine Lefèvre | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Baptiste Lemoyne | LREM | For |
| Marie-Claude Lermytte | RTLI | Abstention |
| Henri Leroy | UMP | Against |
| Pierre-Antoine Levi | UC | Abstention |
| Martin Lévrier | LREM | For |
| Audrey Linkenheld | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Anne-Catherine Loisier | UC | Abstention |
| Jean-François Longeot | UC | Abstention |
| Vivette Lopez | UMP | Against |
| Vincent Louault | RTLI | Abstention |
| Jean-Jacques Lozach | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Monique Lubin | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Virginie Lucot Avril | UMP | Against |
| Victorin Lurel | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Viviane Malet | UMP | Against |
| Claude Malhuret | RTLI | Abstention |
| Didier Mandelli | UMP | Against |
| Alain Marc | RTLI | Abstention |
| Marianne Margaté | CRC | Against |
| Didier Marie | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Hervé Marseille | UC | Abstention |
| Pascal Martin | UC | Abstention |
| Pauline Martin | UMP | Against |
| Michel Masset | RDSE | Against |
| Hervé Maurey | UC | Abstention |
| Pierre Médevielle | RTLI | Abstention |
| Thierry Meignen | UMP | Against |
| Akli Mellouli | GEST | Against |
| Franck Menonville | UC | Abstention |
| Marie Mercier | UMP | Against |
| Serge Mérillou | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Damien Michallet | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Jacques Michau | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Brigitte Micouleau | UMP | Against |
| Alain Milon | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Marie Mizzon | UC | Abstention |
| Marie-Pierre Monier | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Franck Montaugé | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Catherine Morin-Desailly | UC | Abstention |
| Philippe Mouiller | UMP | Against |
| Laurence Muller-Bronn | UMP | Against |
| Solanges Nadille | LREM | For |
| Corinne Narassiguin | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Georges Naturel | UMP | Against |
| Anne-Marie Nédélec | UMP | Against |
| Sylviane Noël | UMP | Against |
| Claude Nougein | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Baptiste Olivier | UMP | Against |
| Mathilde Ollivier | GEST | Against |
| Saïd Omar Oili | LREM | For |
| Alexandre Ouizille | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Pierre Ouzoulias | CRC | Against |
| Olivier Paccaud | UMP | Against |
| Guylène Pantel | RDSE | Against |
| Jean-Jacques Panunzi | UMP | Against |
| Vanina Paoli-Gagin | RTLI | Abstention |
| Paul Toussaint Parigi | UC | Abstention |
| Georges Patient | LREM | For |
| François Patriat | LREM | For |
| Anne-Sophie Patru | UC | Abstention |
| Philippe Paul | UMP | Against |
| Jean-Gérard Paumier | UMP | Against |
| Cyril Pellevat | UMP | Against |
| Clément Pernot | UMP | Against |
| Cédric Perrin | UMP | Against |
| Maurice Perrion | UC | Abstention |
| Évelyne Perrot | UC | Abstention |
| Annick Petrus | UMP | Against |
| Marie-Laure Phinera-Horth | LREM | For |
| Stéphane Piednoir | UMP | Against |
| Bernard Pillefer | UC | Abstention |
| Sebastien Pla | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Kristina Pluchet | UMP | Against |
| Rémy Pointereau | UMP | Against |
| Raymonde Poncet Monge | GEST | Against |
| Émilienne Poumirol | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Frédérique Puissat | UMP | Against |
| Didier Rambaud | LREM | For |
| Salama Ramia | LREM | For |
| Jean-François Rapin | UMP | Against |
| Stéphane Ravier | NI | Against |
| Claude Raynal | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Christian Redon-Sarrazy | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| André Reichardt | UMP | Against |
| Évelyne Renaud-Garabedian | UMP | Against |
| Hervé Reynaud | UMP | Against |
| Olivia Richard | UC | Abstention |
| Marie-Pierre Richer | UMP | Against |
| Olivier Rietmann | UMP | Against |
| Sylvie Robert | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Pierre Jean Rochette | RTLI | Abstention |
| Teva Rohfritsch | LREM | For |
| Pierre-Alain Roiron | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Bruno Rojouan | UMP | Against |
| Anne-Sophie Romagny | UC | Abstention |
| David Ros | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Laurence Rossignol | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Jean-Yves Roux | RDSE | Against |
| Jean-Luc Ruelle | UMP | Against |
| Denise Saint-Pé | UC | Abstention |
| Daniel Salmon | GEST | Against |
| Hugues Saury | UMP | Against |
| Stéphane Sautarel | UMP | Against |
| Michel Savin | UMP | Against |
| Pascal Savoldelli | CRC | Against |
| Elsa Schalck | UMP | Against |
| Patricia Schillinger | LREM | For |
| Ghislaine Senée | GEST | Against |
| Bruno Sido | UMP | Against |
| Silvana Silvani | CRC | Against |
| Jean Sol | UMP | Against |
| Nadia Sollogoub | UC | Abstention |
| Laurent Somon | UMP | Against |
| Anne Souyris | GEST | Against |
| Lucien Stanzione | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Christopher Szczurek | NI | Against |
| Francis Szpiner | UMP | Against |
| Philippe Tabarot | UMP | Against |
| Rachid Temal | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Lana Tetuanui | UC | Abstention |
| Dominique Théophile | LREM | Non-voting |
| Jean-Claude Tissot | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Simon Uzenat | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Sylvie Valente Le Hir | UMP | Against |
| Mickaël Vallet | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe | UC | Abstention |
| Marie-Claude Varaillas | CRC | Against |
| Jean-Marc Vayssouze-Faure | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Anne Ventalon | UMP | Against |
| Dominique Vérien | UC | Abstention |
| Sylvie Vermeillet | UC | Abstention |
| Pierre-Jean Verzelen | RTLI | Abstention |
| Cédric Vial | UMP | Against |
| Paul Vidal | UMP | Against |
| Jean Pierre Vogel | UMP | Against |
| Louis Vogel | RTLI | Abstention |
| Mélanie Vogel | GEST | Against |
| Dany Wattebled | RTLI | Abstention |
| Michaël Weber | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |
| Robert Wienie Xowie | CRC | Against |
| Adel Ziane | SOC | Abstention vote correction ? original vote unknown |