← All votes

Senate · vote no. 247 · · ✗ Rejected

L'amendement n° 639, présenté par le Gouvernement et sur l'amendement n° 1046, présenté par Mme Archimbaud, à l'article 5 decies du projet de loi, adopté par l'Assemblée nationale après engagement de la procédure accélérée, de modernisation de notre système de santé

Type of vote
Roll-call vote
Voters
341
7 non-voting
Votes cast
244
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
123 votes
to be adopted

16 for 228 against 97 abstentions ▏threshold : 123 votes

In the Senate, “absent” means “did not take part in the vote”: a senator absent from the chamber may have had a colleague vote for them by proxy, which counts as a vote.

Colour by:
CRC — 19 ECO — 10 SOC — 110 RDSE — 17 UC — 42 UMP — 144 NI — 6 CRCSOCRDSEUCUMP Patrick Abate (CRC) — Against Éliane Assassi (CRC) — Abstention Marie-France Beaufils (CRC) — Abstention Michel Billout (CRC) — Abstention Éric Bocquet (CRC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Bosino (CRC) — Abstention Laurence Cohen (CRC) — Abstention Cécile Cukierman (CRC) — Abstention Annie David (CRC) — Abstention Michelle Demessine (CRC) — Abstention Évelyne Didier (CRC) — Abstention Christian Favier (CRC) — Absent Thierry Foucaud (CRC) — Abstention Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin (CRC) — Abstention Pierre Laurent (CRC) — Abstention Michel Le Scouarnec (CRC) — Abstention Christine Prunaud (CRC) — Against Paul Vergès (CRC) — Abstention Dominique Watrin (CRC) — Abstention Aline Archimbaud (ECO) — For Leila Aïchi (ECO) — For Esther Benbassa (ECO) — For Marie-Christine Blandin (ECO) — For Corinne Bouchoux (ECO) — For Ronan Dantec (ECO) — For Jean Desessard (ECO) — For André Gattolin (ECO) — For Joël Labbé (ECO) — For Jean-Vincent Placé (ECO) — For Michèle André (SOC) — Abstention Maurice Antiste (SOC) — Abstention Alain Anziani (SOC) — Abstention David Assouline (SOC) — Abstention Dominique Bailly (SOC) — Abstention Delphine Bataille (SOC) — Against Michel Berson (SOC) — For Jacques Bigot (SOC) — Abstention Maryvonne Blondin (SOC) — Abstention Nicole Bonnefoy (SOC) — Abstention Yannick Botrel (SOC) — Against Jean-Claude Boulard (SOC) — Abstention Martial Bourquin (SOC) — Against Michel Boutant (SOC) — Abstention Nicole Bricq (SOC) — Abstention Claude Bérit-Débat (SOC) — Against Henri Cabanel (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Caffet (SOC) — Abstention Pierre Camani (SOC) — Against Claire-Lise Campion (SOC) — Abstention Thierry Carcenac (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Louis Carrère (SOC) — Absent Françoise Cartron (SOC) — Abstention Luc Carvounas (SOC) — Abstention Bernard Cazeau (SOC) — Abstention Jacques Chiron (SOC) — Abstention Karine Claireaux (SOC) — Abstention Gérard Collomb (SOC) — Abstention Hélène Conway-Mouret (SOC) — Abstention Jacques Cornano (SOC) — Abstention Roland Courteau (SOC) — Against Yves Daudigny (SOC) — Abstention Marc Daunis (SOC) — Against Michel Delebarre (SOC) — Abstention Félix Desplan (SOC) — Against Jérôme Durain (SOC) — Against Alain Duran (SOC) — Against Josette Durrieu (SOC) — Abstention Frédérique Espagnac (SOC) — Against Jean-Jacques Filleul (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Claude Frécon (SOC) — Abstention Corinne Féret (SOC) — Abstention Samia Ghali (SOC) — Abstention Dominique Gillot (SOC) — For Jacques Gillot (SOC) — Abstention Éliane Giraud (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Godefroy (SOC) — For Gaëtan Gorce (SOC) — Abstention Didier Guillaume (SOC) — Abstention Annie Guillemot (SOC) — Abstention Catherine Génisson (SOC) — For Claude Haut (SOC) — Abstention Odette Herviaux (SOC) — For Éric Jeansannetas (SOC) — Abstention Gisèle Jourda (SOC) — Against Philippe Kaltenbach (SOC) — Abstention Antoine Karam (SOC) — Abstention Bariza Khiari (SOC) — Abstention Georges Labazée (SOC) — Against Bernard Lalande (SOC) — Abstention Serge Larcher (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Yves Leconte (SOC) — Abstention Claudine Lepage (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Claude Leroy (SOC) — Against Marie-Noëlle Lienemann (SOC) — Abstention Jeanny Lorgeoux (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Jacques Lozach (SOC) — Abstention Roger Madec (SOC) — Abstention Philippe Madrelle (SOC) — Against Jacques-Bernard Magner (SOC) — Abstention Christian Manable (SOC) — Abstention François Marc (SOC) — Abstention Didier Marie (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Masseret (SOC) — Abstention Rachel Mazuir (SOC) — Abstention Michelle Meunier (SOC) — Abstention Danielle Michel (SOC) — Absent Gérard Miquel (SOC) — Abstention Thani Mohamed Soilihi (SOC) — Abstention Marie-Pierre Monier (SOC) — Abstention Franck Montaugé (SOC) — Against Alain Néri (SOC) — Abstention Georges Patient (SOC) — Abstention François Patriat (SOC) — Abstention Daniel Percheron (SOC) — Abstention Marie-Françoise Perol-Dumont (SOC) — Abstention Hervé Poher (SOC) — Against Daniel Raoul (SOC) — Abstention Claude Raynal (SOC) — Abstention Daniel Reiner (SOC) — Abstention Alain Richard (SOC) — Abstention Stéphanie Riocreux (SOC) — Abstention Sylvie Robert (SOC) — Abstention Gilbert Roger (SOC) — Abstention Yves Rome (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Yves Roux (SOC) — Abstention Patricia Schillinger (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Sueur (SOC) — Abstention Simon Sutour (SOC) — Abstention Catherine Tasca (SOC) — Abstention Nelly Tocqueville (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Louis Tourenne (SOC) — Against René Vandierendonck (SOC) — Abstention Yannick Vaugrenard (SOC) — Abstention Michel Vergoz (SOC) — Abstention Maurice Vincent (SOC) — For Évelyne Yonnet (SOC) — Abstention Richard Yung (SOC) — Against Vincent Éblé (SOC) — Abstention Anne Émery-Dumas (SOC) — Against Michel Amiel (RDSE) — Against Guillaume Arnell (RDSE) — Against Gilbert Barbier (RDSE) — Against Alain Bertrand (RDSE) — Against Joseph Castelli (RDSE) — Against Yvon Collin (RDSE) — Against Pierre-Yves Collombat (RDSE) — Against Philippe Esnol (RDSE) — Against François Fortassin (RDSE) — Against Jean-Noël Guérini (RDSE) — Against Robert Hue (RDSE) — Against Mireille Jouve (RDSE) — Abstention Françoise Laborde (RDSE) — Against Hermeline Malherbe (RDSE) — Against Jacques Mézard (RDSE) — Against Jean-Claude Requier (RDSE) — Against Raymond Vall (RDSE) — Against Annick Billon (UC) — Against Jean-Marie Bockel (UC) — Against Philippe Bonnecarrère (UC) — Against Olivier Cadic (UC) — Against Michel Canévet (UC) — Against Vincent Capo-Canellas (UC) — Against Olivier Cigolotti (UC) — Against Vincent Delahaye (UC) — Against Bernard Delcros (UC) — Against Élisabeth Doineau (UC) — Against Daniel Dubois (UC) — Against Jean-Léonce Dupont (UC) — Against Yves Détraigne (UC) — Against Françoise Férat (UC) — Against Jean-Marc Gabouty (UC) — Against Françoise Gatel (UC) — Against Nathalie Goulet (UC) — Against Jacqueline Gourault (UC) — Against Sylvie Goy-Chavent (UC) — Against Joël Guerriau (UC) — Against Loïc Hervé (UC) — Against Sophie Joissains (UC) — Against Chantal Jouanno (UC) — Against Claude Kern (UC) — Against Jean-Jacques Lasserre (UC) — Against Nuihau Laurey (UC) — Against Anne-Catherine Loisier (UC) — Against Jean-François Longeot (UC) — Against Jean-Claude Luche (UC) — Against Valérie Létard (UC) — Against Hervé Marseille (UC) — Against Hervé Maurey (UC) — Against Michel Mercier (UC) — Against Catherine Morin-Desailly (UC) — Against Pierre Médevielle (UC) — Against Christian Namy (UC) — Against Yves Pozzo di Borgo (UC) — Against Gérard Roche (UC) — Against Henri Tandonnet (UC) — Against Lana Tetuanui (UC) — Against Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe (UC) — Against François Zocchetto (UC) — Against Pascal Allizard (UMP) — Against Gérard Bailly (UMP) — Against François Baroin (UMP) — Against Philippe Bas (UMP) — Against Jérôme Bignon (UMP) — Against Jean Bizet (UMP) — Against François Bonhomme (UMP) — Against Natacha Bouchart (UMP) — Against Gilbert Bouchet (UMP) — Against Michel Bouvard (UMP) — Absent François-Noël Buffet (UMP) — Against Christophe Béchu (UMP) — Against François Calvet (UMP) — Against Christian Cambon (UMP) — Against Agnès Canayer (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Cantegrit (UMP) — Against Jean-Noël Cardoux (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Carle (UMP) — Against Caroline Cayeux (UMP) — Against Patrick Chaize (UMP) — Against Pierre Charon (UMP) — Against Daniel Chasseing (UMP) — Against Alain Chatillon (UMP) — Against François Commeinhes (UMP) — Against Gérard Cornu (UMP) — Against Gérard César (UMP) — Against Philippe Dallier (UMP) — Against René Danesi (UMP) — Against Mathieu Darnaud (UMP) — Against Serge Dassault (UMP) — Against Isabelle Debré (UMP) — Against Francis Delattre (UMP) — Against Catherine Deroche (UMP) — Against Jacky Deromedi (UMP) — Against Marie-Hélène Des Esgaulx (UMP) — Against Chantal Deseyne (UMP) — Against Catherine Di Folco (UMP) — Against Éric Doligé (UMP) — Against Philippe Dominati (UMP) — Against Marie-Annick Duchêne (UMP) — Against Alain Dufaut (UMP) — Against Nicole Duranton (UMP) — Against Louis Duvernois (UMP) — Against Gérard Dériot (UMP) — Against Dominique Estrosi Sassone (UMP) — Against Hubert Falco (UMP) — Against Michel Fontaine (UMP) — Against Michel Forissier (UMP) — Against Alain Fouché (UMP) — Against Bernard Fournier (UMP) — Against Jean-Paul Fournier (UMP) — Against Christophe-André Frassa (UMP) — Against Pierre Frogier (UMP) — Against Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Gaudin (UMP) — Against Jacques Gautier (UMP) — Against Jacques Genest (UMP) — Against Bruno Gilles (UMP) — Against Colette Giudicelli (UMP) — Against Alain Gournac (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Grand (UMP) — Against Daniel Gremillet (UMP) — Against François Grosdidier (UMP) — Against Jacques Grosperrin (UMP) — Against Pascale Gruny (UMP) — Against Charles Guené (UMP) — Against Michel Houel (UMP) — Against Alain Houpert (UMP) — Against Christiane Hummel (UMP) — Against Benoît Huré (UMP) — Against Jean-François Husson (UMP) — Against Jean-Jacques Hyest (UMP) — Against Corinne Imbert (UMP) — Against Alain Joyandet (UMP) — Against Christiane Kammermann (UMP) — Against Roger Karoutchi (UMP) — Against Fabienne Keller (UMP) — Against Guy-Dominique Kennel (UMP) — Against Élisabeth Lamure (UMP) — Against Marc Laménie (UMP) — Against Gérard Larcher (UMP) — Absent Robert Laufoaulu (UMP) — Against Daniel Laurent (UMP) — Against Antoine Lefèvre (UMP) — Against Jacques Legendre (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Leleux (UMP) — Against Jean-Baptiste Lemoyne (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Lenoir (UMP) — Against Philippe Leroy (UMP) — Against Gérard Longuet (UMP) — Against Vivette Lopez (UMP) — Against Michel Magras (UMP) — Against Claude Malhuret (UMP) — Against Didier Mandelli (UMP) — Against Alain Marc (UMP) — Against Patrick Masclet (UMP) — Against Jean-François Mayet (UMP) — Against Marie Mercier (UMP) — Against Brigitte Micouleau (UMP) — Against Alain Milon (UMP) — Against Patricia Morhet-Richaud (UMP) — Against Jean-Marie Morisset (UMP) — Against Philippe Mouiller (UMP) — Against Colette Mélot (UMP) — Against Philippe Nachbar (UMP) — Against Claude Nougein (UMP) — Against Louis Nègre (UMP) — Against Jean-Jacques Panunzi (UMP) — Against Philippe Paul (UMP) — Against Cyril Pellevat (UMP) — Against Cédric Perrin (UMP) — Against Jackie Pierre (UMP) — Against François Pillet (UMP) — Against Xavier Pintat (UMP) — Against Louis Pinton (UMP) — Against Rémy Pointereau (UMP) — Against Ladislas Poniatowski (UMP) — Against Hugues Portelli (UMP) — Against Sophie Primas (UMP) — Against Catherine Procaccia (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Raffarin (UMP) — Against Michel Raison (UMP) — Against André Reichardt (UMP) — Against Bruno Retailleau (UMP) — Against Charles Revet (UMP) — Against Didier Robert (UMP) — Against Bernard Saugey (UMP) — Against René-Paul Savary (UMP) — Against Michel Savin (UMP) — Against Bruno Sido (UMP) — Against Abdourahamane Soilihi (UMP) — Against André Trillard (UMP) — Against Catherine Troendlé (UMP) — Against Michel Vaspart (UMP) — Against Alain Vasselle (UMP) — Against Hilarion Vendegou (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Vial (UMP) — Against Jean Pierre Vogel (UMP) — Against Dominique de Legge (UMP) — Against Albéric de Montgolfier (UMP) — Against Louis-Jean de Nicolaÿ (UMP) — Against Henri de Raincourt (UMP) — Against Robert del Picchia (UMP) — Against Jean-Paul Émorine (UMP) — Against Philippe Adnot (NI) — Against Jean Louis Masson (NI) — Against Robert Navarro (NI) — Absent David Rachline (NI) — Absent Stéphane Ravier (NI) — Against Alex Türk (NI) — Against

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
CRC 0216 0119
ECO 1000 0010
SOC 62280 02110
RDSE 0161 0017
UC 0420 0042
UMP 01420 02144
NI 040 026

All senators

SenatorGroupVote
Patrick Abate CRC Against
Philippe Adnot NI Against
Leila Aïchi ECO For
Pascal Allizard UMP Against
Michel Amiel RDSE Against
Michèle André SOC Abstention
Maurice Antiste SOC Abstention
Alain Anziani SOC Abstention
Aline Archimbaud ECO For
Guillaume Arnell RDSE Against
Éliane Assassi CRC Abstention
David Assouline SOC Abstention
Dominique Bailly SOC Abstention
Gérard Bailly UMP Against
Gilbert Barbier RDSE Against
François Baroin UMP Against
Philippe Bas UMP Against
Delphine Bataille SOC Against
Marie-France Beaufils CRC Abstention
Christophe Béchu UMP Against
Esther Benbassa ECO For
Claude Bérit-Débat SOC Against
Michel Berson SOC For
Alain Bertrand RDSE Against
Jérôme Bignon UMP Against
Jacques Bigot SOC Abstention
Annick Billon UC Against
Michel Billout CRC Abstention
Jean Bizet UMP Against
Marie-Christine Blandin ECO For
Maryvonne Blondin SOC Abstention
Jean-Marie Bockel UC Against
Éric Bocquet CRC Abstention
François Bonhomme UMP Against
Philippe Bonnecarrère UC Against
Nicole Bonnefoy SOC Abstention
Jean-Pierre Bosino CRC Abstention
Yannick Botrel SOC Against
Natacha Bouchart UMP Against
Gilbert Bouchet UMP Against
Corinne Bouchoux ECO For
Jean-Claude Boulard SOC Abstention
Martial Bourquin SOC Against
Michel Boutant SOC Abstention
Michel Bouvard UMP Absent
Nicole Bricq SOC Abstention
François-Noël Buffet UMP Against
Henri Cabanel SOC Against
Olivier Cadic UC Against
Jean-Pierre Caffet SOC Abstention
François Calvet UMP Against
Pierre Camani SOC Against
Christian Cambon UMP Against
Claire-Lise Campion SOC Abstention
Agnès Canayer UMP Against
Michel Canévet UC Against
Jean-Pierre Cantegrit UMP Against
Vincent Capo-Canellas UC Against
Thierry Carcenac SOC Abstention
Jean-Noël Cardoux UMP Against
Jean-Claude Carle UMP Against
Jean-Louis Carrère SOC Absent
Françoise Cartron SOC Abstention
Luc Carvounas SOC Abstention
Joseph Castelli RDSE Against
Caroline Cayeux UMP Against
Bernard Cazeau SOC Abstention
Gérard César UMP Against
Patrick Chaize UMP Against
Pierre Charon UMP Against
Daniel Chasseing UMP Against
Alain Chatillon UMP Against
Jacques Chiron SOC Abstention
Olivier Cigolotti UC Against
Karine Claireaux SOC Abstention
Laurence Cohen CRC Abstention
Yvon Collin RDSE Against
Gérard Collomb SOC Abstention
Pierre-Yves Collombat RDSE Against
François Commeinhes UMP Against
Hélène Conway-Mouret SOC Abstention
Jacques Cornano SOC Abstention
Gérard Cornu UMP Against
Roland Courteau SOC Against
Cécile Cukierman CRC Abstention
Philippe Dallier UMP Against
René Danesi UMP Against
Ronan Dantec ECO For
Mathieu Darnaud UMP Against
Serge Dassault UMP Against
Yves Daudigny SOC Abstention
Marc Daunis SOC Against
Annie David CRC Abstention
Dominique de Legge UMP Against
Albéric de Montgolfier UMP Against
Louis-Jean de Nicolaÿ UMP Against
Henri de Raincourt UMP Against
Isabelle Debré UMP Against
Robert del Picchia UMP Against
Vincent Delahaye UC Against
Francis Delattre UMP Against
Bernard Delcros UC Against
Michel Delebarre SOC Abstention
Michelle Demessine CRC Abstention
Gérard Dériot UMP Against
Catherine Deroche UMP Against
Jacky Deromedi UMP Against
Marie-Hélène Des Esgaulx UMP Against
Jean Desessard ECO For
Chantal Deseyne UMP Against
Félix Desplan SOC Against
Yves Détraigne UC Against
Catherine Di Folco UMP Against
Évelyne Didier CRC Abstention
Élisabeth Doineau UC Against
Éric Doligé UMP Against
Philippe Dominati UMP Against
Daniel Dubois UC Against
Marie-Annick Duchêne UMP Against
Alain Dufaut UMP Against
Jean-Léonce Dupont UC Against
Jérôme Durain SOC Against
Alain Duran SOC Against
Nicole Duranton UMP Against
Josette Durrieu SOC Abstention
Louis Duvernois UMP Against
Vincent Éblé SOC Abstention
Anne Émery-Dumas SOC Against
Jean-Paul Émorine UMP Against
Philippe Esnol RDSE Against
Frédérique Espagnac SOC Against
Dominique Estrosi Sassone UMP Against
Hubert Falco UMP Against
Christian Favier CRC Absent
Françoise Férat UC Against
Corinne Féret SOC Abstention
Jean-Jacques Filleul SOC Abstention
Michel Fontaine UMP Against
Michel Forissier UMP Against
François Fortassin RDSE Against
Thierry Foucaud CRC Abstention
Alain Fouché UMP Against
Bernard Fournier UMP Against
Jean-Paul Fournier UMP Against
Christophe-André Frassa UMP Against
Jean-Claude Frécon SOC Abstention
Pierre Frogier UMP Against
Jean-Marc Gabouty UC Against
Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam UMP Against
Françoise Gatel UC Against
André Gattolin ECO For
Jean-Claude Gaudin UMP Against
Jacques Gautier UMP Against
Jacques Genest UMP Against
Catherine Génisson SOC For
Samia Ghali SOC Abstention
Bruno Gilles UMP Against
Dominique Gillot SOC For
Jacques Gillot SOC Abstention
Éliane Giraud SOC Abstention
Colette Giudicelli UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Godefroy SOC For
Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin CRC Abstention
Gaëtan Gorce SOC Abstention
Nathalie Goulet UC Against
Jacqueline Gourault UC Against
Alain Gournac UMP Against
Sylvie Goy-Chavent UC Against
Jean-Pierre Grand UMP Against
Daniel Gremillet UMP Against
François Grosdidier UMP Against
Jacques Grosperrin UMP Against
Pascale Gruny UMP Against
Charles Guené UMP Against
Jean-Noël Guérini RDSE Against
Joël Guerriau UC Against
Didier Guillaume SOC Abstention
Annie Guillemot SOC Abstention
Claude Haut SOC Abstention
Loïc Hervé UC Against
Odette Herviaux SOC For
Michel Houel UMP Against
Alain Houpert UMP Against
Robert Hue RDSE Against
Christiane Hummel UMP Against
Benoît Huré UMP Against
Jean-François Husson UMP Against
Jean-Jacques Hyest UMP Against
Corinne Imbert UMP Against
Éric Jeansannetas SOC Abstention
Sophie Joissains UC Against
Chantal Jouanno UC Against
Gisèle Jourda SOC Against
Mireille Jouve RDSE Abstention
Alain Joyandet UMP Against
Philippe Kaltenbach SOC Abstention
Christiane Kammermann UMP Against
Antoine Karam SOC Abstention
Roger Karoutchi UMP Against
Fabienne Keller UMP Against
Guy-Dominique Kennel UMP Against
Claude Kern UC Against
Bariza Khiari SOC Abstention
Georges Labazée SOC Against
Joël Labbé ECO For
Françoise Laborde RDSE Against
Bernard Lalande SOC Abstention
Marc Laménie UMP Against
Élisabeth Lamure UMP Against
Gérard Larcher UMP Absent
Serge Larcher SOC Abstention
Jean-Jacques Lasserre UC Against
Robert Laufoaulu UMP Against
Daniel Laurent UMP Against
Pierre Laurent CRC Abstention
Nuihau Laurey UC Against
Michel Le Scouarnec CRC Abstention
Jean-Yves Leconte SOC Abstention
Antoine Lefèvre UMP Against
Jacques Legendre UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Leleux UMP Against
Jean-Baptiste Lemoyne UMP Against
Jean-Claude Lenoir UMP Against
Claudine Lepage SOC Abstention
Jean-Claude Leroy SOC Against
Philippe Leroy UMP Against
Valérie Létard UC Against
Marie-Noëlle Lienemann SOC Abstention
Anne-Catherine Loisier UC Against
Jean-François Longeot UC Against
Gérard Longuet UMP Against
Vivette Lopez UMP Against
Jeanny Lorgeoux SOC Abstention
Jean-Jacques Lozach SOC Abstention
Jean-Claude Luche UC Against
Roger Madec SOC Abstention
Philippe Madrelle SOC Against
Jacques-Bernard Magner SOC Abstention
Michel Magras UMP Against
Hermeline Malherbe RDSE Against
Claude Malhuret UMP Against
Christian Manable SOC Abstention
Didier Mandelli UMP Against
Alain Marc UMP Against
François Marc SOC Abstention
Didier Marie SOC Against
Hervé Marseille UC Against
Patrick Masclet UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Masseret SOC Abstention
Jean Louis Masson NI Against
Hervé Maurey UC Against
Jean-François Mayet UMP Against
Rachel Mazuir SOC Abstention
Pierre Médevielle UC Against
Colette Mélot UMP Against
Marie Mercier UMP Against
Michel Mercier UC Against
Michelle Meunier SOC Abstention
Jacques Mézard RDSE Against
Danielle Michel SOC Absent
Brigitte Micouleau UMP Against
Alain Milon UMP Against
Gérard Miquel SOC Abstention
Thani Mohamed Soilihi SOC Abstention
Marie-Pierre Monier SOC Abstention
Franck Montaugé SOC Against
Patricia Morhet-Richaud UMP Against
Catherine Morin-Desailly UC Against
Jean-Marie Morisset UMP Against
Philippe Mouiller UMP Against
Philippe Nachbar UMP Against
Christian Namy UC Against
Robert Navarro NI Absent
Louis Nègre UMP Against
Alain Néri SOC Abstention
Claude Nougein UMP Against
Jean-Jacques Panunzi UMP Against
Georges Patient SOC Abstention
François Patriat SOC Abstention
Philippe Paul UMP Against
Cyril Pellevat UMP Against
Daniel Percheron SOC Abstention
Marie-Françoise Perol-Dumont SOC Abstention
Cédric Perrin UMP Against
Jackie Pierre UMP Against
François Pillet UMP Against
Xavier Pintat UMP Against
Louis Pinton UMP Against
Jean-Vincent Placé ECO For
Hervé Poher SOC Against
Rémy Pointereau UMP Against
Ladislas Poniatowski UMP Against
Hugues Portelli UMP Against
Yves Pozzo di Borgo UC Against
Sophie Primas UMP Against
Catherine Procaccia UMP Against
Christine Prunaud CRC Against
David Rachline NI Absent
Jean-Pierre Raffarin UMP Against
Michel Raison UMP Against
Daniel Raoul SOC Abstention
Stéphane Ravier NI Against
Claude Raynal SOC Abstention
André Reichardt UMP Against
Daniel Reiner SOC Abstention
Jean-Claude Requier RDSE Against
Bruno Retailleau UMP Against
Charles Revet UMP Against
Alain Richard SOC Abstention
Stéphanie Riocreux SOC Abstention
Didier Robert UMP Against
Sylvie Robert SOC Abstention
Gérard Roche UC Against
Gilbert Roger SOC Abstention
Yves Rome SOC Abstention
Jean-Yves Roux SOC Abstention
Bernard Saugey UMP Against
René-Paul Savary UMP Against
Michel Savin UMP Against
Patricia Schillinger SOC Abstention
Bruno Sido UMP Against
Abdourahamane Soilihi UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Sueur SOC Abstention
Simon Sutour SOC Abstention
Henri Tandonnet UC Against
Catherine Tasca SOC Abstention
Lana Tetuanui UC Against
Nelly Tocqueville SOC Abstention
Jean-Louis Tourenne SOC Against
André Trillard UMP Against
Catherine Troendlé UMP Against
Alex Türk NI Against
Raymond Vall RDSE Against
René Vandierendonck SOC Abstention
Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe UC Against
Michel Vaspart UMP Against
Alain Vasselle UMP Against
Yannick Vaugrenard SOC Abstention
Hilarion Vendegou UMP Against
Paul Vergès CRC Abstention
Michel Vergoz SOC Abstention
Jean-Pierre Vial UMP Against
Maurice Vincent SOC For
Jean Pierre Vogel UMP Against
Dominique Watrin CRC Abstention
Évelyne Yonnet SOC Abstention
Richard Yung SOC Against
François Zocchetto UC Against