← All votes

Senate · vote no. 58 · · ✓ Adopted

L'article unique de la proposition de loi tendant à modifier la loi n° 2011-814 du 7 juillet 2011 relative à la bioéthique en autorisant sous certaines conditions la recherche sur l'embryon et les cellules souches embryonnaires

Type of vote
Roll-call vote
Voters
305
43 non-voting
Votes cast
277
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
139 votes
to be adopted

203 for 74 against 28 abstentions ▏threshold : 139 votes

In the Senate, “absent” means “did not take part in the vote”: a senator absent from the chamber may have had a colleague vote for them by proxy, which counts as a vote.

Colour by:
CRC — 20 ECO — 12 SOC — 128 RDSE — 18 UC — 32 UMP — 131 NI — 7 CRCSOCRDSEUCUMP Éliane Assassi (CRC) — For Marie-France Beaufils (CRC) — For Michel Billout (CRC) — For Éric Bocquet (CRC) — For Laurence Cohen (CRC) — For Cécile Cukierman (CRC) — For Annie David (CRC) — For Michelle Demessine (CRC) — For Évelyne Didier (CRC) — For Christian Favier (CRC) — For Guy Fischer (CRC) — For Thierry Foucaud (CRC) — For Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin (CRC) — For Pierre Laurent (CRC) — For Gérard Le Cam (CRC) — For Michel Le Scouarnec (CRC) — For Isabelle Pasquet (CRC) — For Mireille Schurch (CRC) — For Paul Vergès (CRC) — For Dominique Watrin (CRC) — For Kalliopi Ango Ela (ECO) — For Aline Archimbaud (ECO) — Abstention Leila Aïchi (ECO) — Abstention Esther Benbassa (ECO) — For Marie-Christine Blandin (ECO) — For Corinne Bouchoux (ECO) — For Ronan Dantec (ECO) — For Jean Desessard (ECO) — For André Gattolin (ECO) — Abstention Joël Labbé (ECO) — Abstention Hélène Lipietz (ECO) — Abstention Jean-Vincent Placé (ECO) — For Jacqueline Alquier (SOC) — For Serge Andreoni (SOC) — For Michèle André (SOC) — For Maurice Antiste (SOC) — For Jean-Étienne Antoinette (SOC) — For Alain Anziani (SOC) — For David Assouline (SOC) — For Bertrand Auban (SOC) — For Dominique Bailly (SOC) — For Delphine Bataille (SOC) — For Jean-Pierre Bel (SOC) — Absent Michel Berson (SOC) — For Jacques Berthou (SOC) — For Jean Besson (SOC) — For Maryvonne Blondin (SOC) — For Nicole Bonnefoy (SOC) — For Yannick Botrel (SOC) — For Martial Bourquin (SOC) — For Bernadette Bourzai (SOC) — For Michel Boutant (SOC) — For Claude Bérit-Débat (SOC) — For Jean-Pierre Caffet (SOC) — For Pierre Camani (SOC) — For Claire-Lise Campion (SOC) — For Jean-Louis Carrère (SOC) — For Françoise Cartron (SOC) — For Luc Carvounas (SOC) — For Bernard Cazeau (SOC) — For Yves Chastan (SOC) — For Jacques Chiron (SOC) — For Karine Claireaux (SOC) — For Gérard Collomb (SOC) — For Jacques Cornano (SOC) — For Roland Courteau (SOC) — For Yves Daudigny (SOC) — For Marc Daunis (SOC) — For Michel Delebarre (SOC) — For Jean-Pierre Demerliat (SOC) — For Christiane Demontès (SOC) — For Félix Desplan (SOC) — For Claude Dilain (SOC) — For Claude Domeizel (SOC) — For Odette Duriez (SOC) — For Josette Durrieu (SOC) — For Philippe Esnol (SOC) — For Frédérique Espagnac (SOC) — For Alain Fauconnier (SOC) — For Jean-Luc Fichet (SOC) — For Jean-Jacques Filleul (SOC) — For Jean-Claude Frécon (SOC) — For Jean Germain (SOC) — For Samia Ghali (SOC) — For Dominique Gillot (SOC) — For Jacques Gillot (SOC) — For Jean-Pierre Godefroy (SOC) — For Gaëtan Gorce (SOC) — For Didier Guillaume (SOC) — For Jean-Noël Guérini (SOC) — For Catherine Génisson (SOC) — For Claude Haut (SOC) — For Odette Herviaux (SOC) — For Edmond Hervé (SOC) — For Claude Jeannerot (SOC) — For Philippe Kaltenbach (SOC) — For Ronan Kerdraon (SOC) — For Bariza Khiari (SOC) — For Virginie Klès (SOC) — For Yves Krattinger (SOC) — For Georges Labazée (SOC) — For Serge Larcher (SOC) — For Françoise Laurent-Perrigot (SOC) — For Jacky Le Menn (SOC) — For Alain Le Vern (SOC) — For Jean-Yves Leconte (SOC) — For Claudine Lepage (SOC) — For Jean-Claude Leroy (SOC) — For Marie-Noëlle Lienemann (SOC) — For Jeanny Lorgeoux (SOC) — For Jean-Jacques Lozach (SOC) — For Roger Madec (SOC) — For Philippe Madrelle (SOC) — For Jacques-Bernard Magner (SOC) — For François Marc (SOC) — For Marc Massion (SOC) — For Rachel Mazuir (SOC) — For Michelle Meunier (SOC) — For Danielle Michel (SOC) — For Jean-Pierre Michel (SOC) — For Gérard Miquel (SOC) — For Jean-Jacques Mirassou (SOC) — For Thani Mohamed Soilihi (SOC) — For Robert Navarro (SOC) — For Renée Nicoux (SOC) — For Alain Néri (SOC) — For Jean-Marc Pastor (SOC) — For Georges Patient (SOC) — For François Patriat (SOC) — For Daniel Percheron (SOC) — For Jean-Claude Peyronnet (SOC) — For Bernard Piras (SOC) — For Roland Povinelli (SOC) — For Gisèle Printz (SOC) — For Marcel Rainaud (SOC) — For Daniel Raoul (SOC) — For François Rebsamen (SOC) — For Daniel Reiner (SOC) — For Alain Richard (SOC) — For Roland Ries (SOC) — For Gilbert Roger (SOC) — For Yves Rome (SOC) — For Laurence Rossignol (SOC) — For Patricia Schillinger (SOC) — For Jean-Pierre Sueur (SOC) — For Simon Sutour (SOC) — For Catherine Tasca (SOC) — For Michel Teston (SOC) — For René Teulade (SOC) — For Jean-Marc Todeschini (SOC) — For Richard Tuheiava (SOC) — For André Vairetto (SOC) — For André Vallini (SOC) — For René Vandierendonck (SOC) — For Yannick Vaugrenard (SOC) — For Michel Vergoz (SOC) — For Maurice Vincent (SOC) — For Richard Yung (SOC) — For Vincent Éblé (SOC) — For Anne Émery-Dumas (SOC) — For Nicolas Alfonsi (RDSE) — For Gilbert Barbier (RDSE) — For Jean-Michel Baylet (RDSE) — For Alain Bertrand (RDSE) — For Christian Bourquin (RDSE) — For Jean-Pierre Chevènement (RDSE) — For Yvon Collin (RDSE) — For Pierre-Yves Collombat (RDSE) — For François Fortassin (RDSE) — For Robert Hue (RDSE) — For Françoise Laborde (RDSE) — For Stéphane Mazars (RDSE) — For Jacques Mézard (RDSE) — For Jean-Pierre Plancade (RDSE) — For Jean-Claude Requier (RDSE) — For Robert Tropeano (RDSE) — For Raymond Vall (RDSE) — For François Vendasi (RDSE) — For Jean-Paul Amoudry (UC) — Against Jean Arthuis (UC) — Against Jean-Marie Bockel (UC) — Abstention Jean Boyer (UC) — Against Vincent Capo-Canellas (UC) — For Vincent Delahaye (UC) — For Marcel Deneux (UC) — Against Muguette Dini (UC) — For Daniel Dubois (UC) — Absent Jean-Léonce Dupont (UC) — Non-voting Yves Détraigne (UC) — Against Françoise Férat (UC) — For Nathalie Goulet (UC) — Absent Jacqueline Gourault (UC) — Absent Sylvie Goy-Chavent (UC) — For Joël Guerriau (UC) — For Pierre Jarlier (UC) — For Chantal Jouanno (UC) — For Jean-Jacques Lasserre (UC) — Absent Valérie Létard (UC) — Abstention Hervé Marseille (UC) — Abstention Hervé Maurey (UC) — Absent Jean-Claude Merceron (UC) — For Michel Mercier (UC) — Against Catherine Morin-Desailly (UC) — Abstention Christian Namy (UC) — Against Yves Pozzo di Borgo (UC) — Against Gérard Roche (UC) — For Henri Tandonnet (UC) — Against Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe (UC) — For François Zocchetto (UC) — Against Aymeri de Montesquiou (UC) — Abstention Pierre André (UMP) — Against Gérard Bailly (UMP) — Against Philippe Bas (UMP) — Against René Beaumont (UMP) — For Claude Belot (UMP) — Absent Joël Billard (UMP) — Against Jean Bizet (UMP) — Against Pierre Bordier (UMP) — Against Natacha Bouchart (UMP) — Absent Joël Bourdin (UMP) — Absent Marie-Thérèse Bruguière (UMP) — For François-Noël Buffet (UMP) — Absent Christophe Béchu (UMP) — Against Michel Bécot (UMP) — Against François Calvet (UMP) — Against Christian Cambon (UMP) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Cantegrit (UMP) — For Jean-Noël Cardoux (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Carle (UMP) — Against Caroline Cayeux (UMP) — Abstention Pierre Charon (UMP) — Against Alain Chatillon (UMP) — Absent Jean-Pierre Chauveau (UMP) — Against Marcel-Pierre Cléach (UMP) — Abstention Christian Cointat (UMP) — Against Gérard Cornu (UMP) — Absent Raymond Couderc (UMP) — Abstention Jean-Patrick Courtois (UMP) — Abstention Gérard César (UMP) — Against Philippe Dallier (UMP) — Absent Serge Dassault (UMP) — Absent Isabelle Debré (UMP) — For Francis Delattre (UMP) — For Catherine Deroche (UMP) — For Marie-Hélène Des Esgaulx (UMP) — Against Éric Doligé (UMP) — For Philippe Dominati (UMP) — Absent Michel Doublet (UMP) — Abstention Marie-Annick Duchêne (UMP) — Against Alain Dufaut (UMP) — For André Dulait (UMP) — Absent Ambroise Dupont (UMP) — Absent Louis Duvernois (UMP) — For Gérard Dériot (UMP) — Against Hubert Falco (UMP) — Absent Jacqueline Farreyrol (UMP) — Absent André Ferrand (UMP) — Abstention Louis-Constant Fleming (UMP) — Against Michel Fontaine (UMP) — For Alain Fouché (UMP) — Absent Bernard Fournier (UMP) — Against Jean-Paul Fournier (UMP) — Abstention Christophe-André Frassa (UMP) — Against Pierre Frogier (UMP) — Absent Yann Gaillard (UMP) — Abstention René Garrec (UMP) — Absent Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam (UMP) — Absent Jean-Claude Gaudin (UMP) — Against Jacques Gautier (UMP) — Abstention Bruno Gilles (UMP) — Against Colette Giudicelli (UMP) — Against Alain Gournac (UMP) — Against Francis Grignon (UMP) — Against François Grosdidier (UMP) — Absent Charles Guené (UMP) — Abstention Patrice Gélard (UMP) — Against Michel Houel (UMP) — For Alain Houpert (UMP) — For Jean-François Humbert (UMP) — Absent Christiane Hummel (UMP) — Against Benoît Huré (UMP) — Against Jean-Jacques Hyest (UMP) — Against Pierre Hérisson (UMP) — Absent Sophie Joissains (UMP) — Against Christiane Kammermann (UMP) — For Roger Karoutchi (UMP) — Absent Fabienne Keller (UMP) — For Élisabeth Lamure (UMP) — Against Marc Laménie (UMP) — Against Gérard Larcher (UMP) — Against Robert Laufoaulu (UMP) — Against Daniel Laurent (UMP) — Absent Jean-René Lecerf (UMP) — Abstention Antoine Lefèvre (UMP) — Against Jacques Legendre (UMP) — Absent Jean-Pierre Leleux (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Lenoir (UMP) — Absent Philippe Leroy (UMP) — Against Gérard Longuet (UMP) — Absent Jean-Louis Lorrain (UMP) — Absent Michel Magras (UMP) — Absent Philippe Marini (UMP) — Against Pierre Martin (UMP) — Absent Jean-François Mayet (UMP) — Against Alain Milon (UMP) — For Colette Mélot (UMP) — For Philippe Nachbar (UMP) — Absent Louis Nègre (UMP) — Absent Philippe Paul (UMP) — Against Jackie Pierre (UMP) — Abstention François Pillet (UMP) — Against Xavier Pintat (UMP) — Absent Louis Pinton (UMP) — Abstention Rémy Pointereau (UMP) — Against Christian Poncelet (UMP) — Against Ladislas Poniatowski (UMP) — Absent Hugues Portelli (UMP) — Against Sophie Primas (UMP) — Absent Catherine Procaccia (UMP) — For Jean-Pierre Raffarin (UMP) — Against André Reichardt (UMP) — Absent Bruno Retailleau (UMP) — Against Charles Revet (UMP) — Against Bernard Saugey (UMP) — Abstention René-Paul Savary (UMP) — For Michel Savin (UMP) — Abstention Bruno Sido (UMP) — Against Esther Sittler (UMP) — Against Abdourahamane Soilihi (UMP) — Absent André Trillard (UMP) — Against Catherine Troendlé (UMP) — Absent François Trucy (UMP) — For Hilarion Vendegou (UMP) — Against René Vestri (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Vial (UMP) — Against Dominique de Legge (UMP) — Against Albéric de Montgolfier (UMP) — Against Henri de Raincourt (UMP) — Against Robert del Picchia (UMP) — Against Roland du Luart (UMP) — Against Jean-Paul Émorine (UMP) — For Philippe Adnot (NI) — Abstention Pierre Bernard-Reymond (NI) — Against Philippe Darniche (NI) — Against Gaston Flosse (NI) — Against Jean-François Husson (NI) — Against Jean Louis Masson (NI) — Abstention Alex Türk (NI) — Against

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
CRC 2000 0020
ECO 705 0012
SOC 12700 01128
RDSE 1800 0018
UC 11105 1532
UMP 205916 036131
NI 052 007

All senators

SenatorGroupVote
Philippe Adnot NI Abstention
Leila Aïchi ECO Abstention
Nicolas Alfonsi RDSE For
Jacqueline Alquier SOC For
Jean-Paul Amoudry UC Against
Michèle André SOC For
Pierre André UMP Against
Serge Andreoni SOC For
Kalliopi Ango Ela ECO For
Maurice Antiste SOC For
Jean-Étienne Antoinette SOC For
Alain Anziani SOC For
Aline Archimbaud ECO Abstention
Jean Arthuis UC Against
Éliane Assassi CRC For
David Assouline SOC For
Bertrand Auban SOC For
Dominique Bailly SOC For
Gérard Bailly UMP Against
Gilbert Barbier RDSE For
Philippe Bas UMP Against
Delphine Bataille SOC For
Jean-Michel Baylet RDSE For
Marie-France Beaufils CRC For
René Beaumont UMP For
Christophe Béchu UMP Against
Michel Bécot UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Bel SOC Absent
Claude Belot UMP Absent
Esther Benbassa ECO For
Claude Bérit-Débat SOC For
Pierre Bernard-Reymond NI Against
Michel Berson SOC For
Jacques Berthou SOC For
Alain Bertrand RDSE For
Jean Besson SOC For
Joël Billard UMP Against
Michel Billout CRC For
Jean Bizet UMP Against
Marie-Christine Blandin ECO For
Maryvonne Blondin SOC For
Jean-Marie Bockel UC Abstention
Éric Bocquet CRC For
Nicole Bonnefoy SOC For
Pierre Bordier UMP Against
Yannick Botrel SOC For
Natacha Bouchart UMP Absent
Corinne Bouchoux ECO For
Joël Bourdin UMP Absent
Christian Bourquin RDSE For
Martial Bourquin SOC For
Bernadette Bourzai SOC For
Michel Boutant SOC For
Jean Boyer UC Against
Marie-Thérèse Bruguière UMP For
François-Noël Buffet UMP Absent
Jean-Pierre Caffet SOC For
François Calvet UMP Against
Pierre Camani SOC For
Christian Cambon UMP Abstention
Claire-Lise Campion SOC For
Jean-Pierre Cantegrit UMP For
Vincent Capo-Canellas UC For
Jean-Noël Cardoux UMP Against
Jean-Claude Carle UMP Against
Jean-Louis Carrère SOC For
Françoise Cartron SOC For
Luc Carvounas SOC For
Caroline Cayeux UMP Abstention
Bernard Cazeau SOC For
Gérard César UMP Against
Pierre Charon UMP Against
Yves Chastan SOC For
Alain Chatillon UMP Absent
Jean-Pierre Chauveau UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Chevènement RDSE For
Jacques Chiron SOC For
Karine Claireaux SOC For
Marcel-Pierre Cléach UMP Abstention
Laurence Cohen CRC For
Christian Cointat UMP Against
Yvon Collin RDSE For
Gérard Collomb SOC For
Pierre-Yves Collombat RDSE For
Jacques Cornano SOC For
Gérard Cornu UMP Absent
Raymond Couderc UMP Abstention
Roland Courteau SOC For
Jean-Patrick Courtois UMP Abstention
Cécile Cukierman CRC For
Philippe Dallier UMP Absent
Ronan Dantec ECO For
Philippe Darniche NI Against
Serge Dassault UMP Absent
Yves Daudigny SOC For
Marc Daunis SOC For
Annie David CRC For
Dominique de Legge UMP Against
Aymeri de Montesquiou UC Abstention
Albéric de Montgolfier UMP Against
Henri de Raincourt UMP Against
Isabelle Debré UMP For
Robert del Picchia UMP Against
Vincent Delahaye UC For
Francis Delattre UMP For
Michel Delebarre SOC For
Jean-Pierre Demerliat SOC For
Michelle Demessine CRC For
Christiane Demontès SOC For
Marcel Deneux UC Against
Gérard Dériot UMP Against
Catherine Deroche UMP For
Marie-Hélène Des Esgaulx UMP Against
Jean Desessard ECO For
Félix Desplan SOC For
Yves Détraigne UC Against
Évelyne Didier CRC For
Claude Dilain SOC For
Muguette Dini UC For
Éric Doligé UMP For
Claude Domeizel SOC For
Philippe Dominati UMP Absent
Michel Doublet UMP Abstention
Roland du Luart UMP Against
Daniel Dubois UC Absent
Marie-Annick Duchêne UMP Against
Alain Dufaut UMP For
André Dulait UMP Absent
Ambroise Dupont UMP Absent
Jean-Léonce Dupont UC Non-voting
Odette Duriez SOC For
Josette Durrieu SOC For
Louis Duvernois UMP For
Vincent Éblé SOC For
Anne Émery-Dumas SOC For
Jean-Paul Émorine UMP For
Philippe Esnol SOC For
Frédérique Espagnac SOC For
Hubert Falco UMP Absent
Jacqueline Farreyrol UMP Absent
Alain Fauconnier SOC For
Christian Favier CRC For
Françoise Férat UC For
André Ferrand UMP Abstention
Jean-Luc Fichet SOC For
Jean-Jacques Filleul SOC For
Guy Fischer CRC For
Louis-Constant Fleming UMP Against
Gaston Flosse NI Against
Michel Fontaine UMP For
François Fortassin RDSE For
Thierry Foucaud CRC For
Alain Fouché UMP Absent
Bernard Fournier UMP Against
Jean-Paul Fournier UMP Abstention
Christophe-André Frassa UMP Against
Jean-Claude Frécon SOC For
Pierre Frogier UMP Absent
Yann Gaillard UMP Abstention
René Garrec UMP Absent
Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam UMP Absent
André Gattolin ECO Abstention
Jean-Claude Gaudin UMP Against
Jacques Gautier UMP Abstention
Patrice Gélard UMP Against
Catherine Génisson SOC For
Jean Germain SOC For
Samia Ghali SOC For
Bruno Gilles UMP Against
Dominique Gillot SOC For
Jacques Gillot SOC For
Colette Giudicelli UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Godefroy SOC For
Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin CRC For
Gaëtan Gorce SOC For
Nathalie Goulet UC Absent
Jacqueline Gourault UC Absent
Alain Gournac UMP Against
Sylvie Goy-Chavent UC For
Francis Grignon UMP Against
François Grosdidier UMP Absent
Charles Guené UMP Abstention
Jean-Noël Guérini SOC For
Joël Guerriau UC For
Didier Guillaume SOC For
Claude Haut SOC For
Pierre Hérisson UMP Absent
Edmond Hervé SOC For
Odette Herviaux SOC For
Michel Houel UMP For
Alain Houpert UMP For
Robert Hue RDSE For
Jean-François Humbert UMP Absent
Christiane Hummel UMP Against
Benoît Huré UMP Against
Jean-François Husson NI Against
Jean-Jacques Hyest UMP Against
Pierre Jarlier UC For
Claude Jeannerot SOC For
Sophie Joissains UMP Against
Chantal Jouanno UC For
Philippe Kaltenbach SOC For
Christiane Kammermann UMP For
Roger Karoutchi UMP Absent
Fabienne Keller UMP For
Ronan Kerdraon SOC For
Bariza Khiari SOC For
Virginie Klès SOC For
Yves Krattinger SOC For
Georges Labazée SOC For
Joël Labbé ECO Abstention
Françoise Laborde RDSE For
Marc Laménie UMP Against
Élisabeth Lamure UMP Against
Gérard Larcher UMP Against
Serge Larcher SOC For
Jean-Jacques Lasserre UC Absent
Robert Laufoaulu UMP Against
Daniel Laurent UMP Absent
Pierre Laurent CRC For
Françoise Laurent-Perrigot SOC For
Gérard Le Cam CRC For
Jacky Le Menn SOC For
Michel Le Scouarnec CRC For
Alain Le Vern SOC For
Jean-René Lecerf UMP Abstention
Jean-Yves Leconte SOC For
Antoine Lefèvre UMP Against
Jacques Legendre UMP Absent
Jean-Pierre Leleux UMP Against
Jean-Claude Lenoir UMP Absent
Claudine Lepage SOC For
Jean-Claude Leroy SOC For
Philippe Leroy UMP Against
Valérie Létard UC Abstention
Marie-Noëlle Lienemann SOC For
Hélène Lipietz ECO Abstention
Gérard Longuet UMP Absent
Jeanny Lorgeoux SOC For
Jean-Louis Lorrain UMP Absent
Jean-Jacques Lozach SOC For
Roger Madec SOC For
Philippe Madrelle SOC For
Jacques-Bernard Magner SOC For
Michel Magras UMP Absent
François Marc SOC For
Philippe Marini UMP Against
Hervé Marseille UC Abstention
Pierre Martin UMP Absent
Marc Massion SOC For
Jean Louis Masson NI Abstention
Hervé Maurey UC Absent
Jean-François Mayet UMP Against
Stéphane Mazars RDSE For
Rachel Mazuir SOC For
Colette Mélot UMP For
Jean-Claude Merceron UC For
Michel Mercier UC Against
Michelle Meunier SOC For
Jacques Mézard RDSE For
Danielle Michel SOC For
Jean-Pierre Michel SOC For
Alain Milon UMP For
Gérard Miquel SOC For
Jean-Jacques Mirassou SOC For
Thani Mohamed Soilihi SOC For
Catherine Morin-Desailly UC Abstention
Philippe Nachbar UMP Absent
Christian Namy UC Against
Robert Navarro SOC For
Louis Nègre UMP Absent
Alain Néri SOC For
Renée Nicoux SOC For
Isabelle Pasquet CRC For
Jean-Marc Pastor SOC For
Georges Patient SOC For
François Patriat SOC For
Philippe Paul UMP Against
Daniel Percheron SOC For
Jean-Claude Peyronnet SOC For
Jackie Pierre UMP Abstention
François Pillet UMP Against
Xavier Pintat UMP Absent
Louis Pinton UMP Abstention
Bernard Piras SOC For
Jean-Vincent Placé ECO For
Jean-Pierre Plancade RDSE For
Rémy Pointereau UMP Against
Christian Poncelet UMP Against
Ladislas Poniatowski UMP Absent
Hugues Portelli UMP Against
Roland Povinelli SOC For
Yves Pozzo di Borgo UC Against
Sophie Primas UMP Absent
Gisèle Printz SOC For
Catherine Procaccia UMP For
Jean-Pierre Raffarin UMP Against
Marcel Rainaud SOC For
Daniel Raoul SOC For
François Rebsamen SOC For
André Reichardt UMP Absent
Daniel Reiner SOC For
Jean-Claude Requier RDSE For
Bruno Retailleau UMP Against
Charles Revet UMP Against
Alain Richard SOC For
Roland Ries SOC For
Gérard Roche UC For
Gilbert Roger SOC For
Yves Rome SOC For
Laurence Rossignol SOC For
Bernard Saugey UMP Abstention
René-Paul Savary UMP For
Michel Savin UMP Abstention
Patricia Schillinger SOC For
Mireille Schurch CRC For
Bruno Sido UMP Against
Esther Sittler UMP Against
Abdourahamane Soilihi UMP Absent
Jean-Pierre Sueur SOC For
Simon Sutour SOC For
Henri Tandonnet UC Against
Catherine Tasca SOC For
Michel Teston SOC For
René Teulade SOC For
Jean-Marc Todeschini SOC For
André Trillard UMP Against
Catherine Troendlé UMP Absent
Robert Tropeano RDSE For
François Trucy UMP For
Richard Tuheiava SOC For
Alex Türk NI Against
André Vairetto SOC For
Raymond Vall RDSE For
André Vallini SOC For
René Vandierendonck SOC For
Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe UC For
Yannick Vaugrenard SOC For
François Vendasi RDSE For
Hilarion Vendegou UMP Against
Paul Vergès CRC For
Michel Vergoz SOC For
René Vestri UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Vial UMP Against
Maurice Vincent SOC For
Dominique Watrin CRC For
Richard Yung SOC For
François Zocchetto UC Against