← All votes

Senate · vote no. 120 · · ✗ Rejected

La motion n° 953 présentée par Mmes Nicole Borvo Cohen-Seat, Marie-France Beaufils, Odette Terrade et les membres du groupe communiste républicain et citoyen, tendant à poser la question préalable au projet de loi, adopté par l'Assemblée nationale après déclaration d'urgence, de modernisation de l'économie

Type of vote
Roll-call vote
Voters
328
2 non-voting
Votes cast
230
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
116 votes
to be adopted

28 for 202 against 98 abstentions ▏threshold : 116 votes

In the Senate, “absent” means “did not take part in the vote”: a senator absent from the chamber may have had a colleague vote for them by proxy, which counts as a vote.

Colour by:
CRC — 23 SOC — 95 RDSE — 17 UC — 30 UMP — 159 NI — 6 CRCSOCRDSEUCUMP Éliane Assassi (CRC) — For François Autain (CRC) — For Marie-France Beaufils (CRC) — For Pierre Biarnès (CRC) — For Michel Billout (CRC) — For Nicole Borvo Cohen-Seat (CRC) — For Robert Bret (CRC) — For Jean-Claude Danglot (CRC) — For Annie David (CRC) — For Michelle Demessine (CRC) — For Évelyne Didier (CRC) — For Guy Fischer (CRC) — For Thierry Foucaud (CRC) — For Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin (CRC) — For Gélita Hoarau (CRC) — For Robert Hue (CRC) — For Gérard Le Cam (CRC) — For Josiane Mathon-Poinat (CRC) — For Jack Ralite (CRC) — For Ivan Renar (CRC) — For Odette Terrade (CRC) — For Bernard Vera (CRC) — For Jean-François Voguet (CRC) — For Jacqueline Alquier (SOC) — Abstention Michèle André (SOC) — Abstention Bernard Angels (SOC) — Abstention David Assouline (SOC) — Abstention Bertrand Auban (SOC) — Abstention Robert Badinter (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Bel (SOC) — Abstention Maryse Bergé-Lavigne (SOC) — Abstention Jean Besson (SOC) — Abstention Marie-Christine Blandin (SOC) — For Yannick Bodin (SOC) — Abstention Didier Boulaud (SOC) — Abstention Alima Boumediene-Thiery (SOC) — For Yolande Boyer (SOC) — Abstention Nicole Bricq (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Caffet (SOC) — Abstention Claire-Lise Campion (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Louis Carrère (SOC) — Abstention Bernard Cazeau (SOC) — Abstention Monique Cerisier-ben Guiga (SOC) — Abstention Gérard Collomb (SOC) — Abstention Pierre-Yves Collombat (SOC) — Abstention Roland Courteau (SOC) — Abstention Yves Dauge (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Demerliat (SOC) — Abstention Christiane Demontès (SOC) — Abstention Jean Desessard (SOC) — For Claude Domeizel (SOC) — Abstention Michel Dreyfus-Schmidt (SOC) — Abstention Josette Durrieu (SOC) — Abstention Bernard Dussaut (SOC) — Abstention Bernard Frimat (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Claude Frécon (SOC) — Abstention Charles Gautier (SOC) — Abstention Jacques Gillot (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Godefroy (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Noël Guérini (SOC) — Abstention Claude Haut (SOC) — Abstention Odette Herviaux (SOC) — Abstention Annie Jarraud-Vergnolle (SOC) — Abstention Charles Josselin (SOC) — Abstention Alain Journet (SOC) — Abstention Bariza Khiari (SOC) — Abstention Yves Krattinger (SOC) — Abstention Philippe Labeyrie (SOC) — Abstention Serge Lagauche (SOC) — Abstention Serge Larcher (SOC) — Abstention Louis Le Pensec (SOC) — Abstention Raymonde Le Texier (SOC) — Abstention Alain Le Vern (SOC) — Abstention André Lejeune (SOC) — Abstention Claude Lise (SOC) — Abstention Roger Madec (SOC) — Abstention Philippe Madrelle (SOC) — Abstention Jacques Mahéas (SOC) — Abstention François Marc (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Masseret (SOC) — Abstention Marc Massion (SOC) — Abstention Pierre Mauroy (SOC) — Abstention Louis Mermaz (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Michel (SOC) — Abstention Gérard Miquel (SOC) — Abstention Michel Moreigne (SOC) — Abstention Jacques Muller (SOC) — For Jean-Luc Mélenchon (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Marc Pastor (SOC) — Abstention Daniel Percheron (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Claude Peyronnet (SOC) — Abstention Jean-François Picheral (SOC) — Abstention Bernard Piras (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Plancade (SOC) — Abstention Gisèle Printz (SOC) — Abstention Marcel Rainaud (SOC) — Abstention Daniel Raoul (SOC) — Abstention Paul Raoult (SOC) — Abstention Daniel Reiner (SOC) — Abstention Thierry Repentin (SOC) — Abstention Roland Ries (SOC) — Abstention Gérard Roujas (SOC) — Abstention André Rouvière (SOC) — Abstention Michèle San Vicente-Baudrin (SOC) — Abstention Claude Saunier (SOC) — Abstention Patricia Schillinger (SOC) — Abstention Michel Sergent (SOC) — Abstention Jacques Siffre (SOC) — Abstention René-Pierre Signé (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Pierre Sueur (SOC) — Abstention Simon Sutour (SOC) — Abstention Catherine Tasca (SOC) — Abstention Michel Teston (SOC) — Abstention Jean-Marc Todeschini (SOC) — Abstention Robert Tropeano (SOC) — Abstention André Vantomme (SOC) — Abstention Dominique Voynet (SOC) — For Richard Yung (SOC) — Abstention Nicolas Alfonsi (RDSE) — Abstention Gilbert Barbier (RDSE) — Against Jean-Michel Baylet (RDSE) — Abstention André Boyer (RDSE) — Abstention Michel Charasse (RDSE) — Abstention Yvon Collin (RDSE) — Abstention Gérard Delfau (RDSE) — Abstention François Fortassin (RDSE) — Abstention Nathalie Goulet (RDSE) — Against Pierre Laffitte (RDSE) — Against Daniel Marsin (RDSE) — Against Georges Mouly (RDSE) — Against Georges Othily (RDSE) — Against Bernard Seillier (RDSE) — Against Michel Thiollière (RDSE) — Against François Vendasi (RDSE) — Abstention Aymeri de Montesquiou (RDSE) — Against Nicolas About (UC) — Against Jean-Paul Amoudry (UC) — Against Philippe Arnaud (UC) — Against Jean Arthuis (UC) — Against Denis Badré (UC) — Against Claude Biwer (UC) — Against Didier Borotra (UC) — Against Jean Boyer (UC) — Against Marcel Deneux (UC) — Against Muguette Dini (UC) — Against Daniel Dubois (UC) — Against Jean-Léonce Dupont (UC) — Against Yves Détraigne (UC) — Against Pierre Fauchon (UC) — Against Françoise Férat (UC) — Against Christian Gaudin (UC) — Against Adrien Giraud (UC) — Against Jacqueline Gourault (UC) — Against Jean-Jacques Jégou (UC) — Against Joseph Kergueris (UC) — Against Jean-Claude Merceron (UC) — Against Michel Mercier (UC) — Against Catherine Morin-Desailly (UC) — Against Philippe Nogrix (UC) — Against Anne-Marie Payet (UC) — Against Yves Pozzo di Borgo (UC) — Against Daniel Soulage (UC) — Against André Vallet (UC) — Against Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe (UC) — Against François Zocchetto (UC) — Against Jean-Paul Alduy (UMP) — Against Pierre André (UMP) — Against Gérard Bailly (UMP) — Against José Balarello (UMP) — Against Bernard Barraux (UMP) — Against René Beaumont (UMP) — Against Claude Belot (UMP) — Against Pierre Bernard-Reymond (UMP) — Against Roger Besse (UMP) — Against Joël Billard (UMP) — Against Jean Bizet (UMP) — Against Jacques Blanc (UMP) — Against Paul Blanc (UMP) — Against Pierre Bordier (UMP) — Against Joël Bourdin (UMP) — Against Brigitte Bout (UMP) — Against Jean-Guy Branger (UMP) — Against Dominique Braye (UMP) — Against Paulette Brisepierre (UMP) — Against Elie Brun (UMP) — Against François-Noël Buffet (UMP) — Against Michel Bécot (UMP) — Against Laurent Béteille (UMP) — Against Christian Cambon (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Cantegrit (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Carle (UMP) — Against Auguste Cazalet (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Chauveau (UMP) — Against Marcel-Pierre Cléach (UMP) — Against Christian Cointat (UMP) — Against Gérard Cornu (UMP) — Against Raymond Couderc (UMP) — Against Jean-Patrick Courtois (UMP) — Against Gérard César (UMP) — Against Philippe Dallier (UMP) — Against Serge Dassault (UMP) — Against Isabelle Debré (UMP) — Against Christian Demuynck (UMP) — Against Béatrice Descamps (UMP) — Against Denis Detcheverry (UMP) — Against Éric Doligé (UMP) — Against Philippe Dominati (UMP) — Against Michel Doublet (UMP) — Against Alain Dufaut (UMP) — Against André Dulait (UMP) — Against Catherine Dumas (UMP) — Against Ambroise Dupont (UMP) — Against Bernadette Dupont (UMP) — Against Louis Duvernois (UMP) — Against Gérard Dériot (UMP) — Against Michel Esneu (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Etienne (UMP) — Against Jean Faure (UMP) — Against André Ferrand (UMP) — Against Gaston Flosse (UMP) — Against Alain Fouché (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Fourcade (UMP) — Against Bernard Fournier (UMP) — Against Jean François-Poncet (UMP) — Against Yves Fréville (UMP) — Against Yann Gaillard (UMP) — Against René Garrec (UMP) — Against Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam (UMP) — Against Jean-Claude Gaudin (UMP) — Against Gisèle Gautier (UMP) — Against Jacques Gautier (UMP) — Against François Gerbaud (UMP) — Against Charles Ginésy (UMP) — Against Francis Giraud (UMP) — Against Paul Girod (UMP) — Against Alain Gournac (UMP) — Against Adrien Gouteyron (UMP) — Non-voting Francis Grignon (UMP) — Against Louis Grillot (UMP) — Against Georges Gruillot (UMP) — Against Charles Guené (UMP) — Against Michel Guerry (UMP) — Against Patrice Gélard (UMP) — Against Alain Gérard (UMP) — Against Hubert Haenel (UMP) — Against Françoise Henneron (UMP) — Against Marie-Thérèse Hermange (UMP) — Against Michel Houel (UMP) — Against Jean-François Humbert (UMP) — Against Christiane Hummel (UMP) — Against Benoît Huré (UMP) — Against Jean-Jacques Hyest (UMP) — Against Pierre Hérisson (UMP) — Against Soibahadine Ibrahim Ramadani (UMP) — Against Pierre Jarlier (UMP) — Against Jean-Marc Juilhard (UMP) — Against Christiane Kammermann (UMP) — Against Fabienne Keller (UMP) — Against Alain Lambert (UMP) — Against Élisabeth Lamure (UMP) — Against Marc Laménie (UMP) — Against Gérard Larcher (UMP) — Against André Lardeux (UMP) — Against Robert Laufoaulu (UMP) — Against Jean-François Le Grand (UMP) — Against Jean-René Lecerf (UMP) — Against Dominique Leclerc (UMP) — Against Jacques Legendre (UMP) — Against Philippe Leroy (UMP) — Against Gérard Longuet (UMP) — Against Simon Loueckhote (UMP) — Against Lucienne Malovry (UMP) — Against Philippe Marini (UMP) — Against Pierre Martin (UMP) — Against Lucette Michaux-Chevry (UMP) — Against Alain Milon (UMP) — Against Jean-Luc Miraux (UMP) — Against Dominique Mortemousque (UMP) — Against Bernard Murat (UMP) — Against Colette Mélot (UMP) — Against Philippe Nachbar (UMP) — Against Jacqueline Panis (UMP) — Against Monique Papon (UMP) — Against Charles Pasqua (UMP) — Against Jacques Peyrat (UMP) — Against Jackie Pierre (UMP) — Against François Pillet (UMP) — Against Xavier Pintat (UMP) — Against Louis Pinton (UMP) — Against Rémy Pointereau (UMP) — Against Christian Poncelet (UMP) — Absent Ladislas Poniatowski (UMP) — Against Hugues Portelli (UMP) — Against Catherine Procaccia (UMP) — Against Jean Puech (UMP) — Against Jean Pépin (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Raffarin (UMP) — Against Charles Revet (UMP) — Against Henri Revol (UMP) — Against Philippe Richert (UMP) — Against Yves Rispat (UMP) — Against Roger Romani (UMP) — Against Janine Rozier (UMP) — Against Bernard Saugey (UMP) — Against Bruno Sido (UMP) — Against Esther Sittler (UMP) — Against Louis Souvet (UMP) — Against Yannick Texier (UMP) — Against Henri Torre (UMP) — Against André Trillard (UMP) — Against Catherine Troendlé (UMP) — Against François Trucy (UMP) — Against Jacques Valade (UMP) — Against Alain Vasselle (UMP) — Against Jean-Pierre Vial (UMP) — Against Jean-Paul Virapoullé (UMP) — Against Louis de Broissia (UMP) — Against Henri de Raincourt (UMP) — Against Henri de Richemont (UMP) — Against Josselin de Rohan (UMP) — Against Robert del Picchia (UMP) — Against Roland du Luart (UMP) — Against Jean-Paul Émin (UMP) — Against Jean-Paul Émorine (UMP) — Against Philippe Adnot (NI) — Against Philippe Darniche (NI) — Against Sylvie Desmarescaux (NI) — Against Jean Louis Masson (NI) — Against Bruno Retailleau (NI) — Against Alex Türk (NI) — Against

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
CRC 2300 0023
SOC 5090 0095
RDSE 098 0017
UC 0300 0030
UMP 01570 11159
NI 060 006

All senators

SenatorGroupVote
Nicolas About UC Against
Philippe Adnot NI Against
Jean-Paul Alduy UMP Against
Nicolas Alfonsi RDSE Abstention
Jacqueline Alquier SOC Abstention
Jean-Paul Amoudry UC Against
Michèle André SOC Abstention
Pierre André UMP Against
Bernard Angels SOC Abstention
Philippe Arnaud UC Against
Jean Arthuis UC Against
Éliane Assassi CRC For
David Assouline SOC Abstention
Bertrand Auban SOC Abstention
François Autain CRC For
Robert Badinter SOC Abstention
Denis Badré UC Against
Gérard Bailly UMP Against
José Balarello UMP Against
Gilbert Barbier RDSE Against
Bernard Barraux UMP Against
Jean-Michel Baylet RDSE Abstention
Marie-France Beaufils CRC For
René Beaumont UMP Against
Michel Bécot UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Bel SOC Abstention
Claude Belot UMP Against
Maryse Bergé-Lavigne SOC Abstention
Pierre Bernard-Reymond UMP Against
Roger Besse UMP Against
Jean Besson SOC Abstention
Laurent Béteille UMP Against
Pierre Biarnès CRC For
Joël Billard UMP Against
Michel Billout CRC For
Claude Biwer UC Against
Jean Bizet UMP Against
Jacques Blanc UMP Against
Paul Blanc UMP Against
Marie-Christine Blandin SOC For
Yannick Bodin SOC Abstention
Pierre Bordier UMP Against
Didier Borotra UC Against
Nicole Borvo Cohen-Seat CRC For
Didier Boulaud SOC Abstention
Alima Boumediene-Thiery SOC For
Joël Bourdin UMP Against
Brigitte Bout UMP Against
André Boyer RDSE Abstention
Jean Boyer UC Against
Yolande Boyer SOC Abstention
Jean-Guy Branger UMP Against
Dominique Braye UMP Against
Robert Bret CRC For
Nicole Bricq SOC Abstention
Paulette Brisepierre UMP Against
Elie Brun UMP Against
François-Noël Buffet UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Caffet SOC Abstention
Christian Cambon UMP Against
Claire-Lise Campion SOC Abstention
Jean-Pierre Cantegrit UMP Against
Jean-Claude Carle UMP Against
Jean-Louis Carrère SOC Abstention
Auguste Cazalet UMP Against
Bernard Cazeau SOC Abstention
Monique Cerisier-ben Guiga SOC Abstention
Gérard César UMP Against
Michel Charasse RDSE Abstention
Jean-Pierre Chauveau UMP Against
Marcel-Pierre Cléach UMP Against
Christian Cointat UMP Against
Yvon Collin RDSE Abstention
Gérard Collomb SOC Abstention
Pierre-Yves Collombat SOC Abstention
Gérard Cornu UMP Against
Raymond Couderc UMP Against
Roland Courteau SOC Abstention
Jean-Patrick Courtois UMP Against
Philippe Dallier UMP Against
Jean-Claude Danglot CRC For
Philippe Darniche NI Against
Serge Dassault UMP Against
Yves Dauge SOC Abstention
Annie David CRC For
Louis de Broissia UMP Against
Aymeri de Montesquiou RDSE Against
Henri de Raincourt UMP Against
Henri de Richemont UMP Against
Josselin de Rohan UMP Against
Isabelle Debré UMP Against
Robert del Picchia UMP Against
Gérard Delfau RDSE Abstention
Jean-Pierre Demerliat SOC Abstention
Michelle Demessine CRC For
Christiane Demontès SOC Abstention
Christian Demuynck UMP Against
Marcel Deneux UC Against
Gérard Dériot UMP Against
Béatrice Descamps UMP Against
Jean Desessard SOC For
Sylvie Desmarescaux NI Against
Denis Detcheverry UMP Against
Yves Détraigne UC Against
Évelyne Didier CRC For
Muguette Dini UC Against
Éric Doligé UMP Against
Claude Domeizel SOC Abstention
Philippe Dominati UMP Against
Michel Doublet UMP Against
Michel Dreyfus-Schmidt SOC Abstention
Roland du Luart UMP Against
Daniel Dubois UC Against
Alain Dufaut UMP Against
André Dulait UMP Against
Catherine Dumas UMP Against
Ambroise Dupont UMP Against
Bernadette Dupont UMP Against
Jean-Léonce Dupont UC Against
Josette Durrieu SOC Abstention
Bernard Dussaut SOC Abstention
Louis Duvernois UMP Against
Jean-Paul Émin UMP Against
Jean-Paul Émorine UMP Against
Michel Esneu UMP Against
Jean-Claude Etienne UMP Against
Pierre Fauchon UC Against
Jean Faure UMP Against
Françoise Férat UC Against
André Ferrand UMP Against
Guy Fischer CRC For
Gaston Flosse UMP Against
François Fortassin RDSE Abstention
Thierry Foucaud CRC For
Alain Fouché UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Fourcade UMP Against
Bernard Fournier UMP Against
Jean François-Poncet UMP Against
Jean-Claude Frécon SOC Abstention
Yves Fréville UMP Against
Bernard Frimat SOC Abstention
Yann Gaillard UMP Against
René Garrec UMP Against
Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam UMP Against
Christian Gaudin UC Against
Jean-Claude Gaudin UMP Against
Charles Gautier SOC Abstention
Gisèle Gautier UMP Against
Jacques Gautier UMP Against
Patrice Gélard UMP Against
Alain Gérard UMP Against
François Gerbaud UMP Against
Jacques Gillot SOC Abstention
Charles Ginésy UMP Against
Adrien Giraud UC Against
Francis Giraud UMP Against
Paul Girod UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Godefroy SOC Abstention
Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin CRC For
Nathalie Goulet RDSE Against
Jacqueline Gourault UC Against
Alain Gournac UMP Against
Adrien Gouteyron UMP Non-voting
Francis Grignon UMP Against
Louis Grillot UMP Against
Georges Gruillot UMP Against
Charles Guené UMP Against
Jean-Noël Guérini SOC Abstention
Michel Guerry UMP Against
Hubert Haenel UMP Against
Claude Haut SOC Abstention
Françoise Henneron UMP Against
Pierre Hérisson UMP Against
Marie-Thérèse Hermange UMP Against
Odette Herviaux SOC Abstention
Gélita Hoarau CRC For
Michel Houel UMP Against
Robert Hue CRC For
Jean-François Humbert UMP Against
Christiane Hummel UMP Against
Benoît Huré UMP Against
Jean-Jacques Hyest UMP Against
Soibahadine Ibrahim Ramadani UMP Against
Pierre Jarlier UMP Against
Annie Jarraud-Vergnolle SOC Abstention
Jean-Jacques Jégou UC Against
Charles Josselin SOC Abstention
Alain Journet SOC Abstention
Jean-Marc Juilhard UMP Against
Christiane Kammermann UMP Against
Fabienne Keller UMP Against
Joseph Kergueris UC Against
Bariza Khiari SOC Abstention
Yves Krattinger SOC Abstention
Philippe Labeyrie SOC Abstention
Pierre Laffitte RDSE Against
Serge Lagauche SOC Abstention
Alain Lambert UMP Against
Marc Laménie UMP Against
Élisabeth Lamure UMP Against
Gérard Larcher UMP Against
Serge Larcher SOC Abstention
André Lardeux UMP Against
Robert Laufoaulu UMP Against
Gérard Le Cam CRC For
Jean-François Le Grand UMP Against
Louis Le Pensec SOC Abstention
Raymonde Le Texier SOC Abstention
Alain Le Vern SOC Abstention
Jean-René Lecerf UMP Against
Dominique Leclerc UMP Against
Jacques Legendre UMP Against
André Lejeune SOC Abstention
Philippe Leroy UMP Against
Claude Lise SOC Abstention
Gérard Longuet UMP Against
Simon Loueckhote UMP Against
Roger Madec SOC Abstention
Philippe Madrelle SOC Abstention
Jacques Mahéas SOC Abstention
Lucienne Malovry UMP Against
François Marc SOC Abstention
Philippe Marini UMP Against
Daniel Marsin RDSE Against
Pierre Martin UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Masseret SOC Abstention
Marc Massion SOC Abstention
Jean Louis Masson NI Against
Josiane Mathon-Poinat CRC For
Pierre Mauroy SOC Abstention
Jean-Luc Mélenchon SOC Abstention
Colette Mélot UMP Against
Jean-Claude Merceron UC Against
Michel Mercier UC Against
Louis Mermaz SOC Abstention
Lucette Michaux-Chevry UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Michel SOC Abstention
Alain Milon UMP Against
Gérard Miquel SOC Abstention
Jean-Luc Miraux UMP Against
Michel Moreigne SOC Abstention
Catherine Morin-Desailly UC Against
Dominique Mortemousque UMP Against
Georges Mouly RDSE Against
Jacques Muller SOC For
Bernard Murat UMP Against
Philippe Nachbar UMP Against
Philippe Nogrix UC Against
Georges Othily RDSE Against
Jacqueline Panis UMP Against
Monique Papon UMP Against
Charles Pasqua UMP Against
Jean-Marc Pastor SOC Abstention
Anne-Marie Payet UC Against
Jean Pépin UMP Against
Daniel Percheron SOC Abstention
Jacques Peyrat UMP Against
Jean-Claude Peyronnet SOC Abstention
Jean-François Picheral SOC Abstention
Jackie Pierre UMP Against
François Pillet UMP Against
Xavier Pintat UMP Against
Louis Pinton UMP Against
Bernard Piras SOC Abstention
Jean-Pierre Plancade SOC Abstention
Rémy Pointereau UMP Against
Christian Poncelet UMP Absent
Ladislas Poniatowski UMP Against
Hugues Portelli UMP Against
Yves Pozzo di Borgo UC Against
Gisèle Printz SOC Abstention
Catherine Procaccia UMP Against
Jean Puech UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Raffarin UMP Against
Marcel Rainaud SOC Abstention
Jack Ralite CRC For
Daniel Raoul SOC Abstention
Paul Raoult SOC Abstention
Daniel Reiner SOC Abstention
Ivan Renar CRC For
Thierry Repentin SOC Abstention
Bruno Retailleau NI Against
Charles Revet UMP Against
Henri Revol UMP Against
Philippe Richert UMP Against
Roland Ries SOC Abstention
Yves Rispat UMP Against
Roger Romani UMP Against
Gérard Roujas SOC Abstention
André Rouvière SOC Abstention
Janine Rozier UMP Against
Michèle San Vicente-Baudrin SOC Abstention
Bernard Saugey UMP Against
Claude Saunier SOC Abstention
Patricia Schillinger SOC Abstention
Bernard Seillier RDSE Against
Michel Sergent SOC Abstention
Bruno Sido UMP Against
Jacques Siffre SOC Abstention
René-Pierre Signé SOC Abstention
Esther Sittler UMP Against
Daniel Soulage UC Against
Louis Souvet UMP Against
Jean-Pierre Sueur SOC Abstention
Simon Sutour SOC Abstention
Catherine Tasca SOC Abstention
Odette Terrade CRC For
Michel Teston SOC Abstention
Yannick Texier UMP Against
Michel Thiollière RDSE Against
Jean-Marc Todeschini SOC Abstention
Henri Torre UMP Against
André Trillard UMP Against
Catherine Troendlé UMP Against
Robert Tropeano SOC Abstention
François Trucy UMP Against
Alex Türk NI Against
Jacques Valade UMP Against
André Vallet UC Against
Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe UC Against
André Vantomme SOC Abstention
Alain Vasselle UMP Against
François Vendasi RDSE Abstention
Bernard Vera CRC For
Jean-Pierre Vial UMP Against
Jean-Paul Virapoullé UMP Against
Jean-François Voguet CRC For
Dominique Voynet SOC For
Richard Yung SOC Abstention
François Zocchetto UC Against