← All votes

Senate · vote no. 101 · · ✓ Adopted

L'amendement n° 96, présenté par M. Jean-Jacques Hyest,au nom de la commission des Lois, à l'article 1er du projet de loi constitutionnelle, adopté par l'Assemblée nationale, de modernisation des institutions de la Ve République

Type of vote
Roll-call vote
Voters
328
2 non-voting
Votes cast
327
for + against (excluding abstentions)
Majority required
164 votes
to be adopted

171 for 156 against 1 abstention ▏threshold : 164 votes

In the Senate, “absent” means “did not take part in the vote”: a senator absent from the chamber may have had a colleague vote for them by proxy, which counts as a vote.

Colour by:
CRC — 23 SOC — 95 RDSE — 17 UC — 30 UMP — 159 NI — 6 CRCSOCRDSEUCUMP Éliane Assassi (CRC) — Against François Autain (CRC) — Against Marie-France Beaufils (CRC) — Against Pierre Biarnès (CRC) — Against Michel Billout (CRC) — Against Nicole Borvo Cohen-Seat (CRC) — Against Robert Bret (CRC) — Against Jean-Claude Danglot (CRC) — Against Annie David (CRC) — Against Michelle Demessine (CRC) — Against Évelyne Didier (CRC) — Against Guy Fischer (CRC) — Against Thierry Foucaud (CRC) — Against Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin (CRC) — Against Gélita Hoarau (CRC) — Against Robert Hue (CRC) — Against Gérard Le Cam (CRC) — Against Josiane Mathon-Poinat (CRC) — Against Jack Ralite (CRC) — Against Ivan Renar (CRC) — Against Odette Terrade (CRC) — Against Bernard Vera (CRC) — Against Jean-François Voguet (CRC) — Against Jacqueline Alquier (SOC) — Against Michèle André (SOC) — Against Bernard Angels (SOC) — Against David Assouline (SOC) — Against Bertrand Auban (SOC) — Against Robert Badinter (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Bel (SOC) — Against Maryse Bergé-Lavigne (SOC) — Against Jean Besson (SOC) — Against Marie-Christine Blandin (SOC) — Against Yannick Bodin (SOC) — Against Didier Boulaud (SOC) — Against Alima Boumediene-Thiery (SOC) — Against Yolande Boyer (SOC) — Against Nicole Bricq (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Caffet (SOC) — Against Claire-Lise Campion (SOC) — Against Jean-Louis Carrère (SOC) — Against Bernard Cazeau (SOC) — Against Monique Cerisier-ben Guiga (SOC) — Against Gérard Collomb (SOC) — Against Pierre-Yves Collombat (SOC) — Against Roland Courteau (SOC) — Against Yves Dauge (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Demerliat (SOC) — Against Christiane Demontès (SOC) — Against Jean Desessard (SOC) — Against Claude Domeizel (SOC) — Against Michel Dreyfus-Schmidt (SOC) — Against Josette Durrieu (SOC) — Against Bernard Dussaut (SOC) — Against Bernard Frimat (SOC) — Against Jean-Claude Frécon (SOC) — Against Charles Gautier (SOC) — Against Jacques Gillot (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Godefroy (SOC) — Against Jean-Noël Guérini (SOC) — Against Claude Haut (SOC) — Against Odette Herviaux (SOC) — Against Annie Jarraud-Vergnolle (SOC) — Against Charles Josselin (SOC) — Against Alain Journet (SOC) — Against Bariza Khiari (SOC) — Against Yves Krattinger (SOC) — Against Philippe Labeyrie (SOC) — Against Serge Lagauche (SOC) — Against Serge Larcher (SOC) — Against Louis Le Pensec (SOC) — Against Raymonde Le Texier (SOC) — Against Alain Le Vern (SOC) — Against André Lejeune (SOC) — Against Claude Lise (SOC) — Against Roger Madec (SOC) — Against Philippe Madrelle (SOC) — Against Jacques Mahéas (SOC) — Against François Marc (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Masseret (SOC) — Against Marc Massion (SOC) — Against Pierre Mauroy (SOC) — Against Louis Mermaz (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Michel (SOC) — Against Gérard Miquel (SOC) — Against Michel Moreigne (SOC) — Against Jacques Muller (SOC) — Against Jean-Luc Mélenchon (SOC) — Against Jean-Marc Pastor (SOC) — Against Daniel Percheron (SOC) — Against Jean-Claude Peyronnet (SOC) — Against Jean-François Picheral (SOC) — Against Bernard Piras (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Plancade (SOC) — Against Gisèle Printz (SOC) — Against Marcel Rainaud (SOC) — Against Daniel Raoul (SOC) — Against Paul Raoult (SOC) — Against Daniel Reiner (SOC) — Against Thierry Repentin (SOC) — Against Roland Ries (SOC) — Against Gérard Roujas (SOC) — Against André Rouvière (SOC) — Against Michèle San Vicente-Baudrin (SOC) — Against Claude Saunier (SOC) — Against Patricia Schillinger (SOC) — Against Michel Sergent (SOC) — Against Jacques Siffre (SOC) — Against René-Pierre Signé (SOC) — Against Jean-Pierre Sueur (SOC) — Against Simon Sutour (SOC) — Against Catherine Tasca (SOC) — Against Michel Teston (SOC) — Against Jean-Marc Todeschini (SOC) — Against Robert Tropeano (SOC) — Against André Vantomme (SOC) — Against Dominique Voynet (SOC) — Against Richard Yung (SOC) — Against Nicolas Alfonsi (RDSE) — Against Gilbert Barbier (RDSE) — For Jean-Michel Baylet (RDSE) — Against André Boyer (RDSE) — Against Michel Charasse (RDSE) — Against Yvon Collin (RDSE) — Against Gérard Delfau (RDSE) — Against François Fortassin (RDSE) — Against Nathalie Goulet (RDSE) — For Pierre Laffitte (RDSE) — For Daniel Marsin (RDSE) — For Georges Mouly (RDSE) — For Georges Othily (RDSE) — For Bernard Seillier (RDSE) — For Michel Thiollière (RDSE) — For François Vendasi (RDSE) — Against Aymeri de Montesquiou (RDSE) — For Nicolas About (UC) — Against Jean-Paul Amoudry (UC) — Against Philippe Arnaud (UC) — Against Jean Arthuis (UC) — Against Denis Badré (UC) — Against Claude Biwer (UC) — Against Didier Borotra (UC) — Against Jean Boyer (UC) — Against Marcel Deneux (UC) — Against Muguette Dini (UC) — Against Daniel Dubois (UC) — Against Jean-Léonce Dupont (UC) — Against Yves Détraigne (UC) — Against Pierre Fauchon (UC) — Against Françoise Férat (UC) — Against Christian Gaudin (UC) — Against Adrien Giraud (UC) — Against Jacqueline Gourault (UC) — Against Jean-Jacques Jégou (UC) — Against Joseph Kergueris (UC) — Against Jean-Claude Merceron (UC) — Against Michel Mercier (UC) — Against Catherine Morin-Desailly (UC) — Against Philippe Nogrix (UC) — Against Anne-Marie Payet (UC) — Against Yves Pozzo di Borgo (UC) — Against Daniel Soulage (UC) — Against André Vallet (UC) — Against Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe (UC) — Against François Zocchetto (UC) — Against Jean-Paul Alduy (UMP) — For Pierre André (UMP) — For Gérard Bailly (UMP) — For José Balarello (UMP) — For Bernard Barraux (UMP) — For René Beaumont (UMP) — For Claude Belot (UMP) — For Pierre Bernard-Reymond (UMP) — For Roger Besse (UMP) — For Joël Billard (UMP) — For Jean Bizet (UMP) — For Jacques Blanc (UMP) — For Paul Blanc (UMP) — For Pierre Bordier (UMP) — For Joël Bourdin (UMP) — For Brigitte Bout (UMP) — For Jean-Guy Branger (UMP) — For Dominique Braye (UMP) — For Paulette Brisepierre (UMP) — For Elie Brun (UMP) — For François-Noël Buffet (UMP) — For Michel Bécot (UMP) — For Laurent Béteille (UMP) — For Christian Cambon (UMP) — For Jean-Pierre Cantegrit (UMP) — For Jean-Claude Carle (UMP) — For Auguste Cazalet (UMP) — For Jean-Pierre Chauveau (UMP) — For Marcel-Pierre Cléach (UMP) — For Christian Cointat (UMP) — For Gérard Cornu (UMP) — For Raymond Couderc (UMP) — For Jean-Patrick Courtois (UMP) — For Gérard César (UMP) — For Philippe Dallier (UMP) — For Serge Dassault (UMP) — For Isabelle Debré (UMP) — For Christian Demuynck (UMP) — For Béatrice Descamps (UMP) — For Denis Detcheverry (UMP) — For Éric Doligé (UMP) — For Philippe Dominati (UMP) — For Michel Doublet (UMP) — For Alain Dufaut (UMP) — For André Dulait (UMP) — For Catherine Dumas (UMP) — For Ambroise Dupont (UMP) — For Bernadette Dupont (UMP) — For Louis Duvernois (UMP) — For Gérard Dériot (UMP) — For Michel Esneu (UMP) — For Jean-Claude Etienne (UMP) — For Jean Faure (UMP) — For André Ferrand (UMP) — For Gaston Flosse (UMP) — For Alain Fouché (UMP) — For Jean-Pierre Fourcade (UMP) — For Bernard Fournier (UMP) — For Jean François-Poncet (UMP) — For Yves Fréville (UMP) — For Yann Gaillard (UMP) — For René Garrec (UMP) — For Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam (UMP) — For Jean-Claude Gaudin (UMP) — For Gisèle Gautier (UMP) — For Jacques Gautier (UMP) — For François Gerbaud (UMP) — For Charles Ginésy (UMP) — For Francis Giraud (UMP) — For Paul Girod (UMP) — For Alain Gournac (UMP) — For Adrien Gouteyron (UMP) — For Francis Grignon (UMP) — For Louis Grillot (UMP) — For Georges Gruillot (UMP) — For Charles Guené (UMP) — For Michel Guerry (UMP) — For Patrice Gélard (UMP) — For Alain Gérard (UMP) — For Hubert Haenel (UMP) — For Françoise Henneron (UMP) — For Marie-Thérèse Hermange (UMP) — For Michel Houel (UMP) — For Jean-François Humbert (UMP) — For Christiane Hummel (UMP) — For Benoît Huré (UMP) — For Jean-Jacques Hyest (UMP) — For Pierre Hérisson (UMP) — For Soibahadine Ibrahim Ramadani (UMP) — For Pierre Jarlier (UMP) — For Jean-Marc Juilhard (UMP) — For Christiane Kammermann (UMP) — For Fabienne Keller (UMP) — For Alain Lambert (UMP) — For Élisabeth Lamure (UMP) — For Marc Laménie (UMP) — For Gérard Larcher (UMP) — For André Lardeux (UMP) — For Robert Laufoaulu (UMP) — For Jean-François Le Grand (UMP) — For Jean-René Lecerf (UMP) — For Dominique Leclerc (UMP) — For Jacques Legendre (UMP) — For Philippe Leroy (UMP) — For Gérard Longuet (UMP) — For Simon Loueckhote (UMP) — For Lucienne Malovry (UMP) — For Philippe Marini (UMP) — For Pierre Martin (UMP) — For Lucette Michaux-Chevry (UMP) — For Alain Milon (UMP) — For Jean-Luc Miraux (UMP) — For Dominique Mortemousque (UMP) — For Bernard Murat (UMP) — For Colette Mélot (UMP) — For Philippe Nachbar (UMP) — For Jacqueline Panis (UMP) — For Monique Papon (UMP) — For Charles Pasqua (UMP) — For Jacques Peyrat (UMP) — For Jackie Pierre (UMP) — For François Pillet (UMP) — For Xavier Pintat (UMP) — For Louis Pinton (UMP) — For Rémy Pointereau (UMP) — For Christian Poncelet (UMP) — Absent Ladislas Poniatowski (UMP) — For Hugues Portelli (UMP) — For Catherine Procaccia (UMP) — For Jean Puech (UMP) — For Jean Pépin (UMP) — For Jean-Pierre Raffarin (UMP) — For Charles Revet (UMP) — For Henri Revol (UMP) — For Philippe Richert (UMP) — Non-voting Yves Rispat (UMP) — For Roger Romani (UMP) — For Janine Rozier (UMP) — For Bernard Saugey (UMP) — For Bruno Sido (UMP) — For Esther Sittler (UMP) — For Louis Souvet (UMP) — For Yannick Texier (UMP) — For Henri Torre (UMP) — For André Trillard (UMP) — For Catherine Troendlé (UMP) — For François Trucy (UMP) — For Jacques Valade (UMP) — For Alain Vasselle (UMP) — For Jean-Pierre Vial (UMP) — For Jean-Paul Virapoullé (UMP) — For Louis de Broissia (UMP) — For Henri de Raincourt (UMP) — For Henri de Richemont (UMP) — For Josselin de Rohan (UMP) — For Robert del Picchia (UMP) — For Roland du Luart (UMP) — For Jean-Paul Émin (UMP) — For Jean-Paul Émorine (UMP) — For Philippe Adnot (NI) — For Philippe Darniche (NI) — For Sylvie Desmarescaux (NI) — For Jean Louis Masson (NI) — Abstention Bruno Retailleau (NI) — For Alex Türk (NI) — For

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
CRC 0230 0023
SOC 0950 0095
RDSE 980 0017
UC 0300 0030
UMP 15700 11159
NI 501 006

All senators

SenatorGroupVote
Nicolas About UC Against
Philippe Adnot NI For
Jean-Paul Alduy UMP For
Nicolas Alfonsi RDSE Against
Jacqueline Alquier SOC Against
Jean-Paul Amoudry UC Against
Michèle André SOC Against
Pierre André UMP For
Bernard Angels SOC Against
Philippe Arnaud UC Against
Jean Arthuis UC Against
Éliane Assassi CRC Against
David Assouline SOC Against
Bertrand Auban SOC Against
François Autain CRC Against
Robert Badinter SOC Against
Denis Badré UC Against
Gérard Bailly UMP For
José Balarello UMP For
Gilbert Barbier RDSE For
Bernard Barraux UMP For
Jean-Michel Baylet RDSE Against
Marie-France Beaufils CRC Against
René Beaumont UMP For
Michel Bécot UMP For
Jean-Pierre Bel SOC Against
Claude Belot UMP For
Maryse Bergé-Lavigne SOC Against
Pierre Bernard-Reymond UMP For
Roger Besse UMP For
Jean Besson SOC Against
Laurent Béteille UMP For
Pierre Biarnès CRC Against
Joël Billard UMP For
Michel Billout CRC Against
Claude Biwer UC Against
Jean Bizet UMP For
Jacques Blanc UMP For
Paul Blanc UMP For
Marie-Christine Blandin SOC Against
Yannick Bodin SOC Against
Pierre Bordier UMP For
Didier Borotra UC Against
Nicole Borvo Cohen-Seat CRC Against
Didier Boulaud SOC Against
Alima Boumediene-Thiery SOC Against
Joël Bourdin UMP For
Brigitte Bout UMP For
André Boyer RDSE Against
Jean Boyer UC Against
Yolande Boyer SOC Against
Jean-Guy Branger UMP For
Dominique Braye UMP For
Robert Bret CRC Against
Nicole Bricq SOC Against
Paulette Brisepierre UMP For
Elie Brun UMP For
François-Noël Buffet UMP For
Jean-Pierre Caffet SOC Against
Christian Cambon UMP For
Claire-Lise Campion SOC Against
Jean-Pierre Cantegrit UMP For
Jean-Claude Carle UMP For
Jean-Louis Carrère SOC Against
Auguste Cazalet UMP For
Bernard Cazeau SOC Against
Monique Cerisier-ben Guiga SOC Against
Gérard César UMP For
Michel Charasse RDSE Against
Jean-Pierre Chauveau UMP For
Marcel-Pierre Cléach UMP For
Christian Cointat UMP For
Yvon Collin RDSE Against
Gérard Collomb SOC Against
Pierre-Yves Collombat SOC Against
Gérard Cornu UMP For
Raymond Couderc UMP For
Roland Courteau SOC Against
Jean-Patrick Courtois UMP For
Philippe Dallier UMP For
Jean-Claude Danglot CRC Against
Philippe Darniche NI For
Serge Dassault UMP For
Yves Dauge SOC Against
Annie David CRC Against
Louis de Broissia UMP For
Aymeri de Montesquiou RDSE For
Henri de Raincourt UMP For
Henri de Richemont UMP For
Josselin de Rohan UMP For
Isabelle Debré UMP For
Robert del Picchia UMP For
Gérard Delfau RDSE Against
Jean-Pierre Demerliat SOC Against
Michelle Demessine CRC Against
Christiane Demontès SOC Against
Christian Demuynck UMP For
Marcel Deneux UC Against
Gérard Dériot UMP For
Béatrice Descamps UMP For
Jean Desessard SOC Against
Sylvie Desmarescaux NI For
Denis Detcheverry UMP For
Yves Détraigne UC Against
Évelyne Didier CRC Against
Muguette Dini UC Against
Éric Doligé UMP For
Claude Domeizel SOC Against
Philippe Dominati UMP For
Michel Doublet UMP For
Michel Dreyfus-Schmidt SOC Against
Roland du Luart UMP For
Daniel Dubois UC Against
Alain Dufaut UMP For
André Dulait UMP For
Catherine Dumas UMP For
Ambroise Dupont UMP For
Bernadette Dupont UMP For
Jean-Léonce Dupont UC Against
Josette Durrieu SOC Against
Bernard Dussaut SOC Against
Louis Duvernois UMP For
Jean-Paul Émin UMP For
Jean-Paul Émorine UMP For
Michel Esneu UMP For
Jean-Claude Etienne UMP For
Pierre Fauchon UC Against
Jean Faure UMP For
Françoise Férat UC Against
André Ferrand UMP For
Guy Fischer CRC Against
Gaston Flosse UMP For
François Fortassin RDSE Against
Thierry Foucaud CRC Against
Alain Fouché UMP For
Jean-Pierre Fourcade UMP For
Bernard Fournier UMP For
Jean François-Poncet UMP For
Jean-Claude Frécon SOC Against
Yves Fréville UMP For
Bernard Frimat SOC Against
Yann Gaillard UMP For
René Garrec UMP For
Joëlle Garriaud-Maylam UMP For
Christian Gaudin UC Against
Jean-Claude Gaudin UMP For
Charles Gautier SOC Against
Gisèle Gautier UMP For
Jacques Gautier UMP For
Patrice Gélard UMP For
Alain Gérard UMP For
François Gerbaud UMP For
Jacques Gillot SOC Against
Charles Ginésy UMP For
Adrien Giraud UC Against
Francis Giraud UMP For
Paul Girod UMP For
Jean-Pierre Godefroy SOC Against
Brigitte Gonthier-Maurin CRC Against
Nathalie Goulet RDSE For
Jacqueline Gourault UC Against
Alain Gournac UMP For
Adrien Gouteyron UMP For
Francis Grignon UMP For
Louis Grillot UMP For
Georges Gruillot UMP For
Charles Guené UMP For
Jean-Noël Guérini SOC Against
Michel Guerry UMP For
Hubert Haenel UMP For
Claude Haut SOC Against
Françoise Henneron UMP For
Pierre Hérisson UMP For
Marie-Thérèse Hermange UMP For
Odette Herviaux SOC Against
Gélita Hoarau CRC Against
Michel Houel UMP For
Robert Hue CRC Against
Jean-François Humbert UMP For
Christiane Hummel UMP For
Benoît Huré UMP For
Jean-Jacques Hyest UMP For
Soibahadine Ibrahim Ramadani UMP For
Pierre Jarlier UMP For
Annie Jarraud-Vergnolle SOC Against
Jean-Jacques Jégou UC Against
Charles Josselin SOC Against
Alain Journet SOC Against
Jean-Marc Juilhard UMP For
Christiane Kammermann UMP For
Fabienne Keller UMP For
Joseph Kergueris UC Against
Bariza Khiari SOC Against
Yves Krattinger SOC Against
Philippe Labeyrie SOC Against
Pierre Laffitte RDSE For
Serge Lagauche SOC Against
Alain Lambert UMP For
Marc Laménie UMP For
Élisabeth Lamure UMP For
Gérard Larcher UMP For
Serge Larcher SOC Against
André Lardeux UMP For
Robert Laufoaulu UMP For
Gérard Le Cam CRC Against
Jean-François Le Grand UMP For
Louis Le Pensec SOC Against
Raymonde Le Texier SOC Against
Alain Le Vern SOC Against
Jean-René Lecerf UMP For
Dominique Leclerc UMP For
Jacques Legendre UMP For
André Lejeune SOC Against
Philippe Leroy UMP For
Claude Lise SOC Against
Gérard Longuet UMP For
Simon Loueckhote UMP For
Roger Madec SOC Against
Philippe Madrelle SOC Against
Jacques Mahéas SOC Against
Lucienne Malovry UMP For
François Marc SOC Against
Philippe Marini UMP For
Daniel Marsin RDSE For
Pierre Martin UMP For
Jean-Pierre Masseret SOC Against
Marc Massion SOC Against
Jean Louis Masson NI Abstention
Josiane Mathon-Poinat CRC Against
Pierre Mauroy SOC Against
Jean-Luc Mélenchon SOC Against
Colette Mélot UMP For
Jean-Claude Merceron UC Against
Michel Mercier UC Against
Louis Mermaz SOC Against
Lucette Michaux-Chevry UMP For
Jean-Pierre Michel SOC Against
Alain Milon UMP For
Gérard Miquel SOC Against
Jean-Luc Miraux UMP For
Michel Moreigne SOC Against
Catherine Morin-Desailly UC Against
Dominique Mortemousque UMP For
Georges Mouly RDSE For
Jacques Muller SOC Against
Bernard Murat UMP For
Philippe Nachbar UMP For
Philippe Nogrix UC Against
Georges Othily RDSE For
Jacqueline Panis UMP For
Monique Papon UMP For
Charles Pasqua UMP For
Jean-Marc Pastor SOC Against
Anne-Marie Payet UC Against
Jean Pépin UMP For
Daniel Percheron SOC Against
Jacques Peyrat UMP For
Jean-Claude Peyronnet SOC Against
Jean-François Picheral SOC Against
Jackie Pierre UMP For
François Pillet UMP For
Xavier Pintat UMP For
Louis Pinton UMP For
Bernard Piras SOC Against
Jean-Pierre Plancade SOC Against
Rémy Pointereau UMP For
Christian Poncelet UMP Absent
Ladislas Poniatowski UMP For
Hugues Portelli UMP For
Yves Pozzo di Borgo UC Against
Gisèle Printz SOC Against
Catherine Procaccia UMP For
Jean Puech UMP For
Jean-Pierre Raffarin UMP For
Marcel Rainaud SOC Against
Jack Ralite CRC Against
Daniel Raoul SOC Against
Paul Raoult SOC Against
Daniel Reiner SOC Against
Ivan Renar CRC Against
Thierry Repentin SOC Against
Bruno Retailleau NI For
Charles Revet UMP For
Henri Revol UMP For
Philippe Richert UMP Non-voting
Roland Ries SOC Against
Yves Rispat UMP For
Roger Romani UMP For
Gérard Roujas SOC Against
André Rouvière SOC Against
Janine Rozier UMP For
Michèle San Vicente-Baudrin SOC Against
Bernard Saugey UMP For
Claude Saunier SOC Against
Patricia Schillinger SOC Against
Bernard Seillier RDSE For
Michel Sergent SOC Against
Bruno Sido UMP For
Jacques Siffre SOC Against
René-Pierre Signé SOC Against
Esther Sittler UMP For
Daniel Soulage UC Against
Louis Souvet UMP For
Jean-Pierre Sueur SOC Against
Simon Sutour SOC Against
Catherine Tasca SOC Against
Odette Terrade CRC Against
Michel Teston SOC Against
Yannick Texier UMP For
Michel Thiollière RDSE For
Jean-Marc Todeschini SOC Against
Henri Torre UMP For
André Trillard UMP For
Catherine Troendlé UMP For
Robert Tropeano SOC Against
François Trucy UMP For
Alex Türk NI For
Jacques Valade UMP For
André Vallet UC Against
Jean-Marie Vanlerenberghe UC Against
André Vantomme SOC Against
Alain Vasselle UMP For
François Vendasi RDSE Against
Bernard Vera CRC Against
Jean-Pierre Vial UMP For
Jean-Paul Virapoullé UMP For
Jean-François Voguet CRC Against
Dominique Voynet SOC Against
Richard Yung SOC Against
François Zocchetto UC Against