← All votes

Senate of Canada · roll call no. 10128 · · ✓ Adopted

Miscarriage of Justice Review Commission Act (David and Joyce Milgaard's Law) – C-40 – Third Reading

On 12 December 2024, Senate of Canada: vote adopted, 64 for, 10 against, 1 abstentions.

Official record ↗ ≈ vote on the whole
Summarize with an AI

External tool, not official: nothing is sent until you click, and an AI can make mistakes. The prompt only contains public data from this page. For tools that cannot be pre-filled, the prompt is copied: paste it.

Type of vote
Roll-call vote
Voters
75
Votes cast
74
for + against (excluding abstentions)

64 for 10 against 1 abstention

Colour by:
PSG — 14 ISG — 42 NA — 10 CSG — 18 C — 12 PSGISGNACSGC Dawn Anderson (PSG) — Absent Michèle Audette (PSG) — For Wanda Thomas Bernard (PSG) — Absent Andrew Cardozo (PSG) — For Rodger Cuzner (PSG) — Absent Pierre J. Dalphond (PSG) — For Brian Francis (PSG) — For Daryl S. Fridhandler (PSG) — For Amina Gerba (PSG) — For Peter Harder (PSG) — For Marty Klyne (PSG) — For Pierre Moreau (PSG) — For Tracy Muggli (PSG) — For Judy A. White (PSG) — For David M. Arnot (ISG) — For Peter M. Boehm (ISG) — For Gwen Boniface (ISG) — For Victor Boudreau (ISG) — For Yvonne Boyer (ISG) — Absent Bev Busson (ISG) — For Bernadette Clement (ISG) — For René Cormier (ISG) — For Brent Cotter (ISG) — Absent Mary Coyle (ISG) — For Donna Dasko (ISG) — For Marty Deacon (ISG) — For Tony Dean (ISG) — For Pat Duncan (ISG) — For Éric Forest (ISG) — Absent Rosa Galvez (ISG) — For Margo Greenwood (ISG) — For Nancy J. Hartling (ISG) — For Joan Kingston (ISG) — For Stan Kutcher (ISG) — For Tony Loffreda (ISG) — For Jane MacAdam (ISG) — For Paul J. Massicotte (ISG) — Absent Marnie McBean (ISG) — For John M. McNair (ISG) — For Julie Miville-Dechêne (ISG) — For Lucie Moncion (ISG) — For Rosemary Moodie (ISG) — Absent Marie-Françoise Mégie (ISG) — For Manuelle Oudar (ISG) — For Kim Pate (ISG) — For Chantal Petitclerc (ISG) — For Mohamed-Iqbal Ravalia (ISG) — For Pierrette Ringuette (ISG) — For Raymonde Saint-Germain (ISG) — For Paulette Senior (ISG) — For Paula Simons (ISG) — For Karen Sorensen (ISG) — For Toni Varone (ISG) — For Yuen Pau Woo (ISG) — For Suze Youance (ISG) — For Hassan Yussuff (ISG) — For Charles S. Adler (NA) — Absent Patrick Brazeau (NA) — Absent Raymonde Gagné (NA) — Absent Marc Gold (NA) — For Patti LaBoucane-Benson (NA) — For Mary Jane McCallum (NA) — Absent Marilou McPhedran (NA) — Absent Iris G. Petten (NA) — For David Richards (NA) — Abstention Kristopher Wells (NA) — Absent Mohammad Al Zaibak (CSG) — For Réjean Aucoin (CSG) — For Robert Black (CSG) — For Sharon Burey (CSG) — For Jean-Guy Dagenais (CSG) — Absent Colin Deacon (CSG) — For Percy E. Downe (CSG) — For Clément Gignac (CSG) — For Flordeliz (Gigi) Osler (CSG) — For Rebecca Patterson (CSG) — Absent Paul (PJ) Prosper (CSG) — For Jim Quinn (CSG) — For Mary Robinson (CSG) — For Krista Ross (CSG) — For Larry W. Smith (CSG) — Absent Scott Tannas (CSG) — For Josée Verner (CSG) — Absent Pamela Wallin (CSG) — Absent Salma Ataullahjan (C) — Against Denise Batters (C) — Against Claude Carignan (C) — Against Leo Housakos (C) — Against Michael L. MacDonald (C) — Against Fabian Manning (C) — Against Elizabeth Marshall (C) — Absent Yonah Martin (C) — Against Donald Neil Plett (C) — Against Rose-May Poirier (C) — Absent Judith G. Seidman (C) — Against David M. Wells (C) — Against

Official note: Sitting of 2024-12-12, vote 128 of session 44-1 (Senate vote id 662643).

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
PSG 1100 0314
ISG 3700 0542
NA 301 0610
CSG 1300 0518
C 0100 0212

All senators

SenatorGroupVote
Charles S. Adler NA Absent
Mohammad Al Zaibak CSG For
Dawn Anderson PSG Absent
David M. Arnot ISG For
Salma Ataullahjan C Against
Réjean Aucoin CSG For
Michèle Audette PSG For
Denise Batters C Against
Wanda Thomas Bernard PSG Absent
Robert Black CSG For
Peter M. Boehm ISG For
Gwen Boniface ISG For
Victor Boudreau ISG For
Yvonne Boyer ISG Absent
Patrick Brazeau NA Absent
Sharon Burey CSG For
Bev Busson ISG For
Andrew Cardozo PSG For
Claude Carignan C Against
Bernadette Clement ISG For
René Cormier ISG For
Brent Cotter ISG Absent
Mary Coyle ISG For
Rodger Cuzner PSG Absent
Jean-Guy Dagenais CSG Absent
Pierre J. Dalphond PSG For
Donna Dasko ISG For
Colin Deacon CSG For
Marty Deacon ISG For
Tony Dean ISG For
Percy E. Downe CSG For
Pat Duncan ISG For
Éric Forest ISG Absent
Brian Francis PSG For
Daryl S. Fridhandler PSG For
Raymonde Gagné NA Absent
Rosa Galvez ISG For
Amina Gerba PSG For
Clément Gignac CSG For
Marc Gold NA For
Margo Greenwood ISG For
Peter Harder PSG For
Nancy J. Hartling ISG For
Leo Housakos C Against
Joan Kingston ISG For
Marty Klyne PSG For
Stan Kutcher ISG For
Patti LaBoucane-Benson NA For
Tony Loffreda ISG For
Jane MacAdam ISG For
Michael L. MacDonald C Against
Fabian Manning C Against
Elizabeth Marshall C Absent
Yonah Martin C Against
Paul J. Massicotte ISG Absent
Marnie McBean ISG For
Mary Jane McCallum NA Absent
John M. McNair ISG For
Marilou McPhedran NA Absent
Marie-Françoise Mégie ISG For
Julie Miville-Dechêne ISG For
Lucie Moncion ISG For
Rosemary Moodie ISG Absent
Pierre Moreau PSG For
Tracy Muggli PSG For
Flordeliz (Gigi) Osler CSG For
Manuelle Oudar ISG For
Kim Pate ISG For
Rebecca Patterson CSG Absent
Chantal Petitclerc ISG For
Iris G. Petten NA For
Donald Neil Plett C Against
Rose-May Poirier C Absent
Paul (PJ) Prosper CSG For
Jim Quinn CSG For
Mohamed-Iqbal Ravalia ISG For
David Richards NA Abstention
Pierrette Ringuette ISG For
Mary Robinson CSG For
Krista Ross CSG For
Raymonde Saint-Germain ISG For
Judith G. Seidman C Against
Paulette Senior ISG For
Paula Simons ISG For
Larry W. Smith CSG Absent
Karen Sorensen ISG For
Scott Tannas CSG For
Toni Varone ISG For
Josée Verner CSG Absent
Pamela Wallin CSG Absent
David M. Wells C Against
Kristopher Wells NA Absent
Judy A. White PSG For
Yuen Pau Woo ISG For
Suze Youance ISG For
Hassan Yussuff ISG For