← All votes

House of Commons of Canada · division no. 10018 · · ✗ Rejected

Opposition Motion (Proposed tax changes)

On 26 February 2020, House of Commons of Canada: vote rejected, 27 for, 294 against, 0 abstentions.

Summarize with an AI

External tool, not official: nothing is sent until you click, and an AI can make mistakes. The prompt only contains public data from this page. For tools that cannot be pre-filled, the prompt is copied: paste it.

Type of vote
Supply
Voters
321
Votes cast
321
for + against (excluding abstentions)

27 for 294 against 0 abstention

Colour by:
NDP — 24 Grn — 2 Lib — 155 BQ — 32 Ind — 5 Con — 120 NDPLibBQCon Charlie Angus (NDP) — For Niki Ashton (NDP) — For Taylor Bachrach (NDP) — For Daniel Blaikie (NDP) — For Rachel Blaney (NDP) — For Alexandre Boulerice (NDP) — For Richard Cannings (NDP) — For Laurel Collins (NDP) — For Don Davies (NDP) — For Scott Duvall (NDP) — For Randall Garrison (NDP) — For Leah Gazan (NDP) — For Matthew Green (NDP) — For Jack Harris (NDP) — For Carol Hughes (NDP) — For Gord Johns (NDP) — For Peter Julian (NDP) — For Jenny Kwan (NDP) — For Alistair MacGregor (NDP) — For Brian Masse (NDP) — For Lindsay Mathyssen (NDP) — For Heather McPherson (NDP) — For Mumilaaq Qaqqaq (NDP) — For Jagmeet Singh (NDP) — For Paul Manly (Grn) — For Elizabeth May (Grn) — For Omar Alghabra (Lib) — Against William Amos (Lib) — Against Anita Anand (Lib) — Against Gary Anandasangaree (Lib) — Against René Arseneault (Lib) — Against Chandra Arya (Lib) — Against Jenica Atwin (Lib) — For Vance Badawey (Lib) — Against Larry Bagnell (Lib) — Against Navdeep Bains (Lib) — Against Yvan Baker (Lib) — Against Jaime Battiste (Lib) — Absent Terry Beech (Lib) — Against Rachel Bendayan (Lib) — Against Carolyn Bennett (Lib) — Against Lyne Bessette (Lib) — Against Marie-Claude Bibeau (Lib) — Against Chris Bittle (Lib) — Against Bill Blair (Lib) — Against Kody Blois (Lib) — Against Bob Bratina (Lib) — Against Élisabeth Brière (Lib) — Against Jim Carr (Lib) — Absent Sean Casey (Lib) — Against Bardish Chagger (Lib) — Against François-Philippe Champagne (Lib) — Against Shaun Chen (Lib) — Against Serge Cormier (Lib) — Against Julie Dabrusin (Lib) — Against Pam Damoff (Lib) — Against Sukh Dhaliwal (Lib) — Against Anju Dhillon (Lib) — Against Han Dong (Lib) — Against Francis Drouin (Lib) — Against Emmanuel Dubourg (Lib) — Against Jean-Yves Duclos (Lib) — Against Terry Duguid (Lib) — Against Kirsty Duncan (Lib) — Against Julie Dzerowicz (Lib) — Against Wayne Easter (Lib) — Against Ali Ehsassi (Lib) — Against Fayçal El-Khoury (Lib) — Against Neil Ellis (Lib) — Against Nathaniel Erskine-Smith (Lib) — Against Greg Fergus (Lib) — Against Andy Fillmore (Lib) — Against Pat Finnigan (Lib) — Against Darren Fisher (Lib) — Against Peter Fonseca (Lib) — Against Mona Fortier (Lib) — Against Peter Fragiskatos (Lib) — Against Sean Fraser (Lib) — Against Chrystia Freeland (Lib) — Against Hedy Fry (Lib) — Against Marc Garneau (Lib) — Against Mark Gerretsen (Lib) — Against Karina Gould (Lib) — Against Steven Guilbeault (Lib) — Against Patty Hajdu (Lib) — Against Ken Hardie (Lib) — Against Mark Holland (Lib) — Against Anthony Housefather (Lib) — Against Ahmed Hussen (Lib) — Against Gudie Hutchings (Lib) — Against Angelo Iacono (Lib) — Against Helena Jaczek (Lib) — Against Mélanie Joly (Lib) — Absent Yvonne Jones (Lib) — Against Bernadette Jordan (Lib) — Against Majid Jowhari (Lib) — Against Mike Kelloway (Lib) — Against Iqra Khalid (Lib) — Against Kamal Khera (Lib) — Against Annie Koutrakis (Lib) — Against Irek Kusmierczyk (Lib) — Against Marie-France Lalonde (Lib) — Against Emmanuella Lambropoulos (Lib) — Against David Lametti (Lib) — Against Kevin Lamoureux (Lib) — Against Patricia Lattanzio (Lib) — Against Stéphane Lauzon (Lib) — Against Dominic LeBlanc (Lib) — Against Diane Lebouthillier (Lib) — Against Paul Lefebvre (Lib) — Against Michael Levitt (Lib) — Against Joël Lightbound (Lib) — Against Wayne Long (Lib) — Against Lloyd Longfield (Lib) — Against Tim Louis (Lib) — Against Lawrence MacAulay (Lib) — Against Steven MacKinnon (Lib) — Against James Maloney (Lib) — Against Soraya Martinez Ferrada (Lib) — Against Bryan May (Lib) — Against Karen McCrimmon (Lib) — Against Ken McDonald (Lib) — Against David McGuinty (Lib) — Against John McKay (Lib) — Against Catherine McKenna (Lib) — Absent Ron McKinnon (Lib) — Against Michael McLeod (Lib) — Absent Marco Mendicino (Lib) — Against Alexandra Mendès (Lib) — Against Marc Miller (Lib) — Against Maryam Monsef (Lib) — Against Bill Morneau (Lib) — Absent Robert Morrissey (Lib) — Against Joyce Murray (Lib) — Against Mary Ng (Lib) — Against Jennifer O'Connell (Lib) — Against Seamus O'Regan (Lib) — Absent Robert Oliphant (Lib) — Against Ginette Petitpas Taylor (Lib) — Against Marcus Powlowski (Lib) — Against Carla Qualtrough (Lib) — Against Geoff Regan (Lib) — Against Yves Robillard (Lib) — Against Pablo Rodriguez (Lib) — Against Churence Rogers (Lib) — Against Sherry Romanado (Lib) — Against Anthony Rota (Lib) — Absent Ruby Sahota (Lib) — Against Raj Saini (Lib) — Against Harjit S. Sajjan (Lib) — Against Darrell Samson (Lib) — Against Randeep Sarai (Lib) — Against Francis Scarpaleggia (Lib) — Against Peter Schiefke (Lib) — Against Deb Schulte (Lib) — Against Marc Serré (Lib) — Against Judy A. Sgro (Lib) — Against Brenda Shanahan (Lib) — Against Terry Sheehan (Lib) — Against Maninder Sidhu (Lib) — Against Sonia Sidhu (Lib) — Against Gagan Sikand (Lib) — Against Scott Simms (Lib) — Against Francesco Sorbara (Lib) — Against Sven Spengemann (Lib) — Against Filomena Tassi (Lib) — Against Justin Trudeau (Lib) — Against Ryan Turnbull (Lib) — Against Tony Van Bynen (Lib) — Against Dan Vandal (Lib) — Against Anita Vandenbeld (Lib) — Against Adam Vaughan (Lib) — Against Arif Virani (Lib) — Against Patrick Weiler (Lib) — Against Jonathan Wilkinson (Lib) — Against Jean Yip (Lib) — Against Kate Young (Lib) — Against Salma Zahid (Lib) — Against Lenore Zann (Lib) — Against Sameer Zuberi (Lib) — Against Adam van Koeverden (Lib) — Against Xavier Barsalou-Duval (BQ) — Against Mario Beaulieu (BQ) — Against Stéphane Bergeron (BQ) — Against Yves-François Blanchet (BQ) — Against Maxime Blanchette-Joncas (BQ) — Against Michel Boudrias (BQ) — Against Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe (BQ) — Against Sylvie Bérubé (BQ) — Against Louise Chabot (BQ) — Against Martin Champoux (BQ) — Against Louise Charbonneau (BQ) — Against Claude DeBellefeuille (BQ) — Against Caroline Desbiens (BQ) — Absent Luc Desilets (BQ) — Against Rhéal Éloi Fortin (BQ) — Against Marie-Hélène Gaudreau (BQ) — Against Marilène Gill (BQ) — Against Andréanne Larouche (BQ) — Against Sébastien Lemire (BQ) — Against Simon Marcil (BQ) — Absent Kristina Michaud (BQ) — Against Christine Normandin (BQ) — Against Monique Pauzé (BQ) — Against Yves Perron (BQ) — Against Louis Plamondon (BQ) — Absent Simon-Pierre Savard-Tremblay (BQ) — Against Mario Simard (BQ) — Against Gabriel Ste-Marie (BQ) — Against Alain Therrien (BQ) — Against Luc Thériault (BQ) — Against Denis Trudel (BQ) — Against Julie Vignola (BQ) — Against Yasmin Ratansi (Ind) — Against Ramesh Sangha (Ind) — Against Derek Sloan (Ind) — Absent Marwan Tabbara (Ind) — Against Jody Wilson-Raybould (Ind) — Against Ziad Aboultaif (Con) — Against Scott Aitchison (Con) — Against Dan Albas (Con) — Against Leona Alleslev (Con) — Against Dean Allison (Con) — Against Mel Arnold (Con) — Against Tony Baldinelli (Con) — Against John Barlow (Con) — Against Michael Barrett (Con) — Against Bob Benzen (Con) — Against Candice Bergen (Con) — Against Luc Berthold (Con) — Against James Bezan (Con) — Against Steven Blaney (Con) — Absent Kelly Block (Con) — Against Richard Bragdon (Con) — Against John Brassard (Con) — Against Blaine Calkins (Con) — Against Colin Carrie (Con) — Against Kenny Chiu (Con) — Against Michael Chong (Con) — Against Michael Cooper (Con) — Against James Cumming (Con) — Against Marc Dalton (Con) — Against Raquel Dancho (Con) — Against Scot Davidson (Con) — Against Gérard Deltell (Con) — Against Kerry Diotte (Con) — Against Todd Doherty (Con) — Against Terry Dowdall (Con) — Against Earl Dreeshen (Con) — Against Eric Duncan (Con) — Against Dave Epp (Con) — Against Rosemarie Falk (Con) — Against Ted Falk (Con) — Against Ed Fast (Con) — Against Kerry-Lynne Findlay (Con) — Against Diane Finley (Con) — Against Cheryl Gallant (Con) — Against Garnett Genuis (Con) — Against Marilyn Gladu (Con) — Absent Joël Godin (Con) — Against Jacques Gourde (Con) — Against Tracy Gray (Con) — Against Bernard Généreux (Con) — Against Jasraj Singh Hallan (Con) — Against Randy Hoback (Con) — Against Tamara Jansen (Con) — Against Matt Jeneroux (Con) — Against Pat Kelly (Con) — Against Peter Kent (Con) — Against Robert Kitchen (Con) — Against Tom Kmiec (Con) — Against Michael Kram (Con) — Against Damien Kurek (Con) — Against Stephanie Kusie (Con) — Against Mike Lake (Con) — Against Philip Lawrence (Con) — Against Richard Lehoux (Con) — Against Chris Lewis (Con) — Against Ron Liepert (Con) — Against Dane Lloyd (Con) — Against Ben Lobb (Con) — Against Tom Lukiwski (Con) — Against Dave MacKenzie (Con) — Against Larry Maguire (Con) — Against Richard Martel (Con) — Against Dan Mazier (Con) — Against Kelly McCauley (Con) — Against Phil McColeman (Con) — Absent Greg McLean (Con) — Against Cathy McLeod (Con) — Against Eric Melillo (Con) — Against Rob Moore (Con) — Against Marty Morantz (Con) — Absent Rob Morrison (Con) — Against Glen Motz (Con) — Against John Nater (Con) — Against Erin O'Toole (Con) — Absent Jeremy Patzer (Con) — Against Pierre Paul-Hus (Con) — Against Pierre Poilievre (Con) — Against Alain Rayes (Con) — Against Brad Redekopp (Con) — Against Scott Reid (Con) — Against Michelle Rempel Garner (Con) — Against Blake Richards (Con) — Against Lianne Rood (Con) — Against Alex Ruff (Con) — Against Jag Sahota (Con) — Against Bob Saroya (Con) — Against Andrew Scheer (Con) — Against Jamie Schmale (Con) — Against Kyle Seeback (Con) — Against Martin Shields (Con) — Against Nelly Shin (Con) — Against Doug Shipley (Con) — Against Gerald Soroka (Con) — Against Bruce Stanton (Con) — Against Warren Steinley (Con) — Against Mark Strahl (Con) — Against Shannon Stubbs (Con) — Against David Sweet (Con) — Against Rachael Thomas (Con) — Against Corey Tochor (Con) — Against Tim Uppal (Con) — Against Tako Van Popta (Con) — Against Karen Vecchio (Con) — Against Gary Vidal (Con) — Against Arnold Viersen (Con) — Against Brad Vis (Con) — Against Cathay Wagantall (Con) — Against Chris Warkentin (Con) — Against Kevin Waugh (Con) — Against Len Webber (Con) — Against John Williamson (Con) — Against Alice Wong (Con) — Against David Yurdiga (Con) — Against Bob Zimmer (Con) — Against Chris d'Entremont (Con) — Against

Official note: Sitting of 2020-02-26, division 18 of session 43-1.

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
NDP 2400 0024
Grn 200 002
Lib 11460 08155
BQ 0290 0332
Ind 040 015
Con 01150 05120

All MPs

MPGroupVote
Ziad Aboultaif Con Against
Scott Aitchison Con Against
Dan Albas Con Against
Omar Alghabra Lib Against
Leona Alleslev Con Against
Dean Allison Con Against
William Amos Lib Against
Anita Anand Lib Against
Gary Anandasangaree Lib Against
Charlie Angus NDP For
Mel Arnold Con Against
René Arseneault Lib Against
Chandra Arya Lib Against
Niki Ashton NDP For
Jenica Atwin Lib For
Taylor Bachrach NDP For
Vance Badawey Lib Against
Larry Bagnell Lib Against
Navdeep Bains Lib Against
Yvan Baker Lib Against
Tony Baldinelli Con Against
John Barlow Con Against
Michael Barrett Con Against
Xavier Barsalou-Duval BQ Against
Jaime Battiste Lib Absent
Mario Beaulieu BQ Against
Terry Beech Lib Against
Rachel Bendayan Lib Against
Carolyn Bennett Lib Against
Bob Benzen Con Against
Candice Bergen Con Against
Stéphane Bergeron BQ Against
Luc Berthold Con Against
Sylvie Bérubé BQ Against
Lyne Bessette Lib Against
James Bezan Con Against
Marie-Claude Bibeau Lib Against
Chris Bittle Lib Against
Daniel Blaikie NDP For
Bill Blair Lib Against
Yves-François Blanchet BQ Against
Maxime Blanchette-Joncas BQ Against
Rachel Blaney NDP For
Steven Blaney Con Absent
Kelly Block Con Against
Kody Blois Lib Against
Michel Boudrias BQ Against
Alexandre Boulerice NDP For
Richard Bragdon Con Against
John Brassard Con Against
Bob Bratina Lib Against
Élisabeth Brière Lib Against
Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe BQ Against
Blaine Calkins Con Against
Richard Cannings NDP For
Jim Carr Lib Absent
Colin Carrie Con Against
Sean Casey Lib Against
Louise Chabot BQ Against
Bardish Chagger Lib Against
François-Philippe Champagne Lib Against
Martin Champoux BQ Against
Louise Charbonneau BQ Against
Shaun Chen Lib Against
Kenny Chiu Con Against
Michael Chong Con Against
Laurel Collins NDP For
Michael Cooper Con Against
Serge Cormier Lib Against
James Cumming Con Against
Chris d'Entremont Con Against
Julie Dabrusin Lib Against
Marc Dalton Con Against
Pam Damoff Lib Against
Raquel Dancho Con Against
Scot Davidson Con Against
Don Davies NDP For
Claude DeBellefeuille BQ Against
Gérard Deltell Con Against
Caroline Desbiens BQ Absent
Luc Desilets BQ Against
Sukh Dhaliwal Lib Against
Anju Dhillon Lib Against
Kerry Diotte Con Against
Todd Doherty Con Against
Han Dong Lib Against
Terry Dowdall Con Against
Earl Dreeshen Con Against
Francis Drouin Lib Against
Emmanuel Dubourg Lib Against
Jean-Yves Duclos Lib Against
Terry Duguid Lib Against
Eric Duncan Con Against
Kirsty Duncan Lib Against
Scott Duvall NDP For
Julie Dzerowicz Lib Against
Wayne Easter Lib Against
Ali Ehsassi Lib Against
Fayçal El-Khoury Lib Against
Neil Ellis Lib Against
Dave Epp Con Against
Nathaniel Erskine-Smith Lib Against
Rosemarie Falk Con Against
Ted Falk Con Against
Ed Fast Con Against
Greg Fergus Lib Against
Andy Fillmore Lib Against
Kerry-Lynne Findlay Con Against
Diane Finley Con Against
Pat Finnigan Lib Against
Darren Fisher Lib Against
Peter Fonseca Lib Against
Mona Fortier Lib Against
Rhéal Éloi Fortin BQ Against
Peter Fragiskatos Lib Against
Sean Fraser Lib Against
Chrystia Freeland Lib Against
Hedy Fry Lib Against
Cheryl Gallant Con Against
Marc Garneau Lib Against
Randall Garrison NDP For
Marie-Hélène Gaudreau BQ Against
Leah Gazan NDP For
Bernard Généreux Con Against
Garnett Genuis Con Against
Mark Gerretsen Lib Against
Marilène Gill BQ Against
Marilyn Gladu Con Absent
Joël Godin Con Against
Karina Gould Lib Against
Jacques Gourde Con Against
Tracy Gray Con Against
Matthew Green NDP For
Steven Guilbeault Lib Against
Patty Hajdu Lib Against
Jasraj Singh Hallan Con Against
Ken Hardie Lib Against
Jack Harris NDP For
Randy Hoback Con Against
Mark Holland Lib Against
Anthony Housefather Lib Against
Carol Hughes NDP For
Ahmed Hussen Lib Against
Gudie Hutchings Lib Against
Angelo Iacono Lib Against
Helena Jaczek Lib Against
Tamara Jansen Con Against
Matt Jeneroux Con Against
Gord Johns NDP For
Mélanie Joly Lib Absent
Yvonne Jones Lib Against
Bernadette Jordan Lib Against
Majid Jowhari Lib Against
Peter Julian NDP For
Mike Kelloway Lib Against
Pat Kelly Con Against
Peter Kent Con Against
Iqra Khalid Lib Against
Kamal Khera Lib Against
Robert Kitchen Con Against
Tom Kmiec Con Against
Annie Koutrakis Lib Against
Michael Kram Con Against
Damien Kurek Con Against
Stephanie Kusie Con Against
Irek Kusmierczyk Lib Against
Jenny Kwan NDP For
Mike Lake Con Against
Marie-France Lalonde Lib Against
Emmanuella Lambropoulos Lib Against
David Lametti Lib Against
Kevin Lamoureux Lib Against
Andréanne Larouche BQ Against
Patricia Lattanzio Lib Against
Stéphane Lauzon Lib Against
Philip Lawrence Con Against
Dominic LeBlanc Lib Against
Diane Lebouthillier Lib Against
Paul Lefebvre Lib Against
Richard Lehoux Con Against
Sébastien Lemire BQ Against
Michael Levitt Lib Against
Chris Lewis Con Against
Ron Liepert Con Against
Joël Lightbound Lib Against
Dane Lloyd Con Against
Ben Lobb Con Against
Wayne Long Lib Against
Lloyd Longfield Lib Against
Tim Louis Lib Against
Tom Lukiwski Con Against
Lawrence MacAulay Lib Against
Alistair MacGregor NDP For
Dave MacKenzie Con Against
Steven MacKinnon Lib Against
Larry Maguire Con Against
James Maloney Lib Against
Paul Manly Grn For
Simon Marcil BQ Absent
Richard Martel Con Against
Soraya Martinez Ferrada Lib Against
Brian Masse NDP For
Lindsay Mathyssen NDP For
Bryan May Lib Against
Elizabeth May Grn For
Dan Mazier Con Against
Kelly McCauley Con Against
Phil McColeman Con Absent
Karen McCrimmon Lib Against
Ken McDonald Lib Against
David McGuinty Lib Against
John McKay Lib Against
Catherine McKenna Lib Absent
Ron McKinnon Lib Against
Greg McLean Con Against
Cathy McLeod Con Against
Michael McLeod Lib Absent
Heather McPherson NDP For
Eric Melillo Con Against
Alexandra Mendès Lib Against
Marco Mendicino Lib Against
Kristina Michaud BQ Against
Marc Miller Lib Against
Maryam Monsef Lib Against
Rob Moore Con Against
Marty Morantz Con Absent
Bill Morneau Lib Absent
Rob Morrison Con Against
Robert Morrissey Lib Against
Glen Motz Con Against
Joyce Murray Lib Against
John Nater Con Against
Mary Ng Lib Against
Christine Normandin BQ Against
Jennifer O'Connell Lib Against
Seamus O'Regan Lib Absent
Erin O'Toole Con Absent
Robert Oliphant Lib Against
Jeremy Patzer Con Against
Pierre Paul-Hus Con Against
Monique Pauzé BQ Against
Yves Perron BQ Against
Ginette Petitpas Taylor Lib Against
Louis Plamondon BQ Absent
Pierre Poilievre Con Against
Marcus Powlowski Lib Against
Mumilaaq Qaqqaq NDP For
Carla Qualtrough Lib Against
Yasmin Ratansi Ind Against
Alain Rayes Con Against
Brad Redekopp Con Against
Geoff Regan Lib Against
Scott Reid Con Against
Michelle Rempel Garner Con Against
Blake Richards Con Against
Yves Robillard Lib Against
Pablo Rodriguez Lib Against
Churence Rogers Lib Against
Sherry Romanado Lib Against
Lianne Rood Con Against
Anthony Rota Lib Absent
Alex Ruff Con Against
Jag Sahota Con Against
Ruby Sahota Lib Against
Raj Saini Lib Against
Harjit S. Sajjan Lib Against
Darrell Samson Lib Against
Ramesh Sangha Ind Against
Randeep Sarai Lib Against
Bob Saroya Con Against
Simon-Pierre Savard-Tremblay BQ Against
Francis Scarpaleggia Lib Against
Andrew Scheer Con Against
Peter Schiefke Lib Against
Jamie Schmale Con Against
Deb Schulte Lib Against
Kyle Seeback Con Against
Marc Serré Lib Against
Judy A. Sgro Lib Against
Brenda Shanahan Lib Against
Terry Sheehan Lib Against
Martin Shields Con Against
Nelly Shin Con Against
Doug Shipley Con Against
Maninder Sidhu Lib Against
Sonia Sidhu Lib Against
Gagan Sikand Lib Against
Mario Simard BQ Against
Scott Simms Lib Against
Jagmeet Singh NDP For
Derek Sloan Ind Absent
Francesco Sorbara Lib Against
Gerald Soroka Con Against
Sven Spengemann Lib Against
Bruce Stanton Con Against
Gabriel Ste-Marie BQ Against
Warren Steinley Con Against
Mark Strahl Con Against
Shannon Stubbs Con Against
David Sweet Con Against
Marwan Tabbara Ind Against
Filomena Tassi Lib Against
Luc Thériault BQ Against
Alain Therrien BQ Against
Rachael Thomas Con Against
Corey Tochor Con Against
Justin Trudeau Lib Against
Denis Trudel BQ Against
Ryan Turnbull Lib Against
Tim Uppal Con Against
Tony Van Bynen Lib Against
Adam van Koeverden Lib Against
Tako Van Popta Con Against
Dan Vandal Lib Against
Anita Vandenbeld Lib Against
Adam Vaughan Lib Against
Karen Vecchio Con Against
Gary Vidal Con Against
Arnold Viersen Con Against
Julie Vignola BQ Against
Arif Virani Lib Against
Brad Vis Con Against
Cathay Wagantall Con Against
Chris Warkentin Con Against
Kevin Waugh Con Against
Len Webber Con Against
Patrick Weiler Lib Against
Jonathan Wilkinson Lib Against
John Williamson Con Against
Jody Wilson-Raybould Ind Against
Alice Wong Con Against
Jean Yip Lib Against
Kate Young Lib Against
David Yurdiga Con Against
Salma Zahid Lib Against
Lenore Zann Lib Against
Bob Zimmer Con Against
Sameer Zuberi Lib Against