← All votes

Dáil Éireann · division · · ✓ Adopted

Health Service Executive (Governance) Bill 2012: Report Stage (Resumed) and Final Stage

Summarize with an AI

External tool, not official: nothing is sent until you click, and an AI can make mistakes. The prompt only contains public data from this page. For tools that cannot be pre-filled, the prompt is copied: paste it.

Type of vote
"That the Bill do now pass."
Voters
129
Votes cast
129
for + against (excluding abstentions)

88 for 41 against 0 abstention

Colour by:
SF — 14 Lab — 33 Ind — 22 FF — 19 FG — 74 People Before Profit Alliance — 1 Socialist Party — 1 Workers and Unemployed Action — 1 NI — 1 SFLabIndFFFG Gerry Adams (SF) — Absent Michael Colreavy (SF) — Against Seán Crowe (SF) — Against Pearse Doherty (SF) — Against Dessie Ellis (SF) — Against Martin Ferris (SF) — Against Pádraig Mac Lochlainn (SF) — Against Mary Lou McDonald (SF) — Absent Sandra McLellan (SF) — Against Jonathan O'Brien (SF) — Against Brian Stanley (SF) — Against Peadar Tóibín (SF) — Against Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin (SF) — Against Aengus Ó Snodaigh (SF) — Against Joan Burton (Lab) — For Eric J. Byrne (Lab) — For Michael Conaghan (Lab) — For Ciara Conway (Lab) — For Joe Costello (Lab) — Absent Robert Dowds (Lab) — For Anne Ferris (Lab) — For Eamon Gilmore (Lab) — Absent Dominic Hannigan (Lab) — For Brendan Howlin (Lab) — For Kevin Humphreys (Lab) — For Alan Kelly (Lab) — Absent Seán Kenny (Lab) — For Ciaran Lynch (Lab) — For Kathleen Lynch (Lab) — For John Lyons (Lab) — For Eamonn Maloney (Lab) — For Michael McCarthy (Lab) — For Michael McNamara (Lab) — For Ged Nash (Lab) — For Derek Nolan (Lab) — For Jan O'Sullivan (Lab) — For Ann Phelan (Lab) — For Ruairí Quinn (Lab) — For Pat Rabbitte (Lab) — For Brendan Ryan (Lab) — Absent Seán Sherlock (Lab) — Absent Arthur Spring (Lab) — For Emmet Stagg (Lab) — For Joanna Tuffy (Lab) — For Jack Wall (Lab) — Absent Alex White (Lab) — Absent Aodhán Ó Ríordáin (Lab) — Absent Thomas P. Broughan (Ind) — Against Joan Collins (Ind) — Against Clare Daly (Ind) — Against Stephen Donnelly (Ind) — For Luke 'Ming' Flanagan (Ind) — Against Tom Fleming (Ind) — Against Noel Grealish (Ind) — Against John Halligan (Ind) — Absent Michael Healy-Rae (Ind) — Against Colm Keaveney (Ind) — Absent Michael Lowry (Ind) — For Finian McGrath (Ind) — Against Mattie McGrath (Ind) — For Catherine Murphy (Ind) — Against Denis Naughten (Ind) — For Patrick Nulty (Ind) — Against Maureen O'Sullivan (Ind) — Against Willie Penrose (Ind) — For Thomas Pringle (Ind) — Against Shane Ross (Ind) — Against Róisín Shortall (Ind) — Against Mick Wallace (Ind) — Against John Browne (FF) — Absent Dara Calleary (FF) — Against Niall Collins (FF) — Absent Barry Cowen (FF) — Against Timmy Dooley (FF) — Against Sean Fleming (FF) — Absent Billy Kelleher (FF) — Against Seamus Kirk (FF) — Against Michael P. Kitt (FF) — Absent Micheál Martin (FF) — Absent Charlie McConalogue (FF) — Against Michael McGrath (FF) — Against John McGuinness (FF) — Absent Michael Moynihan (FF) — Against Willie O'Dea (FF) — Absent Brendan Smith (FF) — Against Robert Troy (FF) — Against Éamon Ó Cuív (FF) — Against Seán Ó Fearghaíl (FF) — Against James Bannon (FG) — For Seán Barrett (FG) — Absent Tom Barry (FG) — For Pat Breen (FG) — For Richard Bruton (FG) — For Ray Butler (FG) — For Jerry Buttimer (FG) — For Catherine Byrne (FG) — For Ciarán Cannon (FG) — For Joe Carey (FG) — For Paudie Coffey (FG) — For Áine Collins (FG) — For Sean Conlan (FG) — For Paul Connaughton (FG) — For Noel Coonan (FG) — Absent Marcella Corcoran Kennedy (FG) — For Simon Coveney (FG) — Absent Michael Creed (FG) — For Lucinda Creighton (FG) — Absent Jim Daly (FG) — For John Deasy (FG) — Absent Jimmy Deenihan (FG) — Absent Pat Deering (FG) — For Regina Doherty (FG) — For Paschal Donohoe (FG) — Absent Andrew Doyle (FG) — For Bernard Durkan (FG) — For Damien English (FG) — For Alan Farrell (FG) — For Frankie Feighan (FG) — For Frances Fitzgerald (FG) — Absent Peter Fitzpatrick (FG) — For Charles Flanagan (FG) — For Terence Flanagan (FG) — For Brendan Griffin (FG) — For Noel Harrington (FG) — For Simon Harris (FG) — Absent Brian Hayes (FG) — Absent Tom Hayes (FG) — Absent Martin Heydon (FG) — Absent Phil Hogan (FG) — For Heather Humphreys (FG) — For Derek Keating (FG) — For Paul Kehoe (FG) — For Enda Kenny (FG) — Absent Seán Kyne (FG) — For Anthony Lawlor (FG) — For Peter Mathews (FG) — For Nicky McFadden (FG) — Absent Dinny McGinley (FG) — For Joe McHugh (FG) — For Tony McLoughlin (FG) — For Olivia Mitchell (FG) — For Mary Mitchell O'Connor (FG) — For Michelle Mulherin (FG) — For Dara Murphy (FG) — For Eoghan Murphy (FG) — Absent Dan Neville (FG) — For Michael Noonan (FG) — For Kieran O'Donnell (FG) — For Patrick O'Donovan (FG) — For Fergus O'Dowd (FG) — For John O'Mahony (FG) — For Joe O'Reilly (FG) — For John Perry (FG) — For John Paul Phelan (FG) — For James Reilly (FG) — For Michael Ring (FG) — For Alan Shatter (FG) — For David Stanton (FG) — For Billy Timmins (FG) — Absent Liam Twomey (FG) — Absent Leo Varadkar (FG) — For Brian Walsh (FG) — For Richard Boyd Barrett (People Before Profit Alliance) — Against Joe Higgins (Socialist Party) — Absent Seamus Healy (Workers and Unemployed Action) — Against Helen McEntee (NI) — For

Official note: Sitting of 2013-06-12, vote 2.

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
SF 0120 0214
Lab 2500 0833
Ind 5150 0222
FF 0120 0719
FG 5700 01774
People Before Profit Alliance 010 001
Socialist Party 000 011
Workers and Unemployed Action 010 001
NI 100 001

All TDs

TDGroupVote
Gerry Adams SF Absent
James Bannon FG For
Seán Barrett FG Absent
Tom Barry FG For
Richard Boyd Barrett People Before Profit Alliance Against
Pat Breen FG For
Thomas P. Broughan Ind Against
John Browne FF Absent
Richard Bruton FG For
Joan Burton Lab For
Ray Butler FG For
Jerry Buttimer FG For
Catherine Byrne FG For
Eric J. Byrne Lab For
Dara Calleary FF Against
Ciarán Cannon FG For
Joe Carey FG For
Paudie Coffey FG For
Áine Collins FG For
Joan Collins Ind Against
Niall Collins FF Absent
Michael Colreavy SF Against
Michael Conaghan Lab For
Sean Conlan FG For
Paul Connaughton FG For
Ciara Conway Lab For
Noel Coonan FG Absent
Marcella Corcoran Kennedy FG For
Joe Costello Lab Absent
Simon Coveney FG Absent
Barry Cowen FF Against
Michael Creed FG For
Lucinda Creighton FG Absent
Seán Crowe SF Against
Clare Daly Ind Against
Jim Daly FG For
John Deasy FG Absent
Jimmy Deenihan FG Absent
Pat Deering FG For
Pearse Doherty SF Against
Regina Doherty FG For
Stephen Donnelly Ind For
Paschal Donohoe FG Absent
Timmy Dooley FF Against
Robert Dowds Lab For
Andrew Doyle FG For
Bernard Durkan FG For
Dessie Ellis SF Against
Damien English FG For
Alan Farrell FG For
Frankie Feighan FG For
Anne Ferris Lab For
Martin Ferris SF Against
Frances Fitzgerald FG Absent
Peter Fitzpatrick FG For
Charles Flanagan FG For
Luke 'Ming' Flanagan Ind Against
Terence Flanagan FG For
Sean Fleming FF Absent
Tom Fleming Ind Against
Eamon Gilmore Lab Absent
Noel Grealish Ind Against
Brendan Griffin FG For
John Halligan Ind Absent
Dominic Hannigan Lab For
Noel Harrington FG For
Simon Harris FG Absent
Brian Hayes FG Absent
Tom Hayes FG Absent
Seamus Healy Workers and Unemployed Action Against
Michael Healy-Rae Ind Against
Martin Heydon FG Absent
Joe Higgins Socialist Party Absent
Phil Hogan FG For
Brendan Howlin Lab For
Heather Humphreys FG For
Kevin Humphreys Lab For
Derek Keating FG For
Colm Keaveney Ind Absent
Paul Kehoe FG For
Billy Kelleher FF Against
Alan Kelly Lab Absent
Enda Kenny FG Absent
Seán Kenny Lab For
Seamus Kirk FF Against
Michael P. Kitt FF Absent
Seán Kyne FG For
Anthony Lawlor FG For
Michael Lowry Ind For
Ciaran Lynch Lab For
Kathleen Lynch Lab For
John Lyons Lab For
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn SF Against
Eamonn Maloney Lab For
Micheál Martin FF Absent
Peter Mathews FG For
Michael McCarthy Lab For
Charlie McConalogue FF Against
Mary Lou McDonald SF Absent
Helen McEntee NI For
Nicky McFadden FG Absent
Dinny McGinley FG For
Finian McGrath Ind Against
Mattie McGrath Ind For
Michael McGrath FF Against
John McGuinness FF Absent
Joe McHugh FG For
Sandra McLellan SF Against
Tony McLoughlin FG For
Michael McNamara Lab For
Olivia Mitchell FG For
Mary Mitchell O'Connor FG For
Michael Moynihan FF Against
Michelle Mulherin FG For
Catherine Murphy Ind Against
Dara Murphy FG For
Eoghan Murphy FG Absent
Ged Nash Lab For
Denis Naughten Ind For
Dan Neville FG For
Derek Nolan Lab For
Michael Noonan FG For
Patrick Nulty Ind Against
Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin SF Against
Éamon Ó Cuív FF Against
Seán Ó Fearghaíl FF Against
Aodhán Ó Ríordáin Lab Absent
Aengus Ó Snodaigh SF Against
Jonathan O'Brien SF Against
Willie O'Dea FF Absent
Kieran O'Donnell FG For
Patrick O'Donovan FG For
Fergus O'Dowd FG For
John O'Mahony FG For
Joe O'Reilly FG For
Jan O'Sullivan Lab For
Maureen O'Sullivan Ind Against
Willie Penrose Ind For
John Perry FG For
Ann Phelan Lab For
John Paul Phelan FG For
Thomas Pringle Ind Against
Ruairí Quinn Lab For
Pat Rabbitte Lab For
James Reilly FG For
Michael Ring FG For
Shane Ross Ind Against
Brendan Ryan Lab Absent
Alan Shatter FG For
Seán Sherlock Lab Absent
Róisín Shortall Ind Against
Brendan Smith FF Against
Arthur Spring Lab For
Emmet Stagg Lab For
Brian Stanley SF Against
David Stanton FG For
Billy Timmins FG Absent
Peadar Tóibín SF Against
Robert Troy FF Against
Joanna Tuffy Lab For
Liam Twomey FG Absent
Leo Varadkar FG For
Jack Wall Lab Absent
Mick Wallace Ind Against
Brian Walsh FG For
Alex White Lab Absent