← All votes

Senate of Canada · roll call no. 10070 · · ✗ Rejected

An Act to amend the Criminal Code (bail reform) – C-48 – Third Reading – Amendment (Sen. Carignan)

On 28 November 2023, Senate of Canada: vote rejected, 22 for, 55 against, 3 abstentions.

Official record ↗
Summarize with an AI

External tool, not official: nothing is sent until you click, and an AI can make mistakes. The prompt only contains public data from this page. For tools that cannot be pre-filled, the prompt is copied: paste it.

Type of vote
Roll-call vote
Voters
80
Votes cast
77
for + against (excluding abstentions)

22 for 55 against 3 abstentions

Colour by:
PSG — 14 ISG — 39 NA — 10 CSG — 16 C — 15 PSGISGNACSGC Dawn Anderson (PSG) — Against Michèle Audette (PSG) — Absent Diane Bellemare (PSG) — Against Wanda Thomas Bernard (PSG) — Abstention Andrew Cardozo (PSG) — Against Jane Cordy (PSG) — Against Rodger Cuzner (PSG) — Absent Pierre J. Dalphond (PSG) — Against Brian Francis (PSG) — Against Amina Gerba (PSG) — Against Clément Gignac (PSG) — Against Peter Harder (PSG) — Against Marty Klyne (PSG) — Against Judy A. White (PSG) — Against David M. Arnot (ISG) — Against Peter M. Boehm (ISG) — Against Gwen Boniface (ISG) — Against Yvonne Boyer (ISG) — Absent Bev Busson (ISG) — Against Bernadette Clement (ISG) — Against René Cormier (ISG) — Absent Brent Cotter (ISG) — Against Mary Coyle (ISG) — Against Donna Dasko (ISG) — Absent Marty Deacon (ISG) — Against Tony Dean (ISG) — Against Pat Duncan (ISG) — Against Renée Dupuis (ISG) — Against Éric Forest (ISG) — Against Rosa Galvez (ISG) — Against Margo Greenwood (ISG) — Against Nancy J. Hartling (ISG) — Against Mobina S. B. Jaffer (ISG) — Against Stan Kutcher (ISG) — Absent Frances Lankin (ISG) — Absent Tony Loffreda (ISG) — Against Jane MacAdam (ISG) — Against Paul J. Massicotte (ISG) — Against Julie Miville-Dechêne (ISG) — Against Lucie Moncion (ISG) — Against Rosemary Moodie (ISG) — Against Marie-Françoise Mégie (ISG) — Against Ratna Omidvar (ISG) — Against Kim Pate (ISG) — Against Chantal Petitclerc (ISG) — Against Iris G. Petten (ISG) — Against Mohamed-Iqbal Ravalia (ISG) — Against Pierrette Ringuette (ISG) — Against Raymonde Saint-Germain (ISG) — Against Paula Simons (ISG) — Against Karen Sorensen (ISG) — Absent Yuen Pau Woo (ISG) — Against Hassan Yussuff (ISG) — Against Réjean Aucoin (NA) — Abstention Patrick Brazeau (NA) — Absent Raymonde Gagné (NA) — Absent Marc Gold (NA) — Against Joan Kingston (NA) — Against Patti LaBoucane-Benson (NA) — Against Mary Jane McCallum (NA) — Against John M. McNair (NA) — Against Marilou McPhedran (NA) — Against Krista Ross (NA) — Against Robert Black (CSG) — Against Sharon Burey (CSG) — Against Jean-Guy Dagenais (CSG) — For Colin Deacon (CSG) — Absent Percy E. Downe (CSG) — Against Stephen Greene (CSG) — Absent Flordeliz (Gigi) Osler (CSG) — Abstention Dennis Glen Patterson (CSG) — For Rebecca Patterson (CSG) — For Paul (PJ) Prosper (CSG) — Against Jim Quinn (CSG) — For David Richards (CSG) — For Larry W. Smith (CSG) — For Scott Tannas (CSG) — For Josée Verner (CSG) — For Pamela Wallin (CSG) — For Salma Ataullahjan (C) — For Denise Batters (C) — For Pierre-Hugues Boisvenu (C) — For Claude Carignan (C) — For Leo Housakos (C) — For Michael L. MacDonald (C) — For Fabian Manning (C) — Absent Elizabeth Marshall (C) — For Yonah Martin (C) — For Percy Mockler (C) — For Victor Oh (C) — For Donald Neil Plett (C) — For Rose-May Poirier (C) — Absent Judith G. Seidman (C) — For David M. Wells (C) — For

Official note: Sitting of 2023-11-28, vote 70 of session 44-1 (Senate vote id 624639).

By group

Group ForAgainstAbst. Non-votingAbsentTotalBreakdown
PSG 0111 0214
ISG 0330 0639
NA 071 0210
CSG 941 0216
C 1300 0215

All senators

SenatorGroupVote
Dawn Anderson PSG Against
David M. Arnot ISG Against
Salma Ataullahjan C For
Réjean Aucoin NA Abstention
Michèle Audette PSG Absent
Denise Batters C For
Diane Bellemare PSG Against
Wanda Thomas Bernard PSG Abstention
Robert Black CSG Against
Peter M. Boehm ISG Against
Pierre-Hugues Boisvenu C For
Gwen Boniface ISG Against
Yvonne Boyer ISG Absent
Patrick Brazeau NA Absent
Sharon Burey CSG Against
Bev Busson ISG Against
Andrew Cardozo PSG Against
Claude Carignan C For
Bernadette Clement ISG Against
Jane Cordy PSG Against
René Cormier ISG Absent
Brent Cotter ISG Against
Mary Coyle ISG Against
Rodger Cuzner PSG Absent
Jean-Guy Dagenais CSG For
Pierre J. Dalphond PSG Against
Donna Dasko ISG Absent
Colin Deacon CSG Absent
Marty Deacon ISG Against
Tony Dean ISG Against
Percy E. Downe CSG Against
Pat Duncan ISG Against
Renée Dupuis ISG Against
Éric Forest ISG Against
Brian Francis PSG Against
Raymonde Gagné NA Absent
Rosa Galvez ISG Against
Amina Gerba PSG Against
Clément Gignac PSG Against
Marc Gold NA Against
Stephen Greene CSG Absent
Margo Greenwood ISG Against
Peter Harder PSG Against
Nancy J. Hartling ISG Against
Leo Housakos C For
Mobina S. B. Jaffer ISG Against
Joan Kingston NA Against
Marty Klyne PSG Against
Stan Kutcher ISG Absent
Patti LaBoucane-Benson NA Against
Frances Lankin ISG Absent
Tony Loffreda ISG Against
Jane MacAdam ISG Against
Michael L. MacDonald C For
Fabian Manning C Absent
Elizabeth Marshall C For
Yonah Martin C For
Paul J. Massicotte ISG Against
Mary Jane McCallum NA Against
John M. McNair NA Against
Marilou McPhedran NA Against
Marie-Françoise Mégie ISG Against
Julie Miville-Dechêne ISG Against
Percy Mockler C For
Lucie Moncion ISG Against
Rosemary Moodie ISG Against
Victor Oh C For
Ratna Omidvar ISG Against
Flordeliz (Gigi) Osler CSG Abstention
Kim Pate ISG Against
Dennis Glen Patterson CSG For
Rebecca Patterson CSG For
Chantal Petitclerc ISG Against
Iris G. Petten ISG Against
Donald Neil Plett C For
Rose-May Poirier C Absent
Paul (PJ) Prosper CSG Against
Jim Quinn CSG For
Mohamed-Iqbal Ravalia ISG Against
David Richards CSG For
Pierrette Ringuette ISG Against
Krista Ross NA Against
Raymonde Saint-Germain ISG Against
Judith G. Seidman C For
Paula Simons ISG Against
Larry W. Smith CSG For
Karen Sorensen ISG Absent
Scott Tannas CSG For
Josée Verner CSG For
Pamela Wallin CSG For
David M. Wells C For
Judy A. White PSG Against
Yuen Pau Woo ISG Against
Hassan Yussuff ISG Against